Sleeping with Cannibals
Our intrepid reporter gets up close and personal with New Guinea natives who say they still eat their fellow tribesmen.
- By Paul Raffaele
- Photographs by Paul Raffaele
- Smithsonian magazine, September 2006, Subscribe
(Page 2 of 6)
As we pass through Yaniruma, I’m surprised that no Indonesian police officer demands to see the government permit issued to me allowing me to proceed. "The nearest police post is at Senggo, several days back along the river," Kembaren explains. "Occasionally a medical worker or official comes here for a few days, but they're too frightened to go deep into Korowai territory."
Entering the Korowai rain forest is like stepping into a giant watery cave. With the bright sun overhead I breathe easily, but as the porters push through the undergrowth, the tree canopy's dense weave plunges the world into a verdant gloom. The heat is stifling and the air drips with humidity. This is the haunt of giant spiders, killer snakes and lethal microbes. High in the canopy, parrots screech as I follow the porters along a barely visible track winding around rain-soaked trees and primeval palms. My shirt clings to my back, and I take frequent swigs at my water bottle. The annual rainfall here is around 200 inches, making it one of the wettest places on earth. A sudden downpour sends raindrops spearing through gaps in the canopy, but we keep walking.
The local Korowai have laid logs on the mud, and the barefoot porters cross these with ease. But, desperately trying to balance as I edge along each log, time and again I slip, stumble and fall into the sometimes waist-deep mud, bruising and scratching my legs and arms. Slippery logs as long as ten yards bridge the many dips in the land. Inching across like a tightrope walker, I wonder how the porters would get me out of the jungle were I to fall and break a leg. "What the hell am I doing here?" I keep muttering, though I know the answer: I want to encounter a people who are said to still practice cannibalism.
Hour melts into hour as we push on, stopping briefly now and then to rest. With night near, my heart surges with relief when shafts of silvery light slip through the trees ahead: a clearing. "It's Manggel," Kembaren says—another village set up by Dutch missionaries. "We'll stay the night here."
Korowai children with beads about their necks come running to point and giggle as I stagger into the village—several straw huts perched on stilts and overlooking the river. I notice there are no old people here. "The Korowai have hardly any medicine to combat the jungle diseases or cure battle wounds, and so the death rate is high," Kembaren explains. "People rarely live to middle age." As van Enk writes, Korowai routinely fall to interclan conflicts; diseases, including malaria, tuberculosis, elephantiasis and anemia, and what he calls "the khakhua complex." The Korowai have no knowledge of the deadly germs that infest their jungles, and so believe that mysterious deaths must be caused by khakhua, or witches who take on the form of men.
After we eat a dinner of river fish and rice, Boas joins me in a hut and sits cross-legged on the thatched floor, his dark eyes reflecting the gleam from my flashlight, our only source of light. Using Kembaren as translator, he explains why the Korowai kill and eat their fellow tribesmen. It's because of the khakhua, which comes disguised as a relative or friend of a person he wants to kill. "The khakhua eats the victim's insides while he sleeps," Boas explains, "replacing them with fireplace ash so the victim does not know he's being eaten. The khakhua finally kills the person by shooting a magical arrow into his heart." When a clan member dies, his or her male relatives and friends seize and kill the khakhua. "Usually, the [dying] victim whispers to his relatives the name of the man he knows is the khakhua," Boas says. "He may be from the same or another treehouse."
I ask Boas whether the Korowai eat people for any other reason or eat the bodies of enemies they've killed in battle. "Of course not," he replies, giving me a funny look. "We don't eat humans, we only eat khakhua."
The killing and eating of khakhua has reportedly declined among tribespeople in and near the settlements. Rupert Stasch, an anthropologist at Reed College in Portland, Oregon, who has lived among the Korowai for 16 months and studied their culture, writes in the journal Oceania that Korowai say they have "given up" killing witches partly because they were growing ambivalent about the practice and partly in reaction to several incidents with police. In one in the early '90s, Stasch writes, a Yaniruma man killed his sister's husband for being a khakhua. The police arrested the killer, an accomplice and a village head. "The police rolled them around in barrels, made them stand overnight in a leech-infested pond, and forced them to eat tobacco, chili peppers, animal feces, and unripe papaya," he writes. Word of such treatment, combined with Korowais' own ambivalence, prompted some to limit witch-killing even in places where police do not venture.
