The Changing Face of Bhutan
As the last Himalayan Buddhist kingdom cautiously opens itself to the world, traditionalists fear for its unique culture
- By Arthur Lubow
- Smithsonian magazine, March 2008, Subscribe
On rural highways in Bhutan, trucks hauling huge pine logs rush past women bowed beneath bundles of firewood strapped to their backs. In the capital of Thimphu, teenagers in jeans and hooded sweat shirts hang out smoking cigarettes in a downtown square, while less than a mile away, other adolescents perform a sacred Buddhist act of devotion. Archery, the national sport, remains a fervent pursuit, but American fiberglass bows have increasingly replaced those made of traditional bamboo. While it seems that every fast-flowing stream has been harnessed to turn a prayer drum inside a shrine, on large rivers, hydroelectric projects generate electricity for sale to India, accounting for almost half the country's gross national product.
A tiny nation of 700,000 people positioned uneasily between two giants—India to the south and China to the north—Bhutan was almost as isolated as the mythical realm of Shangri-La, to which it is still compared, until the early 1960s, when the first highway was constructed. Now in a sequence of carefully calibrated moves, the last independent Himalayan Buddhist kingdom has opened itself to the outside world, building better roads, mandating instruction in English for schoolchildren, establishing a television network and introducing Internet service. This month, citizens will conclude voting for a two-house parliament that will turn the country from a traditional monarchy into a constitutional one. The elections were mandated by the fourth king, Jigme Singye Wangchuck, before he abdicated in favor of his then 26-year-old son, Jigme Khesar Namgyel Wangchuck, at the end of 2006. Two political parties scrambled into existence after the decree.
And in another unusual move for the insular country, Bhutan is putting its rich culture on display in the United States in two major exhibitions. The first, which opened at the Honolulu Academy of Arts (February 23-May 23) and will travel to the Rubin Museum of Art in New York City and the Asian Art Museum in San Francisco, focuses on the country's sacred Buddhist art—not only painting and sculpture, but also ancient ritual dances, known as Cham, which are usually performed by monks to bless onlookers and impart Buddhist teachings. The second showcase is the annual Smithsonian Folklife Festival, to be staged this summer (June 25-29 and July 2-6) on the National Mall in Washington, D.C. It will include demonstrations of traditional Bhutanese dancing, weaving, metalworking, woodcarving and herbal medicine.
The two exhibitions are part of the centennial anniversary celebration of the nation's monarchy, which was founded on December 17, 1907. More important, Bhutanese leaders hope that the shows will raise awareness of the country's unique culture. "What is required of a small country with a small population is felt ever more strongly with all this globalization," says Dasho Penden Wangchuk, the Secretary of Home and Cultural Affairs. "We feel ourselves a drop in the ocean. And what do we need to survive? Our culture. You want to preserve a plant or the black-necked crane because they are endangered. But [people] are the highest form of living being. The world goes gaga over a particular variety of orchid, but here is a nation. Would you like to see Bhutan disappear?"
Like much of the country's early history, the origins of the name "Bhutan" are obscure; it may derive from Sanskrit words that mean "end of Tibet." Certain facts, however, are clear. Tantric, or Vajrayana, Buddhism—which employs esoteric techniques as a shortcut to enlightenment—took root in Bhutan in the eighth century through the efforts of the Indian sage Padmasambhava, who traveled widely in Tibet and Bhutan and is reverentially referred to as Guru Rinpoche, or "precious teacher." His influence is everywhere, not only in the many temples said to have been constructed by him and his followers, but also in contemporary jurisprudence. When I asked a former Bhutanese smoker why the country banned cigarette sales (a brisk black-market trade persists), I was told that tobacco is made of the ash of a demoness who was shattered into a thousand pieces when kicked by Guru Rinpoche's horse. Such stories probably began as parables for how Buddhism superseded the animist Bon religion in Bhutan. However, the old gods were never completely effaced. Even today, the Himalayas in Bhutan are regarded as deities, and the Bhutanese government forbids mountain climbing, which has attracted so many tourists to neighboring Nepal.
The leader who unified the country in the 17th century, Ngawang Namgyal, is revered today as a saint. Fleeing a power struggle in Tibet in 1616, he settled in western Bhutan, where his particular brand of Buddhism, known as the Drukpa school, was already well entrenched. The charismatic Zhabdrung ("at whose feet one submits"), as he is known, repelled Tibetan armies, subdued feudal lords within Bhutan and began the system of dzongs—the fortresses that combine religious and civil jurisdiction in each district. The characteristic style of Bhutanese architecture, with its bay windows and elevated, pitched roofs, as well as the country's religious rituals and unique dress style (the kimono-like gho for men and kira for women), stemmed from the Zhabdrung's desire to distinguish the country from its expansion-minded neighbor Tibet.
More than anything, though, Buddhism is central to Bhutan's identity. "We believe that Bhutan without Buddhism would not be Bhutan," said Lyonpo Ugyen Tshering, a former Secretary of Labor and Human Resources and now a candidate for the National Assembly. Bhutanese Buddhism flourished for centuries in relative isolation. But the modern world—particularly as seen on television, which arrived legally in the kingdom in 1999—has already produced some undesirable changes. "Acts of violence in the movies, which show so much fighting, have not been so good for our youth," Penden Wangchuk said. "We have had gang fights and youths fighting with each other. This is not a healthy thing. Bhutan stands for peace, tolerance and nonviolence."
