Teaming up with Thoreau
One hundred fifty years after the publication of Walden, Henry David Thoreau is helping scientists monitor global warming
- By Michelle Nijhuis
- Photographs by Richard Howard
- Smithsonian magazine, October 2007, Subscribe
(Page 3 of 5)
Primack, joined by his doctoral student Miller-Rushing, now had detailed reports on Concord's flora from Thoreau and Hosmer, and it was time to compare the past with the present.
It's not easy to collaborate with dead botanists. Thoreau's penmanship was atrocious, and he used antiquated botanical names. Using the research of an amateur botanist and Thoreau admirer named Ray Angelo, Primack and Miller-Rushing deciphered Thoreau's and Hosmer's tables.
During their first year of fieldwork, in 2003, Primack and Miller-Rushing searched the sunniest, warmest corners of Concord, just as Thoreau had, looking for the first blooms. They found a place on the campus of the private Middlesex School where flowers turned up especially early. They talked a local farmer into allowing them to survey his fields. They walked the railroad tracks behind the site of Thoreau's cabin at Walden Pond.
When Primack found the season's first blue violet bloom on the gravel railroad bed, he was so absorbed that he failed to hear a construction truck approaching on the rails. The driver pulled up just 20 yards from the surprised researcher and angrily demanded that he explain himself. Primack quickly made clear he was no saboteur, but a botanist, and vowed to be more cautious. But as Thoreau himself surely would have, Primack and Miller-Rushing continued to inspect the tracks for flowers, paying for their persistence with a few run-ins with local police.
"We learned that if you're going to look at plants along the tracks, look at them briefly, always have a lookout and be ready to run into the woods," Miller-Rushing says.
In the spring of 2004, they began reprising Thoreau's work in earnest. With the help of several undergraduates, Primack and Miller-Rushing combed the warmest places in town. As they navigated crowds of tourists at Minute Man National Historical Park or stepped around the sunbathers at Walden Pond, they found they had a lot in common with their quirky collaborator. "We'd come out of the woods, sometimes covered with mud, and start asking people if they would move their towels so we could see the flowers," Miller-Rushing remembers. "That's when we realized that we weren't normal people."
What they discovered wasn't quite normal, either. Primack and Miller-Rushing compared three years of their results with those of Thoreau and Hosmer, focusing on the 43 plant species with the most complete records. They learned that some common plants, such as the highbush blueberry and a species of sorrel, were flowering at least three weeks earlier than in Thoreau's time. On average, they found, spring flowers in Concord were blooming a full seven days earlier than in the 1850s—and their statistics clearly showed a close relationship between flowering times and rising winter and spring temperatures.
Primack and Miller-Rushing also found other naturalists who had carried on Thoreau's tradition of obsessive observation. Robert Stymeist, a retired accountant and devoted birder, frequents the trails of Mount Auburn Cemetery in Cambridge, a shady, arboretum-like spot that attracts colorful waves of migrating birds each spring. Stymeist, 59, has been watching and recording them for almost as long as he can remember: when he was just 10 years old, too young to be trusted with a key to the cemetery gates, he began sneaking into the grounds, binoculars and bird guide in hand. "It's just always been my spot," he says.
Single Page « Previous 1 2 3 4 5 Next »
Subscribe now for more of Smithsonian's coverage on history, science and nature.









Comments (3)
Aside from the ecological value of Thoreau's observations, more important is his initiative at passive resistance, perhaps the first recorded in American history, whereby a lone person takes it upon himself to insulate himself from what he perceives as the threatening forces around him, in this case, an entire town. Whether Thoreau's existence at Walden Pond is seen as the visioning of a madman, or the politically incorrect posture of a visionary may be the ultimate debate in American society by the script he left behind, but may well provide a context in which to view American history and its struggle with democracy between majority and minority forces that finds a broad audience in the liberty that Americans find so appealing, and so necessary. That it may also be found to be of similar value to other nations and cultures is more a matter of its acceptance at home and whether it is relegated to fine literature or fine political activism but relevant no more. It is the relevance of Walden Pond in a society of political complacency in which it finds its most logical voice, if a noise it makes upon the horizon of human history, or in the hearts of its patrons.
Posted by Pat on December 30,2008 | 01:09 PM
The comment I posted earlier was the first comment I have posted and the first time i've been on the site, although i am a subscriber. I didn't finish the article when i posted it because i didn't see that it scrolled to another page. Please omit my comments i see the relevance now and answered a lot of my questions and saw many faults in my comments. haha my bad. I still think thoreau was up to something else on a smaller scale within the season and it was a lucky coincidence that his work could be used to reinforce the blantant obvious fact of global warming. Can we see a steady correlation of flowering through the 20th century? It seems as far back as the 1900's global warming was observed in flowering trees and plants but if it is steady and oil is exponential could this be evidence of non anthropogenic warming?
Posted by TOM LYLE on March 19,2008 | 01:20 AM
Excellent article by an excellent journalist. I've enjoyed the work of Michelle Nijhuis ever since she started as an intern at High County News about ten years ago. I hadn't seen anything by her for several years until I ran across this article in a doctor's office. I'm glad she's still around and doing well.
Posted by Tim Stevens on March 8,2008 | 08:39 PM
Great read, I have been keeping records of bird migration (spring) for the past 6 years. I am also doing inventory of the plants on my 2 acres of mostly native habitat. http://www.birdbox.us/plants/pages/3index.html I never considered recording the date of flowering. I may add such to my records. There is so much to know, so little a window to do it, as spring shows up with brevity, everything rushing to maturation while the window allows. Thanks for the article. tp
Posted by Tom Peterson on January 29,2008 | 02:46 PM