Invasion of the Longhorn Beetles
In Worcester, Massachusetts, authorities are battling an invasive insect that is poised to devastate the forests of New England
- By Peter Alsop
- Photographs by Max Aguilera-Hellweg
- Smithsonian magazine, November 2009, Subscribe
On a pleasant july evening Donna Massie steered her car into her driveway at the bottom of Whitmarsh Avenue in Worcester, Massachusetts. Her husband, Kevin, and his friend Jesse were huddled beside Jesse's car, a gold Hyundai Sonata, and were peering closely at one of its doors. They were staring not at a dent but at a striking black-and-white beetle, about the width of Donna's pinkie and half as long, with bluish legs and two banded antennas that curved back over the length of its body like the whiskers of a catfish.
The beetle gently probed the surface of the car with its forelegs. None of the three was much of a bug person, and Donna was decidedly anti-bug, stipulating a death-to-insect policy in her house. Still, the beetle transfixed her. It was larger than any she'd ever encountered, and with its otherworldly colors it was almost beautiful. Before the creature whirled its wings and flew away, Massie and her husband decided that it must be a June bug, albeit a freakish sort.
The insect might have escaped further notice, and evaded authorities altogether, if the Massies had not hosted a cookout two days later in their backyard, where others began to notice the curious beetles. They were hard to miss, creeping along the trunks of the maple trees that fringed the Massies' yard. Their black wing casings stood out starkly against the silver bark. One beetle planted itself on Kevin's pant leg and had to be pried loose. Then Donna noticed something unnerving. Near the base of one maple, she found a beetle sprinkled with sawdust, its head submerged in a dime-size hole in the tree's trunk. It seemed to be eating its way inward.
The following morning, Donna searched the Internet and identified her backyard visitor as an Asian longhorned beetle, also known by the abbreviation ALB. Her search also turned up a pest alert from the state of Florida that warned of the dangers posed by the insect. Donna began leaving messages with various agricultural authorities.
Patty Douglass, who works for the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA), was in her office in Wallingford, Connecticut, 75 miles south of Worcester, when Donna Massie's call came through. In her position as the plant health director for Connecticut, Massachusetts and Rhode Island, Douglass regularly fields phone calls from gardeners, landscapers and amateur entomologists who believe they've encountered one of the nonnative insects on the USDA's threat list. Nearly all of these calls prove to be in error, as the insect universe is almost incomprehensibly large and varied, and mistakes in identification are easily made. The beetle order alone contains some 350,000 known species; by comparison, the total number of bird species is roughly 10,000.
Massie took a photograph of the beetle with her cellphone and sent it in. The portrait was pixelated, but the beetle's speckled black-and-white abdomen and its telltale antennas were unmistakable. Within 24 hours of receiving the image, Douglass and Jennifer Forman Orth, an invasive species ecologist with the Massachusetts Department of Agricultural Resources, were standing beside Massie in her backyard, staring up at her trees. Douglass spotted one of the insects, confirming with her own eyes a scenario that she and others at the USDA had long feared—an ALB outbreak in New England. She grabbed Massie's arm. "Oh, God," she said. "They're really here."
For most of its history, the Asian longhorned beetle occupied a small, largely unremarkable niche in the forests of China, Korea and Japan. It was not known as a serious pest. In the 1960s and 1970s, however, the Chinese government began to plant enormous windbreaks of millions of trees in its northern provinces in response to erosion and deforestation. These windbreaks were composed almost entirely of poplar trees, which mature quickly and tolerate the arid, cold climate of northern China. As it happens, the poplar is a tree favored by the ALB, along with maple, birch, elm and several other hardwoods. The beetle is unique among invasive forest pests for attacking such a broad array of hosts, which is partly why it is so dangerous.
Adult beetles feed on leaves, twigs and young bark. Females deposit anywhere from 35 to 90 eggs, one at a time, in pits they dig in the bark. When the eggs hatch, ALB larvae bore into the cambium, the tissue that ferries the tree's nutrients, and then they move into the heartwood. Over several years, this tunneling chokes off a tree's supply of nutrients and kills it—a death by a thousand cuts.
In the 1980s, as China's poplar forests matured, the ALB population exploded. Within a few years, hundreds of millions of trees were infested, and the Chinese government had to cut tens of thousands of acres of forest to prevent the beetle's further trespass.
Meanwhile, China, along with the rest of the world, experienced a surge in foreign trade. Since 1970, global sea trade has tripled, and today more than 90 percent of the world's goods travel at least one leg of their journey by ship. The United States went from importing 8 million sea containers in 1980 to more than 30 million in 2000. And most of those products—diapers, televisions, umbrellas—are packed in crates or on pallets made of wood. In the 1980s, pallets of infested poplar began to leave Chinese ports, carrying Asian longhorned beetle larvae. A stowaway on the global shipping network, the insect came into nearly instant contact with warehouses across the world.
