Sleeping with Cannibals
Our intrepid reporter gets up close and personal with New Guinea natives who say they still eat their fellow tribesmen.
- By Paul Raffaele
- Photographs by Paul Raffaele
- Smithsonian magazine, September 2006, Subscribe
For days I've been slogging through a rain-soaked jungle in Indonesian New Guinea, on a quest to visit members of the Korowai tribe, among the last people on earth to practice cannibalism. Soon after first light this morning I boarded a pirogue, a canoe hacked out of a tree trunk, for the last stage of the journey, along the twisting Ndeiram Kabur River. Now the four paddlers bend their backs with vigor, knowing we will soon make camp for the night.
My guide, Kornelius Kembaren, has traveled among the Korowai for 13 years. But even he has never been this far upriver, because, he says, some Korowai threaten to kill outsiders who enter their territory. Some clans are said to fear those of us with pale skin, and Kembaren says many Korowai have never laid eyes on a white person. They call outsiders laleo ("ghost-demons").
Suddenly, screams erupt from around the bend. Moments later, I see a throng of naked men brandishing bows and arrows on the riverbank. Kembaren murmurs to the boatmen to stop paddling. "They're ordering us to come to their side of the river," he whispers to me. "It looks bad, but we can't escape. They'd quickly catch us if we tried."
As the tribesmen's uproar bangs at my ears, our pirogue glides toward the far side of the river. "We don't want to hurt you," Kembaren shouts in Bahasa Indonesia, which one of our boatmen translates into Korowai. "We come in peace." Then two tribesmen slip into a pirogue and start paddling toward us. As they near, I see that their arrows are barbed. "Keep calm," Kembaren says softly.
Cannibalism was practiced among prehistoric human beings, and it lingered into the 19th century in some isolated South Pacific cultures, notably in Fiji. But today the Korowai are among the very few tribes believed to eat human flesh. They live about 100 miles inland from the Arafura Sea, which is where Michael Rockefeller, a son of then-New York governor Nelson Rockefeller, disappeared in 1961 while collecting artifacts from another Papuan tribe; his body was never found. Most Korowai still live with little knowledge of the world beyond their homelands and frequently feud with one another. Some are said to kill and eat male witches they call khakhua.
The island of New Guinea, the second largest in the world after Greenland, is a mountainous, sparsely populated tropical landmass divided between two countries: the independent nation of Papua New Guinea in the east, and the Indonesian provinces of Papua and West Irian Jaya in the west. The Korowai live in southeastern Papua.
My journey begins at Bali, where I catch a flight across the Banda Sea to the Papuan town of Timika; an American mining company's subsidiary, PT Freeport Indonesia, operates the world's largest copper and gold mine nearby. The Free Papua Movement, which consists of a few hundred rebels equipped with bows and arrows, has been fighting for independence from Indonesia since 1964. Because Indonesia has banned foreign journalists from visiting the province, I entered as a tourist.
After a stopover in Timika, our jet climbs above a swampy marsh past the airport and heads toward a high mountain. Beyond the coast, the sheer slopes rise as high as 16,500 feet above sea level and stretch for 400 miles. Waiting for me at Jayapura, a city of 200,000 on the northern coast near the border with Papua New Guinea, is Kembaren, 46, a Sumatran who came to Papua seeking adventure 16 years ago. He first visited the Korowai in 1993, and has come to know much about their culture, including some of their language. He is clad in khaki shorts and trekking boots, and his unflinching gaze and rock-hard jaw give him the look of a drill sergeant.
The best estimate is that there are some 4,000 Korowai. Traditionally, they have lived in treehouses, in groups of a dozen or so people in scattered clearings in the jungle; their attachment to their treehouses and surrounding land lies at the core of their identity, Smithsonian Institution anthropologist Paul Taylor noted in his 1994 documentary film about them, Lords of the Garden. Over the past few decades, however, some Korowai have moved to settlements established by Dutch missionaries, and in more recent years, some tourists have ventured into Korowai lands. But the deeper into the rain forest one goes, the less exposure the Korowai have had to cultures alien to their own.
After we fly from Jayapura southwest to Wamena, a jumping-off point in the Papuan highlands, a wiry young Korowai approaches us. In Bahasa Indonesia, he says that his name is Boas and that two years ago, eager to see life beyond his treehouse, he hitched a ride on a charter flight from Yaniruma, a settlement at the edge of Korowai territory. He has tried to return home, he says, but no one will take him. Boas says a returning guide has told him that his father was so upset by his son's absence that he has twice burned down his own treehouse. We tell him he can come with us.
