Teaming up with Thoreau
One hundred fifty years after the publication of Walden, Henry David Thoreau is helping scientists monitor global warming
- By Michelle Nijhuis
- Photographs by Richard Howard
- Smithsonian magazine, October 2007, Subscribe
(Page 4 of 5)
The ecologists' quest also led them to Kathleen Anderson, a great-grandmother and lifelong birder, who has lived on a wooded property south of Boston for nearly six decades. Born in rural Montana, she remembers that her mother rewarded her and her siblings for spotting the first bluebird or daffodil, inspiring a record-keeping habit that Anderson, now 84, continues to this day. Her elaborate daily diaries, shelved in her low-ceilinged farmhouse, detail not only family weddings, births and the news of the day but also natural phenomena ranging from bird arrivals to frog choruses to the newest blooms in her yard. "I guess I'm an old-fashioned naturalist—I'm curious about everything," she says. "But I never in my wildest dreams thought that these records would be of any significance. I even wondered if my children would be interested in them."
Like Thoreau's data, the records of these naturalists were idiosyncratic and tricky to analyze. Amateurs don't usually record exactly how long they searched for an animal, or how many people were looking, or how certain they were about what they saw—and these gaps make professional scientists nervous. "Scientists are used to analyzing other scientists' data," says Miller-Rushing. "We're not so comfortable venturing into the world of personal journals."
But Primack and Miller-Rushing found that the bird records from Mount Auburn, Anderson's diaries and data collected by trained researchers at the Manomet Center for Conservation Sciences on the Massachusetts coast all told a similar story. On average, migratory birds are turning up earlier every year in eastern Massachusetts. And as with the precocious blooms in Concord, the shifts in schedule are best explained by warming temperatures.
Even in the mythic American landscape of Concord, global warming is disrupting the natural world. Since Thoreau's time, average temperatures have risen more than four degrees Fahrenheit because of local urban development as well as global climatic warming. Concord, once a farming community, is now a busy suburb—Boston is just a half-hour drive from Walden Pond—and expanses of warmth-absorbing concrete and blacktop have created a "heat island" of higher temperatures in the greater metropolitan area.
Seasonal routines such as migration, blooming and breeding are the pulse of the planet, and everything from agriculture to allergy outbreaks depend on their timing—and, often, their precise coordination. "Pollinators have to be around when plants are flowering, seed dispersers have to be around when seeds are available, leaves have to be around for herbivores to eat them," says Miller-Rushing. "There are endless numbers of these relationships, and we don't have a lot of good information about what happens when their timing gets jumbled up."
While some flowers in Concord, like the bluets in Sleepy Hollow Cemetery, are blooming weeks earlier than in Thoreau's time, others haven't changed their schedules. Observations from Thoreau and other naturalists reveal that plants are reacting to temperature changes more dramatically than short-distance migratory birds, suggesting that climate change could divide plants from their pollinators. Spring's acceleration is far from orderly.
That's disturbing news, because many plants and animals are already declining in eastern Massachusetts for other reasons. Though Concord has more parkland and natural spaces than many communities, thanks to strong local support for land conservation, human habits have changed over the past century and a half, and habitats have changed with them. River meadows, once mown for hay, have declined, along with local agriculture, and many have gradually turned to swamp forest. As hunting dwindled, white-tailed deer began devouring woodland plants. Invasive plants such as Oriental bittersweet and black swallowwort have infiltrated Concord, even covering the banks of Walden Pond. "The woods are being repopulated by things Thoreau never even knew about," says Peter Alden, a Concord native and veteran naturalist.
Of the nearly 600 plant species for which Thoreau recorded flowering times during the 1850s, Primack and Miller-Rushing found only about 400, even with the help of expert local botanists. Among the missing is the arethusa orchid, which Thoreau described with admiration in 1854: "It is all color, a little hook of purple flame projecting from the meadow into the air....A superb flower."
Single Page « Previous 1 2 3 4 5 Next »
Subscribe now for more of Smithsonian's coverage on history, science and nature.









Comments (3)
Aside from the ecological value of Thoreau's observations, more important is his initiative at passive resistance, perhaps the first recorded in American history, whereby a lone person takes it upon himself to insulate himself from what he perceives as the threatening forces around him, in this case, an entire town. Whether Thoreau's existence at Walden Pond is seen as the visioning of a madman, or the politically incorrect posture of a visionary may be the ultimate debate in American society by the script he left behind, but may well provide a context in which to view American history and its struggle with democracy between majority and minority forces that finds a broad audience in the liberty that Americans find so appealing, and so necessary. That it may also be found to be of similar value to other nations and cultures is more a matter of its acceptance at home and whether it is relegated to fine literature or fine political activism but relevant no more. It is the relevance of Walden Pond in a society of political complacency in which it finds its most logical voice, if a noise it makes upon the horizon of human history, or in the hearts of its patrons.
Posted by Pat on December 30,2008 | 01:09 PM
The comment I posted earlier was the first comment I have posted and the first time i've been on the site, although i am a subscriber. I didn't finish the article when i posted it because i didn't see that it scrolled to another page. Please omit my comments i see the relevance now and answered a lot of my questions and saw many faults in my comments. haha my bad. I still think thoreau was up to something else on a smaller scale within the season and it was a lucky coincidence that his work could be used to reinforce the blantant obvious fact of global warming. Can we see a steady correlation of flowering through the 20th century? It seems as far back as the 1900's global warming was observed in flowering trees and plants but if it is steady and oil is exponential could this be evidence of non anthropogenic warming?
Posted by TOM LYLE on March 19,2008 | 01:20 AM
Excellent article by an excellent journalist. I've enjoyed the work of Michelle Nijhuis ever since she started as an intern at High County News about ten years ago. I hadn't seen anything by her for several years until I ran across this article in a doctor's office. I'm glad she's still around and doing well.
Posted by Tim Stevens on March 8,2008 | 08:39 PM
Great read, I have been keeping records of bird migration (spring) for the past 6 years. I am also doing inventory of the plants on my 2 acres of mostly native habitat. http://www.birdbox.us/plants/pages/3index.html I never considered recording the date of flowering. I may add such to my records. There is so much to know, so little a window to do it, as spring shows up with brevity, everything rushing to maturation while the window allows. Thanks for the article. tp
Posted by Tom Peterson on January 29,2008 | 02:46 PM