Morocco's Extraordinary Donkeys
The author returns to Fez to explore the stubborn animal's central role in the life of this desert kingdom
- By Susan Orlean
- Photographs by Eric Sander
- Smithsonian magazine, September 2009, Subscribe
The donkey I couldn't forget was coming around a corner in the walled city of Fez, Morocco, with six color televisions strapped to his back. If I could tell you the exact intersection where I saw him, I would do so, but pinpointing a location in Fez is a formidable challenge, a little like noting GPS coordinates in a spider web. I might be able to be more precise about where I saw the donkey if I knew how to extrapolate location using the position of the sun, but I don't. Moreover, there wasn't any sun to be seen and barely a sliver of sky, because leaning in all around me were the sheer walls of the medina—the old walled portion of Fez—where the buildings are so packed and stacked together that they seem to have been carved out of a single huge stone rather than constructed individually, clustered so tightly that they blot out the shrieking blue and silver of the Moroccan sky.
The best I can do is to say that the donkey and I met at the intersection of one path that was about as wide as a bathmat and another that was slightly larger—call it a bath sheet. The Prophet Muhammad once counseled that the minimum width of a road should be seven cubits, or the width of three mules, but I would wager that some of Fez's paths fall below that standard. They were laid out in the late eighth century by Idriss I, founder of the dynasty that spread Islam in Morocco, and they are so narrow that bumping into another person or a pushcart is no accident; it is simply the way you move forward, your progress more like a pinball than a pedestrian, bouncing from one fixed object to the next, brushing by a man chiseling names into grave markers only to slam into a drum maker stretching goat skin on a drying rack, then to carom off a southbound porter hauling luggage in a wire cart.
In the case of my meeting the donkey, the collision was low-impact. The donkey was small. His shoulders were about waist-high, no higher; his chest was narrow; his legs straight; his hooves quite delicate, about the size of a teacup. He—or she, perhaps—was donkey-colored, that is, a soft mouse gray, with a light-colored muzzle and dark brown fur bristling out of its ears. The televisions, however, were big—boxy tabletop sets, not portables. Four were loaded on the donkey's back, secured in a crazy jumble by a tangle of plastic twine and bungee cords. The remaining two were attached to the donkey's flanks, one on each side, like panniers on a bicycle. The donkey stood squarely under this staggering load. He walked along steadily, making the turn crisply and then continuing up the smaller path, which was so steep that it had little stone stairs every yard or two where the gain was especially abrupt. I caught only a glimpse of his face as he passed, but it was utterly endearing, all at once serene and weary and determined. There may have been a man walking beside him, but I was too transfixed by the sight of the donkey to remember.
This encounter was a decade ago, on my first trip to Fez, and even amid the dazzle of images and sounds you are struck with in Morocco—the green hills splattered with red poppies, the gorgeous tiled patterning on every surface, the keening call from the mosques, the swirl of Arabic lettering everywhere—the donkey was what stayed with me. It was that stoic expression, of course. But even more, it was seeing, in that moment, the astonishing commingling of past and present—the timeless little animal, the medieval city and the pile of electronics—that made me believe that it was possible for time to simultaneously move forward and stand still. In Fez, at least, that seems to be true.
Just a mile outside Casablanca's Mohammed V Airport, on the side of a four-lane high-speed roadway, underneath a billboard for a cellular service provider, a dark-brown donkey ambled along, four huge sacks filled to bursting strapped to a makeshift harness on its back. I had been back in Morocco for less than an hour. My recollection already felt concrete—that there were donkeys everywhere in the country, that they operated like little pistons, moving people and things to and fro, defying the wave of modernity that was washing gently over the country—and that the television donkey of Fez had not been just an odd and singular anecdote.
On my first trip to Morocco, I had seen the television donkey and then countless more, trudging through Fez with loads of groceries, propane tanks, sacks of spices, bolts of fabrics, construction material. When my trip was over and I returned home, I realized I had fallen in love with donkeys in general, with the plain tenderness of their faces and their attitude of patient resignation and even their occasionally baffling, intractable moods. In the United States, most donkeys are kept as pets and their pessimism seems almost comical. In Morocco, I knew that the look of resignation was often coupled with a bleaker look of fatigue and sometimes despair, because they are work animals, worked hard and sometimes thanklessly. But seeing them as something so purposeful—not a novelty in a tourist setting but an integral part of Moroccan daily life—made me love them even more, as flea-bitten and saddle-sore and scrawny as some of them were.
