Tracking the Elusive Lynx
Rare and maddeningly elusive, the "ghost cat" tries to give scientists the slip high in the mountains of Montana
- By Abigail Tucker
- Photographs by Ted Wood
- Smithsonian magazine, February 2011, Subscribe
(Page 3 of 6)
Lynx used to be more widespread in the United States than they are today—nearly half of the states have historical records of them, though some of those animals could have been just passing through. There have been population spikes in the recent past—the 1970s brought a veritable lynx bonanza to Montana and Wyoming, possibly thanks to an overflow of lynx from Canada—but heavy fur trapping likely reduced those numbers. Plus, the habitat that lynx prefer has become fragmented from fires, insect invasions and logging. In 2000, lynx were listed as threatened under the Endangered Species Act.
Squires began his project in anticipation of the listing, which freed up federal funding for lynx research. At the time, scientists knew almost nothing about the U.S. populations. Montana was thought to be home to about 3,000 animals, but it has become clear that the number is closer to 300. “The stronghold is not a stronghold,” Squires says. “They are much rarer than we thought.” Hundreds more are scattered across Wyoming, Washington, Minnesota and Maine. Wildlife biologists have reintroduced lynx in Colorado, but another reintroduction effort in New York’s Adirondack Mountains fizzled; the animals just could not seem to get a foothold. Bobcats and mountain lions—culinary opportunists not overly dependent on a single prey species—are much more common in the lower 48.
In the vast northern boreal forests, lynx are relatively numerous; the population is densest in Alberta, British Columbia and the Yukon, and there are plenty in Alaska. Those lynx are among the most fecund cats in the world, able to double their numbers in a year if conditions are good. Adult females, which have an average life expectancy of 6 to 10 years (the upper limit is 16), can produce two to five kittens per spring. Many yearlings are able to bear offspring, and kitten survival rates are high.
The northern lynx population rises and falls according to the snowshoe hare’s boom-and-bust cycle. The hare population grows dramatically when there is plenty of vegetation, then crashes as the food thins out and predators (goshawks, bears, fox, coyotes and other animals besides lynx) become superabundant. The cycle repeats every ten years or so. The other predators can move on to different prey, but of course the lynx, the naturalist Ernest Thompson Seton wrote in 1911, “lives on Rabbits, follows the Rabbits, thinks Rabbits, tastes like Rabbits, increases with them, and on their failure dies of starvation in the unrabbited woods.” Science has borne him out. One study in a remote area of Canada showed that during the peak of the hare cycle, there were 30 lynx per every 40 square miles; at the low point, just three lynx survived.
The southern lynx and hare populations, though small, don’t fluctuate as much as those in the north. Because the forests are naturally patchier, the timber harvest is heavier and other predators are more common, hares tend to die off before reaching boom levels. In Montana, the cats are always just eking out a living, with much lower fertility rates. They prowl for hares across huge home ranges of 60 square miles or more (roughly double the typical range size in Canada when the living is easy) and occasionally wander far beyond their own territories, possibly in search of food or mates. Squires kept tabs on one magnificent male that traveled more than 450 miles in the summer of 2001, from the Wyoming Range, south of Jackson, over to West Yellowstone, Montana, and then back again. “Try to appreciate all the challenges that animal confronted in that huge walkabout. Highways, rivers, huge areas,” Squires says. The male starved to death that winter.
Of the animals that died while Squires was tracking them, about a third perished from human-related causes, such as poaching or vehicle collisions; another third were killed by other animals (mostly mountain lions); and the rest starved.
The lynx’s future depends in part on the climate. A recent analysis of 100 years of data showed that Montana now has fewer frigid days and three times as many scorching ones, and the cold weather ends weeks earlier, while the hot weather begins sooner. The trend is likely the result of human-induced climate change, and the mountains are expected to continue heating up as more greenhouse gases accumulate in the atmosphere. This climate shift could devastate lynx and their favorite prey. To blend in with the ground cover, the hare’s coat changes from brown in summer to snowy white in early winter, a camouflage switch that (in Montana) typically happens in October, as daylight grows dramatically shorter. But hares are now sometimes white against a snowless brown background, possibly making them targets for other predators and leaving fewer for lynx, one of the most specialized carnivores. “Specialization has led to success for them,” says L. Scott Mills, a University of Montana wildlife biologist who studies hares. “But might that specialization become a trap as conditions change?”
The lynx’s precarious status makes even slight climate changes worrisome. “It’s surprising to me how consistently low their productivity is over time and how they persist,” Squires says. “They’re living right on the edge.”
Single Page « Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 Next »
Subscribe now for more of Smithsonian's coverage on history, science and nature.