In August 1996, Ingram Carner, a landlord in Brooklyn, New York, noticed that the Norway maples on his property were full of strange perforations, each slightly thicker than a pencil and so perfectly spherical they looked as if they'd been drilled. When the culprit was identified, and the USDA realized the nature of the threat—a beetle with the capacity to destroy numerous native hardwoods—the agency began cutting down thousands of infested trees and chipping them. That's the best way to ensure the beetle's demise; insecticides don't reach it once it has burrowed past the cambium, although they might protect unafflicted trees. In addition, the USDA established a quarantine around much of New York City, prohibiting anyone from transporting wood that could host the beetle. The restriction is still in place. In the 13 years since the initial outbreak, authorities have documented the ALB in Queens, Staten Island, northern New Jersey and on Long Island. The work of eradicating the beetle from the New York City area continues.
Infestations have also been discovered in Chicago and Toronto. The beetles have been intercepted in dozens of ports and warehouses across the country, from Mobile, Alabama, to Bellingham, Washington. But the discovery of an ALB outbreak in Worcester marked an ominous turn. While previous infestations were confined to urban areas with relatively thin tree cover, Worcester—a city of 175,000 people 40 miles west of Boston—is full of trees, most of them hardwoods. More troubling, the city sits at the southern edge of the great Northern hardwood forest, millions of contiguous acres stretching to Canada and the Great Lakes. If the beetle escaped into such a forest, it could prove the most devastating arboreal pest we've ever known, occasioning more damage than Dutch elm disease, gypsy moths and chestnut blight combined. It could change the face of the New England woods.
Subscribe now for more of Smithsonian's coverage on history, science and nature.









Comments (21)
+ View All Comments
what do these beatles look like? i just saw one in my home it has orange wings can you id these? sincerly, tom stony brook ny 11790
Posted by tom on December 29,2011 | 08:07 AM
I found one of these beetles while at a church supper in the woods of Southern Utah. Do I need to report it? And to whom? For verification, I brought it home in a plastic bag. I found the article informing, but this vital piece of the puzzle was missing: what to do if you find one.
Posted by Candice Stoddard on August 4,2010 | 12:52 AM
They are ravaging NYC, just check out this map:
http://www.pallettruth.com/beetle-nyc-wood-infestation/
They're all over the place in the city, and they need to be stopped.
The chart I linked too above explains that all trees which are infested need to be cut down, and chipped. Also, inspect wood products like wood pallets for any infestation.
Posted by John S. Hager on June 10,2010 | 05:32 PM
Hi as I was doing some yard work I noticed a similar beetle and perhaps the same one as featured in this article. I live in Hawai'i and am not sure if they are present here or if I have come across something similar but I have noticed that there have been some boring beetles or other insects that have hollowed out the woody sections of both my plumeria as well as my bougainvillea. I was wondering what sorts of measures could be taken to eradicate or prevent these things from spreading. I have purchased a systemic but are there any other methods.
Mahalo,
Dan
Posted by Daniel Armitage on April 1,2010 | 08:23 PM
They chipped the hardwoods? That seems terribly wasteful. Couldn't they have made boards and had them inspected before they went out? What did they do with the chips? That could be pelletized and provide heat. I literally get nauseous thinking about a Walnut tree being ripped to shreds and discarded.
Also, has anyone experimented with companion planting? Many plants are so abhorrent to insects that they will not nest near them. And some substances might be ingested in the roots of the trees to make them repel visitors.
Posted by William Ross on November 22,2009 | 09:28 AM
I don’t know anything about entomology, but I had no problems understanding the article. The story was written in easy to understand language, so that it would appeal to a wide range of audiences. The story was also presented emotionally, but was still informative. The way the story was told chronologically was beneficial to the reader and made it easier to follow.
Posted by Pam Swan on November 13,2009 | 11:51 AM
I really enjoyed this article; it was extremely well written and informative. Through the vivid use of imagery and expert examples the author grabbed my attention about a subject on which I had no previous knowledge.
I had no idea that this situation had come about, much less the severity of it. It is crazy to think that a small beetle can have such a huge environmental impact. I agree that increasing citizen awareness is one of the best immediate ways to prevent the continued spread of the beetle.
Posted by Allison Turner on November 13,2009 | 08:36 AM
This is such a sad story. The seriousness of this situation is drastically increased since these beetles don't pick and choose the types of trees that they infest. I wonder if there is any threat of the infestation spreading to the southwest states, and if so, what we plan to do to stop it?
Posted by David Reed on November 11,2009 | 01:40 PM
I found this article to be extremely informative. As someone who is not from the New England region, I have never seen of or heard about the Asian Longhorned Beetle.
The author did a great job of informing the reader about where the beetle originated, how it came to America and the consequences of infestation. With the beetle's wide variety of tree preferences, it is easy to understand the severity of the threat.
