Invasion of the Longhorn Beetles
In Worcester, Massachusetts, authorities are battling an invasive insect that is poised to devastate the forests of New England
- By Peter Alsop
- Photographs by Max Aguilera-Hellweg
- Smithsonian magazine, November 2009, Subscribe
(Page 3 of 4)
We have no choice but to fight the insect. The costs of not doing so are enormous—one USDA study puts the potential ALB damage in the United States at more than $650 billion, and that's accounting only for trees in municipalities, not on forested lands. The federal government has spent in excess of $250 million on ALB eradication efforts thus far, and more than $24 million in Worcester. Each known outbreak—in New York, New Jersey, Chicago and Worcester—was discovered in a densely populated area, by an alert citizen, after years of infestation. But what if other infestations are taking place out of sight—near a warehouse in a small town in New Hampshire, perhaps, or behind a lumberyard in upstate New York?
I asked E. Richard Hoebeke, a Cornell University entomologist who has studied the Asian longhorned beetle as long as anyone in the United States, about possible undetected infestations. He talked about the many years the beetle had been invading before it came to our attention. He spoke of the overwhelming number of shipping containers pouring into the country.
"Are there other infestations?" he said. "I'm certain of it. Worcester won't be the last."
Concerned that the beetle might find its way into the Northern hardwoods, I visited the ecologist David Foster, director of the Harvard Forest, a 3,000-acre parcel in central Massachusetts that is the site of long-term ecological research. How might the beetle change the New England landscape? To ask that question, as it turns out, is to invite others—questions about what shaped the land in the first place. By way of explanation, Foster took me into the woods.
Much of the Harvard Forest, like more than half of New England, was cleared by farmers in the 18th and 19th centuries and later abandoned. Not far into our walk we passed a crumbling stone wall that cut a straight line through the woods. It was nearing dusk, and a skin of ice covered the snow. Foster, a tall man with dark hair and the ruddy complexion of someone who spends a lot of time outdoors, took big, crunching steps along the trail. We passed a stand of pines and ducked under some fallen snags, and then we came to level land populated by maples and birch. "Beetle food," said Foster, wryly.
It would seem to be our poor luck that so much of New England contains habitat so well suited to the ALB, but, as Foster pointed out, that is at least in part of our own making. In the mid-19th century, New England's settlers began to abandon their farms—lured by cities and by the opening of the West—and their fields returned to forest. Trees such as birch and maple and pine spread first and farthest, on land that once hosted more hemlock, beech and oak, which are not susceptible to the beetle. "Most people walk through these woods and don't see the human impact," Foster said. "But if we compare the vegetation of these forests in 1600 with the vegetation of today, we see huge changes. There's a tremendous increase in species like red maple, which is favored by the beetle."
We have shaped the forest in other ways, too. Chestnut trees once accounted for perhaps a quarter of the Eastern forest. But they were wiped out by the 1950s by an Asian fungus brought here on Japanese nursery stock. A shipment of logs from Europe in 1931 introduced Dutch elm disease, another fungal blight, which infected elms across the Northeast. The European gypsy moth, let loose in Massachusetts in the 1860s, has ravaged oaks and other trees, and the hemlock woolly adelgid, an Asian insect introduced to the East Coast in 1951, has caused widespread mortality in hemlocks. Another invasive Asian beetle, the emerald ash borer, is destroying millions of ash trees in the Midwest and Middle Atlantic. The cumulative effect of these and other pests and pathogens is a more homogenous forest, and one that is more vulnerable to invasion. "We're setting ourselves up for more catastrophe," Foster said.
Forests are becoming even more fragile as the climate warms and the range of native forest pests expands. In the Rocky Mountains, hundreds of thousands of acres of aspen have begun to succumb to the combined pressures of drought, disease, warmer weather and insect predation—a phenomenon termed "sudden aspen decline." Pine trees there are dying in even greater numbers: mountain pine beetles, aided by drought and mild winters, are laying waste to millions of acres.
As the evening grew dark, Foster and I turned back toward his office. We stopped at the edge of the forest, and we could see barns and a snow-covered field and the distant lights of a farmhouse. From where we stood, the Worcester outbreak was less than 40 miles away. I wondered what the beetle might do were it to make it here to the Harvard Forest, which harbors some of the oldest woods in all of Massachusetts.
"Even if it comes through here," Foster said, "there'll still be a forest. It may not be the same, but the forest will continue." He kicked at the snow with the toe of one boot and looked out over the field. "It is such a generalist, though," he said of the beetle. "It likes so many trees. I don't know. It really is one of the worst nightmares."