Still, the eating of khakhua persists, according to my guide, Kembaren. "Many khakhua are murdered and eaten each year," he says, citing information he says he has gained from talking to Korowai who still live in treehouses.
On our third day of trekking, after hiking from soon after sunrise to dusk, we reach Yafufla, another line of stilt huts set up by Dutch missionaries. That night, Kembaren takes me to an open hut overlooking the river, and we sit by a small campfire. Two men approach through the gloom, one in shorts, the other naked save for a necklace of prized pigs' teeth and a leaf wrapped about the tip of his penis. "That's Kilikili," Kembaren whispers, "the most notorious khakhua killer." Kilikili carries a bow and barbed arrows. His eyes are empty of expression, his lips are drawn in a grimace and he walks as soundlessly as a shadow.
The other man, who turns out to be Kilikili's brother Bailom, pulls a human skull from a bag. A jagged hole mars the forehead. "It's Bunop, the most recent khakhua he killed," Kembaren says of the skull. "Bailom used a stone ax to split the skull open to get at the brains." The guide's eyes dim. "He was one of my best porters, a cheerful young man," he says.
Bailom passes the skull to me. I don't want to touch it, but neither do I want to offend him. My blood chills at the feel of naked bone. I have read stories and watched documentaries about the Korowai, but as far as I know none of the reporters and filmmakers had ever gone as far upriver as we're about to go, and none I know of had ever seen a khakhua's skull.
The fire's reflection flickers on the brothers' faces as Bailom tells me how he killed the khakhua, who lived in Yafufla, two years ago. "Just before my cousin died he told me that Bunop was a khakhua and was eating him from the inside," he says, with Kembaren translating. "So we caught him, tied him up and took him to a stream, where we shot arrows into him."
Bailom says that Bunop screamed for mercy all the way, protesting that he was not a khakhua. But Bailom was unswayed. "My cousin was close to death when he told me and would not lie," Bailom says.
Single Page « Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 Next »
Subscribe now for more of Smithsonian's coverage on history, science and nature.









Comments (30)
I read this article, more than six years after it was first published. I wonder what changes (if any) have occurred in the Korowai lifestyle during the intervening period. My emotions are mixed about the author. Mr. Rafaele seems to lament the coming demise of this people's way of life, yet his own determination to go deep into their lands and reach a group which supposedly has never met a white person is the very catalyst to begin this process of cultural change....
Posted by Karen Herschell on September 9,2012 | 10:51 AM
do they have pets???????
Posted by natatia on June 27,2012 | 09:51 AM
Jonathan Kua, When Christ stated that we must eat of His body, and drink of His blood, but even though there is debate among different christian faiths regarding this, most, believe the try;th that Jesus was being figurative or at least meaning this discourse in a figurative sense; that much is obvious even to most casual readers. However, even those who are in error, believing they are actually eating and drinking Jesus' body and blood believe that the elements are changed supernaturally in a way that does not impart the sin of Cannibalism to them. Even if it were a cannibalistic act, which it is not, the command was regarding Christ alone; elsewhere believes are figuratively, and by implication litterally, warned against biting and devouring one another with covetousness. You are intentionally misrepresenting Christianity by using rhetoric to justify the sin and covetousness of both these people and yourself ; and you know it.
Posted by Chris on January 9,2012 | 03:44 PM
I have a pre WWII bow with flat bamboo string and 3 intric atly carved arrows, all different all arrows have intricatly carved wooden heads with bamboo shafts. Brought back by missionarries years ago. Would like to know value and sell.
Posted by Dan Thomas on January 2,2012 | 12:59 PM
This is sensational and exaggerated. It is not accurate. The author makes wild claims. Many people from other parts of Papua (formerly Irian Jaya and not PNG) and foreign people have been to the Korowai. I was in this area three years ago.
Posted by ambiang kobak on October 13,2011 | 04:50 PM
I am from West Papua, born and raised.
pateriot comments are good. Many times westerners moan about dying cultures and not changing them - so that we can remain museum curios? Years ago I was hunting with a village elder and he said to me, "Do the white people want us to stay the same forever? Do they think we are pigs to be left in the dirt? Why can we not want to have a better life? Without war? With medicine? Do they want to keep that all for themselves? Or do they want to keep us down so they can take our wealth for themselves."
