Defending the Rhino
As demand for rhino horn soars, police and conservationists in South Africa pit technology against increasingly sophisticated poachers
- By Richard Conniff
- Smithsonian magazine, November 2011, Subscribe
(Page 5 of 5)
Illegal trafficking in rhino horn does not seem to be confined to a single criminal syndicate or game farm. “A lot of people are gobsmacked by how pervasive that behavior is throughout the industry,” said Traffic’s Milliken. “People are just blinded by greed—your professional hunters, your veterinarians, the people who own these game ranches. We have never seen this level of private sector complicity with gangs supplying horn to Asia.”
Like Milliken, most conservationists believe trophy hunting can be a legitimate contributor to the conservation of rhinos. But they have also seen that hunting creates a moral gray zone. The system depends on harvesting a limited number of rhinos under permits issued by the government. But when the price is right, some trophy-hunting operators apparently find they can justify killing any rhino. Obtaining permits becomes a technicality. The South African government is debating a moratorium on rhino hunting.
For Milliken, the one hopeful sign is that the price for rhino horn seems to have spiked too quickly to be attributable to increased demand alone. That is, the current crisis may be a case of the madness of crowds—an economic bubble inflated by speculative buying in Asia. If so, like other bubbles, it will eventually go bust.
In the meantime, the rhinos continue to die. At Hluhluwe-iMfolozi, poachers last year killed 3 black rhinos and 12 whites. “We have estimated that what we are losing would basically overtake the birthrate in the next two years, and populations will start to drop down,” said San-Mari Ras, a district ranger. That is, the park may no longer have any seed stock to send to other new habitats.
From the floor of her office, Ras picked up the skull of a black rhino calf with a neat little bullet hole into its brain. “They will take a rhino horn even at this size,” she said, spreading her thumb and index finger. “That’s how greedy the poachers can be.”
Richard Conniff’s latest book, The Species Seekers, comes out in paperback this month.
Single Page « Previous 1 2 3 4 5
Subscribe now for more of Smithsonian's coverage on history, science and nature.
Related topics: Mammals Hunting South Africa
Additional Sources
“Guidelines for large herbivore translocation simplified: black rhinoceros case study,” Wayne L. Linklater et al., Journal of Applied Ecology, April 2011









Comments (8)
Defending the rhino will be like turning back the tide as South Africa continues to devolve. However these heroic efforts should not be abandoned.
Posted by Thomas Michael Andres on February 4,2012 | 01:11 AM
Thank you for this in-depth article on the rhino's situation. It's spreading awareness and inspiring folks to take action that will surely help save this gentle beast... it sure got me involved!
Posted by Wildlife Margrit on December 22,2011 | 11:03 AM
Thank you for a timely and much needed article concerning rhino poaching in Africa. It is a pitiful reflection on our species that these oldest of mammals could become extinct due to our superstitions and blind ignorance in what we think/wish/hope a horn of keratin can do. And for South Africa to issue new hunting permits to Dawie Groenewald, one is tempted to believe there are more than the currently arrested 13 suspects in this horrif case. I look at Africa and I see human greed in a mad race to see which goes extinct first: the elephant or the rhino. Neither is acceptable to me; either is an unconscionable sin committed against nature and the world my, and your, grandchildren deserve to inherit.
Posted by Linda Reifschneider on November 28,2011 | 06:07 PM
Also a reason why humans are worthless too.
Posted by Guest on November 13,2011 | 12:57 PM
Isn't it possible to amputate the rhino horns at a safe point to make killing them valueless? Then the horns can be sold.
Posted by Moiraz on November 9,2011 | 09:56 PM
I enjoyed this article. I had the opportunity to dart hunt a black rhino in 2005 in the same province. Was glad to see it taken care of by a Vet, and then let go to roam. These animals are so facinating.
Posted by Colleen on November 5,2011 | 07:45 PM
we have to keep our rhino's safe.
Posted by carol watson on October 22,2011 | 07:10 PM
We are all from the same place, God took the dirt from the ground and made humans just like he did with aniamls, so why are some of us so cruel and others are so caring?
Posted by Ruth on October 20,2011 | 01:01 PM