Travel
arrow left arrow right
Fall colors while fishing
Fall in New England
Valley
Ominous Storm
Rose in The Cloister's
Bayside
Early morning on a Minnesota lake
Dandelion family
Mother and Son
Friendly face in a flower
Geological Exuberance
Spectator of a Mevlevi Sema ceremony
Spotting future possibilities.
Stockholm night
Wrigley in April
Spitzkoppe
two horses in love
A bird's photobomb
a love meeting between 2 horses-miss you
Bushman Hunter-Gatherers
A male breathless after chasing down his prey.
Weary of Intruders
Elephant viewing while touring Kruger National Park.
14th Annual Smithsonian.com Photo Contest
Spectator of a Mevlevi Sema ceremony

My class's teaching assistant, a long-time Istanbul resident, mentioned that this demonstration of Sufi meditation was the equivalent of a Civil War reenactment in the US: devoid of real intentions and recreated for educational purposes. But it still felt uncomfortable to watch this hour-long "show" of what was supposed to be men praying, meditating, and connecting with G-d. Was my presence there truly appropriate? Was taking this photo appropriate? The scene is beautiful, yes, but is it acceptable to be a spectator to such a practice for entertainment without being an adherent? Where does the line of appropriation lie?

TAGS: Film, Islam, Turkey

photographer avatar
Arlington, Virginia, United States of America
Member since 2016
Photo Information
Copyright:
© Sarah Robinson.
All rights reserved.
Image Source: print_negative
Date Taken: 05.2015
Filed Under: Travel
Camera Information
Date Uploaded: Nov. 15, 2016, 11:03 a.m.
Report This
SMITHSONIAN.COM COLLECTIONS
PHOTO LOCATION Istanbul, Turkey