On the night of december 11, 2008, a freezing rain fell over Worcester, and in the hours before dawn Clint McFarland woke several times to the patter of sleet against his window. In the morning, when he stepped outside, he hardly recognized the city. Under a burden of ice, trees had fallen haphazardly onto cars and houses. Limbs littered the streets; nearly half the roads in Donna Massie's neighborhood were impassable. The ice storm, the worst in a decade, had blanketed much of the Northeast, leaving nearly a million homes and businesses without power, injecting an unforeseeable element of chaos into an already complicated beetle eradication effort.
Contractors up and down the East Coast, from as far south as Florida, began arriving in the city in pursuit of debris-removal work, many of them unaware of the ordinance against removing wood from a quarantined area. In the days after the storm, several trucks were seen carting tree limbs away, despite patrols by environmental police. "We know that wood has been moved out of the city," McFarland told me when I caught up with him the following week. "That's our paramount concern right now. It can't happen again."
Single Page « Previous 1 2 3 4 Next »
Subscribe now for more of Smithsonian's coverage on history, science and nature.









Comments (22)
+ View All Comments
Very educational and helpful article. Also thank you for the work that you all are doing to remedy Beetle Infestations. Last year (2012) we began to notice signs of the Emerald Ash Borer Beetle on our Ash Trees. Upon inspection, we found small holes, but are unsure of the cause, as they seem more to be caused by the Wood Peckers, pecking holes in the trunks. (They are more or less round, with bark stripped below them, and into the cambium of the tree.) You mention "Heat treatment" for the Asian Longhorm Beetle. So, I'm wondering if smoke from camp fires might deter both types of beetle in some way(s)? For we've also noticed that the trees in direct line with the smoke seem to be less effected than those that are not. Not sure if this could mean that the smoke scared the Wood Peckers away this winter, which is why we noticed that that something was going on with the Ash Trees, or that the smoke may serve as a Beetle deterrent. We live in a rural area, so camp fires are permitted here. Would love to know your thoughts on smoke as a beetle deterrent. Thanks, and keep up the great work! F.N.O.
Posted by Ladybug G on April 2,2013 | 06:53 PM
what do these beatles look like? i just saw one in my home it has orange wings can you id these? sincerly, tom stony brook ny 11790
Posted by tom on December 29,2011 | 08:07 AM
I found one of these beetles while at a church supper in the woods of Southern Utah. Do I need to report it? And to whom? For verification, I brought it home in a plastic bag. I found the article informing, but this vital piece of the puzzle was missing: what to do if you find one.
Posted by Candice Stoddard on August 4,2010 | 12:52 AM
They are ravaging NYC, just check out this map:
http://www.pallettruth.com/beetle-nyc-wood-infestation/
They're all over the place in the city, and they need to be stopped.
The chart I linked too above explains that all trees which are infested need to be cut down, and chipped. Also, inspect wood products like wood pallets for any infestation.
Posted by John S. Hager on June 10,2010 | 05:32 PM
Hi as I was doing some yard work I noticed a similar beetle and perhaps the same one as featured in this article. I live in Hawai'i and am not sure if they are present here or if I have come across something similar but I have noticed that there have been some boring beetles or other insects that have hollowed out the woody sections of both my plumeria as well as my bougainvillea. I was wondering what sorts of measures could be taken to eradicate or prevent these things from spreading. I have purchased a systemic but are there any other methods.
Mahalo,
Dan
Posted by Daniel Armitage on April 1,2010 | 08:23 PM
They chipped the hardwoods? That seems terribly wasteful. Couldn't they have made boards and had them inspected before they went out? What did they do with the chips? That could be pelletized and provide heat. I literally get nauseous thinking about a Walnut tree being ripped to shreds and discarded.
Also, has anyone experimented with companion planting? Many plants are so abhorrent to insects that they will not nest near them. And some substances might be ingested in the roots of the trees to make them repel visitors.
Posted by William Ross on November 22,2009 | 09:28 AM
I don’t know anything about entomology, but I had no problems understanding the article. The story was written in easy to understand language, so that it would appeal to a wide range of audiences. The story was also presented emotionally, but was still informative. The way the story was told chronologically was beneficial to the reader and made it easier to follow.
Posted by Pam Swan on November 13,2009 | 11:51 AM
I really enjoyed this article; it was extremely well written and informative. Through the vivid use of imagery and expert examples the author grabbed my attention about a subject on which I had no previous knowledge.
I had no idea that this situation had come about, much less the severity of it. It is crazy to think that a small beetle can have such a huge environmental impact. I agree that increasing citizen awareness is one of the best immediate ways to prevent the continued spread of the beetle.
Posted by Allison Turner on November 13,2009 | 08:36 AM
This is such a sad story. The seriousness of this situation is drastically increased since these beetles don't pick and choose the types of trees that they infest. I wonder if there is any threat of the infestation spreading to the southwest states, and if so, what we plan to do to stop it?
