Buenos Aires: a City's Power and Promise
The stylish and affordable capital of Argentina has become a big hit with growing numbers of foreigners
- By Daniel Politi
- Photographs by Anibal Greco
- Smithsonian magazine, June 2009, Subscribe
(Page 2 of 5)
There's a joke usually attributed to the Mexican writer Octavio Paz: "Mexicans descend from the Aztecs, Peruvians from the Incans, and Argentines...from the boats."
Argentina didn't really begin to open its doors to immigrants until after it gained independence from Spain, which had colonized it in 1580 and made Buenos Aires a capital in 1776. With the British defeat of Spanish naval forces in 1805, Argentina's criollos, or people born in Latin America of European lineage, began to seek freedom from Spanish rule. Criollo leaders voted to depose the Spanish viceroy in Buenos Aires on May 25, 1810.
Today, the Cabildo—the building in which the criollos debated that action—is a museum that commemorates the May revolution. It fronts the Plaza de Mayo, renamed for the event and a focal point of civic and political life.
Still, many in Argentina remained loyal to Spain. It took José de San Martín, the native son of a Spanish officer, to organize an army and urge lawmakers to declare independence from Spain, which they did on July 9, 1816. Martín went on to lead a liberating army throughout the continent before exiling himself, beginning in 1824, to Belgium, England and France. Today, his body rests in a mausoleum in the Buenos Aires Metropolitan Cathedral, steps from the Cabildo, surrounded by three statues of female figures representing the nations that revere Martín as a liberator: Argentina, Peru and Chile.
Blessed with wide-open spaces and some of the world's most fertile lands, the new nation—with its 1853 constitution modeled after the United States'—turned to England for capital. Great Britain invested in everything from railways and banks to meat-processing plants. Today, British landmarks abound. The dome of the 1915 Retiro railway station was designed by British architects and made with Liverpool steel, and the subway system, the first in South America, was designed by a British company in 1913. One of the subway lines—the "A"—still operates with the original wooden cars.
But newly independent Argentina was missing an important component: people. In 1853, the Argentine political thinker Juan Bautista Alberdi declared that "to govern is to populate," and Argentina embraced immigrants, most of them from Spain and Italy. Between 1869 and 1914, the population grew from 1.8 million to 7.8 million. By 1914, about 30 percent of Argentina's population was foreign-born, nearly twice the percentage of immigrants in the United States at that time.
Today, the Hotel de Inmigrantes, where until the 1950s newcomers were allowed to stay free for five days, is the site of the Immigration Museum. The Boca neighborhood, near the old port, was the center of immigrant life, particularly for Italians. It's now a tourist attraction; on Sundays, Caminito Street is lined with souvenir sellers and tango dancers.
During the boom years early in the 20th century, Buenos Aires' upper classes developed what some called a "money fetish" and emulated Europe's aristocracy—especially Paris'. As a result, Buenos Aires acquired its answer to the Avenue de l'Opéra (and a world-class opera house). Buenos Aires is "a great city of Europe, giving the sensation of premature growth, but, by its prodigious advancement, the capital of a continent," the French statesman Georges Clemenceau wrote after visiting in 1910. And in a 1913 book about his travels, British diplomat James Bryce seconded the notion: "Buenos Aires is something between Paris and New York. Everybody seems to have money and to like spending it and to like letting everybody else know that it is being spent."
Not everyone was impressed by the nation's eagerness to copy continental fashions. After he visited Buenos Aires in 1923, the Colombian writer José María Vargas Vila called Argentina the "Nation of Plagiarism."
Single Page « Previous 1 2 3 4 5 Next »
Subscribe now for more of Smithsonian's coverage on history, science and nature.









Comments (32)
+ View All Comments
I suggest dealing with a specialist for our immigration matters. Sometime you try by yourself, but in argentina could be imposible. I've contracted immigrationsupport.com.ar and forgot about problems and wasted time. And enjoy argenina, you will find lovely landscapes!
Posted by Johana aredes on November 14,2012 | 10:17 PM
@davidglen77
Sure, seems the robbery is a national sports now, but you are wrong, the mayor (M.Macri) is not the chief of the Federal Police, is the national government, thru the Homeland Ministry and now the Security Ministry, please check your info... ;-)
Posted by Javier on April 27,2011 | 02:34 PM
Robberies are the most popular sport and way to get easy money in Buenos Aires Capital City. The robbery at Banco Provincia is just part of daily life here, and of course the city government turns a blind eye on everybody and spends public funds on new park benches, tourist attractions and the like, Here’s some video footage from a robbery at my candy store that took place back in July 2010. Nice and quick and well planned as you can see, after reporting it to the police and almost every other store on our block being held up at gunpoint, of course we still NEVER see a police officer around here. The mayor, Mauricio Macri, just had a lovely wedding and loves to blame the president for everything that happens in the country, however he is the one in charge of the police, but of course does nothing to protect the people…….NOW YOU KNOW WHAT IS GOING ON IN BUENOS AIRES, CAPITAL FEDERAL!! http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ypn-gjCETr4
Posted by davidglen77 on January 11,2011 | 06:05 PM
The Buenos aries Argentina is a wonderful city with delicious cuisine, hip nightlife, and mesmerizing shopping activities attract many people towards it and its beauty. Even i will run to it if i get a chance.
http://www.travelamerica360.com/buenos-aires-argentina.html
Posted by jadesmith on November 3,2010 | 01:47 AM
The Colon Theatre's been reopened!!!
