Steering Ships Through a Treacherous Waterway
Braving storms with 20-foot seas, an elite group of ship pilots steers through one of the world's most treacherous waterways—the mouth of the Columbia River
- By Matt Jenkins
- Photographs by Ed Kashi
- Smithsonian magazine, February 2009, Subscribe
(Page 3 of 4)
"On a good day, I rarely look at the radar," she said. "That picture is in my head." It was not an exaggeration: one of the tests the bar pilots must pass to earn their license requires them to draw the nautical chart of the bar from memory. "You really know the water that you're working."
Despite all the jet-powered wizardry at their disposal, the pilots' stock in trade is still their feel for the water. They are drawn from the top ranks of ship captains. Many have more than three decades of sea experience, and all carry "unlimited master" licenses, which allow them to captain any ship of any kind, anywhere in the world.
Lewin, who's also the bar pilot group's administrator, was visiting San Francisco when we first met, as luck would have it, at a bar with a commanding view of the Bay Bridge, which the Cosco Busan would hit three months later. "What you learn from doing this a long time is that you never know what's going to happen," Lewin said. "But you always have an alternative. When you stop thinking ahead, you get in trouble."
He went on: "A big part of piloting is anticipating what the sea's going to do to you, and using nature's power to your advantage. You're trying to balance all these forces, and they're different every trip.
"It's Zen, I guess, in a funny sort of way. Too much yang, you're in trouble. Too much yin, same thing. If you get your yin and yang in balance, you make it."
Aboard the Ansac Orient, Dempsey described how, on a bad bar, heavy swells can lift a ship's propeller out of the water and stall the engine, leaving the vessel at the mercy of the currents. "Losing the engine on the bar—you don't wanna do that too often," she said. It has happened to her twice, and the standard operating procedure in that kind of emergency is pretty straightforward. "You kind of, um, hang on," she said, "while the crew tries to restart the engine." A ship can drop its anchors in an effort to hold fast in the channel, but bar-pilot wisdom is that the tactic will likely achieve little more than ripping the anchors off the ship.
A deeply loaded ship—or a short one that can't span two swells—can bottom out on the bar and break in half. And a tall-sided car carrier like the Rainbow Wing can surrender to high winds and veer out of the ship channel onto the shoals.
Late summer brings somewhat better weather and an entirely different hazard: fishing season, when the river clots up with small sport-fishing boats that are often oblivious to the container ships bearing down on them. "Basically," said Mike Glick, another pilot, "they'll risk their life for a stupid fish on the hook."
Summer can bring heavy fog, as well.
Which can mean heavy fog during fishing season.
And, of course, a ship's radars can always conk out at the worst possible moment—say, in heavy fog during fishing season.
Add to that the linguistic gumbo aboard most ships, and even a small problem can rapidly compound itself. "You may have six or seven different languages spoken on the same ship," Lewin said. "And when things are going wrong, everybody gets excited and reverts to their native language."
The pilots all have a story about the day they almost hung up their float coats for good. Last February, a storm front crossed the bar just as Dan Jordan was piloting a tanker out to sea. The waves got so powerful they started pushing the ship backward, forcing Jordan to execute a rare and risky turnaround on the bar before running the ship to shelter upriver. In 2005, another pilot was forced to run a bulk carrier called the Tilos onto the beach to avoid hitting a sport-fishing boat in the ship channel.
Lewin's most memorable day came five years ago. In a storm, the bar can push a ship to the point where it can no longer power its way through the water and begins spinning out of control, like a car on ice. When that happened to him, Lewin was aboard a ship inbound from China. "Brand-new ship, maiden voyage—a loaded tanker," he said. "And as I'm coming in across the bar, all of a sudden this swell was a little bigger than I'd anticipated. The swell's hitting my ship one way, and I want to turn the other way. I started making my turn early, but the ship doesn't wanna turn—in fact, I'm starting to turn the wrong way," he said. "So I put more rudder on it. I put the rudder all the way over—hard right rudder—and asked for all the rpms they could give me. And the ship still kept turning the other way. So I'm pointed right at the North Jetty, with a loaded tanker full of gasoline, going as fast as the ship will go. And I had no control. The sea was taking control of the ship."