The medina in Fez may well be the largest urbanized area in the world impassable to cars and trucks, where anything that a human being can't carry or push in a handcart is conveyed by a donkey, a horse or a mule. If you need lumber and rebar to add a new room to your house in the medina, a donkey will carry it in for you. If you have a heart attack while building the new room on your house, a donkey might well serve as your ambulance and carry you out. If you realize your new room didn't solve the overcrowding in your house and you decide to move to a bigger house, donkeys will carry your belongings and furniture from your old house to your new one. Your garbage is picked up by donkeys; your food supplies are delivered to the medina's stores and restaurants by mule; when you decide to decamp from the tangle of the medina, donkeys might carry your luggage out or carry it back in when you decide to return. In Fez, it has always been thus, and so it will always be. No car is small enough or nimble enough to squeeze through the medina's byways; most motorbikes cannot make it up the steep, slippery alleys. The medina is now a World Heritage site. Its roads can never be widened, and they will never be changed; the donkeys might carry in computers and flat-screen televisions and satellite dishes and video equipment, but they will never be replaced.
I am not the first American woman to be fascinated by the working animals of the medina. In 1927, Amy Bend Bishop, wife of eccentric, wealthy gallery owner Cortlandt Field Bishop, passed through Fez on a grand tour of Europe and the Mediterranean, and was intrigued by the 40,000 donkeys and mules working at the time. She was also disturbed by their poor condition, and she donated $8,000—the equivalent of at least $100,000 today—to establish a free veterinary service in Fez. The service was named the American Fondouk—"fondouk" is Arabic for inn—and after a stint in temporary quarters the clinic opened up in a whitewashed compound built around a shaded courtyard on the Route de Taza, a busy highway just outside the medina, where it has operated ever since. The Fondouk has become well known in Fez, even among the animals. Dozens of times creatures have shown up at the Fondouk's massive front gate, unaccompanied, needing help; just days before I arrived, for instance, a donkey having some sort of neurological crisis stumbled in on its own. It is possible that these wanderers were left at the door by their owners before the Fondouk opened in the early morning, but Fez and Morocco and the American Fondouk all seem to be magical places, and after spending even a few hours in Fez, the idea that animals find their own way to the Fondouk's shady courtyard doesn't seem unlikely at all.
Subscribe now for more of Smithsonian's coverage on history, science and nature.









Comments (35)
Eleanor Hoffmann discovered Morocco in 1927. Her first juvenile story was published by Thomas Nelson and was about a donkey who eventually ended up at the Fondouk. It was titled Melika and her Donkey.
Posted by Caroline Williams on June 20,2012 | 03:11 PM
My son and I were disheartened to see the cruelty of dunkeys, cats and dogs in Morocco. There need to be a school of Veterinarians that are willing to do a good deed and have the cats and dogs spayed and neutered to stop the reproduction. They are also in dire need of medical attention, with bruises and cuts being untreated. It is not enough to post pictures of these poor animals. Lets do something about it!
Posted by on June 28,2011 | 07:29 PM
After having raised donkeys, or, asses, as they are referred to in the Bible, the article brought back memories, very dear memories of our herd which once numberd about sixty. All were dear friends, and part of our family. They came in many sizes from nine hands to fourteen hands in height. Most amazing was just how much work each one could do relative to their sizes, whether they were doing draft work or were carrying loads. We learned that they can carry fifty percent of their weight. No need to worry if the load was too heavy, or unbalanced. In such instances they would not move. Once the matter was corrected they would perform tasks asked of them. Once tired they stopped, and rested. So sad that humans would interperet such as their being stubborn rather than as a show of intelligence. All were grand friends, kind, gentle, watchful, sure footed. It is no surprise the the author would have liked to have had one of her own. She had better move out of New York City to the more pristine areas of New York State where she could have members of that noble species. They would,very soon, become as dear to her as her own chlldren.
