Annette von Jouanne at Oregons Otter Rock Beach Annette von Jouanne stands in the ocean along Oregon's Otter Rock Beach, near where she's been experimenting with wave energy buoys.

Annette von Jouanne

Catching a Wave, Powering an Electrical Grid?

Electrical engineer Annette von Jouanne is pioneering an ingenious way to generate clean, renewable electricity from the sea

  • By Elizabeth Rusch
  • Smithsonian magazine, July 2009

Article Tools

  • Font
    		•  Share/Save/Bookmark Share
  • Email
    		•
  • Print
    		•  Digg Digg
  • Comments
    		•  StumbleUpon StumbleUpon
  • RSS
    		•  Reddit Reddit

    Photo Gallery

    Wave infographic

    Catching a Wave, Powering an Electrical Grid?

    Explore more photos from the story


    Video Gallery

    Deploying the Wave Energy Buoy

    Deploying the Wave Energy Buoy

    See a prototype of a wave energy buoy bob up and down on the water's surface as researchers from Oregon State University study its efficacy


    Related Links

    Wallace Energy Systems and Renewables Facility at Oregon State University
    Columbia Power Technologies

    (Page 4 of 5)

    More from Smithsonian.com

    George Boehlert, a marine scientist and director of the center, looks out of his office at a field of undulating sea grass. "What we know now is what we don't know," says Boehlert, whose dirty blond curls resemble ocean waves. "Ocean energy is a fast-moving field and environmental researchers have a lot of questions."

    For instance, the buoys absorb energy from waves, reducing their size and power. Would shrunken swells affect sand movement and currents near shore, perhaps contributing to erosion?

    Buoys, as well as the power cables that would connect to the electrical grid on-shore, emit electromagnetic fields. And mooring cables would thrum in the currents, like a guitar string. Might these disturbances confuse whales, sharks, dolphins, salmon, rays, crabs and other marine animals that use electromagnetism and sound for feeding, mating or navigation?

    Would birds collide with the buoys or turtles become entangled in the cables?

    Would anchors create artificial reefs that attract fish not normally found in that habitat?

    Would deploying, maintaining and removing buoys disturb the seafloor or otherwise change the ocean environment?

    "I want to know the answers to these questions, too," von Jouanne says. "The last thing I want to do is harm the ocean and its beautiful creatures." To study the environmental risks and allow wave-energy engineers to test their inventions, she and colleagues at Oregon State, including Boehlert, are building a floating test berth nearby. It is scheduled to open next year and at its center will be a buoy full of instruments to collect data on how well wave-energy converters are performing.

    The test berth is part of a massive effort to move wave energy out of the lab and onto the electrical power grid. Through a new Energy Department-funded national marine renewable energy center, researchers from all over the country will have the chance to refine their inventions in the WESRF energy lab, test them in the Hinsdale wave flume and perfect them in the ocean. "This is what we need to do to fully explore wave energy as part of a renewable energy portfolio, for the state, the nation and the world," von Jouanne says.

    Boehlert and others say that even if wave energy has some local environmental impacts, it would likely be far less harmful than coal- and oil-fired power plants. "The effects of continuing to pump carbon into the atmosphere could be much worse for marine life than buoys bobbing in the waves," he says. "We want ocean energy to work."

    She was in the water when the epiphany struck. Of course, Annette von Jouanne was always in the water, swimming in lakes and pools as she was growing up around Seattle, and swimming distance freestyle competitively in high-school and college meets. There's even an exercise pool in her basement, where she and her husband (a former Olympic swimmer for Portugal) and their three kids have spent a great deal of time...swimming.

    But in December 1995 she was bodysurfing in Hawaii over the holidays. She'd just begun working as an assistant professor of electrical engineering at Oregon State University. She was 26 years old and eager to make a difference—to find or improve upon a useful source of energy, preferably one that wasn't scarce or fleeting or unpredictable or dirty. The sun was going down. The wind was dying. She was bobbing in the swells.

