Condors in a Coal Mine
California's lead bullet ban protects condors and other wildlife, but its biggest beneficiaries may be humans
- By John Moir
- Smithsonian.com, September 09, 2008, Subscribe
(Page 2 of 3)
Some gun groups—including the National Rifle Association—have lobbied against any restrictions on lead ammunition. They object to the higher cost of alternative ammunition and say the research linking poisoned condors to lead bullet fragments is not definitive. Many opponents view attempts to regulate lead ammunition as an attack on their right to hunt. For more than two decades, their fierce opposition prevented the enactment of legislation to curtail the use of toxic lead bullets.
Last year, in one of the most significant developments in condor conservation history, California legislators passed a bill restricting lead bullets. Despite intense lobbying by gun organizations, Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger signed legislation that requires the use of nonlead ammunition for big game hunting in much of California. The ban went into effect in July.
"The lead bullet ban is a huge step forward and gives the condor a real chance for recovery," said Kelly Sorenson, executive director of the Ventana Wildlife Society. "But there are only a few game wardens to enforce this law. Its success will depend on hunters understanding that lead is deadly."
California's new lead bullet ban was designed to protect condors and other wildlife. But while the ban was being debated, intriguing new research was emerging to suggest that the biggest beneficiaries may be humans.
In 2007, the condor's lead-poisoning problems caught the attention of William Cornatzer, a physician in Bismarck, North Dakota, who had joined the board of directors of the Peregrine Fund, a group that manages condor releases near the Grand Canyon.
An avid hunter, Cornatzer was intrigued by studies demonstrating what happens to a lead bullet when it hits a game animal. Condor biologists had shown that the bullet shatters into dozens and sometimes hundreds of tiny fragments that scatter widely from the wound site, leaving behind a deadly "snowstorm" of toxic lead that poisons condors and other scavengers such as ravens and bald eagles. Audubon California, an environmental conservation group, has identified 48 birds and other animals that are harmed by spent ammunition. Cornatzer wondered if humans might also be at risk.
Early in 2008, Cornatzer contacted the North Dakota Department of Health and arranged to collect 100 one-pound packages of ground venison donated by hunters to North Dakota food pantries. A radiologist helped Cornatzer run CT scans on the packages. They were stunned to discover that 59 of them contained metal fragments.
"The scans just lit up with tiny bits of metal," Cornatzer said. "I almost fell over. I could not believe how much metal was in the meat."
The North Dakota Department of Health ran additional scans that showed the metal fragments tested strongly for lead. Concerned about the potential risks for humans, North Dakota officials recommended the destruction of tons of venison still in storage at food pantries.
Spurred by the North Dakota findings, health departments in several other states ran similar tests and also found tainted meat. In the largest survey of donated venison, Minnesota officials X-rayed 1,239 packages and found 22 percent to be contaminated with lead.
"The lead fragments are so small that you can't feel them in your mouth when you are eating venison burger or sausage," Cornatzer said.
Single Page « Previous 1 2 3 Next »
Subscribe now for more of Smithsonian's coverage on history, science and nature.









Comments (23)
Condor mines is the most leading company of extracting mines.Condor blanco is extracting various types of mines underneath the earth like gold,iron,uranium etc.
Posted by maria jose on January 9,2012 | 04:29 AM
Good one. Condor Blanco mine ltd was created to invest in mining as well as exploration opportunities in chile.Its true that condor mine is the leading company that extracting mine in large amount.
Posted by maria jose on October 30,2011 | 11:45 PM
Condor Blanco Mines has been created to invest in mining and exploration opportunities in chile.I agree that mining deals are increasing day by day and condor mines is the biggest mine company that extracting mines in huge amount.
Posted by maria jose on October 24,2011 | 11:26 PM
We owe these caring men our most heart felt gratitude. These will not only save the condor but the many humans that consume the meat from a hunt. If the rest of the hunters heed the warning and switch to non-lead ammo, they will undoubtedly save their innocent children from health problems caused by lead.
Posted by Dacey on October 18,2011 | 12:12 AM
Nice.Mines extraction is really a difficult task and requires various labors efforts since it requires lots of hard work efforts for extracting the mines therefore the condor Blanco mines managing director is focusing on it.
Posted by maria jose on October 13,2011 | 03:06 AM
Condors are the endangered species.The species has become endangered due to human encroachments.So the rest of the condors are finding their shelter in coal mines
Posted by Dacey on September 25,2011 | 12:46 AM
Condor mines is the famous company but it is relating the condor with the coal mines.Condor Blanco mines is doing same that means extracting the mines whether it is a coal ,gold or any other mine
Posted by Dacey on September 2,2011 | 04:10 AM
Unfortunately the fact is that a lot of people won't care. They'll just say if you don't want to risk the danger, don't eat the meat. Others won't care about the birds and other animals. Still many others simply won't believe that such a small ammount of lead could be dangerous. They'll just ignore it and keep shooting with lead bullets. The stupid thing is, the people who pass these bills know this from experience with other such bills. What needs to be done is to just completely ban the production of lead bullets altogether. But then, that would be expecting to much intelligence and consideration from the masses. Honestly, humanity in general is a sad and sorry race. Some people aren't, but the majority don't give one bit about anything that doesn't directly, (and immediately) affect themselves, or those they care about.