Answer that all you who never want us to change. I mourn the loss of my culture. Many of my children are forgetting their ways and language. But only a fool wishes for the old days in which we constantly warred, suffered. Where a simple cut could mean death. Really? Thats wonderful? If you like it so much why do you make laws to protect people?
My people also ate others. But even amongst us there we others who said, "it is wrong to eat human flesh. They are our brothers."
It is funny that westerners have changed much over the centuries and still change. That is ok. But the naked black man in New Guinea? No, he must never change.
Yet it is good too to see people looking at my land and caring. Thank you
EYK
Posted by Elabo Kobak on October 12,2011 | 07:12 PM
For the ignorant American Paul, it is NOT Indonesian PNG, the country is correctly named Aryan Jaya. It is like calling Tibet, China! And FYI, the world's largest island is actually Australia, as technically it IS an island.
Posted by Rene on July 26,2011 | 10:57 AM
Whoever you are an anthropologist or whatever your field is, did you really find out why these people whom you so called westerners, civilized, breed of high intellegence etc etc find out why they practised canabalism? Were they looking for protein? Why they were so much food supply especially meat, wild pigs, snakes, fish, wallabies etc and yet they perfer to kill someone for human flesh? Was it a daily slaughtering as you would do it in your farms? Common, give us a break? When Jesus teaches that " If you do not eat my body and blood, you will have life," and his disciples in their secret house church celeberate holy communion, they were accused of being canibals, so you say you people from west do not have practiced such now you called it deplorable act? Give us a break. The practise is attached to religion and traditional belief systems. Work it out.
Posted by Jonathan Kua on June 10,2011 | 09:16 AM
Quite thrilling and enlightening story. Manu cultures have come and gone, but contact with "civilization" has brought more pain than gain to countless "primitive" peoples - American Indians, Australian Aborigines, and many many more to a lesser extent.
While you smugly bask in the glory for bringing Korowai culture to the "world", your visit is an additional nail in their culture's coffin.
Posted by Thaddaeus Rweyemamu on May 27,2011 | 04:01 AM
To Hildegarde, how can you be so judgmental? And, how can you be so stupid at the same time? Poligamy = murder and cannibalism??? First of all, in Poligamy, the people are married. That is all God requires. Was Abraham evil for having more than one wife? No...Fact is, the New Testament says for a bishop to have only one wife. Doesn't that suggest that the other disciples, Christians, can have 2 or more wives? Of course!!! But, trying to equate murder and cannibalsim with poligamy, stupid. War is not a crime in and of itself. Standing around and letting millions of people die would have been a crime and evil concerning the Jews. Stop with your judgmental attitudes...
Posted by Grasshopper on March 29,2011 | 02:42 AM
Many comments here focus largely on the Korowai cannibalistic culture. This article has so much more to tell, and I personally think it is an absolutely enticing and somewhat thrilling account of the diversities that remain within a world obsessed with modernities of the 21st century. These people are rooted to the core in historical beliefs, traditions and practices, and I hope these reach many future generations of Korowai. Fantastic. Thank you for sharing it.
Posted by Emma on February 9,2011 | 12:02 PM
The bit about Michael Rockefeller going missing near cannibalistic tribes is very misleading.He swam off in a river and didn't return...he either drowned or fell victim to a crocodile.Evidence for him being cannibalized was found to be circumstantial.
Posted by Oliver on February 4,2011 | 01:03 PM
Fascinating article. Paul Raffaele is amazingly brave.
Posted by Anon on January 26,2011 | 03:18 AM
Well, as Christians, you are very judgemental and your reporting is also a reflection of your judgemental state of mind.
ALL nations and cultures have had certain practices in their past lives, and some even still exist today, but no-one is reporting in a biased manner about those practices and rituals. Yes, it is sad that some tribes are practicing cannabalism. But how does that differ from for example polygamy? Polygamy is also wrong. I think, as Christians, we should be tolerable towards other cultures and their rituals. Once the people of such tribes decides on their own to become Christians, then one can only teach them to stop cannabalism.
What about all the war and famine resulting from it? Christians are easily ready to judge and make war, but does not see that as a crime? Really, change your mindset!
Let them be, the world needs mysteries. The world needs people who are brave enough to preserve their cultures, rites and rituals, and their government should do everything in their power to preserve it.