    "As the sun set, it hit me: I could ride waves all day and all night, all year long," says von Jouanne. "Wave power is always there. It never stops. I began thinking that there's got to be a way to harness all the energy of an ocean swell, in a practical and efficient way, in a responsible way."

    Today, von Jouanne is one of the driving forces in the fast-growing field of wave energy—as well as its leading proponent. She will explain to anyone who will listen that unlike wind and solar power, wave energy is always available. Even when the ocean seems calm, swells are moving water up and down sufficiently to generate electricity. And an apparatus to generate kilowatts of power from a wave can be much smaller than what's needed to harness kilowatts from wind or sunshine because water is dense and the energy it imparts is concentrated.

    All that energy is also, of course, destructive, and for decades the challenge has been to build a device that can withstand monster waves and gale-force winds, not to mention corrosive saltwater, seaweed, floating debris and curious marine mammals. And the device must also be efficient and require little maintenance.

    Still, the allure is irresistible. A machine that could harness an inexhaustible, nonpolluting source of energy and be deployed economically in sufficient numbers to generate significant amounts of electricity—that would be a feat for the ages.

    Engineers have built dozens of the machines, called wave-energy converters, and tested some on a small scale. In the United States, waves could fuel about 6.5 percent of today's electricity needs, says Roger Bedard of the Electric Power Research Institute, an energy think tank in Palo Alto, California. That's the equivalent of the energy in 150 million barrels of oil—about the same amount of power that is produced by all U.S. hydroelectric dams combined—enough to power 23 million typical American homes. The most powerful waves occur on western coasts, because of strong west-to-east global winds, so Great Britain, Portugal and the West Coast of the United States are among the sites where wave energy is being developed.

    Aside from swimming, von Jouanne's other passion as a youngster was learning how things work. It started with small appliances. An alarm clock broke. She unscrewed the back, fixed the mechanism and put it back together. She was about 8 years old. "That was so exciting for me," she says. She moved on to calculators and then to a computer she bought with money from her paper route. One day, she waited for her parents to leave the house so she could take apart the television and reassemble it before they returned. (Von Jouanne cautions kids not to do as she did: "there is a high-voltage component.")

    When her brothers, older by eight and ten years, came home for college breaks, she pored over their engineering textbooks. (An older sister pursued a business degree.) "Reading them confirmed that, yup, this is what I want to do," she recalls.

    She studied electrical engineering as an undergraduate at Southern Illinois University and for her doctorate at Texas A&M University. She was often one of the few women in a class. "I never saw myself as a woman engineer," she says. "I saw myself as an engineer trying to make things better for the world."

    At Oregon State University, she related her wave-tossed epiphany to Alan Wallace, a professor of electrical engineering who shared her fascination with the ocean's power. "We started saying, there's got to be a way to harness this energy," she recalls. They studied the wave-energy converters then being produced and looked up centuries-old patents for contraptions to extract power from waves. Some resembled windmills, animal cages or ship propellers. A modern one looked like a huge whale. The gadgets all had one problem in common: they were too complicated.

    Take, for example, a device called the Pelamis Attenuator, which was recently deployed for four months off the coast of Portugal by Pelamis Wave Power. It looks like a 500-foot-long red snake. As waves travel its length, the machine bends up and down. The bending pumps hydraulic fluid through a motor, which generates electricity. Complex machines like this are riddled with valves, filters, tubes, hoses, couplings, bearings, switches, gauges, meters and sensors. The intermediate stages reduce efficiency, and if one component breaks, the whole device goes kaput.

    After analyzing the field, von Jouanne says, "I knew we needed a simpler design."

    Von Jouanne's lab is named in memory of Wallace, who died in 2006, but the Wallace Energy Systems & Renewables Facility (WESRF) is familiarly known as "We Surf." Painted in deep blues and grays and bearing murals of curling waves, the lab has been a research facility and testing ground for such innovative products as an all-electric naval ship, a hovercraft and the Ford Escape Hybrid engine. In one corner is a tall buoy that resembles a huge copper-top battery. Beside it another buoy looks like two cross-country skis with wire strung between them. The designs were among von Jouanne's earliest. "Breakthroughs are almost always born of failures," she says.