Posted by David Reed on November 11,2009 | 01:40 PM
I found this article to be extremely informative. As someone who is not from the New England region, I have never seen of or heard about the Asian Longhorned Beetle.
The author did a great job of informing the reader about where the beetle originated, how it came to America and the consequences of infestation. With the beetle's wide variety of tree preferences, it is easy to understand the severity of the threat.
The wide variety of sources and personal accounts provided in the story allowed me to experience the infestation from several different viewpoints. Also, the author's way of describing the scenes made me feel as though I was walking alongside him, experiencing the devastation first-hand.
It is tragic to have to kill so many trees in order to stop the infestation from spreading. I'm hopeful that through increased citizen awareness from stories such as this further infestations in other areas can be prevented.
Posted by Taylor Holder on November 10,2009 | 10:15 PM
I have worked for TruGreen in the Chicago area for over ten years, In the early to mid 2000's we were contracted by the state Ag dept. to treat over 5,000 trees along streets in different inner city areas, this was for specifically the Asian Long Horned beetle, We used a fairly common (To Arborists, and tree professionals) product called Mauget, It's a liquid that is slowly absorbed into the bottom of the tree aprox. 1/2 inch in to the tree and brought up the tree to the crown, There are many different types of this product to treat Iron deficiencies to fertilizers, to insect problems, Imicide was used with great results, So good in fact that are services were no longer needed, I'm writing this because every time I read an article on these beetles it always ends with a no cure, or nothing can be done, I'm not sure if there is a anti Mauget conspiracy going on or what, Injectacide B is another product that will work for Emerald Ash Borers yet it gets no mention, sure it's a strong insecticide, But the alternative is dead then no trees, time to stop hating everything that isn't biodegradable, As long as you aren't eating any treated trees you'll be fine. By the way I have no connection to this product or company, I just know it works.
Posted by marc on November 7,2009 | 07:05 PM
As an Entomologist working for the NH Department of Agriculture, Markets and Food, I can tell you emphatically that as of today ALB has not been found NH. Our department receives calls on a regular basis from many people, most of whom are almost positive that they have discovered ALB and so far all of these calls have resulted in observations of insect look-a-likes that are not ALB. Usually the ALB-suspect turns out to be a White-Spotted Sawyer or a Western Conifer Seed Bug, but sometimes (like today for example) it turns out to be a Red-Legged Grasshopper. Nevertheless, we take ever caller seriously and encourage everyone to continue to be on full alert for this pest and please contact us if you find any suspects. You never know when someone like Donna Massie is going to call with the real deal.
Posted by John Weaver on November 6,2009 | 02:41 PM
The clock is ticking on the Long Horn beetle problem. We had one at our house in Berlin, NH this summer, but didn't at that time know what it was. It landed on our porch railing. If I had known just what species it was and how devastating it can be, there would have been one less in the gene pool a few seconds after observing its landing and subsequent take off. As it was, we didn't see any information posted on this beetle until almost a month later. Now I have to wonder how long the beautiful forested area that surrounds us will remain intact.
Posted by Art Sederquist on November 5,2009 | 02:35 PM
We can all thank the incompetent leadership of USDA-PPQ for the so called "invasion". As a Plant Protection and Quarantine Officer, Sea Port of NY, my colleagues and I used to find all types of Wood Boring Insects in Crates and Dunnage from foreign origins. (1979-1984).
Asian Longhorn Beetle is just one of many potentially harmful wood boring insects. We used to find many species of related Cerambycids, Buprestids (Metallic Borers), Scolytids (Darkling Beetles, Bostrichids, Lyctids, and Urocyrus and Sirex spp.(Wasps/Sawflies)...All attacked healthy trees in their countries of origin.
PPQ Inspectors in the field pleaded with USDA Management to impose mandatory fumigation on all foreign crates, dunnage, and untreated lumber. Instead, they deemed most of the mentioned species to be of non-quarantine significance. They did not make the decision based on sound Biological principles. Rather, they felt that mandatory fumigation would impede commerce, and adversely affect international trade. Hence, they opened the flood gates for these highly destructive insects. Today, thanks to the incompetence and irresponsible USDA management of the 80's, we have a plethora of wood boring insects that we are trying to control: Citrus Long Horn Beetle, Emerald Ash Borer/Buprestidae, Pine Tree Shoot Borer-Scolytidae.
Oh incidentally, mandatory fumigation for wood crated material was finally mandated about ten years ago. A bit late, don't you think?
Posted by Wood Peckin PPQ Man on November 5,2009 | 11:59 AM
+ View All Comments