Dana Allison
Posted by Dana Allison on June 25,2011 | 08:53 PM
Have read most of the comments about donkeys and feel for them greatly. However, we can do something as well as holding up Amy Bend Bishop as the lovely benefactor that she was.
I am sure if you look there will be a donkey rescue site in most capital cities. Small gifts are usually very well received.
Posted by valerie on March 29,2011 | 11:16 PM
Great story about the donkeys. I was born in Morocco, and have felt sorry for the poor creatures ever since I was a child (especially the hard working ones in the Fez medina). I am so glad to read that some manage to find their own way to the American Fondouk! I always wanted to adopt a baby donkey, or a baby dromedary, but my parents never let me!
Kitty Morse, author
Cooking at the Kasbah: Recipes from my Moroccan Kitchen
www.kittymorse.com
Posted by Kitty Morse on February 5,2010 | 11:27 PM
Lovely story. I personally know the Vet who looks after these animals and they are very lucky to have such a caring vet. He is a fantastic vet as well as a human being. He always has time for his patients, 4 legged and 2 legged.
I remember my husband getting transferred to the States from Canada, and seriously, the only person I regretted leaving was my vet, but, in fact, he took this position the same time that we left Montreal. I have not seen him for 15 years, but I can tell you that I miss him and his humour.
Posted by Donna Crossley on January 6,2010 | 07:03 PM
Thank you for the wonderful article! I was a Peace Corps volunteer in Taza, Morocco and have many fond memories of the donkeys there. They always seemed so patient and hard-working and were not very well treated. I always wished I could do something for them, and am very glad to hear about the American fondouk that is doing so much for the donkeys and other animals. Great story!!
Posted by Laura on December 28,2009 | 06:03 PM
LOVED your article,it broke my heart when I remembered seeing those poor animals carrying all those heavy loads.
Donkeys have been my favourite animal since I was a child.I was brought up in Alexandria,Egypt.On summer vacations, we would go to our farm.The first thing I used to do was run and kiss my little Donkey.I saw her beautiful...those long eyelashes,those big sad eyes, mesmerised me.
I live in NC now and have a donkey shrine.A picture of my donkey and myself at age 10.3 donkey statues,one (carried all the way from Italy)ceramic,2 ceramic donkeys from South Africa.All topped with water colour paintings of Donkeys.Also on another table a silver one from Marocco and a Baccara from France. Donkeys are not stubborn,they just know what they do not want to do.They are determined,hard working and loyal.Dislike the phrase "stuborn like a mule or donkey".
Posted by Jihan El Shayeb on October 5,2009 | 07:01 PM
Many thanks to author Susan Orlean and photographer Eric Sander for reviving fond memories of our family’s visit to Morocco in 1992. During our six-year assignment in Port Gentil, Gabon (French Equatorial Africa), we had the opportunity to visit a dozen or so countries on the African continent – none more memorable than our tour of Morocco and her four royal cities.
Dragging our 2-1/2 year old son and 6-year old daughter up and down the crowded and narrow walkways of Fez’s medina seemed insurmountable until our guide, Mohammed suggested hiring a donkey. After a brief departure, Mohammed returned with “Gray” (our name for the sturdy, gentle creature) who would cost us the equivalent of $15 for the day. “Not bad” I thought as we folded up our wheeled stroller and began strapping it and our children onto Gray’s back. “One problem” Mohammed took us aside and whispered. “You must hire the driver for the day, too”.
“Here’s the pinch” we thought as visions of our souvenir shopping trip dimmed, “how much for the driver”? Obviously of lesser importance than the donkey, the driver cost us only $10 bucks for the day. We took Mohammed and his wife to a nice, local restaurant for dinner (complete with belly dancers) as a way of thanking him for his service and friendship during our 4-day visit. He reciprocated by having us all to his home for couscous on Friday.