Posted by James on January 9,2009 | 07:00 PM
We owe these caring men our most heart felt gratitude. These will not only save the condor but the many humans that consume the meat from a hunt. If the rest of the hunters heed the warning and switch to non-lead ammo, they will undoubtedly save their innocent children from health problems caused by lead.
Posted by Leo Nebel on September 25,2008 | 09:56 PM
I have seen this wonderful creature flying over my head, every one around was astonished. If people could experience the same they would appreciate it's wonder and contribution to our world. It's a shame we cannot appreciate both the creature nor the efforts of the park service to keep it alive an thriving.
Posted by on September 24,2008 | 08:03 AM
I am dumbfounded that all states have not banned lead shot! I think it is inexcusable.
Posted by Jerry Haig on September 22,2008 | 11:46 PM
This article makes me think of all the lead weights my family and I lost while fishing when I was growing up. Sometimes the line snagged and was broken and left in the river/stream while trying to free it, and sometimes we dropped the lead weights while putting them on the line but didn't retrieve them. Also we handled the lead weights with our bare hands. I'm sure we weren't the only ones. A We all need to be educated on this danger, and all take steps to elimenate lead in our environment.
Posted by S. Neal on September 22,2008 | 05:02 PM
Wow!I feel so bad for the Condors. But it's good that they increased the population!
Posted by denise on September 20,2008 | 01:54 PM
I am E-mailing this article to my daughter whose husband gathers Antelope for meatr to eat. I do not know if he is aware of the lead bullets affect, but he is well read and I hope that he knows about lead bullets
Posted by MARION ROUSSEAU on September 19,2008 | 08:41 PM
I've seen the Condor's at the Grand Canyon and it is always a highlight of the visit.The support for these amazing birds is substantial and hopefully their recovery will continue.
Posted by Sue Schmidt on September 19,2008 | 07:34 PM
The destruction of wild life habitat is utterly rampant. Just so more developers can make more money and the rich & near rich can have more luxurious homes. Instead lets bring back the interior of cities large & small by renewal. Block by block. Even the rain forests are being leveled and mankind will be sorry after it is too late.
Posted by LaDonna English on September 19,2008 | 12:20 PM
It is so hard to understand progress, but at the same time is amazing to see all the efforts to recover endanger species. The only condor I have seen was in a Museum.
Posted by J. Silva on September 19,2008 | 09:31 AM
Wonderful article. Now if the rest of the country would follow California's lead........
Posted by Cherry on September 18,2008 | 01:15 AM
Bullets are not the only source of lead. They use lead weights to balance tires on cars and other vehicles. These fly off and land in the road or road side. Those that land in the road get ground into very small pieces that get into the environment and food chain. My wife and I walk a three mile route around a big block and we pick up any trash we find along the way. I have been very surprised at the number of these lead weights we find on almost every walk. Has anyone ever done a study of the lead balancing weights that are flying off as people drive?
Posted by Dave Gardener on September 18,2008 | 10:17 PM
I am ever so grateful to those with a broader view. You have a commitment to ALL life and because of your intelligence and concerns you persue these issues. Thank you all! I know far too many personally who could not care less about condors, owls, and all other living creatures, as long as THEIR lives go on. Thank you to those of you who understand the critical connection to all living things. Without you, our planet and lives would be even more close to peril than it already is. Please know how appreciated you are.
Posted by pj on September 18,2008 | 09:24 PM
It is scary to think of all the venison I ate when I was a child and into my teens. Does this also apply to wild turkeys shot in the central part of the US, namely Kansas and Missouri?
Posted by Elizabeth Engle on September 18,2008 | 08:46 PM
I work near the Vermillion Cliffs wilderness area and have had numerous occasions to view these magnificent birds both soaring over 2,000 feet above the cliffs and also perched on rocks near the Colorado River. The lead poisoning that sickens these birds is a concern for hunters and non-hunters alike as cited by the study of ground venison donated to food pantries. I hope that the condor restoration project can continue so that future generations will be able to see these fantastic birds soaring free.
Posted by Kelli Wiggins on September 18,2008 | 07:38 PM
I really enjoyed reading your article. It is very informative and an eye opener. In July, we went on a trip to Parker, Arizona. On our way back to Fresno, California, on Highway 95, our vehicle, a van, was struck by a very large bird and broke the windshield. It looked like what I believe was a Condor that at first looked disoriented just before it decided to take off for flight in our direction. I remember the wing span and from reading your article, I know truly believe it may have been a Condor. What I am wondering is, if this bird had lead poison, would it make a bird confused or disoriented as if it were off course? Especially if this Condor had not been tested and treated right away?
Posted by Victoria Rangel on September 18,2008 | 06:55 PM
Awesome story!!! I drove past two adult condors on Hyw 1 in 1974. They are amazing and I am so glad that the work to save them is being successful!!!
Posted by Donna Rafuse on September 18,2008 | 05:37 PM
The article "Condors in a coal mine" was must interesting and informative. Thanks. Rich
Posted by Rich Matson on September 18,2008 | 04:44 PM
This was an EXCELLENT article!! Thank you.
Posted by Liz McCleaster on September 18,2008 | 03:11 PM
Amazing! To paraphrase Donne: no creature is an island unto themselves.
Posted by Shir-El, Eilat, Israel on September 13,2008 | 07:28 AM