Listening to Bacteria
By studying microbial communications, Bonnie Bassler has come up with new ways to treat disease
- By Natalie Angier
- Smithsonian magazine, July-August 2010, Subscribe
(Page 2 of 5)
Bassler and her peers are guardedly optimistic that their insights into the circuitry of quorum sensing will eventually yield a new, safer generation of antibiotics. Rather than seeking to kill bacteria outright, as current antibiotics do—an approach that readily leads to drug resistance—the novel therapeutics would simply muzzle the molecular messages that induce bacteria to cause disease. Bassler explains the difference between the two approaches this way: “Let’s say I’m a bacterium, and you’re hitting me with a drug like penicillin that pops the bacterial membrane, but I happen to have a mutation that makes me impervious to that popping effect,” she says. “No question about it, I’ll have an immediate growth advantage.”
But let’s say you are instead using an anti-quorum-sensing drug designed to inhibit bacterial communication, she continues, “and I’m a bacterium with a mutation that makes me immune to the blocker.” Great: I’m a microbe that’s trying to get in touch with my friends, but because of the blocker, nobody around me is listening. If virulence depends on effective bacterial communication, she says, my lone little mutation will give me no growth advantage at all: “What good does it do me?”
Thomas Silhavy, a microbiologist at Princeton who headed the faculty committee that hired Bassler 16 years ago (“I hit a home run,” he says of hiring her. “I hit it out of the park”), is among those with high hopes for eventual spinoffs from quorum-sensing studies. “Of course, it’s always a big, multimillion-dollar challenge to turn basic research into an FDA-approved drug,” he says. “But I think there’s a very real chance this approach will work and give us new tools for intervening in particular diseases.” He cites the case of cystic fibrosis, a congenital disorder in which mucus builds up in the lungs and hosts colonies of bacteria called pseudomonas. Infections that normal adults would readily brush away can fulminate for years in cystic fibrosis patients, until one day the chronic turns virulent and overwhelms the body: uncontrollable pseudomonas infection is a major cause of death among people with the disease. Scientists have traced the onset of virulence to the release of quorum-sensing molecules, the chemical messengers that incite the bacteria to begin operating as a group. In theory, Silhavy says, a drug that blocked the pseudomonal calls to mayhem could prove invaluable in the treatment of the devastating disorder.
Bassler and other researchers have identified a number of molecules that disrupt quorum sensing in test-tube experiments with pseudomonas and cholera bacteria; the test molecules seem to protect worms exposed to the virulent microbes. Bassler even tried her hand at drug development with a start-up company a few years ago. The effort foundered, and she is the first to concede that a medication based on the approach is probably a decade or more away. Nevertheless, the possibility of her work someday being translated from the lab bench to the bedside is part of her ongoing inspiration.
“We’re scientists, we’re curious about how nature works, but we’re also do-gooders,” she says. “It’s fantastic to think that the same experiments we’d do to understand how information gets into cells could have a practical side to them, too.”
It’s a sunny Saturday in Philadelphia, and outdoors, in a park, is where most people might choose to be. Yet the lecture hall at the Wagner Free Institute of Science, with its dim amber lighting, wooden chairs, dried blowfish, human skulls and other Victorian bric-a-brac, is full of people mesmerized by the woman up front, who seems to be carrying her own piece of sun. Bassler’s communication skills are not confined to divining petri dish dishings. She is a dynamo of a public speaker, who regularly dazzles both professional and lay audiences like this one with her vivid descriptions of microbial politics. “She can be very charismatic, but with just enough geekiness to let you know she’s a serious scientist,” says Stephen Winans of Cornell University. People love her dry humor and her blend of merry diva grandeur and aw-shucks insistence that she is just an “imposter” who does “genetics for dopes.”
“Bacteria are the oldest organisms on earth,” Bassler booms from the stage. “They’ve been here for four billion years. They make up 50 percent of the biomass of the earth and nearly 100 percent of its biodiversity.”
If you think bacteria, you probably think disease, putrefaction and germs, and reach for your hand sanitizer. Bassler wants to set you straight. “You live in intimate association with bacteria, and you couldn’t survive without them,” she says. Trillions of human cells make up the human body, but there are at least ten times that number of bacterial cells in you or on you. You are, at best, only 10 percent human. Bacteria coat your skin in an ultrathin protective armor, which helps keep harmful microbes at bay. The bacteria in your gut make vitamins K and B12. You like lettuce? Your intestinal flora gamely generate enzymes so you can digest it. It’s a happy trans-taxa tit-for-tat affair. For bacteria, “it’s the good life, it’s fat city” to dwell in the rich environs of a human being, Bassler says. It’s much better, she goes on, than striking out on their own “in a puddle or free-living in the ocean. Those are nutrient deserts compared to us.” Bacteria may be microscopic—three million can fit onto a pinhead—but they are not invisible. The next time you visit the Grand Canyon and your heart soars at the splendid strawberry-rhubarb striations of rock, take a moment to thank the makers. “Bacteria mineralized the rocks, they deposited the iron,” Bassler says. “They made the geology we see.”
Single Page « Previous 1 2 3 4 5 Next »
Subscribe now for more of Smithsonian's coverage on history, science and nature.










