Revolutionary Road
Efforts to turn the Vietnam War's notorious Ho Chi Minh Trail into a major highway have uncovered battle scars from the past while paving a way to a brighter future
- By David Lamb
- Photographs by Mark Leong
- Smithsonian magazine, March 2008, Subscribe
The old Ho Chi Minh trail passes right by Bui Thi Duyen's doorstep in the hamlet of Doi. The hamlet, quiet and isolated, is of no consequence today, but during what the Vietnamese call the "American War," many thousands of northern soldiers knew Doi, 50 miles south of Hanoi, as an overnight stop on their perilous journey to the southern battlefields. The camouflaged network of footpaths and roads they traveled was the world's most dangerous route. One North Vietnamese soldier counted 24 ways you could die on it: malaria and dysentery could ravage you; U.S. aerial bombardments could disintegrate you; tigers could eat you; snakes could poison you; floods and landslides could wash you away. Sheer exhaustion took its toll as well.
When the war ended in 1975, much of the Ho Chi Minh Trail was abandoned. The jungle pushed in to reclaim the supply depots, rickety bridges and earthen bunkers that stretched more than a thousand miles from a gorge known as Heaven's Gate outside Hanoi to the approaches of Saigon. Hamlets like Doi were left to languish, so remote they weren't even on maps. That North Vietnam had been able to build the trail—and keep it open in the face of relentless American attacks—was considered one of the great feats of warfare. It was like Hannibal crossing the Alps or General Washington the Delaware—an impossibility that became possible and thus changed the course of history.
I met Duyen when I returned to Vietnam last May to see what was left of the trail that bore the name of the country's revolutionary leader. She was sitting under a blue tarpaulin, trying to fan away the breathless heat and hoping to sell a few sweet potatoes and half a dozen heads of lettuce spread out on a makeshift bench. At 74, her memory of the war remained crystal clear. "There was not a day without famine then," she said. "We had to farm at night because of the bombing. Then we'd go up in the mountains and eat tree roots." What food the villagers had—even their prized piglets—they gave to the soldiers who trekked through Doi, pushing bicycles laden with ammunition or stooped under the weight of rice, salt, medicine and weapons. She called them the "Hanoi men," but in reality many were no more than boys.
These days, though, Duyen has things other than the war on her mind. With Vietnam's economy booming, she wonders if she should cut her ties with tradition and swap the family's 7-year-old water buffalo for a new Chinese-made motor scooter. It would be an even trade; both are worth about $500. She also wonders what impact Vietnam's most ambitious postwar public works project will have on Doi. "Without that road, we have no future," she says.
The project, started in 2000 and scheduled to take 20 years to complete, is turning much of the old trail into the Ho Chi Minh Highway, a paved multilane artery that will eventually run 1,980 miles from the Chinese border to the tip of the Mekong Delta. The transformation of trail to highway struck me as an apt metaphor for Vietnam's own journey from war to peace, especially since many of the young workers building the new road are the sons and daughters of soldiers who fought, and often died, on the Ho Chi Minh Trail.
The old infiltration and supply route—which the Vietnamese call Truong Son Road, after the nearby mountain range—wasn't a single trail at all. It was a maze of 12,000 miles of trails, roads and bypasses that threaded through eastern Laos and northeastern Cambodia and crisscrossed Vietnam. Between 1959 and 1975 an estimated two million soldiers and laborers from the Communist North traversed it, intent on fulfilling Ho Chi Minh's dream to defeat South Vietnam's U.S.-backed government and reunite Vietnam. Before leaving Hanoi and other northern cities, some soldiers got tattoos that proclaimed: "Born in the North to die in the South."
During the war, which I covered for United Press International in the late 1960s, the Ho Chi Minh Trail had an aura of foreboding mystery. I could not imagine what it looked like or who trekked down it. I assumed I would never know. Then in 1997, I moved to Hanoi—the "enemy capital," I used to call it in my wartime dispatches—as a correspondent for the Los Angeles Times. Almost every male I met over 50 had been on the trail, and during my four years in Hanoi and on subsequent trips to Vietnam, I filled several notebooks with their stories. They invited me into their homes, eager to talk, and not once was I received with anything but friendship. I came to realize that the Vietnamese had put the war behind them, even as many Americans still struggled with its legacy.