Spencer Harris, Shafter, California
Posted by Spencer Harris on September 27,2009 | 01:00 PM
Great story. My father was stationed in Kenitra for two years in the early 70's. He insisted we live in town. We also traveled everywhere. Including Fez. The donkeys were not only funny but a cultural experience. As were the food and the people. Good to see that some things will never change. PS to Al about the smell. Some places in this country smell worse.
Posted by Bill on September 26,2009 | 11:19 PM
To Ms Orlean, I realy enjoyed your artcle on the donkeys of Morrocco. To see what donkeys can do and do in the US,
I invite you to look at my website;
BUTTERNUTRIDGEDONKEYS.COM
Here are photos of our guys visitig in hospitas, nursing homes, ARC sites etc.
The donkeys seem to know what is being asked of them and make great contact with patients and staff. We have several stories of people coming up and out of silence to touch and feel the healing cotact.
Please let me know what you think, thanks ken p
Posted by Rev. Dr. Ken Parker on September 25,2009 | 10:49 PM
Great article, but it left out what happens to the waste from 40,000 donkeys that is dropped every day all over the city? If the donkeys do a dump twice a day that's 80,000 piles plus all the sheep, mules, dogs, etc. And it must rain sometime.. That city must stink, yet not a word in the story. Phewwww!!! Have a nice day, Al
Posted by Al on September 15,2009 | 10:16 AM
I loved this article. I was especially touched by the veterinay service - how the animals that appear to arrive of their own accord! What a meaningful and noble pursuit. My husband is a veterinarian and I have him reading this article as well. I hope to visit the city and the clinic one day soon. Thank you for a wonderfully written piece. I enjoyed it thoroughly.
Posted by Natalie on September 12,2009 | 11:06 AM
i loved the article. i lived in morocco for two years and traveld around the country a great deal. your article took me back as my wife and i did in 07. she thought all the donkeys looked sad and the sheep and goats looked as though they were to closely related. we in america have animals in our families s pets......in morocco life is not so easy on man or beast. keep up the good work. i enjoy the mag.
dan hayden
Posted by dan hayden on September 9,2009 | 01:00 AM
Susan.
I loved your story about the donkeys in Morocco.
Would like to second the motion that you should write a screenplay about them. Having delighted in "The Orchid Thief" and the fascinating movie that came out of it, I know there is an opportunity there for a terrific movie.
I hope you do find your own donkey, will be waiting to hear more.
Posted by Roxane on September 9,2009 | 10:01 AM
Susan and Eric, Congratulations on a fine article with excellent photos each of which brought back memories of our visit to Morocco and specifically of our walkabouts in the Fez Medina in March of this year. In the Medina and in the countryside we experienced a bit of the working life of the people and of the omnipresent ever patient donkeys. Had we known of the Fondouk we surely would have paid it a visit. We look forward to reading your next travel article with yet more well chosen photos.
Posted by Ron Slivka on September 9,2009 | 08:15 AM
I LIVED FOR TWO YEARS IN MOROCCO, TRAVELED ALL OVER THE COUNTRY, AND RETURNED WITH MY (american) WIFE FOR THREE WKS IN 07. SHE ALWAYS THOUGHT THE DONKEYS LOOKED SAD AND THE GOATS AND SHEEP WERE TO CLOSELY RELATED. I'VE SEEN ALL THE USUAL USES OF DONKEYS-PULLING PLOWS, CARTS, WATERWELL OPERATION, AND OF COURSE PERSONNAL TRANSPORTION...THE ARTICLE WAS GREAT-IT GIVES THE NON-TRAVELER A VERY GOOD LOOK AT THE COUNTRY ITSELF AND ONE OF ITS MAJOR FORMS OF TRANSPORTATION-----MOROCCO-ITS PEOPLE-THE DONKEYS AND YOUR MAGAZINE ARE GREAT...I LOVE IT ALL. DAN HAYDEN
Posted by dan hayden on September 7,2009 | 12:08 AM
Wonderful article. Brought back fond memories. In a casbah in Fez, we met a donkey loaded with (what appeared to be) hundreds of freeshly tanned sheep hides. They were headed for a hillside to be spread for drying.
