The Science of Sarcasm? Yeah, Right
How do humans separate sarcasm from sincerity? Research on the subject is leading to insights about how the mind works. Really
- By Richard Chin
- Smithsonian.com, November 14, 2011, Subscribe
(Page 3 of 3)
In an experiment by Patricia Rockwell, a sarcasm expert at the University of Louisiana at Lafayette, observers watched the facial expressions of people making sarcastic statements. Expressions around the mouth, as opposed to the eyes or eyebrows, were most often cited as a clue to a sarcastic statement.
The eyes may also be a giveaway. Researchers from California Polytechnic University found that test subjects who were asked to make sarcastic statements were less likely to look the listener in the eye. The researchers suggest that lack of eye contact is a signal to the listener: “This statement is a lie.”
Another experiment that analyzed sarcasm in American TV sitcoms asserted that there’s a “blank face” version of sarcasm delivery.
Despite all these clues, detecting sarcasm can be difficult. There are a lot of things that can cause our sarcasm detectors to break down, scientists are finding. Conditions including autism, closed head injuries, brain lesions and schizophrenia can interfere with the ability to perceive sarcasm.
Researchers at the University of California at San Francisco, for example, recently found that people with frontotemporal dementia have difficulty detecting sarcasm. Neuropsychologist Katherine Rankin has suggested that a loss of the ability to pick up on sarcasm could be used as an early warning sign to help diagnose the disease. “If someone who has the sensitivity loses it, that’s a bad sign,” Rankin says. “If you suddenly think Stephen Colbert is truly right wing, that’s when I would worry.”
Many parts of the brain are involved in processing sarcasm, according to recent brain imaging studies. Rankin has found that the temporal lobes and the parahippocampus are involved in picking up the sarcastic tone of voice. While the left hemisphere of the brain seems to be responsible for interpreting literal statements, the right hemisphere and both frontal lobes seem to be involved in figuring out when the literal statement is intended to mean exactly the opposite, according to a study by researchers at the University of Haifa.
Or you could just get a sarcasm detection device. It turns out scientists can program a computer to recognize sarcasm. Last year, Hebrew University computer scientists in Jerusalem developed their “Semi-supervised Algorithm for Sarcasm Identification.” The program was able to catch 77 percent of the sarcastic statements in Amazon purchaser comments like “Great for insomniacs” in a book review. The scientists say that a computer that could recognize sarcasm could do a better job of summarizing user opinions in product reviews.
The University of Southern California’s Signal Analysis and Interpretation Laboratory announced in 2006 that their “automatic sarcasm recognizer,” a set of computer algorithms, was able to recognize sarcastic versions of “yeah, right” in recorded telephone conversations more than 80 percent of the time. The researchers suggest that a computerized phone operator that understands sarcasm can be programmed to “get” the joke with “synthetic laughter.”
Now that really would be a useful invention. Yeah, right.
Subscribe now for more of Smithsonian's coverage on history, science and nature.









Comments (81)
+ View All Comments
"a computerized phone operator that understands sarcasm can be programmed to “get” the joke with “synthetic laughter" Yikes, that will be the day I throw out my phone!
Posted by Robin Burns on December 2,2012 | 01:14 PM
So the British 'slow clap' would be the equivalent of blank-face sarcasm. Well done, Brits! Something to emulate.
Posted by Gerry Ketchum on November 26,2012 | 05:09 PM
I for one despise the use of sarcasm at the level it has risen to in our culture. it's like a sweet treat; it's tasty, and you love to eat it. but if you eat it too much your teeth go rotten and your health takes a dive and your breath stinks. and that is what I believe is happening to our language. also mike bonner makes a good point.
Posted by george on November 25,2012 | 05:24 PM
Yeah, canned laughter would go over really well the 20% of the time the algorithm failed :)
Posted by VB3 on November 13,2012 | 03:08 PM
Nice to see you've split the article into three pages.
Posted by Mike bonner on November 2,2012 | 04:09 AM
I think there is a misunderstanding between the meaning of sarcasm and irony. In my opinion they are very different things, though most of the times they are used together. Irony is just a sharp bladed knife that is neither good nor bad in itself. It's just a powerful tool. Sarcasm, however is the act of using that tool with the intention of hurting someone. I like irony and I use it a lot, but I hate sarcasm. I get it all the time and I used to smile on it, but every sarcastic comment being told to me just decreases my respect level towards that person. In my experience, the most sarcastic people are the ones with the most serious self-esteem issues. (too high or too low, but not healthy)
Posted by Doe on September 10,2012 | 08:05 AM
"Yeahhh. rightttttt." "Ohh surree." Oh nooo I couldn't possibly do thattt. Those are some examples of sarcasm
Posted by Noah on August 11,2012 | 04:03 PM
I was interested in the huge discrepancy between a northerner and southerner's appreciation for sarcasm. I would love to see an analysis applied east to west as well. As a New Englander who moved out to California for a stint, I found myself moving back home after 4 years in part due to a lack of appreciation for my well-honed sarcastic arts!
Posted by jill on June 28,2012 | 01:19 AM
Really..? Wow,and you're really smart.. so... got to be true. Those who can't pick up on sacrcasm are potentially brain damaged, huh? No kidding? Those who can pick up on sarcasm and buy all of the junk force they're fed-every waking second are....? That's right, genious...(ok, going for maximum sacasm) Don't throw your iphone down the chute...nothing, ok, you're brain dead...yes, you are
Posted by Max Johnson on June 27,2012 | 02:38 PM
One point to make, however, is that those of us who do not enjoy sarcasm are often perceived as people who do not get sarcasm. On the contrary, we understand the joke. We get the humor. We catch the sarcasm. We just don't particularly find it...funny. It's one thing to know something as humor. It's another to make me laugh. While there are many people who are oblivious to sarcasm, the sarcastic types among us need to really understand that, as others have mentioned, sarcasm can cut like a knife. It does have a negative tone to it. Language studies may suggest that sarcasm attenuates this negativity, but the attenuation is subjective. The lessening of its effect seems to benefit you and not the target of the sarcasm. Perhaps it hints at a greater level of insecurity, this lack of sincerity in American culture we have fostered.
Posted by Cf on May 25,2012 | 01:53 AM
Well, I think I liked this article, but I'm not sure yet. Maybe I could run it through a working sarcasm detector, then voice a stronger opinion. (Sarcasm turned off now) I love the great sarcasmic pearls of the 1950s radio comedies and detective series. Leaping ahead, I LOVE (sarcasm is dripping now) all the reality shows on TV.
Posted by Gail Hixenbaugh on April 11,2012 | 05:07 PM
Funny, that Americans would boost their ability to understand sarcasm.
Posted by Axel on March 1,2012 | 10:50 AM
Well... my family's portrait is in the Webster Dictionary when you look up this word. I personally think that humor and sarcasm are on a continuum... Sarcasm does tear the flesh... but humor and wit is a different story and often confused with the corniest of joke tellers. My soon to be X for one. Poor guy. I don't think he ever got me and I now I know I never got him. Heavy sigh.
Posted by C. Schwalbe on February 1,2012 | 10:33 PM
Sarcasm is fascinating no matter how you look at it. One of the most comprehensive sources about sarcasm that I have been able to find online is published by the Sarcasm Society: http://www.sarcasmsociety.com/sarcasm.html
Posted by kufu on February 1,2012 | 06:10 PM
+ View All Comments