Finding Serenity on Japan's San-in Coast
Far from bustling Tokyo, tradition can be found in contemplative gardens, quiet inns and old temples
- By Francine Prose
- Photographs by Hans Sautter
- Smithsonian magazine, September 2009, Subscribe
(Page 3 of 4)
Our capable companion, Chieko Kawasaki—many of the smaller Japanese cities and towns provide volunteer English-speaking guides through the municipal tourist bureaus, if you contact them in advance—explains the many superstitions associated with the castle. According to one, construction was plagued by problems until workers discovered a skull pierced by a spear; only after the skull was given a proper ceremonial burial did the building proceed smoothly. And as we stand on the top level, looking out over Lake Shinji, Chieko tells us that the island in the middle of the lake—Bride Island—is believed to have sprung up when a young wife, mistreated by her mother-in-law, decided to return to her family via a shortcut over the frozen lake. When the ice melted unexpectedly and she fell through and drowned, a goddess took pity on her and turned her into an island.
As Chieko speaks, I find myself thinking again of Lafcadio Hearn, and of the delight he took in hearing—and recording—such stories. In his essay "The Chief City of the Province of the Gods," Hearn repeats the tale, which he calls "The Island of the Young Wife." His summary is an abbreviated version of what Chieko has just told us. Perhaps the myth has continued to evolve and grow over the intervening decades, and perhaps it is as alive today as it was in Hearn's time, and in the centuries before that.
Hearn's former house and the museum next door, at the base of the castle hill, are located in an old samurai neighborhood. At the Hearn Museum, as at Izumo-taisha, we again find ourselves among pilgrims. Only this time they are fellow pilgrims. A steady parade of Japanese visitors files reverently past vitrines containing a range of memorabilia, from the suitcase Hearn carried with him to Japan to handsome copies of first editions of his books, photographs of his family, his pipes and the conch shell with which he allegedly called his servants to relight his pipe, letters in his idiosyncratic handwriting and tiny cages in which he kept pet birds and insects. What seems to inspire particular interest and tenderness among his fans is the high desk that Hearn had specially made to facilitate reading and writing because he was so short and his vision so poor (one eye had been lost in a childhood accident). Beginning writers everywhere might take a lesson from Hearn's working method: when he thought he was finished with a piece, he put it in his desk drawer for a time, then took it out to revise it, then returned it to the drawer, a process that continued until he had exactly what he wanted.
Hearn's image is everywhere in Matsue; his sweet, somewhat timid and melancholy mustachioed face adorns lampposts through the city, and in souvenir shops you can even purchase a brand of tea with his portrait on the package. It is generally assumed that Hearn's place in the heart of the Japanese derives from the fervor with which he adopted their culture and attempted to make it more comprehensible to the West. But in his fascinating 2003 book about the relationship between 19th-century New England and Japan, The Great Wave, literary critic and historian Christopher Benfey argues that Hearn, who despised the bad behavior of foreign travelers and deplored the avidity with which the Japanese sought to follow Western models, "almost alone among Western commentators...gave eloquent voice to...Japanese anger—and specifically anger against Western visitors and residents in Japan."
"Hearn," notes Benfey, "viewed Japan through an idealized haze of ghostly ‘survivals' from antiquity." Fittingly, his former residence could hardly seem more traditionally Japanese. Covered in tatami mats and separated by sliding shoji screens, the simple, elegant rooms are characteristic of the multipurpose, practical adaptability of Japanese homes, in which sitting rooms are easily converted to bedrooms and vice versa. Sliding back the outer screens provides a view of the gardens, artful arrangements of rocks, a pond, a magnolia and a crape myrtle, all of which Hearn described in one of his best-known essays, "In a Japanese Garden." The noise of the frogs is so perfectly regular, so soothing, so—dare I say it?—Zenlike that for a moment I find myself imagining (wrongly) that it might be recorded.
In his study, Hearn worked on articles and stories that got steadily less flowery (a failing that dogged his early, journalistic prose) and more evocative and precise. In "The Chief City of the Province of the Gods," Hearn wrote that the earliest morning noise one hears in Matsue is the "pounding of the ponderous pestle of the kometsuki, the cleaner of rice—a sort of colossal wooden mallet....Then the boom of the great bell of Zokoji, the Zenshu temples," then "the melancholy echoes of drumming...signaling the Buddhist hour of morning prayer."
These days, Matsue residents are more likely to be awakened by the noise of traffic streaming along expressways bordering the lake. But even given the realities of contemporary Japan, it is surprisingly easy to find a place or catch a glimpse of something that—in spirit, if not in precise detail—strikes you as being essentially unchanged since Hearn spent his happiest days here.
One such site is the Jozan Inari Shrine, which Hearn liked to pass through on his way to the school at which he taught. Located not far from the Hearn Museum, in the park at the base of Matsue Castle, the shrine—half-hidden amid the greenery and a bit difficult to find—contains thousands of representations of foxes, the messengers of the god (or goddess, depending on how the deity is represented) Inari, who determines the bounty of the rice harvest and, by extension, prosperity. Passing through a gate and along an avenue of sphinxlike foxes carved in stone, you reach the heart of the shrine, in a wooded glade crowded with more stone foxes, pitted by weather, covered with moss, crumbling with age—and accompanied by row after row of newer, bright, jaunty-looking white and gold ceramic foxes. Inari shrines, which have become increasingly popular in Japan, are thought by some to be haunted and best avoided after dark. When we reach the one in Matsue, the sun is just beginning to set, which may be part of the reason we are all alone there. With its simultaneously orderly and haphazard profusion of foxes, the place suggests those obsessional, outsider-art masterpieces created by folk artists driven to cover their homes and yards with polka dots or bottles or buttons—the difference being that the Inari Shrine was generated by a community, over generations, fox by fox.