The casbah was an interesting place centered about a sloping covered three donkey wide street. Within the complex was a sheep slaughter house, a brassworking shop, and many other stores.
A tiny three year old girl was wandering alone amid the traffic. She obviously knew her way. She impressed our ladies.
Fez is an ancient city and the site of ther first Arab universitry. The "Fez" is the symbol of a scholar.
Posted by Bob Backlund on September 7,2009 | 05:35 PM
Very nice!
Posted by V. Acoutin on September 6,2009 | 12:08 PM
What a fascinating article! The donkeys work amazingly hard, unlike my two Sicilian donkeys, Paco & Luigi, who have never carried an ounce on their little backs! I'm really happy to hear about the existence of the American Fondouk. I hope Susan Orlean gets to one day experience living with a donkey of her own- but please be sure to make that TWO donkeys- a lone donkey is a sad donkey and there's nothing like the sight of two donkeys happily running and playing together. Thanks for writing an eye-opening article!
Posted by Diana on September 5,2009 | 12:30 AM
I love donkeys!
What do you call a cold donkey?
A brrrrrro
Posted by Suzy McMinn on September 5,2009 | 08:09 PM
Annie of Oklahoma might also have noted that donkeys often serve the sheep farmer as a guardian of that precious, wool-laden commodity! While many may keep donkeys as pets, many farmers are comforted knowing that those braying donkeys with teeth bared at the sight of a coyote (donkeys have an inherent dislike of coyotes and all canines) stand sentinel each night and day. Donkey rescue organizations exist to connect farmers with an abused or neglected donkey desperately seeking a pasture. Thank you for this compelling story of the Moroccan donkeys.
Posted by Janet once of the wind-swept plains and now of the East Coast on September 5,2009 | 07:25 PM
Thank you "Three Mules" for your reality check. I was sad after reading this article in the waiting room of my dentist's office the other day. But your witty comment has lightened my heart.
Posted by Donna on September 5,2009 | 07:25 PM
Thank you for this article! It is wonderfully written and brought back a lot of memories of my study abroad in Morocco two years ago.
I lived for part of my study abroad in a very, very small rural village in central Morocco with a family who had a donkey. That donkey indeed performed innumerable, valuable tasks for the family, including fetching very heavy loads of water from the well, carrying back thorny scrub brush for firewood, and amusing my 6 year old homestay brother and his young cousins--all with flies in its eyes.
They are wonderfully patient, endearing, and enduring animals, and I appreciated seeing them recognized in this article.
One last note, I think you would find the American flag also flying at the American Legation in Tangier. It was our first property abroad, as Morocco was the first country to recognize the young U.S. of A! It is one of the U.S.'s only national historic landmark buildings located outside of the United States.
Thanks again!
Posted by Alison on September 5,2009 | 11:52 AM
I imagined your every experience, from walking the narrows streets and finding the incredible hard working Donkey carrying the televisions, to the very last experience at the market. I felt and imagined myself as one of the spectators, I even felt emotional towards the young H’mar at the market being sold. I imagined, that maybe it would have been sort like an animal fairytale, if you would have bought the Donkey and offered a happy ending without the hard labor. Thanks for taking me on such a trance into the Moroccan life of a Donkey.
Posted by Alexa on September 4,2009 | 03:21 PM
Thank you for the article which I enjoyed greatly. I have one remark though concerning describing Morocco as a desert kingdom which is inaccurate. Eventhough tourists have this idea about Morocco, yet in real life it is an agricultural country where exists the largest fertile land and forests in the Arab world, the largest mountain range and the second talest mountain in north Africa. In some places its reaches 48c° and in others -30c°. In fact the diversity in Morocco is phenomenon. In one or two hours car drive you can move from sand dunes to snow covered mountains and ski resorts to mildly sunny and prestine beaches. Also, the biodiversity in Morocco is only second to turkey in the whole Mediteranean region. Thats why describing Morocco as a waste land would be unfair.
regards
Posted by Ali on September 4,2009 | 07:23 AM
What a lovely article.
It made me think of the wonderful travel book, "The Donkey Inside", by Ludwig Bemelmans.