Comments (9)
Incredible! I've imagined a lot of stuff that eventually was proven or came true (like the fall of the USSR), some of it incredibly obvious stuff, but I NEVER in my wildest dreams considered bacterial communication! Amazing! Just be certain that they don't add your name to their language ("Attack Bonnie!") or you'll have a whole new problem on your hands. Seriously though, I think you've hit on something that will make antibiotics look so primitive and, hopefully, something they won't be able to overcome!
Posted by Glenn McGrew on November 2,2010 | 07:59 AM
God made man in his own image and likeness. Deolal Mahabir
Five years ago (August 2005), after meditation one morning a thought became clear to me. Five seconds of thought takes a long time to write down, especially if it was a developing thought that just crested at that moment.
I reflected on the thought or idea from somewhere in the bible it was… “God made man in his own likeness, and gave him dominion over all.” At that moment an immediate reaction was, yeah! Tell that to the bacteria in you belly.
As the thought unraveled even further, I kept thinking that there are good bacteria and bad bacteria. Parallel to this thought was another thought that we are the carrier of all possible pathogen at any one given moment in time. For sure if the ‘bad’ bacteria should gain control over their host it would only be because the immune system was compromised and the ‘bad’ bacteria was not kept in check.
Meanwhile in another part of the world, the microbial world, the ‘good’ bacteria and the ‘bad’ bacteria were a having a discussion. The ‘good’ bacteria was telling the ‘bad’ bacteria is you continue to dominate our host, then there will at some point come down from up above- acid rains (here acid rains is meant to be antibiotics) and that will destroy you, if that does not happen you will certainly cause global warming (fevers to the host) on our planet (the body). If they go to war, and if the bad bacteria should defeat the good bacteria that would lead to malefic effects or even destroy the planet (the body). We should all try to live in harmony with each on in a friendly eco system.
I told one of my teachers, Dr. Sharma and he laughed speechlessly since he had not imagined a thought as far fetched as this, but it made so much sense and ponder for a long while and then said…beautiful, beautiful. This all came from my meditation practice.
Posted by Deolal Mahabir on September 15,2010 | 05:46 PM
Bonnie Bassler's article has vindicated me after almost 60 years. Way back in 1946-7 I took a rudimentary course in Virus's and Bacteriology. The field was just getting attention after penicillan and etc. we were still concerned with how to fight what were then common health problems such as trichinosis and polio. Then as now I was interested in everything,and had sought a job as a health inspector.I recall studying the tobacco mosaic virus I think because it was large and prolific enough to give us an idea of how things worked.
Our main tools were a microscope, petri dishes, an oven and patience. In a short paper on my observations I noted that the viruses seemed to have basic communication skills, to me they seemed to sense danger, were able to adapt and change in order to survive as did other living things. They also seemed to be able to communicate, like ants, when the pickings were good suddenly thay all knew etc. Others said I was nuts, but I continued to believe after all these years the Bonnie Bassler story lends some credibility to my theory. Thanks Bonnie B.
Posted by Charles Welcome on August 18,2010 | 12:42 PM
I recall reading about the ability of hyenas to eat things that were at a state of decomposition that defied belief. I have often wondered how they could do so without becoming sick. Could it be that they can turn off the bacterial communications in a way to render them harmless?
Posted by Kenneth Davis on August 16,2010 | 09:44 PM
Anything to combat bacterial resistance is good news.I have heard of work on bacteriophages to deal with resistance.
Posted by Lyle Gaulding on July 19,2010 | 07:59 PM
Nataslie Angier wrote an excellent article with just the right mix of personal/scientific info, just like her subject, Bonnie Bassler is all that. A fascinating and inspiring read.
Posted by Lee Fairbanks on July 15,2010 | 12:29 PM
I read this article in the Smithsonian Magazine and I have to say this research is awesome. I've often wondered if there was a more natural way to fight disease, like inhibiting something withing the bacteria/virus itself; without bad drug side affects. This gives me hope. I also liked the way the article was written. I have no science degree, but the writer made it very easy to understand the scientific processes and terminology. Thanks for this. Please keep articles like this coming!
Posted by Esther Ditterline Riddell on July 15,2010 | 07:44 AM
I can only hope Bonnie Bessler's work leads to the drug that will block the "pseudomonal calls to mayhem" and is developed in time to help my lovely 17-year-old grandniece fight off her cystic fibrosis.
Posted by Marilyn McMorris Gottwald on July 8,2010 | 10:05 PM
I was excited to learn about bacterial linguistics, as I soaked in a hot bath trying to get over a cold. I wonder, can temperature (fever) play a role in messages the bacteria send and receive? When fever plays a helpful role in overcoming illness, perhaps it deters the production of "let's go" molecular signals. Other bacteria could have adapted to high fever, which triggers their signals. Conversely, common lore is that when the body gets chilled, it is more vulnerable to illness. Could a lowered body temperature trigger signals for some bacteria to multiply?
There is so much to learn, and Smithsonian does a great job of expanding the world of its readers. Thank you.
Posted by Barbara Rosenthal on July 7,2010 | 02:47 PM