    Her breakthrough was to conceive of a device that has just two main components. In the most recent prototypes, a thick coil of copper wire is inside the first component, which is anchored to the seafloor. The second component is a magnet attached to a float that moves up and down freely with the waves. As the magnet is heaved by the waves, its magnetic field moves along the stationary coil of copper wire. This motion induces a current in the wire—electricity. It's that simple.

    By early 2005, von Jouanne had engineered one of her prototypes and wanted to test whether it was waterproof. She hauled the wave-energy converter to her basement, into a flume that circulates water to let her swim in place. Her daughter Sydney, then 6, sat on the prototype, much as a seal might cling to a real buoy. It floated.

    Next she phoned a nearby wave pool, where people go to play in simulated waves.

    "Do you rent out your pool?" she said.

    "For how many people?" the attendant asked.

    "Not many people—one wave-energy buoy."

    The park donated two early mornings to her venture. Von Jouanne anchored the machine with ten 45-pound weights from a health club. It performed well in the playful waves, bobbing up and down without sinking.

    Then came the real test, at one of the longest wave simulators in North America.

    At the west end of the leafy Oregon State University campus, past the scholarly red-brick buildings, is a massive T-shaped steel shed in a giant paved lot. Though the building is 50 miles from the Pacific Ocean and well beyond the reach of killer tidal waves, a blue and white metal sign at its entrance says "Entering Tsunami Hazard Zone."

    When von Jouanne first brought a buoy to test in the 342-foot-long concrete flume at Oregon State's Hinsdale Wave Research Laboratory, "things didn't go as planned," says Dan Cox, the facility's director, with a laugh. Von Jouanne and co-workers plopped the buoy in the 15-foot-deep channel and buffeted it with two-, three- and four-foot waves. The first five-foot wave tipped it over.

    "We had a ballast problem," von Jouanne says somewhat sheepishly. She goes on, "We're electrical engineers, and we really needed more help from ocean engineers, but to get them we needed more funding, and to get more funding we needed to show some success."

    Von Jouanne kept refining her buoys. A small group watched as a five-foot wave headed for one of her latest versions. As the buoy lifted with the surge, a 40-watt light bulb on top of it, powered by wave energy, lighted up. "We all cheered," Cox recalls.

    Route 20 winds from Oregon State to the coast though cedar and fir trees, following the Yaquina River. Near the mouth of the river is a sandy spit with low buildings decorated with oyster shells and gnarly driftwood. Breezes set halyards from the nearby marina clanking against metal masts. This is the home of Oregon State's Hatfield Marine Science Center, devoted to research about marine ecosystems and ocean energy.

    George Boehlert, a marine scientist and director of the center, looks out of his office at a field of undulating sea grass. "What we know now is what we don't know," says Boehlert, whose dirty blond curls resemble ocean waves. "Ocean energy is a fast-moving field and environmental researchers have a lot of questions."

    For instance, the buoys absorb energy from waves, reducing their size and power. Would shrunken swells affect sand movement and currents near shore, perhaps contributing to erosion?

    Buoys, as well as the power cables that would connect to the electrical grid on-shore, emit electromagnetic fields. And mooring cables would thrum in the currents, like a guitar string. Might these disturbances confuse whales, sharks, dolphins, salmon, rays, crabs and other marine animals that use electromagnetism and sound for feeding, mating or navigation?

    Would birds collide with the buoys or turtles become entangled in the cables?

    Would anchors create artificial reefs that attract fish not normally found in that habitat?

    Would deploying, maintaining and removing buoys disturb the seafloor or otherwise change the ocean environment?

    "I want to know the answers to these questions, too," von Jouanne says. "The last thing I want to do is harm the ocean and its beautiful creatures." To study the environmental risks and allow wave-energy engineers to test their inventions, she and colleagues at Oregon State, including Boehlert, are building a floating test berth nearby. It is scheduled to open next year and at its center will be a buoy full of instruments to collect data on how well wave-energy converters are performing.