It's at points like this that I feel at risk of having fallen into the trap into which, it is often claimed, Hearn tumbled headlong—that is, the pitfall of romanticizing Old Japan, the lost Japan, and ignoring the sobering realities of contemporary life in this overcrowded country that saw a decade of economic collapse and stagnation during the 1990s and is now facing, along with the rest of us, yet another financial crisis.
Single Page « Previous 1 2 3 4 Next »
Subscribe now for more of Smithsonian's coverage on history, science and nature.









Comments (8)
Thank you for writing so fondly about Matsue. I lived in Matsue was 6 months before moving up the coast to Tottori. Part of me wishes that more westerners understood the beauty of the city and of the Sanin coast. The other more selfish part wishes to keep a secret among the few of us who've traveled or lived there. I'm so happy such an eloquent person shares in the secret.
Posted by Alison Davis on January 31,2011 | 05:10 PM
I've been living in Japan for a total of about 16 years now. I enjoyed Ms. Prose's article on Matsue and Hagi and have been to both, Matsue twice, Hagi several times primarily to look at the ceramics. Ms. Prose mentions being somewhat mystified by the Japanese passion for what she calls extreme sweets. When I first came to Japan, I also found many Japanese sweets to be too sweet. However, she may be interested to know that the Japanese are rather mystified by the American passion for what they consider "extreme" sweets. For them, American cakes, cupcakes, cookies, pastries, etc. are all much too sweet (not to mention the portions also being too large). I'm sure that if she had tried some Japanese cookies or cakes, she might have found them lacking in sweetness and flavor. While both American and Japanese sweets rely on generous amounts of sugar, it is interesting that there seems to be a difference in how the sweetness is sensed and that the amount of sweetness tolerated depends on what is being eaten.
Posted by Bob Potter on October 14,2009 | 09:48 PM
My husband and I just returned from Japan and our first visit to Matsue, where we met, for the first time, my second cousins, descendants of my paternal grandmother's sister, and walked in the home where my grandmother lived until she married my grandfather and immigrated to America. A friend just sent us the September 2009 issue of the Smithsonian magazine with your article about Matsue, which refreshed our memories and whetted our appetites to return there. You wrote a beautiful article!
Posted by Susan Blackwell on October 11,2009 | 12:54 PM
For almost forty years, I have searched in vain for the words to a poem I heard read by an English Professor in post-graduate school.
The poem was called, simply, "Words", by Lafcadio Hearn.
It would please me mightily if anyone could provide a copy of this delightful, short poem.
Thank you!
Posted by Louise G. Smith on September 3,2009 | 12:05 AM
Dear Ms. Prose:
Thank you for your fascinating article featuring the San-in coast on the southwest tip of Honshu, the main island of Japan. It brought back a flood of memories from the time when I, as a young naval petty officer, was given my “Dream Assignment”: a set of orders to serve an eighteen-month tour of duty at Kami-Seya, a communications base located approximately 15 kilometers, or 10 miles west of Yokohama.
Although I did not have the opportunity to visit the San-in coast of Honshu, I did experience much of the beauty in and around Kanagawa Prefecture in the short amount of time I served at Kami-Seya before reassignment to Hakata Station or Camp Brady, a former Japanese Air Force base, now a U.S. multi-service communications base located at the tip of the peninsula across the bay from Fukuoka City, on the San-in coast of the southern island of Kyushu.
Japan is the most photogenic country I have visited, and you did a great job capturing that in your article. Everywhere I went I was greeted with unbelievable displays of warmth and hospitality. Whether traveling by foot, motorcycle, auto or rail, people went out of their way to help me with directions. And to this day, that is the same goodwill I extend to anyone – whether a U.S. citizen or a foreigner – who appears to be in need of direction, because that is the image of my community, my state and my country I would like for people to take home with them.
Posted by David Moudry on September 3,2009 | 11:33 AM
Dear Ms. Prose:
Thank you for your travel essay about this part of Japan.
I just returned from Japan at the end of July myself, your article provided further information about that beautiful region, just like you - I am planning to revisit Japan again in the near future. I can not wait to ride the bike in Kyoto and see all places you listed in the essay. Old and traditional parts of Japan, where, fill with peace and charm will always be my special hideaway on earth. Thank again for the wonderful writing and stunning photos. Enjoy it very much!
Posted by Grace Yevs on September 2,2009 | 09:29 PM
I lived in Shimane Prefecture as a participant in the Japan Exchange and Teaching Program (JET) in the mid-1990s. Saw the cover of September's Smithsonian and immediately recognized Izumo Taisha! Thank you for this lovely article capturing much of the beauty and magic of the area. I'm only sorry that now the secret of Shimane is really out :)
Posted by Emily Metzgar on August 27,2009 | 06:56 AM
I'm a descendant of Lafcadio Hearn's Irish family, and I wrote a research paper on his relationship with Japan. As I was in Japan anyway, I went to Matsue to do some research. It is an incredible and beautiful place! I love the slow pace - such a stark contrast with the bustling cities. I also had the opportunity to meet my cousin, Bon Koizumi, who is a professor at a woman's college in Shimane Prefecture. He's a gentle, good-natured but slightly eccentric fellow - surprisingly similar to how I imagine Lafcadio himself to be.
Thank you for writing this nice article - your description of Hearn was quite appropriate, I thought. If you want some more materials for further studying his life, send me an email! I have some great stuff that I've been able to collect from my family in Ireland.
Posted by Jake Hawkesworth on August 26,2009 | 01:47 PM