Related topics: Carnivores Hunting Montana Mountains
Additional Sources
"Ghost Cat: a historic land deal will protect forests for the rare Canada lynx—if researchers can find it," Scott McMillion, Nature Conservancy Magazine, Winter 2009
"Movements of a Male Canada Lynx Crossing the Greater Yellowstone Area, Including Highways," John R. Squires and Robert Oakleaf, Northwest Science Notes, 2005
"Winter Prey Selection of Canada Lynx in Northwestern Montana," John R. Squires and Leonard F. Ruggiero, Journal of Wildlife Management, April 2007
"Characteristics of an unharvested lynx population during a snowshoe hare decline," Kim G. Poole, Journal of Wildlife Management, October 1994









Comments (7)
Tina, While not a researcher I know much data can be learned from observation, viewing, photography, scat analysis, interviewing locals and hunters, autopsies, and if adventurous enough with software modeling. The idea that two thirds of the animals being tracked died should in itself tell an ethical person to stop. How many of these deaths were the result of a drugged animal with a noose around it's neck running into traffic, or too disoriented and distracted to find food. If "a dedicated researcher without traps and radio collars would be lucky to see one lynx in ten years," and I've seen fifty without trying, can I get paid for my insight? To me this approach is akin to thinking people die from hypothermia, let's throw some in the ice water and collect the data as they suffer and die, then we'll know what to do. These animals do not require rocket science, if you want to help them help the local rabbits, if you want to help the rabbits, plant some grass. Common sense is lacking here. Alan Strech
Posted by Alan Strech on November 5,2012 | 06:46 PM
Alan Strech, you have no idea what you're talking about. "A multitude of other ways to get the data"? Name three. Name one. A dedicated researcher without traps and radio collars would be lucky to see one lynx in ten years. This animal can range over hundreds of square miles of rugged mountains, and leaves tracks only in snow, often deep snow. Want to try tracking one without a collar? You first! "Of the animals that died while Squires was tracking them, about a third perished from human-related causes, such as poaching or vehicle collisions; another third were killed by other animals (mostly mountain lions); and the rest starved." Now tell me how to get information like that without radio collars-- which are not "permanent nooses" but are sized so the animal can follow its normal routine and are generally designed to fall off after a certain time. The trapping is done with as little disruption to the animals as possible. The information gained is often critical to their conservation and survival, as is stated clearly in this article. If you have any better ideas, your nearest university department of wildlife conservation would like to hear them.
Posted by Tina Rhea on March 22,2012 | 06:04 PM
"Snow Phantom" was an interesting read. In our neighborhood we have 3 or 4 of their brethren, bobcats (Lynx rufus), which we welcome. What we don't do is pursue them with snowmobiles, bait them, trap them, drug them and tie transmitters to their necks. One can only imagine the horror of a wild animal waking up in and from a drugged state with a permanent noose around their neck. Where I'm from we shun people who torture animals, not revere them. There are a multitude of other ways to get the data that is neither lazy nor cruel. Shame on them.
Posted by Alan Strech on February 22,2011 | 10:05 PM
well, im gonna have a nice discussion tomorrow about this.I could understand this text well...
Posted by luiz on February 21,2011 | 06:10 PM
Dear Ms. Tucker,
This is a wonderful story and I loved the photographs of the lynx. I just have one criticism; I saw the same photographs (and read essentially the same story, with only a slightly different text) a few months ago while waiting in the dentist's office in Nature Conservancy Magazine.
I would have preferred, if you're publishing the same story twice, to have some different pictures to go with the slightly different text.
all the best,
Grayson Hugh
Posted by Grayson Hugh on February 2,2011 | 07:34 PM
Hi
Interesting article on the linx. It was mentioned that the lynx can bare young at a very early age, one year I believe.
Could it be that the diet of the lynx, which is exclusively rabbits may have something to do with this early onset of the ability to become pregnant? I believe that rabbits are able to not only pregnant at less than a year, but that they also can have overlapping pregnancies.
I feel that the lynx ingesting so many rabbits in its lifetime over countless generations have become linked to the hormonal balances and influences of the rabbit and have inadvertently become physically adapted to the hormonal cycles of the rabbit.
Posted by Amphibian. on January 28,2011 | 07:58 PM
Ms. Tucker: While you followed the team on the track of the lynx, you carried us along--not only through the anecdotal asides, but with sentences so deftly written they operated like hidden cameras. You kept us in the world with your words. If that piece does not win honors--such as republication in America's Best Essays--the judges should hang their heads like the guy who found nothing in those cages. Well done.
Posted by Mike Robinson on January 22,2011 | 10:16 AM