    The test berth is part of a massive effort to move wave energy out of the lab and onto the electrical power grid. Through a new Energy Department-funded national marine renewable energy center, researchers from all over the country will have the chance to refine their inventions in the WESRF energy lab, test them in the Hinsdale wave flume and perfect them in the ocean. "This is what we need to do to fully explore wave energy as part of a renewable energy portfolio, for the state, the nation and the world," von Jouanne says.

    Boehlert and others say that even if wave energy has some local environmental impacts, it would likely be far less harmful than coal- and oil-fired power plants. "The effects of continuing to pump carbon into the atmosphere could be much worse for marine life than buoys bobbing in the waves," he says. "We want ocean energy to work."

    Von Jouanne recently towed her best-performing buoy—her 11th prototype—out through Yaquina Bay and one and a half miles offshore. The buoy, which resembles a giant yellow flying saucer with a black tube sticking through the middle, was anchored in 140 feet of water. For five days it rose and fell with swells and generated around 10 kilowatts of power. In the next two to three years, Columbia Power Technologies, a renewable energy company that has supported von Jouanne's research, plans to install a buoy generating between 100 and 500 kilowatts of electricity in the test berth off the coast of Oregon.

    "A few years ago," Cox says of von Jouanne, "she was working on a shoestring. Now she has government getting behind her work and companies knocking at her door. That's incredibly fast advancement that bodes well for the future of wave energy."

    Another of Von Jouanne's inventions, the first of its kind, is a machine that tests wave-energy converters without having to get them wet. A prototype buoy is secured inside a metal carriage that mimics the up-and-down motion of ocean waves. Electrical equipment monitors the power the buoy generates. The test bed looks like an elevator car in the middle of her lab.

    Wave-energy researchers from other institutions will be welcome to use von Jouanne's test bed, but at the moment, it holds one of her own energy-converter buoys. A student sitting at a nearby computer commands the device to simulate waves 1 meter high traveling 0.6 meters per second with 6-second intervals between wave peaks.

    "That's a small summer wave," von Jouanne says.

    The machine hums, lurches and heaves like an amusement park ride.

    As the buoy moves up and down, a gauge registers the juice it produces. The needle moves. One kilowatt, two, then three.

    "That's enough to power two houses," says von Jouanne.

    Elizabeth Rusch is a Portland, Oregon-based journalist and author of The Planet Hunter and other children's science books.


    1 2 3 4 5


     
    Comments

    This is a great story, portraying the human side to an emerging technology and industry. We often think technology evolves from big budgets and armies of engineers, but this story reminds us that it can happen from the efforts of a dedicated few who treat it as a labor of love. The work can take place as much in a family bathtub or community swimming pool, as in a high tech laboratory.

    John Lavrakas
    Newport, OR

    Posted by John Lavrakas on June 25,2009 | 09:33AM

    "Complex machines like [Pelamis] are riddled with valves, filters, tubes, hoses, couplings, bearings, switches, gauges, meters and sensors. The intermediate stages reduce efficiency, and if one component breaks, the whole device goes kaput."

    Rather like aeroplanes, automobiles and wind turbines?
    A Penny Farthing is simpler than a derailleur gear road bicycle with all its complicated linkages but it's not more efficient.

    Similarly a single engine failure on a 747 doesn't cause it to go kaput and the same applies to a properly engineered Wave Energy Converter.

    Posted by Max CC on June 25,2009 | 02:57PM

    The Devil is in the details. The voltage generated by the coil is N ∂φ/∂t where N is the number of turns in the coil,φ is the magnetic flux and t is the time it takes to make the magnet move through the coil. ∂φ/∂t is the rate of change of magnetic flux. Thus the magnet must be large to generate an adequate magnetic flux and larger the magnet, the greater its inertia (t becomes greater) and thus the lower the voltage generated.

