A Wildlife Mystery in Vietnam
The discovery of the saola alerted scientists to the strange diversity of Southeast Asia's threatened forests
- By Richard Stone
- Smithsonian magazine, August 2008, Subscribe
(Page 2 of 3)
Robichaud is one of the few scientists who have observed a live saola. In early 1996, an adult female was captured and sold to a zoo in central Laos. "She was a remarkable animal," he says. Nicknamed "Martha," she stood about waist high, her 18-inch horns sweeping back over her neck. Although the saola's closest relatives are cows and bison, it resembles a diminutive antelope. It has coarse, chestnut-brown hair and a thick, white streak above its eyes. Its anatomical claim to fame is massive scent glands bulging from its cheeks. Martha would flare a fleshy flap covering a gland and dab a pungent green musk on rocks to mark her territory.
Robichaud says he was most fascinated by Martha's calmness. A few days after her arrival at the zoo, she ate from a keeper's hand and allowed people to stroke her. "The saola was tamer and more approachable than any domestic livestock I've ever been around," he says. "You can't pet a village pig or cow." The only thing sure to spook a saola is a dog: one whiff of a canine and it crouches low, snorting and tilting its head forward as if preparing to spear the enemy. (Saolas are presumably preyed upon by dholes, or Asiatic wild dogs, common predators in saola territory.) Remove the threat, though, and the saola regains the Zen-like composure that in Laos has earned it the nickname "the polite animal."
Martha's equanimity around people may have been genuine, but she died just 18 days after her capture. It was then that zookeepers discovered that she had been pregnant. But they could not determine her cause of death. The handful of other saolas that have been taken into captivity also perished quickly. In June 1993, hunters turned over two young saola to Tuoc and his colleagues in Hanoi. Within months, the pair succumbed to infections.
The saola's baffling fragility underscores how little is known about its biology or evolutionary history. Robichaud and conservation biologist Robert Timmins have proposed that saola were once widespread in the wet evergreen forests that covered Southeast Asia until several million years ago. These forests receded during cool, dry ice ages, leaving just a few patches suitable for saola. "If we leave the saola alone," says Tuoc, "I think—no, I hope—it will survive."
Other scientists argue for hands-on assistance. Pierre Comizzoli of the Smithsonian's Center for Species Survival says a captive breeding program is the only option left to save the saola from extinction. He teamed up with scientists from the Vietnamese Academy of Science and Technology in Hanoi on a survey late last year to find possible locations for a breeding site.
"It's a sensitive topic," he acknowledges. "But captive breeding doesn't mean that we are going to put saolas in cages, or do industrial production of saolas." Instead, he envisions putting an electric fence around a select swath of saola habitat, perhaps half an acre. "They would have access to their natural environment and could feed themselves, and at the same time we could start to study them," says Comizzoli, adding that something as simple as fresh dung would be "fantastic" for research purposes.
After fording the river, Tuoc and my family and I hike to a ranger station. The next leg of our journey is on motorcycles. Their make, Minsk, is emblazoned in Cyrillic on the gas tank. Our sons, sandwiched between my wife and a ranger, have never ridden a motorcycle before, and they squeal with delight. For several miles, we tear uphill on an empty, curvy road faster than this anxious parent would like. At the end of the road, we hike into the misty hills on our quest to spot a saola.
Preserving this habitat will help a host of other rare creatures, including the two other new mammals in Vietnam that Tuoc helped uncover, both primitive kinds of deer: the large-antlered muntjac, in 1994, and the diminutive Truong Son muntjac, in 1997. Strange beasts continue to emerge from these forests, including the kha-nyou, a rodent identified in 2006 as a species thought to have been extinct for 11 million years. "If we lose the saola," says Long, "it will be a symbol of our failure to protect this unique ecosystem."
Single Page « Previous 1 2 3 Next »
Subscribe now for more of Smithsonian's coverage on history, science and nature.









Comments (8)
great!!
Posted by erin on May 25,2011 | 03:45 PM
I know I'm commenting over a year after this article was written but I haven't read it before. First, I have to comment on the people talking about who originally discovered the saola. Although I do think it is very important to give credit where credit is due, everyone seems to be focusing on the not so important part of the article. I feel the main point of the article is to let people know why it is imperative to save the rainforests of Southeast Asia. If this animal remained undiscovered for all these years, what other plant and animal species could be hiding in these forests? How many have gone and will go extinct before we ever learn of them? The deforestation of this area is a huge crisis and this article helps people understand why it's so important that we save it.
Posted by Cristalle Olson on December 8,2009 | 03:28 AM
Well you may not have found this mammal till 1969 and 1970.
Posted by Dale Gilliam on October 4,2008 | 07:54 PM
Dale, well put. And the hubris often comes from the foreigner "white" person wanting to claim credit for discovery, when it should be for documentation. These natives appear not to care about documentation in the same way other cultures do, neither is wrong or right. However, it is wrong to claim credit for discovery just b/c you were the first to document something. Indeed, if John MacKinnon was the first to document this species with a scientific name, perhaps he should have found out who the first villager was that knew of the saola, and give that person credit. This, being an almost impossible task, leads us back to the question of who gets credit. In this light, perhaps the onus of this dilemma is on the choice of words used by the reporter of such news. "First to document", may have been a better choice of words in this case. Also mentioning that the villagers, whom have lived with this species for quite some time, are the true "discoverers". This would be an appropriately humble addition for those who are not reading between the lines.
Posted by MG on August 26,2008 | 04:05 PM
There is a one-hundred percent probability the saola was not discovered by those merited in this article. Ten's if not hundred's of thousands of local inhabitants have seen, observed, hunted and known of the saola for just as many years. How does one discover a species that is already known? It's called scientific hubris.
Posted by Dale Remund on August 22,2008 | 04:14 PM
I believe the discovery of the saola is generally credited with John MacKinnon of the WWF, who gave it its scientific name. Touring the area near the border with Laos soon after Vietnam began opening to the West, it was he who spotted a pair of antlers in a villager's home and recognized them as being unknown to science.
Posted by Jeff Wise on August 21,2008 | 05:25 PM
Sherri, The most comprehensive observations of captive saola have been published by William Robichaud (Physical and behavioral description of a captive saola, Pseudoryx nghetinhensis; Journal-of-Mammalogy 1998; 79(2): 394-405). Other published reports rather focused on chromosomal studies in the saola. I am not sure that infectious disease were tested on the captive animal. In any case, it would be really difficult to draw conclusions from a so small number of samples. Thank you for your interest. Pierre Comizzoli
Posted by Pierre Comizzoli on August 13,2008 | 09:41 AM
Hello, My name is Sherri Rosenthal and I had a few questions on the article about the Saola. First I was wanting to know if when the Saola were brought back to where they were being kept in captivity were they able to test for infections? Also what kind of testing were they able to do on the deceased Saola? Could they keep any long enough in captivity to test on a live specimen? Like what kind of diseases or infections is it prone to and if the transportation was too strenuous for it physically as well as mentally? Also is their more scientific data being contemplated as well as being carried out? I just want to let you know I thoroughly enjoyed your article and I look to hearing more about this most intriguing animal and it's life. Please also let me know if you or anyone related to this article can answer any of my questions. Thank You so much for reading this. Sincerely, Sherri Rosenthal
Posted by Sherri Rosenthal on August 5,2008 | 07:09 PM