Trong Thanh was one of those who greeted me—at the door of his home, tucked deep in a Hanoi alleyway, with a cup of green tea in hand. One of North Vietnam's most celebrated photographers, he had spent four years documenting life on the Ho Chi Minh Trail and had toured the United States with his pictures in 1991. The images spoke of the emotions of war more than the chaos of combat: a North Vietnamese soldier sharing his canteen with a wounded enemy from the South; a moment of tenderness between a teenage soldier and a nurse who looked no older than 15; three adolescent privates with faint smiles and arms over one another's shoulders, heading off on a mission from which they knew they would not return. "After taking their picture, I had to turn away and weep," Thanh said.
Thanh, whom I interviewed in 2000, six months before his death, pulled out boxes of photos, and soon the pictures were spread across the floor and over the furniture. The faces of the youthful soldiers stayed with me for a long time—their clear, steady eyes, the unblemished complexions and cheeks without whiskers, the expressions reflecting fear and determination. Their destiny was to walk down the Ho Chi Minh Trail. It would be left to their children to be the first generation in more than a hundred years not to know the sounds of battle or the bondage of foreign domination.
"It used to take two or three months for a letter from your family to reach you on the front," Thanh said. "But those were our happiest times on Truong Son, when we got mail from home. We'd read the letters aloud to each other. Pretty soon one soldier would laugh over something in a letter, then everyone would laugh. Then you'd feel so guilty for being happy, you'd cry, and the whole forest would echo with falling tears."
Subscribe now for more of Smithsonian's coverage on history, science and nature.









Comments (14)
Tran Dau says, ""People in Saigon don't care anymore if their neighbor fought for the South or the North.... It's just a matter of history."
That's all nice and good for him, but why don't you ask a Southerner whether or not they resented him. From a Saigon native's perspective, the victorious army acted a lot more like conquerors than liberators. There were implicit o preferential treatments for Northerners (even compared to Southerners who fought for the NVA or NLF), and explicit discrimination against Southerners with any taint of the former goverment.
Interesting article, but as usual the perspective of the South Vietnamese is conveniently ignored.
Posted by Linh Dang on March 2,2010 | 04:29 PM
Actually saw part of the Ho Chi Minh Trail during my service in Vietnam, 1968-1970, as I served in I Corps. Was shot down not far from the Ashau Valley along the "trail".
Actually worked with a Vietnamese refugee long after the war who was an anti-aircraft gunner in I Corps with the "other" side. We shared some of our experiences as old soldiers do, and I was able to share some of my photographs with him and his family.
The most beautiful spot in Vietnam that I saw was the cascading river below Khe Sanh. But I have no desire to return. Did write a book about my experiences and those of my unit, but it's never been published.
Served with the 4th/77th Aerial Rocket Artillery stationed out of Camp Evans north of Hue.
Posted by Loren Gee on November 30,2009 | 10:36 AM
I spent from 67 68 humping those mountians of the central highlands my dog and i forget the bombs and bullits that was the most beauiful place i have ever been bill herrera 39th scout dog 173rd abn bde
Posted by bill herrera on September 15,2009 | 02:48 PM
David,
On the Internet, I found your name when I searched for Colonel Dong Si Nguyen.
Can you send me the whole article ?!
I'm doing research about The Ho Chi Minh Trail for a documentary and I like to get in touch with you tot talk about this unique path.
Many thanks,
Jeroen Samwel
Amsterdam
Posted by Jeroen Samwel on February 16,2009 | 09:46 AM
In my day ('68-69)I fantasized about driving Hwy 14 from Kontum to Hue, but wouldn't have lived to tell about it I'm sure. I hold no grudges against any Vietnamese, I reserve those for the US citizens and politicians who chose to throw victory to the wind with a rationale I will probably really, truly, never understand. I wish Vietnam luck and prosperity.
Posted by Rick Nelson on January 12,2009 | 06:52 PM
Thank you David for the fine article. Hope we will see more about Viet Nam. I was with 1st Bn.,7th Marines in '68 near DaNang. I hope to return to see this beautiful country and beautiful people again.
Posted by John Gates on January 5,2009 | 10:38 AM
This is a great article. I am referring to it at the end of the course on Vietnam that I tutor for SUNY/Empire State College Center for Distance Learning, and an example of what life is like there now. The Colonel's comment at the end is truly reflective and important. Spent two tours in the 1960's: at Kontum with ARVN 22nd Division 63-64, and at Ankhe with 1st Cavalry Division 66-67. Memorable events include a motor movement from Kontum to Pleiku through Mang Yang/An Khe passes to Dieu Tri RR station, train down the coast to Ninh Hoa, and return a month later in early 1964; Civic action duties at Plateau Gi northeast of Kontum mid-64; and air cavalry combat operations on the Bong Son Plain Feb - Jun 1967 at Fire Bases Santana, English, Geronimo.
