Forbidden No More
As Beijing gets ready to host its first Olympics, a veteran journalist returns to its once-restricted palace complex
- By Paul Raffaele
- Smithsonian magazine, March 2008, Subscribe
(Page 3 of 4)
During the Qing dynasty (1644-1912), only Manchu girls were eligible to become the emperor's concubines. (Manchus, warlike nomads from the northern steppes, made up just 2 percent of China's population yet ruled the country.) Typically, the empress dowager—the emperor's mother—led the selection process. In a famous 18th-century Chinese novel, Dream of a Red Mansion, an imperial concubine reflects on her pampered servitude: "How much happier are those whose home is a hut in a field, who eat salt and pickles and wear clothes of cotton, than she is who is endowed with wealth and rank, but separated from her flesh and blood."
Passions and ambitions stewed in this world within a world. In Chinese lore, more than 200 concubines died on the orders of the 16th-century emperor Shizong. Seeking to end their misery, 16 members of his harem stole into his bedchamber one night to strangle him with a silken cord and stab him with a hairpin. The emperor lost an eye in the struggle, but the empress saved his life. Court executioners then tore the limbs from the concubines and displayed their severed heads on poles.
Concubines often developed close attachments to the eunuchs, whose role as royal servants in China long preceded the building of the Forbidden City. In his autobiography, Emperor Puyi wrote that eunuchs at the court "were most numerous during the Ming dynasty (1368-1644) when they reached a strength of 100,000," but that number had dwindled to about 3,000 by the time Puyi became emperor, in 1908. The eunuchs, castrated to prevent nonimperial pregnancies among the concubines, tended to know their master's weaknesses and were often willing to exploit them. "The emperor in many cases became the plaything of those pariahs from the normal world," writes Taisuke Mitamura in Chinese Eunuchs: The Structure of Intimate Politics. "They deftly colored for their own purposes the ruler's picture of the outside world and turned him against any ministers who tried to oppose their influence."
Most eunuchs had chosen their way of life, says Yuan. "It seemed a little thing to give up one pleasure for so many," an unnamed eunuch told the British Sinologist John Blofeld in City of Lingering Splendour, Blofeld's memoir of early 20th-century Beijing. "My parents were poor, yet suffering that small change, I could be sure of an easy life in surroundings of great beauty and magnificence; I could aspire to intimate companionship with lovely women unmarred by their fear or distrust of me. I could even hope for power and wealth of my own."
The eunuch Li Lienying aligned himself with China's most infamous concubine, Empress Dowager Cixi. Only the third ruling empress in China's two-millennium imperial history, Cixi was perceived as the power behind the Dragon Throne for some 47 years, until her death in 1908. Court gossip had it that she fell in love with Li Lienying, and that they conspired to murder her potential rivals; British journalists depicted her as a cunning, sexually depraved tyrant. But Sterling Seagrave writes in Dragon Lady, his 1992 biography of the empress, that "slandering Tzu Hsi (Cixi) became a literary game over the decades." Her reign coincided with the empire's tumultuous decline.
Cixi entered the Forbidden City as a concubine in 1851, at age 16, and delivered Emperor Xianfeng his only male heir five years later, Seagrave writes. After Xianfeng died in 1861, possibly from the effects of his extended debaucheries, her son, then 5, took the throne as Emperor Tongzhi; she was named an empress dowager and Tongzhi's co-regent. Tongzhi ruled as emperor for only two years before dying of smallpox or syphilis at age 18, and Cixi again served as regent—first when her 3-year-old nephew was named Emperor Guangxu, and again when, as an adult, he was nearly deposed for allying himself with a radical reform movement that failed. Just before she died in 1908, at age 72, Cixi arranged for Guangxu's nephew—her grandnephew—to be named the last emperor of China.
Her place in the Chinese imagination is suggested by the number of homegrown tourists I saw jockeying for camera position at a small stone well near the northern gate by the Palace of Peace and Longevity. The story goes that when European troops, in Beijing in 1900 to put down the Boxer Rebellion, threatened to attack the Forbidden City, Cixi summoned Guangxu and his favorite concubine, Zhen Fei, then ordered the palace evacuated. Zhen Fei begged for the emperor to stay behind and negotiate with the invaders. The empress, enraged at the so-called Pearl Concubine, ordered some eunuchs to get rid of her, which they supposedly did by throwing her down this well.
Seagrave writes that there is no evidence to support this "dark fable." And Cixi's great-great-nephew, Yehanara Gen Zheng, a Manchu nobleman, offers an alternative version. "The concubine was sharp-tongued and often stood up to Cixi, making her angry," he told me. "When they were about to flee from the foreign troops, the concubine said she'd remain within the Forbidden City. Cixi told her that the barbarians would rape her if she stayed, and that it was best if she escaped disgrace by throwing herself down the well. The concubine did just that." Whatever the truth—and from the size of the well I doubt both versions—Chinese visitors are drawn to it by the thousands.
Single Page « Previous 1 2 3 4 Next »
Subscribe now for more of Smithsonian's coverage on history, science and nature.









Comments (3)
what is forbidden no more, but it really is an interesting topic..........
Posted by shanautica ford on February 2,2011 | 02:18 PM
Twilight in the Forbidden City has been republished with all the original photographs and a bonus previously unpublished chapter of Johnston's meeting with the 13th Dalai Lama...
Great price at Amazon.com!
http://www.amazon.com/Twilight-Forbidden-City-Illustrated-revised/dp/0968045952/
A great read especially if you are interested in China!
Posted by Mark on April 17,2009 | 02:07 AM
I am sorry that potted histories like this one by Mr Raffaele will proliferate during the Olympic year in Beijing. What does it matter how many dragons were depicted throughout the Forbidden City? An irrelevance that the Palace Museum's Li Ji was right to shrug off. The Palace is extraordinary and its spaces and buildings among the most beautiful in the world. Fortunately my childhood home alongside ChingShan and opposite the northern gate of the Forbidden City, was close enough to allow me to explore it often as a child, between the years 1943 and 1949. Although Beijing was then occupied by the Japanese, the guards ignored me and I could wander there with my minder. It is indeed different now and has lost its silent splendor, becoming an entertainment centre. It has not been restored, it is being re-stroyed. Neither will Raffaele's journalistic facts and figures enlighten serious people. I strongly recommend reading Reginald F. Johnston's "Twilight in the Forbidden City" He was Emperor Puyi's tutor and spent years there when the place was still Imperial.
Posted by D'Alpoim Guedes on July 20,2008 | 11:29 PM
I really want to go to China this summer 4 u know what! This article was great! :) :]
Posted by Meg on March 10,2008 | 09:37 AM
I have been there twice with my Chinese wife.I am always amazed at the wonder of the Forbidden City,The stories about the Dragon Lady are great.As her 6 year old son ruled China she sat behind a silk certain and listened if she did not agree with the visitor she pulled a rope that was attached to a sword above the visitors head, consealed amongst silk scarves at the top of the tall ceiling.The visitor had to stand in a square marked on the floor in order to speak to the Emperor,this square was dead center of the swords drop. I wonder how many met there fate standing in that tiny square on the floor?? Robert Schlund & Lian Wen Ling Chongqing,China
Posted by Robert Schlund on March 10,2008 | 09:27 AM
I belive that it is wonderful that they are opening the forbindden city to the public. There is much history there that can be scholers can use to find more out about Chian magnificent past and if should be shared with the people of Chian after all it is there history and anserty to.
Posted by Emma Rose on February 26,2008 | 02:41 PM