Posted by Mitch Kemp on September 2,2009 | 05:56 PM
I was amused and fascinated by Susan Orlean's recount of her expirience in Morrocco with the steadfast, dutiful donkeys that keep commerce humming. As I was reading, I could visualize a wonderful and humorous Disney or Pixar animated feature based on the Fondouk and donkey society there. She should consider writing a screenplay and submitting it for that purpose.
Posted by Kathleen Dahm on September 2,2009 | 09:04 AM
Denys Frappier is one of my heroes. I live an hour from Fez and have taken my animals there many times over the 13 years I've lived here. I always marvel at the menagerie in the courtyard and the remarkable care that each patient receives from Denys, Fatima, or one of the many interns from myriad countries (a team of Czech vet students watched over my dying cat). The donkeys are indeed remarkably resilient and attractive creatures. So glad you chose to honor them and those who care for them in this article.
Posted by Karen on August 29,2009 | 05:28 PM
I loved reading Susan Orlean's article "Where Donkeys Deliver". I am privileged to share my life with a non-working Sicilian donkey here in the U.S. and I know first hand the "endearing" look Susan mentions. I am happy to know that the Donkeys in Morocco have the American Fondouk and Dr. Frappier looking after them.
These little beasts of burden are so wrapped up in history and gazing into their eyes is a clear reflection of that.
Posted by Karen on August 28,2009 | 11:24 AM
What a wonderful story of your experience with donkeys in Morocco. Six years ago, I observed and watched donkeys in Multan in Pakistan working the fields. The owner would load all the hay he could on the back of a donkey and send it down the road alone, to another port, where it was met by another family member. This donkey walked several miles to its destination. I looked for miles around and saw nothing but fields of grain growing and one lonely donkey carrying its goods to another farm. Growing up in USA, as a child we were taught that donkeys and mules are dumb animals. Now, that I have seen how they can be trained and how hard they work all day; I have to disagree with this analysis. I marveled at the amount of work load they can carry. This animal is vital in many parts of the world helping with transportation of goods and services. This was a beautiful story. I too, hope next year I will be able to visit this beautiful country. Thanks for the memories. Annie of Oklahoma
Posted by Annie on August 27,2009 | 02:02 PM
How wonderful to have it all put together so well.
I visited Fez 25 years ago and marveled at the narrow streets and souks where a man worked whose great grandfather was in the same souk.
Our guide had to leave to visit a family member in the hospital and a friend continued our tour. About 1 1/2 hours later he rejoined us. How he found us I will never know.
Guides on rebates from purchases so the more you buy, the happier they are. I bought a dozen rugs, bags (the leather was still ripe) and a table and a donkey carried them all back to the Palais Jamais.
Thank you for the memories.
Posted by Quentin on August 25,2009 | 03:28 PM
Lady, The roads are narrow for 2 reasons: Air conditioning (cool in the alleys desert hot outside in summer) and security (try to take over the city and advance on foot with sword in tight alleys). You should not have trusted the donkey when he told you the Koran says alleys should be 3 mules wide.
Posted by 3 mules on August 23,2009 | 08:48 AM
I read your article even though it is quite long. I enjoyed every bit o f it because I love donkeys.
I am Moroccan and I have seen them working at my grandma's farm when I was a child.
It is true that the animals of the farm were never pets but they were all treated with respect and humanity because they were the survival of the family. They produce the food and the money to buy it.
I consider donkeys to be very noble. They are goal oriented and hard working and if something is not of their liking good luck making them do it.
Thank you for a delightful reading.
Posted by Fatima on August 22,2009 | 11:16 AM
Thanks for the great story!
I come from the city, and I know what you are talking about :).
One comment:
When you say "The Koran actually specifies the ideal width of a road—seven cubits, or the width of three mules", please provide the corresponding reference to where is this stated in the Koran. I am not aware of such specification, and I am not sure if that really exists in the Koran. If this specification exists at all, I think it'll probably exist as a saying of the prophet Mohamed, but that is not to be confused with the Koran. Anyways, a reference to the right underlying verse or saying would be better and more accurate:).
Regards.
Posted by Fayssal on August 22,2009 | 10:20 AM