Posted by Hildegarde du Plessis on November 15,2010 | 03:51 AM
I find this very fascinating, and I hope they continue there ways. there cannibalism is fine, since its there way of life. It may not fit our way of life, but we kill non the less and have some cannibals in our society. At least there society is natural, and not artificial. In some ways I feel the grass is much greener on there side then on our side. Maybe someday I will visit there.
Posted by Stu on November 14,2010 | 07:44 PM
I would really applaud the "culture" of these savages if they could snack on the guts of all their psycho admirers that have posted here.
Posted by stenly on August 15,2010 | 10:52 PM
I grew up amongst the Kuka Kuka warriors of the Eastern Highlands District of Papua New Guinea in the 1960's. My parents were medical missionaries from the USA. In the early 60's the natives advised us that the only white man that they ate was a French missionary and he tasted like rotten milk. They preferred the flavor of their own. We were happy to let them know that we all tasted "rotten.
Posted by Tim Tuccelli on June 12,2010 | 01:06 AM
I throughly enjoyed this article and the people should be left alone to live there life the way they see it. The problem with the world today is that we poke our noses where they don't belong and are not wanted. Then we wonder why they hate us. God made us all different and we should just accept it.
Posted by Sharon on May 17,2010 | 03:49 PM
let them do their thing. if you don't like cannibalism, don't live there. if they want to learn about the modern world, let them. who are we to control the lives of others? we may not like they way they live, but they probably don't like the way we live either. who are we to say that our way is the right way? if you are criticizing the cannibals, you need to grow up.
Posted by teddy on March 28,2010 | 01:02 PM
This is horrible something must be done to save the lives of the people who are affected most by their cannibalism act.
Posted by TABITHA GITHU on January 12,2010 | 05:55 AM
I actually liked this report, but first,I was totally disgusted but thanks for explaining stuff so i've got a new understanding now.
Posted by Rianne Avighaelle Sialaanca Veilaianice on September 3,2009 | 10:17 AM
This is verying interesting and i am half PNG and after reading this i see another side of PNG i never knew before, at first i used to think ewww!! about the killing people but now i have a whole new understanding.
Posted by Tori Hanneford on August 7,2009 | 07:27 PM
Thank you for the story, it was absolutely reviting!! The loss of a culture to history is always very sad. We have no knowledge of the vast majority of cultures that have existed in the past. It has only been since the advent of writing that mankind has been able to document cultures and pass this knowledge down to us to any appreciable degree. We attempt to glean more through archeological means but truly only ever get a bare shadow of how life was and the people that lived. Although the loss of primitive cultures now are more significant because they are becoming increasingly rare, we are at the same time better able to document them and preserve their knowledge for posterity.
We wish to save these cultures in their primitive forms for our own benefits more then the benefits the people involved. We wish to keep them like a living museum or human zoo. The societies tend to be violent and butal with very high mortality rates. In this case the savagery even involves cannabalism. As the author rightly points out, many of the youth voluntarily leave for more civilized areas were they can find a better life. Should we allow these societies to fade away and disappear? In my opinion, the answer is a resounding yes! This is not to say that we should allow the culture to be lost forever. Every effort should be made to document the primitive cultures and societies before they are gone for good.
Someday perhaps my Grandson and the Grandson of a member of a native primitive tribe in New Guinea can sit across from each other while enjoying a good cup of coffee and cheap cigar. Both, happy with were they are in life and knowing were they came from!
Posted by pateriot on August 6,2009 | 08:02 PM
It is a wondeful work done by Mr.Raffaele .It is really amazing to know that cannibalism is still followed in this world.The narration gives a clear picture about the true lifestyle of Cannibals and also it brings out their values for life,culture and tradition.The narration made me feel that i am one among the travellers and i had the thrilling experience of being into a rainy dense forest.Through this article it has come to limelight that eventhough the world is taken over by advanced civilizations and modern practices there are people who live far enough not to have an impact of these developments..."THREE CHEERS" to the brave author for giving us a valuable note on our fellowmen who resembles us in physique but are still with the stone age culture,character and tradition!!!!!!!!!!!!