The wide variety of sources and personal accounts provided in the story allowed me to experience the infestation from several different viewpoints. Also, the author's way of describing the scenes made me feel as though I was walking alongside him, experiencing the devastation first-hand.
It is tragic to have to kill so many trees in order to stop the infestation from spreading. I'm hopeful that through increased citizen awareness from stories such as this further infestations in other areas can be prevented.
Posted by Taylor Holder on November 10,2009 | 10:15 PM
I have worked for TruGreen in the Chicago area for over ten years, In the early to mid 2000's we were contracted by the state Ag dept. to treat over 5,000 trees along streets in different inner city areas, this was for specifically the Asian Long Horned beetle, We used a fairly common (To Arborists, and tree professionals) product called Mauget, It's a liquid that is slowly absorbed into the bottom of the tree aprox. 1/2 inch in to the tree and brought up the tree to the crown, There are many different types of this product to treat Iron deficiencies to fertilizers, to insect problems, Imicide was used with great results, So good in fact that are services were no longer needed, I'm writing this because every time I read an article on these beetles it always ends with a no cure, or nothing can be done, I'm not sure if there is a anti Mauget conspiracy going on or what, Injectacide B is another product that will work for Emerald Ash Borers yet it gets no mention, sure it's a strong insecticide, But the alternative is dead then no trees, time to stop hating everything that isn't biodegradable, As long as you aren't eating any treated trees you'll be fine. By the way I have no connection to this product or company, I just know it works.
Posted by marc on November 7,2009 | 07:05 PM
As an Entomologist working for the NH Department of Agriculture, Markets and Food, I can tell you emphatically that as of today ALB has not been found NH. Our department receives calls on a regular basis from many people, most of whom are almost positive that they have discovered ALB and so far all of these calls have resulted in observations of insect look-a-likes that are not ALB. Usually the ALB-suspect turns out to be a White-Spotted Sawyer or a Western Conifer Seed Bug, but sometimes (like today for example) it turns out to be a Red-Legged Grasshopper. Nevertheless, we take ever caller seriously and encourage everyone to continue to be on full alert for this pest and please contact us if you find any suspects. You never know when someone like Donna Massie is going to call with the real deal.
Posted by John Weaver on November 6,2009 | 02:41 PM
The clock is ticking on the Long Horn beetle problem. We had one at our house in Berlin, NH this summer, but didn't at that time know what it was. It landed on our porch railing. If I had known just what species it was and how devastating it can be, there would have been one less in the gene pool a few seconds after observing its landing and subsequent take off. As it was, we didn't see any information posted on this beetle until almost a month later. Now I have to wonder how long the beautiful forested area that surrounds us will remain intact.
Posted by Art Sederquist on November 5,2009 | 02:35 PM
We can all thank the incompetent leadership of USDA-PPQ for the so called "invasion". As a Plant Protection and Quarantine Officer, Sea Port of NY, my colleagues and I used to find all types of Wood Boring Insects in Crates and Dunnage from foreign origins. (1979-1984).
Asian Longhorn Beetle is just one of many potentially harmful wood boring insects. We used to find many species of related Cerambycids, Buprestids (Metallic Borers), Scolytids (Darkling Beetles, Bostrichids, Lyctids, and Urocyrus and Sirex spp.(Wasps/Sawflies)...All attacked healthy trees in their countries of origin.
PPQ Inspectors in the field pleaded with USDA Management to impose mandatory fumigation on all foreign crates, dunnage, and untreated lumber. Instead, they deemed most of the mentioned species to be of non-quarantine significance. They did not make the decision based on sound Biological principles. Rather, they felt that mandatory fumigation would impede commerce, and adversely affect international trade. Hence, they opened the flood gates for these highly destructive insects. Today, thanks to the incompetence and irresponsible USDA management of the 80's, we have a plethora of wood boring insects that we are trying to control: Citrus Long Horn Beetle, Emerald Ash Borer/Buprestidae, Pine Tree Shoot Borer-Scolytidae.
Oh incidentally, mandatory fumigation for wood crated material was finally mandated about ten years ago. A bit late, don't you think?
Posted by Wood Peckin PPQ Man on November 5,2009 | 11:59 AM
This is truly a heart-breaking scenario, with economic ramifications (maple syrup, fall "leaf-peepers") and cultural--not to mention the obvious probable environmental devastation. The Maple leaf is Canada's national symbol, like our Bald Eagles, and ubiquitous throughout the New England region.
Understanding how this beetle was introduced to the US makes it also seem that much more crucial to have strong controls in place regarding how goods are transported; quality control and safety go beyond the product itself to the containers it arrives in and the method of transportation.
We must figure this one out--there is no room for failure.
Posted by Kate Nugent on November 2,2009 | 12:42 PM
+ View All Comments