Only after another swell took hold of the ship and providentially swung it back onto the channel's centerline did Lewin manage to squeak through. It may have been then that Lewin first picked up his Zen shtick.
Single Page « Previous 1 2 3 4 Next »
Subscribe now for more of Smithsonian's coverage on history, science and nature.









Comments (27)
I had the priveledge of working in that specific environment for 11 years, and I can only say that the whole crew there (Marine Pilots, Pilot Boat Operators/Deckhands and Helicopter crews) are an absolute professional outfit that can accomplish some incredible feats of ability while maintaining an extremely safe culture of operations. Cheers!!
Posted by Wayneiac on April 17,2012 | 09:03 AM
You are most definitely a privileged individual.
Posted by Dexter Eby on November 24,2010 | 01:18 PM
I am so privileged to work for the Columbia River Bar Pilots. I am in awe daily of the job they do. I have the good fortune to have seen it first hand (and gotten extremely sea sick). They are all phenominal.
Great article. You gotta love Captain Dan.
Posted by Felecia eby on August 6,2010 | 12:52 PM
I am hoping to hear from Marilyn Derichs Moran - who commented above about George Erbe - I am the granddaughter of George (daughter of Frances Jean Erbe Schmitz) and I would love to hear from you. He used to make those pancakes for me too (and my brothers and sister). I would love to hear more of what you know about him!!
Posted by Candace Schmitz Lugviel on June 26,2010 | 11:29 PM
Yowza!
Posted by Laura Lynne on September 12,2009 | 02:13 PM
Captain George Erbe, who was one of the Astoria bar pilots (1940-1960 approximately) loved his work. We, as kids, when visiting, were privileged to hear about his work when he returned from a piloting job, often early in the morning. He would tell his stories while making "Uncle George's Hotcakes" for us. Prior to joining the Astoria Bar Pilots Association, he had been a bar pilot on the Yangtze. The Japanese invasion of China and WW II forced him to send his family back to the States and he later followed. This article and the pictures are a treasure I share with my own children and grandchildren, while making more "Uncle George's".
Posted by Marilyn Derichs Moran on June 7,2009 | 12:55 PM
Great article. Having fished for years out of Ilwaco and having crossed the bar in a small boat on the best of days, I can attest to the job the pilots perform. It is a great side show to the fishing to watch the pilot boat or helo making thee trip out with the pilots. It is also fun to listen to the communications between the pilots and the ships. As a result, my son is currently attending Cal Maritime Academy, as many of the Columbia River Bar Pilots have done,in hopes of one day becoming a Columbia River pilot. As for Travis who wants more info, check out California Maritime Academy at www.csum.edu.
Posted by Tuck on April 1,2009 | 01:55 AM
this is a great article, im am very interested in becoming a harbor pilot. I live in northeast florida im about to graduate high school is their any info anybody can share with me to help get me started. THANKS
Posted by travis on March 30,2009 | 12:07 AM
Outstanding article!! I'm an ex U.S. Navy Harbor and Docking Pilot and now a Civil Service Ship Pilot working for the Subase in Groton, Connecticut. Always fascinating to hear of Pilot exploits from other ports around the world. I've climbed those ladders, rode the helos and know the perils well. Kudos to the Columbia Bar Pilots and all those that that help "keep 'em 'tween the ditches".
Posted by Capt Rich Willette on March 22,2009 | 09:00 PM
Good article about good job! I became more proud of our profession. Best wishes to all pilots.
Posted by sergey shabal,sankt-petersburg pilot, russia on March 19,2009 | 03:25 PM
I am a Seattle naval architect. I was raised in Astoria and have known many bar pilots and boat operators over the years. I have crossed the bar with them a number of times, in good weather and bad. Your article is excellent. You have provided an excellent description of their operation and added to my knowledge, but more impressively you have captured the spirit and feeling of this little known but essential piece of world commerce. Thank You.