    Posted by Moderate Redoy on June 29,2009 | 10:39AM

    The up-down motion could be converted simply to rotating motion of a manetized rotor of an electric generator. With this rotor in a quasi horizontal position perpendicular to the vertical motion of the wave action the gyroscopic condition of the system would help to stabilize the buoy mounting against more aggressive wave action. I was thinking of the "yankee" screwdriver as a means of coverting vertical motion to rotating motion as a simple technic.

    Posted by Robert Meek on June 29,2009 | 04:45PM

    Meaning no offense to the people in the article but I cannot believe there is no mention of Steven Salter and the "Salter Duck".

    We had this technology in 1974 and if it weren't for Parliament mistakenly/foolishly (your choice) killing the project, we could have been refining his work ever since. Also, his device was definitely not one to which "The gadgets all had one problem in common: they were too complicated." applies.

    Posted by Ben on July 2,2009 | 06:25PM

    I suspect that equally important to developing a wave energy converter would be to develop a wave energy enhancer. In other words, the power developed by Ms. von Jouanne's buoys is limited to the vagaries of the type wave it harnesses.

    Both the strength and direction of waves can be manipulated by the depth of the ocean bottom. As ocean waves approach the shallow depth of a beach they are bent and the wave height increases. More than 50-years ago, Doc Walters, demonstrated this with a wave generator. He changed the tank's water depth by placing wide blocks of metal of various thickness (and shape) in the water. When a lens-shaped block was placed in the water as an artificial "ocean" bottom, the waves were bent and came to a focal point the same as light through a lens. The waves can be tightly managed. Where the waves cross, there are nodes and height-on-height super-waves; they are like controlled 'rogue waves'. The energy surges.

    Instead of taking a buoy out 1-1/2 miles to an ocean depth of 140' as Ms. von Jouanne did, it may be better to consider shallow depths. By constructing an off-shore reef of specific shape and depth, the restructured cookie-cutter waves will allow a different shape buoy to optimize the harvest of massive power from each predictable wave rather than from a sole point on the wave. Better: harness controlled rogue waves.

    Posted by Andy Olsen on July 2,2009 | 07:07PM

    I would think that the greater ocean depth is necessary to counter the water depth changes due to tides. The amount of slack in the anchor line with a 10 foot tide is not as noticeable in 140ft of water then say 40ft. (angle of the buoy line at low tide accounting for drift) It would seem important to keep the fixed coil as vertical as possible.

    Otherwise, a very simple design, that would be relatively inexpensive to produce, and maintain. Kudos to Von Jouanne

    Posted by Larry on July 4,2009 | 09:05AM

    Nice story - good practical application of physics as well, but there's already a simple device under patent process which operates on fresh or sea water, and looks to have the capability of pumping (per square meter of pump area) 333,000 gallons of liquid an hour to a 150 foot head for no "manufactured" energy in. Combining both technologies could provide an optimum process. Hydraulics certainly can be an efficient energy source. The devices could be incorporated each to the other and be fully synergistic.

    Posted by Bill on July 7,2009 | 01:01PM

    It is wonderful to read about Annette von Jouanne and her initiative and drive to perfect her device for generating electricity from the ocean waves ("Catching a Wave" by Elizabeth Rusch). I was the Project Manager for the successful demonstration of generating electricity from the tides using the "Gorlov Helical Turbine" (GHT). The project was supported by the Long Island Power Authority (LIPA), the New York State Energy R&D Authority (NYSERDA), GCK, Inc. (the owner of the patents on the GHT), and myself, and took place in the tidal channel between Shelter Island and North Haven Peninsula (near Sag Harbor) off Long island, New York in 2004. The two GHTs, submerged over the bow of a barge moored in the channel, immediately began generating electricity upon being lowered into place, producing an average power of about two kilowatts during the twenty hours per day of tidal flow. The GHTs are rugged, reliable and commercially available, in contrast to other systems such as the propeller type which recently failed in the East River of New York City. I should warn Ms. von Jouanne that after demonstrating the reliability of her "wave energy converter" in real ocean waves, not a trivial step, obtaining the funding for a commercial installation (millions of dollars to generate multi-megawatts) is the primary problem in making a significant impact. Whether the "American Clean Energy and Security Act" now before the Congress, if enacted, will provide funding for commercial scale "alternative energy systems" such as ocean waves and tidal flows is a real question.
    Richard S. Greeley
    St. Davids, PA