The next morning eight of us board a chartered Twin Otter, a workhorse whose short takeoff and landing ability will get us to Yaniruma. Once we're airborne, Kembaren shows me a map: spidery lines marking lowland rivers and thousands of square miles of green jungle. Dutch missionaries who came to convert the Korowai in the late 1970s called it "the hell in the south."
After 90 minutes we come in low, following the snaking Ndeiram Kabur River. In the jungle below, Boas spots his father’s treehouse, which seems impossibly high off the ground, like the nest of a giant bird. Boas, who wears a daisy-yellow bonnet, a souvenir of “civilization,” hugs me in gratitude, and tears trickle down his cheeks.
At Yaniruma, a line of stilt huts that Dutch missionaries established in 1979, we thump down on a dirt strip carved out of the jungle. Now, to my surprise, Boas says he will postpone his homecoming to continue with us, lured by the promise of adventure with a laleo, and he cheerfully lifts a sack of foodstuffs onto his shoulders. As the pilot hurls the Twin Otter back into the sky, a dozen Korowai men hoist our packs and supplies and trudge toward the jungle in single file bound for the river. Most carry bows and arrows.
The Rev. Johannes Veldhuizen, a Dutch missionary with the Mission of the Reformed Churches, first made contact with the Korowai in 1978 and dropped plans to convert them to Christianity. "A very powerful mountain god warned the Korowai that their world would be destroyed by an earthquake if outsiders came into their land to change their customs," he told me by phone from the Netherlands a few years ago. "So we went as guests, rather than as conquerors, and never put any pressure on the Korowai to change their ways." The Rev. Gerrit van Enk, another Dutch missionary and co-author of The Korowai of Irian Jaya, coined the term "pacification line" for the imaginary border separating Korowai clans accustomed to outsiders from those farther north. In a separate phone interview from the Netherlands, he told me that he had never gone beyond the pacification line because of possible danger from Korowai clans there hostile to the presence of laleo in their territory.
Single Page 1 2 3 4 5 6 Next »
Subscribe now for more of Smithsonian's coverage on history, science and nature.









Comments (30)
+ View All Comments
I read this article, more than six years after it was first published. I wonder what changes (if any) have occurred in the Korowai lifestyle during the intervening period. My emotions are mixed about the author. Mr. Rafaele seems to lament the coming demise of this people's way of life, yet his own determination to go deep into their lands and reach a group which supposedly has never met a white person is the very catalyst to begin this process of cultural change....
Posted by Karen Herschell on September 9,2012 | 10:51 AM
do they have pets???????
Posted by natatia on June 27,2012 | 09:51 AM
Jonathan Kua, When Christ stated that we must eat of His body, and drink of His blood, but even though there is debate among different christian faiths regarding this, most, believe the try;th that Jesus was being figurative or at least meaning this discourse in a figurative sense; that much is obvious even to most casual readers. However, even those who are in error, believing they are actually eating and drinking Jesus' body and blood believe that the elements are changed supernaturally in a way that does not impart the sin of Cannibalism to them. Even if it were a cannibalistic act, which it is not, the command was regarding Christ alone; elsewhere believes are figuratively, and by implication litterally, warned against biting and devouring one another with covetousness. You are intentionally misrepresenting Christianity by using rhetoric to justify the sin and covetousness of both these people and yourself ; and you know it.
Posted by Chris on January 9,2012 | 03:44 PM
I have a pre WWII bow with flat bamboo string and 3 intric atly carved arrows, all different all arrows have intricatly carved wooden heads with bamboo shafts. Brought back by missionarries years ago. Would like to know value and sell.
Posted by Dan Thomas on January 2,2012 | 12:59 PM
This is sensational and exaggerated. It is not accurate. The author makes wild claims. Many people from other parts of Papua (formerly Irian Jaya and not PNG) and foreign people have been to the Korowai. I was in this area three years ago.
Posted by ambiang kobak on October 13,2011 | 04:50 PM
I am from West Papua, born and raised.
pateriot comments are good. Many times westerners moan about dying cultures and not changing them - so that we can remain museum curios? Years ago I was hunting with a village elder and he said to me, "Do the white people want us to stay the same forever? Do they think we are pigs to be left in the dirt? Why can we not want to have a better life? Without war? With medicine? Do they want to keep that all for themselves? Or do they want to keep us down so they can take our wealth for themselves."