Still, most of Bhutan's leaders seem to think that controlled contact with the outside world will be beneficial. Inaugurated in 1974, tourism has since grown steadily; in 2007, nearly 20,000 foreigners visited Bhutan. Travelers are required to make all arrangements through an approved tour operator and spend about $200 a day in the country. This "high-value, low-impact" tourism aims to avoid the experience of Nepal, where hordes of backpackers roam the country without spending much money.
Subscribe now for more of Smithsonian's coverage on history, science and nature.









Comments (11)
Slobbidy and his wife just got back after spending 2 weeks in Bhutan.He stated not only were the Bhutanese a very happy people but short in stature. (The Men approx.5'5")Slobbidys 6'2";he felt like giant.
Posted by Wag on November 24,2008 | 07:50 PM
Mr Wilson, Let me presume that you are not blind because you were able to see Mr infact Lynpo Thakur Singh Powdel at the smoithsonian festival. Or is it the sight of Lynpo Thakur that made you busy and had to look for other reasons for criticising Bhutan. Let me guess that in the process you missed the Lhotshampa dance that was performed on the stage. I think you know what "Lhotshampa" is since you seem to know too much about Bhutan. when a noble organizaton like smithsonian is doing a noble work, it is best that insignificant indiduals like us appreciate their effort.world will be better of without indiduals who try to instill chaos and in the society and indiduals who try to find sides on the egg.
Posted by Phuntsho on July 24,2008 | 12:07 PM
Mr Krishna Bajgai, you will have to ask the refugees why they are suffering, supposing they do from your comment. you would better get some idea on the background of the problem before you even raise such a sensitive issue.
Posted by Phuntsho on July 24,2008 | 11:31 AM
"Changing Face of Bhutan" is an appropriate topic for the Smithsonian seems to have joined the drukpas, a minority group in the entire demography of Bhutan, sucessfully display that it is purely a country of the drukpas. The festival was totally exclusive of the southern culture and traditons except for the physical presence of Mr. Thakur Singh Poudel, Education Minister. Like the United States, Bhutan has diversity of various groups with different cultural, traditional and linguistic differences more start and contrasting than the ones that appear among the various cultural groups in the US. Attempts by the Bhutanese government have been going on for the last one and half decades to paint Bhutan as culturally pure at the expence of excluding the other non-drukpa cultures of Bhutan. It is regretful that an organization like the Smithsonian has not not looked to respect this diversity of the Bhutanese people.
Posted by Wilson on July 7,2008 | 09:20 AM
what about the bhutanese refugees who are now spending a painful life in nepal and wants to return their own home i.e bhutan.and i want to know why they become a refugee.
Posted by krishna bajgai on July 1,2008 | 11:36 AM
I think its not true about the prosecution. No matter what religion the people of bhutan follow they still receive equal treatment.( eventhough the percentage of other religion is very low)
Posted by Tee Choden on June 26,2008 | 09:46 PM
Slight updates on what is happening in Bhutan after Arthur visit: 1. New government is formed after DPT swept 45 of 47 assembly seats, 2. Our beloved 5th King’s coronation will take place later this year, not in spring as mentioned in the article. 3. There is raise in tourist's tariff from 200 US$ now to 250 US$/day starting 2009.
Posted by Nyendra Wangchuk on June 20,2008 | 02:41 AM
This is in regard to the posting by Mert Hersberger on April 2. Followers of Christ nor followers of any other religion are not prosecuted in Bhutan. As far as I know they cannot proselytize.
Posted by Khensee wangmo on June 3,2008 | 08:48 PM
It always brings back fond memories of my studies at the University of Texas at El Paso, whenever I see photos of Bhutanese architecture. The UTEP campus had it all, down to massive stylized versions of prayer wheels carved out of stone next to the Student Union building. If more of the students were familiar with what those sculptures represented, maybe the wheels would have been more appreciated if installed next to the engineering center during finals. Edward Duarte, Civil Engineer, Class of 1983.
Posted by edward duarte on May 14,2008 | 05:23 PM
Bhutan is a more spiritual than any Christian country I ever been too. I too wish for freedom of religious expression, but please do not assume that Bhutanese do not have peace simply because they don't follow Christ.
Posted by C. Chumbley on April 7,2008 | 05:18 AM
I hope that the moves to democracy will open up the way for citizens to be more free to seek out the Creator and find peace with God. It is a shame that those who follow Christ still suffer persecution in a land where the former king considered the happiness index as a way of tracking the health of the nation. Perhaps Bhutanese Christians will soon have freedom to meet and worship more freely. Kindly and calmly,
Posted by Mert Hershberger on April 2,2008 | 11:28 PM
I've just returned from my second visit to Bhutan in 10 months. Where else do people from toddler to very senior citizen wave and smile at every vehicle that passes, where people say "thank you" when you take their photo (yes, no hand out for a tip), where bolders are hammered into large rocks, then to smaller rocks, and finally into gravel to build a road, where children can safely walk alone even on mountain roads? I only hope that commercialism will not infect the population.
Posted by DALE REDMOND on April 2,2008 | 10:00 AM
This was a very interesting article which was followed up by an article in my home town newspaper, the Pittsburgh Post Gazette by Mackenzie Carpenter. It turns out that a Pittsburgher sort of adopted Bhutan and helped them toward their road to democracy, even helping them design their first postage stamp. The article can be found at http://www.post-gazette.com/pg/08083/867092-35.stm.
Posted by Howard Swartz on March 23,2008 | 02:04 PM
An informative article. Thank you and warm regards
Posted by Barbara Godden Secord on March 13,2008 | 02:14 PM