    Posted by Richard S. Greeley on July 8,2009 | 08:29AM

    Can the plastic that is out in the ocean be mined and recycled? Can plastic be fashioned into machine parts? I am not an engineer or a scientist, just a curious person.

    Posted by Martha Quigley on July 15,2009 | 05:39PM

    good idea i have often watched the wave action and wondered vwhy someone don't make use of the obvious energy poteintually available all over the world stay with it i can see a lot of potential with this idea bill hainline ---frustrated erstwhile inventor

    Posted by bill hainline on July 15,2009 | 07:44PM

    There is a vast amount of energy in the ocean, BUT, HUMANS ALSO RELY ON THE OCEAN BECAUSE IT IS A FOOD SOURCE, PROVIDES RECREATION, AND MOST IMPORTANT IT IS THE SOURCE OF LIFE. IF THE OCEAN DIES, HUMANS WILL FOLLOW. THE OCEAN AS A SOURCE OF POWER IS A GREAT IDEA, BUT HUMANS DON'T SEEM TO SEE THE FAR REACHING RESULTS OF THEIR TECHNOLOGY, THEY CUT OFF THEIR NOSE TO SPITE THEIR FACE. ISSUES LIKE ELECTROMAGNETIC ENERGY RELEASE IN THE WATER FROM THE SURROUNDING CABLES AND BUOYS. THE ELECTROMAGNETIC ENERGY RELEASED INTO THE WATER WARMS THE WATER, WHICH IS A BIG MISTAKE AND ANYONE STUDYING ENERGY SHOULD KNOW THAT MUCH. THE METHANE GAS ESCAPES. METHANE GAS IS A GREEN HOUSE GAS, AND HAS A SYNERGY EFFECT ON THE PROBLEM OF CARBON DIOXIDE. WARMING THE OCEAN ALSO BRINGS DEADLY BACTERIA TO FISH.

    I COULD GO ON AND ON, BUT FOLKS INTO A SOURCE OF RENEWABLE ENERGY SHOULD LOOK AT THE LONG TERM EFFECTS OF THEIR IDEAS.
    WE ALL KNOW ABOUT WIND AND SOLAR TYPES OF ENERGY. THEY ARE GIVEN TO US TO USE, BUT WE CANNOT EVERY SATISFIED UNLESS WE ARE DESTROYING NATURE TO GET THE ALMIGHTY DOLLAR. PROFIT AND GREED WILL BE HUMANS DOWNFALL. NOT ONLY vON JOUANNE, BUT ALL FOLKS INTO USING THE OCEAN SHOULD BE VERY FAMILIAR WITH THE PROBLEMS OF WAVE ENERGY AND ITS AFFECTS ON THE OCEAN. HUMAN GREED WILL BE THE DOWNFALL OF LIFE ON EARTH.

    Posted by Barbara on July 28,2009 | 10:29AM

    Its okay to take energy from waves becaus scientists can find a way to harness the gas and other bad particles and chemicals.The ocean is also over

    Posted by on September 8,2009 | 06:53PM

    Post a Comment


    Name: (required)

    Email: (required)

    Comment:



    Advertisement


    - - - Advertisements - - -


    Join Us

    Facebook

    Facebook

    Become a fan of Smithsonian magazine's official Facebook page!

    Twitter

    Follow Smithsonian magazine on Twitter

    Smithsonian magazine presents

    6th Annual Smithsonian Photo Contest Winners

    Out of more than 17,000 entries contributed from around the world, Smithsonian and its readers select the year's best