Posted by C.W.Raymond on April 13,2008 | 08:39 PM
Greetings David, Its always a pleasure reading your work. I played golf yesterday with Michael Mann form RMIT. He is in town for meetings with Chuck Feeney and his Bd. of Dir. Also a large contingent from UQ in Brisbane. All is well here in SF. I miss the contact with Chris Oechsli, but know he is doing whats necessary. Best regards to your wife as I love her work as well. Be well. Did you enjoy the book on Chuck's life? Bob
Posted by Bob Matousek on March 8,2008 | 12:45 PM
This brought back a lot of memories when I was in Kontum, Pleiku and Darlac. I want to go back to visit this trail someday.
Posted by Tien Hoang on March 5,2008 | 07:48 AM
Can anyone who knows Vietnam and the Vietnamese people believe this: "An elegantly dressed young woman" had "a live pig strapped to her motor scooter's rear rack," and In a fourth-grade class somewhere near the Ben Hai river, a teacher was using "power point" to teach history, and "sons and daughters of farmers, dressed in spotlessly clean white shirts and blouses, red ties, blue pants and skirts" greeted the author in unission in English, "Good morning and welcome, sir" What happened to the perceptive author of "Vietnam Now: A reporter returns" ?
Posted by hung nguyen on March 3,2008 | 06:02 PM
Very good article. My husband and I went along the Ho Chi Minh Trail in Laos in 1998/1999 walking over 700km along the Truong Son Mountains. We also completed the Ho Chi Minh Trail in Vietnam and for our sins we wrote a book on it. One question we did ask the commander of the Ho Chi Minh Trail, Lieutenant General Dong Si Nguyen, was – does the new Ho Chi Minh highway run along the route of the old Ho Chi Minh Trail? He said that the new highway location was chosen to be a delicate balance between the historic Ho Chi Minh Trail route and the need to open up new routes for the economy in the remote mountains villages. However, for simplicity if you follow route 14 and 15 as a tourist in Vietnam you will not be that far off the main areas.
Posted by Virginia Morris on March 3,2008 | 11:35 AM
I saw parts of all four Corps of, what was then, South Vietnam during my two tours as a USAF combat engineer (RED HORSE) from '68 through '71. Although ravaged by years of war, it was a very beautiful country even then. I would love to someday return and see the beauty of Vietnam at peace!
Posted by Al Maberry on February 28,2008 | 08:52 PM
I was stationed at II coreps hqs in '65. i was what they called a "pack rat". In oather words we carried our communicatikons equipment on our back and provide air support for the vn special forces, 82nd 10`1st and 173rd abrn. I saw more of II Corps than I would have liked to. As to wanting to go back for a visit. NEVER!!!!!! We webt iver as young kids and came home to vermin and curses about how we were treating the viet namese when we arrived in San Francisco. The only good thing was thqat when we boarded the plkane in TSN slow going and I just wanted OUT before an attack came. When I got up to the airplane off thge ramp, 6 stewardeswses were waiting there (and they were extremely beautiful), and each of them gave each of us a very lingerifng french kiss. Will never forget it.
Posted by Tom Wetherington on February 28,2008 | 04:42 PM
Former NVA Col. Tran Dau says, ""People in Saigon don't care anymore if their neighbor fought for the South or the North.... It's just a matter of history." Good for him, and for both sides. However, I wonder if the enraptured veterans of the Ho Chi Minh Trail ever realized that their war was one of aggression, and that both their and others' sacrifices were the product of the ideology that underlay that aggression. If one counts the costs throughout the region, to include the associated strife in Laos and Cambodia, those costs amounted to more than 3 million dead. However, as has been said, "History is written by the victors." Yet even with the Trail's role as an essential supply route, its own survival was "a near-run thing." Some years later, a retired U.S. Army Lt. General said he met a former Soviet official who had been in charge of providing the supplies the NVA needed to sustain their operations during the early 1970s. That official told him that, by the end, for every twelve units (of anything) that started down the Trail, just one made it to destination -- and that if the American bombing interdiction had continued just another few months, the Soviet Union would have "pulled the plug." So, fortunately for North Vietnam, the (Democratic-controlled) Congress of the U.S. "pulled the plug" first, leaving our South Vietnamese allies without their promised air support in case of a post-1973 Treaty violation, and thus the North's invasion of 1975 succeeded.
Posted by Jonathan Myer on February 27,2008 | 08:51 PM