In response to Joe Pepper:in the early 1960’s the bar pilots moved from the hand rowed skiff, lowered from a former minesweeper, to the Peacock. This boat was based on a German North Sea rescue boat. The Peacock featured a stern ramp from which a powered skiff was launched and retrieved. She was exceptionally seaworthy and served the pilots well for about 40 years until she was replaced by the Chinook.
Posted by Tom Dyer on March 1,2009 | 01:56 PM
A fascinating article about this dangerous profession. What these Columbia River Bar Pilots accomplish is indeed, seamanship at its finest. A few years ago I visited Astoria, Oregon for the first time and was exposed to this beautiful city and learned of the Columbia Bar, the Bar pilots and their history. I can't wait to go back. Your wonderful informative article about this usual occupation further whetted my appetite to return to this city and learn more.
Posted by David Dvorak on February 26,2009 | 11:17 AM
Sorry to differ with B Vineyard's post about the ship that hit a Bay Area bridge, an accident mentioned in our article, but we did in fact get it right. It was the Bay Bridge, not the Golden Gate, as this recent news article about the accident points out: www.mercurynews.com/topstories/ci_11734488?nclick_check=1 Thanks for your interest.
Posted by Terence Monmaney, Executive Editor, Smithsonian on February 19,2009 | 04:50 PM
Facinating artical, the public often see large ships navigating up and down many rivers and harbors I don't think many of them even know that a local pilot is on the bridge. wether at the bar or local harbor, Pilots are the unsung heros protecting the locals from harm. Michael J. Scanlon, CWO4 USCG (ret) Chariman, Rhode Island State Pilotage Commission
Posted by Michael Scanlon on February 16,2009 | 08:58 AM
The article was informative for someone who has an interest in navigation of waterways. However, the pilot who brushed a bridge in California, hit the Golden Gate Bridge, not the Bay Bridge and I do not know a restaurant he could sit and discuss this in with the local informant with a view, which was of the Bay Bridge. Need a bit of editorial help. But great information on the scene in Portland. Thank you.
Posted by B Vineyard on February 13,2009 | 12:58 AM
My wife and I remember our visit to Astoria and driving over that breath-taking bridge, going into Washington. What the river pilots do is a wonderful service, and your article told their story well. Thank you.
Posted by Dan Myers on February 9,2009 | 02:33 PM
Fascinating, well-written story about these awe-inspiring men and woman, who brave such treacherous conditions to really make a difference in the world. Thank you, Matt Jenkins, and Ed Kashi -I look forward to seeing your photographs in the mag.
Posted by Linette Doheney on February 7,2009 | 08:21 PM
Wonderful article. It brought back many memories in the early sixties when I lived near Astoria and worked for WCA the airline serving the area back then. I got to know some of the bar pilots back then due to the fact that many times on outbound ships they could not make it back on the Peacock 2 after crossing out to the ocean from the bar. This then created a long ride on the outbound ship. Sometimes to San Francisco or much further. They would fly back to Astoria via Portland. I was the first to welcome them back at the Astoria airport. One such pilot I remember well was Kenneth McAlpine. I admired all of the pilots who lived lives of true adventure.
Ken Goudy Jr Oregon City, OR
Posted by Ken Goudy Jr on February 7,2009 | 05:46 PM
too bad they didn't cover in the article about where the river pilots and the bar pilolts will merge--or the 100 plus mile voyage of the river pilots.
Posted by glenn stotten on February 4,2009 | 12:41 AM
Thank you for this wonderful article. As a child we regularly visited my grandparents who lived high on a hill that overlooked the entire Columbia River bar. This was before the construction of the bridge and a huge treat for us was a ride across the bar area on the ferry to the Washington side and back. I have always marveled at the those who were able to navigate those treacherous waters. Thank you again for helping remind us all that we aren't really in charge of nature.
