Who Do You Love?
Bo Diddley's beat changed the course of rock music. And his lyrics evoked a history that reached all the way to Africa.
- By Ned Sublette
- Smithsonian magazine, August 2008, Subscribe
I helped Bo Diddley find a drummer once.
It was in 1971. I was 19, reading underground comics one sleepy afternoon at Roach Ranch West, a spacious, hippie-stuff shop in Albuquerque, when a black man wearing a big black hat walked in and said: "I'm Bo Diddley."
It was, in the argot of the day, a cosmic moment. Could this really be Bo "47 miles of barbed wire" Diddley stepping out of the blue, announcing his presence in a remote desert city? Was I hallucinating?
No, it really was that founding father of rock 'n' roll. He had relocated his family from Southern California to Los Lunas, New Mexico, after being shaken up by a big earthquake, and he wanted to play a free show.
"Do you know any drummers?" he asked.
It happened that there was a drummer in the Roach Ranch at that very moment—Mike Fleming, who played with a local cover band called Lemon. I pointed him out. They spoke, and Bo Diddley said he'd be back later. Somebody called the local Top 40 station to announce the show.
Bo Diddley played that night to a packed-out back room at Roach Ranch West, with his wife and three daughters singing with him and Mike Fleming on drums. I sat on the floor in front of the improvised stage, close enough for him to sweat on me, studying him as he pulled a variety of sounds out of his cranked-up rhythm guitar to drive the audience wild. He wasn't doing an oldies show, he was doing funky new material. I shouted and shouted for "Who Do You Love." Which, finally, he played.
Ellas McDaniel, professionally known as Bo Diddley, died June 2 at the age of 79. He is remembered above all for his signature rhythm. Tell any drummer, in any bar band anywhere, to play a Bo Diddley beat, and he'll know what to do.
But Bo Diddley was so much more than a beat. He was a transforming figure. After him, music was different. His debut single, "Bo Diddley" (1955), announced that the whole game had changed. He showed how you could build a whole pop record around a rhythm and a rhyme. You didn't even need chord changes.
He put the beat front and center. To make that work, he chose the most compelling beat he could: the two-bar rhythm that Cubans know as clave. All the Chicago blues guys dipped into rumba blues, but this was another take on it. The Latin connection was so strong that Bo Diddley used maracas as a basic component of his sound. But sidekick Jerome Green didn't play maracas like a Cuban, and Bo Diddley didn't play that rhythm like a Cuban; he swung it, like an African-American who'd been playing on street corners in Chicago. And Bo Diddley's way of expressing that two-bar feel, known across a wide swath of Africa, was in turn a fountainhead for the development of rock 'n' roll, which would repeatedly cross Afro-Cuban and Af-rican-American rhythmic sensibilities.
Cover bands play the Bo Diddley beat formulaically. But in Bo Diddley's hands, the beat was alive. He did something different with it every time he recorded it. It's the difference between copying and creating.
He was born Ellas Bates in McComb, Mississippi, not far from the Louisiana border, on December 30, 1928. His teenage mother was unable to care for him, and he never knew his father, so the future Bo Diddley was adopted by his mother's cousin Gussie McDaniel, who gave him her last name and moved him to Chicago when he was about 7. There he was present at the creation of one of the great American musics: the electric Chicago blues.
The city was full of African-Americans looking for work and escaping the poverty, discrimination and lynchings of the Jim Crow South, and they constituted a strong local audience for music. More than a decade younger than Muddy Waters, and almost 20 years younger than Howlin' Wolf, Ellas McDaniel was a punk kid by comparison. "We used to be three dudes going down the street with a washtub, a little raggedy guitar and another cat with maracas," he told writer Neil Strauss in 2005. "Bo Diddley," his first record, went to No. 1 on the rhythm and blues chart without denting the pop chart. He appeared on "The Ed Sullivan Show" on November 20, 1955—almost a year before Elvis Presley did. But Sullivan got mad at him for playing "Bo Diddley" instead of his one-chord cover version of "Sixteen Tons" (then the top recording in the nation, but by Tennessee Ernie Ford) and never had him back.
Subscribe now for more of Smithsonian's coverage on history, science and nature.