Posted by Mauricio on September 17,2010 | 02:30 PM
As beautiful and atractive this city is , the crime rate is sky high I am surprise that a magazine like this one recomend a place like this for older americans to retire. The places apartment, housing in general are as expencive as the USA if you want security and civility. I love Buenos Aires Great place to visit !!!
Posted by Maria Thetford on August 8,2010 | 01:05 AM
Please note, the last name of Argentina's liberator is San Martin, not Martin. It is sad that your editors did not catch the error.
Posted by Silvia Ruksenas on May 4,2010 | 01:03 AM
I have visited Buenos Aires plenty of times and I love it more every time I visit. The people are engaging and looking to have a good conversation with strangers, unlike most Americans. There are awesome clubs and the night life is more exciting then even in Manhattan. The food is amazing and very affordable. Yes there is some pollution and some crime, but what very large city does not have these same issues. If you are a Smart traveler you will not run into any issues with crime! Its just the idiots that walk around with gold all over that attract attention. Argentina has a lot of great qualities that America has lost over the years. The family unity is extremal strong. People love just relating in the parks and drinking mate with friends and family. Buenos Aires is thrilling and full of smart, good looking people. No question you should visit this European style city.
Posted by Julian on March 15,2010 | 12:01 PM
Hey, last year I went to Argentina and took some Tango classes. I found an apartment rental buenos aires that was great. I was near the downtown so I spent all days watching tango shows, it is a fantastic dance.
I would like to keep practising it.
Mark
http://www.4rentargentina.com
Posted by Mark on November 18,2009 | 10:07 AM
Wow, the divergence of opinion is really intriguing. I'm an American heading to BA on vacation in October and I am definitely looking forward to a place where flashy, spoiled complainers are not comfortable. I'm planning on being vigilant just like everywhere else I have travelled as well as my own city (Boston). I look forward to the steak, the wine, the architecture and developing my own opinion...
Posted by James on September 2,2009 | 08:29 PM
Funny to see the bimodal perspectives here. As an American expat currently living in BA, I certainly see both sides, but two words seem to capture this place thus far--overrated and disorganized.
Beauty, charm, nostalgia, blah blah. That can be found in many places-other Latin cities, Europe, all over the world, including the states.
I suppose my problem is that everyone from abroad that needs an excuse to feel energized from their boring lives will talk up BA.
But how's this for perspective--just about every legitimate, hard-working local that I meet desperately wishes they could move to America, including New York, et. al.
The pollution is terrible, the cars are everywhere and dangerous, especially for pedestrians. The busses are plentiful yet dirty, and the people are borderline lazy. The noise, well, I have never been in a noisier city, and all-night long.
Yes, the food is tasty and inexpensive, but I don't mind cooking. However, my chief complaint is the lack of access for biking.
There is absolutely nowhere to bike and if so, would be dangerous getting there. To me, this point serves as the microcosm for BA.
To all, Suerte.
Ciao.
Posted by Francis Francis on August 22,2009 | 08:25 PM
Such diverse comments about a city that's always attracted me. I've lived in Paris for 2 years, Geneva for 2 years and have been to Russia many times. I was actually attacked by 3 Gypsy women (not men!) in Ekaterinburg (Ural Mountains), broad daylight, on a main street, where not one Russian came to my rescue, about 4 years ago. But can someone tell me, then, despite all the crime and pollution, which is everywhere now, how difficult is it to go, find an apartment (to rent or buy), and find work if you were, say, a qualified translator and teacher? Sounds like an exciting place which I'll be sure to visit at any rate.
Thanks!
Posted by Rob on August 14,2009 | 07:26 PM
I am 80 years old.In was born in BA ;I married had two children and lived there for 36 years;then I moved to USA where I am living for the last 44 years.
The Tango never abandoned my mind for a moment in all these years...It is part of myself.
Working for the toy industry ,I visited 18 countries all over the world.I was in China on three different occasions,one time for six months;another for 3 months and finally for a month and a half.
The argentinians are very intelligent diplomatics and a little bit conceited...,most of us are graduated from "la Universidad de la Calle."
With this comment I would like to reach to somebody with the authority to put together an exchange program with China for students 15-18 years old.
If we argentinians learn from the chinese how to apply our mental gifts to the good of the country, it will be the best response to all the negatives comments about ourselves from insiders and outsiders.But we have to be humble and respectfull with them,because they earned by themselves what they have.
Posted by omar nicieza on August 5,2009 | 02:33 PM
I don't know if all these complainers and detractors are just trying to scare more complainers and detractors away. If so, I hope it works.
Buenos Aires is a beautiful city in a beautiful country.
It has its flaws, but if you have some street smarts, you won't have to go back come whining about the "serious crime." Just quit flashing your money around and begging to have it stolen from you.
This is a city where those who are aware of what's going on around them can flourish and find plenty to appreciate. Those who are pampered and overprivileged should take about a month in Queens behaving the same oblivious way that got them victimized here and see where it gets them.
If you are afraid of a little dirt or smoke, or you can't live without showing off your brand new $1,000 handbag, best stay home, though.
Posted by Kate Sedgwick on July 24,2009 | 05:49 PM
+ View All Comments