Posted by Patco13 on February 4,2009 | 10:03 PM
I read this article and enjoyed it immensely. It's a story little known or appreciated outside the maritime industry. I'm a graduate of the California Maritime Academy in Vallejo, CA (Class of 1963) and I sailed for many years in the merchant marine, and achieving my Captain's License along the way. I took ships in and out of the Columbia River many times during my sea-going years, and I always admired and respected the Columbia River Bar Pilots as being "the best in the business". Theirs is a job (and a responsibility) fraught with dangers at every turn -- and one requiring exceptional seamanship skills, outstanding ship-handling abilities, excellent health & fitness, and remarkable timing. I'm proud to say that several of my classmates from Cal Maritime Academy have risen in their profession to become Columbia River Bar Pilots -- and all have served the maritime industry well.... Captain Manny Aschemeyer Licensed Master Master (retired) Warner Springs, CA
Posted by Captain Manny Aschemeyer on February 4,2009 | 01:12 PM
My family have a histroy of river and seafareing going back to Queen Elizabeth the first, but the Thames was nothing like what I have just read. Well done to all who go down in boats and just keep bobbing along. I have seen many from my window but not read to much about the price they have to pay. It was a grand story and should be read by many who think its a piece of cake. The Brit on the hill. Brian.
Posted by brian sivers on February 3,2009 | 08:52 PM
I recently moved to Astoria, and I would see those little pilot boats going up to the big ships and running alongside them for a while and I wondered what was going on. Until I visited the Columbia River Maritime Museum. There I learned about the bar and river pilots and how they get onto and off of those ships. There's a display there:a big rope and board ladder going strait up one wall... whew! Even indoors with both the floor and the wall stationary and securely fixed together, it's no easy feat. Thanks for a great article.
Posted by Catherine Martin on January 31,2009 | 07:20 PM
I live here in Astoria just a stones throw from the Bar Pilots office. Before evoloving to the use of a Helicopter and Jet Boat, Bar Piolts in the last 30 years have actualled had to be rowed in a skif to the ship from a Pilot Boat Tender. Then a Pilot Boat Tender was built with a motorized boat that was stowed and launched from a groove in its stern.
I still have a drink or two almost daily with Don, who just turned 80, a retired Bar Piolt. He has some great stories about being rowed out to piolt a ship.
Captain Jerry Donnelly - Astoria, Oregon
Posted by Jerry Donnelly on January 31,2009 | 02:05 PM
very interesting article, enjoyed reading it. us landlubbers never hear of such things and the danger associated with them. Bravo and well done for all Pilots. bring more articles of the same caliber
Posted by A. M. Weidenbacher on January 28,2009 | 02:24 PM
Wow, perhaps this immediate snow storm we are experiencing here has colored my enthusiasm but this was one of the best written and thoroughly engaging articles I have ever read. Thank you Matt Jenkins for allowing us to experience the Bar Pilots through your eyes.
Posted by Randy Zuercher on January 28,2009 | 10:42 AM
When the helo doesn't fly in the winter, how do those 4 million dollar jet skis work? Didn't I read an article about a boat being built in Germany for the Columbia River bar pilots years ago and how they made a promise to the industry to keep the bar open for business?? has the group lived up to that promise?
Posted by Joe Pepper on January 27,2009 | 08:48 PM
What a splendidly written article. It really brought the work of the Portland pilots to life in the most graphic way. As a retired Liverpool pilot I have huge admiration for their work. Well done. Geoff Topp
Posted by Geoff Topp retired liverpool Pilot (UK) on January 25,2009 | 05:36 PM
I was glad to read this article, as the Bar and River Pilots do a great job in getting ships over the bar and up the Columbia River. Best Regards Paul R. Monk (Retired GM/Intl.Shipping/Ptld.,Ore.)
Posted by Paul R. Monk on January 24,2009 | 12:36 AM