Smithsonian Education

What's Missing from Classrooms When Asian American and Pacific Islander Voices Aren't Included?

Through co-creation efforts with K-12 educators and Asian American community partners, the National Veterans Network, elementary and middle school educators, Asian Pacific American Center interns and National Museum of American History staff, learn more about the stories behind objects. (Smithsonian Asian Pacific American Center)
Through co-creation efforts with K-12 educators and Asian American community partners, the National Veterans Network, elementary and middle school educators, Asian Pacific American Center interns and National Museum of American History staff, learn more about the stories behind objects. (Smithsonian Asian Pacific American Center)

During the summer of 2018, the Smithsonian Asian Pacific American Center (APAC) had the privilege of collaborating with four educators and the National Veterans Network on the co-creation of new elementary and middle school activities focusing on the incarceration of 120,000 Japanese Americans during World War II. We gathered in Washington, D.C. to test new ideas for classroom-ready activities that would immerse educators and their students in stories about Japanese American individuals who were incarcerated, volunteered to serve in the military, or resisted Executive Order 9066. 

We asked ourselves:

How can we thoughtfully partner with educators and collaborate on encouraging our youngest learners to find meaningful connections with Asian American and Pacific Islander stories?

While we tested the usability of new activities and lesson plans, we visited the Smithsonian National Museum of American History’s exhibition,Righting a Wrong: Japanese Americans and World War IIto see the exhibition’s objects, archival materials, and other interactive materials firsthand. During this visit, one of the educators in our small cohort, a 2nd grade teacher for D.C. Public Schools, pulled me aside to talk about how he was grappling with “the hook” for elementary lessons about this history. What stories would resonate with a 2nd grade student? He shared that in looking at the objects and thinking about how so many young children were displaced during this time, losing friendships and a sense of home, one story that personally struck him was that families were not allowed to bring pets to camp. As a dog owner, this was a devastating thought for him, and indeed, for young people thinking about what would happen if something you loved and cared for was no longer a part of your life.

The activities co-created as an outcome of this educator’s emotional and empathetic connection ask students to question and think about the idea of fairness, an appropriate strategy for younger elementary students. Other ideas linking historical empathy with developmentally appropriate questions turned into two activity books for elementary school and middle school teachers and students, asking them to think about what life was like in camp and what they would have done if faced with Executive Order 9066.

Male teacher in front of library holding two images to room of students at round tables.
Middle school teacher Brian Mason teaches his students about Japanese American incarceration camp experiences through a document-based query set he co-created in partnership with the National Veterans Network. (Smithsonian Asian Pacific American Center)

The experience of co-creating activities with educators and community partners served as another reminder that learning about Asian Americans and Pacific Islanders (AAPIs) is essential for all grade levels and vital for learning opportunities throughout the year to be more reflective of the U.S. population. In addition to the history of Japanese American incarceration, there are countless more AAPI stories to tell, such as Filipino Americans shaping American labor movements, Pacific Islander artists and activists raising awareness on the impacts of climate change in their communities, and more. There is more work to be done to better understand the needs of educators so that we can come together to ensure AAPI inclusion in curricula across the country.

At APAC, our constant aim is to uplift and amplify the stories of AAPIs across the country. Since 2018, we have continued to listen and learn from K-12 educators and professors about the challenges in learning about, absorbing, and teaching AAPI stories. Pervasive stereotypes that AAPI individuals and communities face, such as the perpetual foreigner and model minority myths, are just some of the barriers that have limited meaningful inclusion in educational materials. AAPIs have been present throughout America’s past through migration, labor, activism, science innovation, art, literature, community organizing, and so much more. When AAPI stories and voices are missing from what students learn, grappling with our current moment of increased hate and violence, and thoughtfully discussing this with students runs the risk of becoming even more difficult without support and resources to contextualize what we are witnessing today.

Still image of a webinar presentation with three presenters and a slide reading "Where did Model Minority come from?"
Educators present the origins of the model minority myth stereotype for the "We Are Not A Stereotype" video series. (Smithsonian Asian Pacific American Center)

Recognizing the need for content support that explores topics in history and today, APAC is pleased to share a series of resources co-created with educators and AAPI community members:

We Are Not A Stereotype: Breaking Down APA Bias is an educational video series created by educators for educators. From videos about Asian-Black solidarity movements for liberation to caste apartheid in South Asian American communities, viewers meet content experts who not only share their knowledge and research, but also their lived experiences as AAPI community members.

Learning Together connects K-12 educators to AAPI voices and stories through interviews, links to community-created educational resources, tips on how to discuss anti-Asian hate with students, book recommendations, discussion prompts, and more.

Making Art + Global Interconnections introduces educators to four new art-making ideas for the virtual, in-person or hybrid classroom. These activities were co-created by AAPI artists and educators and will introduce users to activities that connect us with stories in the Marshall Islands, Bangladesh, Syria, Lebanon, and Hawaiʻi.

There is much more work to be done. APAC continues to engage with even more K-12 educators and AAPI community members to co-create more accessible and easily available resources and supports that will help bring AAPI stories into every classroom across the country.

Andrea Kim Neighbors

Andrea Kim Neighbors serves as the Manager of Education Initiatives for the Smithsonian Asian Pacific American Center (APAC), where she collaborates with educators and Asian American and Pacific Islander content specialists on the development of APAC’s National Education Program. Before joining APAC, Andrea was Manager of Community Partnerships at The Phillips Collection in Washington, D.C. and Tour Manager at the Wing Luke Museum of the Asian Pacific American Experience in Seattle, WA, designing customized museum experiences to best fit the needs of local educators. Andrea was a Getty Leadership NextGen 2019 Fellow and a Board Officer for the American Alliance of Museum’s Diversity Professional Network. She holds a BA and MA in Cultural Anthropology, with fieldwork experiences Mongolia and the Russian Far East studying the politicization of childhood.

More From This Author »