Comments (6)
But did Ellas McDaniel / Bo Diddley actually write the lyrics to "Who Do You Love"? If not, who did? Thought I saw a reference to 1928 somewhere, but not an author name. Thanks to anyone answering this. Ken
Posted by Ken Gregory on July 5,2012 | 07:34 PM
James, I would love to see the photos, barje@bellsouth.net
Posted by Manuel Barje on June 16,2009 | 12:01 PM
I owned and operated The Roach Ranch West, 120 Yale SE, Albuquerque,New Mexico from its opening in 1970 to its closing in 1976. Manuel Barje pulled up at the curb on the afternoon of the show, inquiring as to the availability of the back room for a Bo Diddley concert that evening. Not beleving for a moment this was on the level, I agreed and set about promoting the event. One call to our friends at KRST-FM and the house was a sell out. That is a figure of speach as of course the concert was presented for free. Ned Sublett's account of the evening is quite accurate and a pleasure to read. It brought back many wonderful memories of a very special time. I have a series of photos of the evening and I know there is a reel to reel audio recording of the event, it's wereabouts are unknown. Mike Flemming is still a good friend and is currently very active in the music/movie scene here in the Land Of Enchantment. PEACE NOW
Posted by James Battey on January 22,2009 | 08:38 PM
I was the bass player that night at the Roach Ranch, we hadn't even unpacked yet after the move from Granada Hills, Bo said "find a place for us to play", it was a fun night, strange to read about it because it was a small place, Mike also played at Taos with us later and we hung out at Dennis Hopper's place, good memories, Thanks. Manuel Barje
Posted by Manuel on August 5,2008 | 05:59 PM
Sublette writes: "Tell any drummer, in any bar band anywhere, to play a Bo Diddley beat, and he'll know what to do." Not according to Bo Diddley. As he repeatedly said, almost everybody played the beat incorrectly, with the drummer usually trying to play Bo's rhythm guitar part.
Posted by Leon Despair on August 5,2008 | 12:21 PM
I love this article. I thank Ned Sublette so much for contributing. This is one of the most valuable pieces of research I have seen lately. Ned if you read these please contact me
Posted by kristin on August 5,2008 | 04:53 AM
If music was petroleum, Mississippi would have been Texas instead of the squalid little crossroads cotton plantation it became. This is a terrific homage to an artist of immense significance! How many people, in ANY walk of life, leave behind a contribution so essential and enduring and instantly recognizable as the Bo Diddley Beat? Imagine music over the past half century without it. Bo Diddley was a giant, and Mr. Sublette's fine tribute is up to the task of framing his legacy.
Posted by Jim Smith on July 31,2008 | 08:20 AM
"Who Do You Love", a great article on Bo Diddly. I remember the original "Bo Diddly" coming out, it was played pretty regularly on LA Pop radio and was a hit. I saw Bo twice, in Hawaii in 1986 and the San Dimas, Cal Red Beans and Rice Fest in early 90s. Oh yeah, saw him again with Chuck Berry at LB Blues Festival in about 2002. I really enjoyed your breaking down his musical influences and styles..helps me to understand him better. Big loss for music. Jeff Finley Yuma, AZ
Posted by Jeff Finley on July 25,2008 | 08:15 PM
Fantastic Article! As a young boy growing up in the late 50s, early 60s in the heartland of America (St. Louis), I loved rock and roll, rhythym and blues and soul music. Bo Diddley along with Little Richard, Chuck Berry, Jerry Lee Lewis and Elvis Presley were the royalty of those days. But Bo Diddley's beat in my mind was always the best. I once put $.50 into a jukebox (at $.05 a play) and punched Bo Diddley's "You Can't Judge A Book" 10 times. The owner of the teenage hangout finally had to unplug the jukebox because it got to be too much for some people. Not me, I could have listened to it all 10 times and then 10 more. I saw Bo play at Harrah's Casino (in the appropriately named VooDoo Lounge) a couple years ago. He was still as powerful a musician as he had been as a young man. Generations of Americans of all races can be very thankful to men like Bo Diddley for giving us some of the best music in the world. Thanks for your article. Dave Chaeney
Posted by David Chaeney on July 5,2008 | 12:59 PM