Answer that all you who never want us to change. I mourn the loss of my culture. Many of my children are forgetting their ways and language. But only a fool wishes for the old days in which we constantly warred, suffered. Where a simple cut could mean death. Really? Thats wonderful? If you like it so much why do you make laws to protect people?
My people also ate others. But even amongst us there we others who said, "it is wrong to eat human flesh. They are our brothers."
It is funny that westerners have changed much over the centuries and still change. That is ok. But the naked black man in New Guinea? No, he must never change.
Yet it is good too to see people looking at my land and caring. Thank you
EYK
Posted by Elabo Kobak on October 12,2011 | 07:12 PM
For the ignorant American Paul, it is NOT Indonesian PNG, the country is correctly named Aryan Jaya. It is like calling Tibet, China! And FYI, the world's largest island is actually Australia, as technically it IS an island.
Posted by Rene on July 26,2011 | 10:57 AM
Whoever you are an anthropologist or whatever your field is, did you really find out why these people whom you so called westerners, civilized, breed of high intellegence etc etc find out why they practised canabalism? Were they looking for protein? Why they were so much food supply especially meat, wild pigs, snakes, fish, wallabies etc and yet they perfer to kill someone for human flesh? Was it a daily slaughtering as you would do it in your farms? Common, give us a break? When Jesus teaches that " If you do not eat my body and blood, you will have life," and his disciples in their secret house church celeberate holy communion, they were accused of being canibals, so you say you people from west do not have practiced such now you called it deplorable act? Give us a break. The practise is attached to religion and traditional belief systems. Work it out.
Posted by Jonathan Kua on June 10,2011 | 09:16 AM
Quite thrilling and enlightening story. Manu cultures have come and gone, but contact with "civilization" has brought more pain than gain to countless "primitive" peoples - American Indians, Australian Aborigines, and many many more to a lesser extent.
While you smugly bask in the glory for bringing Korowai culture to the "world", your visit is an additional nail in their culture's coffin.
Posted by Thaddaeus Rweyemamu on May 27,2011 | 04:01 AM
To Hildegarde, how can you be so judgmental? And, how can you be so stupid at the same time? Poligamy = murder and cannibalism??? First of all, in Poligamy, the people are married. That is all God requires. Was Abraham evil for having more than one wife? No...Fact is, the New Testament says for a bishop to have only one wife. Doesn't that suggest that the other disciples, Christians, can have 2 or more wives? Of course!!! But, trying to equate murder and cannibalsim with poligamy, stupid. War is not a crime in and of itself. Standing around and letting millions of people die would have been a crime and evil concerning the Jews. Stop with your judgmental attitudes...
Posted by Grasshopper on March 29,2011 | 02:42 AM
Many comments here focus largely on the Korowai cannibalistic culture. This article has so much more to tell, and I personally think it is an absolutely enticing and somewhat thrilling account of the diversities that remain within a world obsessed with modernities of the 21st century. These people are rooted to the core in historical beliefs, traditions and practices, and I hope these reach many future generations of Korowai. Fantastic. Thank you for sharing it.
Posted by Emma on February 9,2011 | 12:02 PM
The bit about Michael Rockefeller going missing near cannibalistic tribes is very misleading.He swam off in a river and didn't return...he either drowned or fell victim to a crocodile.Evidence for him being cannibalized was found to be circumstantial.
Posted by Oliver on February 4,2011 | 01:03 PM
Fascinating article. Paul Raffaele is amazingly brave.
Posted by Anon on January 26,2011 | 03:18 AM
Well, as Christians, you are very judgemental and your reporting is also a reflection of your judgemental state of mind.
ALL nations and cultures have had certain practices in their past lives, and some even still exist today, but no-one is reporting in a biased manner about those practices and rituals. Yes, it is sad that some tribes are practicing cannabalism. But how does that differ from for example polygamy? Polygamy is also wrong. I think, as Christians, we should be tolerable towards other cultures and their rituals. Once the people of such tribes decides on their own to become Christians, then one can only teach them to stop cannabalism.
What about all the war and famine resulting from it? Christians are easily ready to judge and make war, but does not see that as a crime? Really, change your mindset!
Let them be, the world needs mysteries. The world needs people who are brave enough to preserve their cultures, rites and rituals, and their government should do everything in their power to preserve it.
Posted by Hildegarde du Plessis on November 15,2010 | 03:51 AM
+ View All Comments