Posted by Thangalakshmi Ramakrishnan on February 27,2009 | 04:54 PM
Mr.Raffaele is a person with alot of courage. this article is an inspiration to me,as i do believe in cannibalism. in my country India, i have seen a group of holymen feeding on corpses.it is their believe by doing so they become ageless. in near future i would like to meet other tribes who do practice cannibalism.
Posted by Sayantan Das on October 30,2008 | 06:54 AM
do you have a web site that i can join about this stuff? i find this stuff very interesting.
Posted by bluedemond on October 19,2008 | 09:42 PM
Mr. Raffaele is far braver than anyone I know. I hope he is able to recuperate fully and can write many more interesting stories.
Posted by Colette Shannon on July 16,2008 | 03:29 AM
It is truly amazing to read of such an interesting insight of a culture far away from modern day civilization. No matter what their value systems are, it is definitely praiseworthy to note that not everyone is trying to ape the world in terms of being attracted to all its gadgets, gizmos and beliefs. And last but not the least, kudos to such a brave author for allowing us to have a peek at something like this.
Posted by Neel Das on July 10,2008 | 03:17 PM
i like the picture and words. your the best article writer ever.
Posted by amanda on June 10,2008 | 04:59 PM
Cannibalism is one of the worst crimes that can be committed towards a human being. Although this story is highly interesting, we can see that these people do not believe they are killing humans but another creature. It is for the benefit of all humans that this way of life becomes history, and i hope it will.
Posted by jamilah on June 2,2008 | 07:02 AM
I wish these indigenous people could be taught the error of cannibalism while retaining the other wonderful aspects of their culture. I can never believe that cannibalism is acceptable anywhere in the world, in any people group, at any time. I think that the practice should be stopped.
Posted by Julie on May 22,2008 | 10:43 PM
Hello All, An extremely interesting read, I in turn have decided to hike into the heartlands of this country. I'm departing November, and am planning on hiking into this trecherous territory. Please email me closer details on the location of them, and the nearest civilised town for hiking thanks. Kalki French, Djmad722@Hotmail.com
Posted by Kalki French on April 23,2008 | 07:17 AM
What a truly facsinating and factual read!It is sad to think that there way of life could very easily be destroyed and become part of history. However fascinating they could be and however many treasures we could find amongst tribes like the Korowai do we ever stop to think that we could be doing more harm than good by disturbing them and wanting more!
Posted by Jo on March 26,2008 | 08:37 PM
Such is the way of life. It fiercely perpetuates itself, only to be vanquished by time. Mr. Raffaele, I enjoyed your article and photography. Thank you for making me 'feel' the presence of your experience. Sounds like a 'one in a lifetime offer'. Thank you Smithsonian!
Posted by Ife (ee-faye) on March 25,2008 | 10:51 PM
It pains me to here of another people who are going to loose their way of life. Hopefully at least the elders in the tribe will be dead and gone before civilization destroys their world. What a sad situation !
Posted by DENISE on February 11,2008 | 11:30 AM
This is very interesting, and exciting! Is it possible to contact the author, Paul Raffaele, to ask some further questions? I would like to write my anthropology paper on cannibalism that is still being practiced and this tribe really speaks to me. Thanks for a true report on the subject without unneccesary disgust or jugement. Holly
Posted by Holly on January 28,2008 | 01:15 PM
"The Free Papua Movement (OPM) is widely believed to be the core of opposition to the Indonesian Government in West Irian. But it is difficult to track down the OPM as an organization, although not because its security is tight or people unwilling to talk. On the contrary, everyone talks about the OPM; it has few, if any, secrets, and many Irianese proudly proclaim they are "members" of the OPM. A foreigner travelling in West Irian has no difficulty in contacting anti-government activists. They stop you on the street and groups of them gather around when you visit a native village; in short, no one is reluctant to discuss the OPM and their reasons for disliking Indonesians." "The OPM, however, does represent an amorphous mass of anti-Indonesia sentiment. Card-carrying members of the OPM as such must be few, although partisans claim that it has anywhere from 1500 to 5000, oe even 500,000 members." "Regarding the magnitude of the opposition to Indonesian rule, probably a decided majority of the Irianese people, and possibly 85 to 90 percent, are in sympathy with the Free Papua cause or at least intensely dislike Indonesians." - U.S. Ambassador Francis Galbraith 1969.
Posted by Andrew Johnson on January 24,2008 | 05:27 PM