Inside Cape Town
Tourists are flocking to the city, but a former resident explains how the legacy of apartheid lingers
- By Joshua Hammer
- Photographs by Per-Anders Pettersson
- Smithsonian magazine, April 2008, Subscribe
From the deck of a 40-foot sloop plying the chilly waters of Table Bay, Paul Maré gazes back at the illuminated skyline of Cape Town. It is early evening, at the close of a clear day in December. Maré and his crew, racing in the Royal Cape Yacht Club's final regatta before Christmas, hoist the jib and head the sloop out to sea. A fierce southeaster is blowing, typical of this time of year, and Maré's crew members cheer as they tack round the last race buoy and speed back toward shore and a celebratory braai, or barbecue, awaiting them on the club's patio.
Maré, the descendant of French Huguenots who immigrated to South Africa in the late 17th century, is president of the yacht club, one of many white colonial vestiges that still thrive in Cape Town—South Africa's "Mother City." The club, founded in 1904 after the Second Boer War, has drawn an almost exclusively white membership ever since. (Today, however, the club administers the Sail Training Academy, which provides instruction to disadvantaged youth, most of them blacks and coloureds.)
After Nelson Mandela's African National Congress (ANC) won power in South Africa in the democratic elections of 1994 (it has governed since), some of Maré's white friends left the country, fearing that it would suffer the economic decline, corruption and violence that befell other post-independence African nations. Maré's two grown children immigrated to London, but the 69-year-old engineering consultant does not regret remaining in the land of his birth. His life in suburban Newlands, one of the affluent enclaves on the verdant slopes of Table Mountain, is stable and comfortable. His leisure time is centered around his yacht, which he owns with a fellow white South African. "We'll be getting ready for our next crossing soon," says Maré, who has sailed three times across the often stormy south Atlantic.
More than a decade after the end of apartheid, Cape Town, founded in 1652 by the Dutch East India Company's Jan van Riebeeck, is one of the fastest-growing cities in the country. Much of this sprawling metropolis of 3.3 million people at Africa's southern tip has the feel of a European or American playground, a hybrid of Wyoming's Tetons, California's Big Sur and the Provence region of France. White Capetonians enjoy a quality of life that most Europeans would envy—surfing and sailing off some of the world's most beautiful beaches, tasting wine at vineyards established more than 300 years ago by South Africa's first Dutch settlers, and mountain biking on wilderness trails high above the sea. Cape Town is the only major city in South Africa whose mayor is white, and whites still control most of its businesses. Not surprisingly, it's still known as "the most European city in South Africa."
But a closer look reveals a city in the throes of transformation. Downtown Cape Town, where one saw relatively few black faces in the early 1990s (the apartheid government's pass laws excluded nearly all black Africans from the Western Cape province), bustles with African markets. Each day at a central bus depot, combis, or minibuses, deposit immigrants by the hundreds from as far away as Nigeria and Senegal, nearly all of them seeking jobs. The ANC's "black economic empowerment" initiatives have elevated thousands of previously disadvantaged Africans to the middle class and created a new generation of black and mixed-race millionaires and even billionaires. With the racial hierarchy dictated by apartheid outlawed, the city has become a noisy mix of competing constituencies and ethnicities—all jockeying for a share of power. The post-apartheid boom has also seen spiraling crime in black townships and white suburbs, a high rate of HIV infection and a housing shortage that has forced tens of thousands of destitute black immigrants to live in dangerous squatter camps.
Now Cape Town has begun preparing for what will be the city's highest-profile event since the end of white-minority rule in 1994. In 2004, the world soccer federation, FIFA, selected South Africa as the venue for the 2010 World Cup. Preparations include construction of a $300 million, 68,000-seat showcase stadium in the prosperous Green Point neighborhood along the Atlantic Ocean and massive investment in infrastructure. Not surprisingly, the project has generated a controversy tinged with racial overtones. A group of affluent whites, who insist that the stadium will lose money and degrade the environment, has been pitted against black leaders convinced that opponents want to prevent black soccer fans from flooding into their neighborhood. The controversy has abated thanks to a promise by the Western Cape government, so far unfulfilled, to build an urban park next to the stadium. "For Capetonians, the World Cup is more than just a football match," says Shaun Johnson, a former executive of a newspaper group and a top aide to former President Mandela. "It's an opportunity to show ourselves off to the world."
For nearly two years, from August 2005 until April 2007, I experienced Cape Town's often surreal contradictions firsthand. I lived just off a winding country road high in the Steenberg Mountains, bordering Table Mountain National Park and overlooking False Bay, 12 miles south of Cape Town's city center. From my perch, it was easy to forget that I was living in Africa. Directly across the road from my house sprawled the Tokai forest, where I jogged or mountain-biked most mornings through dense groves of pine and eucalyptus planted by Cape Town's English colonial masters nearly a century ago. A half mile from my house, an 18th-century vineyard boasted three gourmet restaurants and a lily-white clientele; it could have been plucked whole from the French countryside.
Yet there were regular reminders of the legacy of apartheid. When I drove my son down the mountain to the American International School each morning, I passed a parade of black workers from the townships in the Cape Flats trudging uphill to manicure the gardens and clean the houses of my white neighbors. Next to my local shopping mall, and across the road from a golf course used almost exclusively by whites, stood an even starker reminder of South Africa's recent past: Pollsmoor Prison, where Mandela spent four and a half years after being moved from Robben Island in April 1984.
Subscribe now for more of Smithsonian's coverage on history, science and nature.









Comments (21)
I find it intriguing and yet funny..... that so many people can comment on racism, (people of all colours).... And will write fancy words... Ignorance is a blessing to some.. Self Importance to others...... I for one am glad I do not live nor would ever wish or desire to spend my hard earned cash visiting a land full of hate and divide.
Posted by Irish~ Heart on September 5,2012 | 12:40 AM
Not while we have the right to vote! We are winning and gaining ground all the time. The best thing to happen would be to declare a independent Republic of the Western Cape, which most people want here anyway.You think the grass is greener on the otherside. I have news for you. As a knowledgeable Portugese gentleman once said'' The Rain Does Not Just Fall On My Neighbour's Roof Top''.
Posted by Andre Martinaglia on December 6,2011 | 11:13 AM
I am sorry to inform you that Mare was not a French Hugeneot, but Italian, born in Calabria, in south east Italy, who arrived at the Cape . He was involved with the French Hugeneot's,and had also to flee religious persecution.He settled in the Drakenstein area,in 1707, marrying the daugther of the first Van Vuuren,namely Susanna, who's mother was French. He was a widower on arrival in South Africa. The surname means, someone who lives by the sea.
In early 2010, this was proved correct,when Johan Botha of ''50/50''TV Program was DNA tested by Professor Hilmar Soodyall on his Maternal side, showing the result a week later that his ancestry originated from Italy, because his mother was a Mare. The surname in some cases has through corruption of the family name also spelt Maree.
Posted by Cav. Andre Martinaglia on June 28,2011 | 02:45 AM
To Joe - unfortunately what you say is true but hopefully this will change over time.
Alexis - I am moving there soon too. I think it is a wonderful place.
South Africa is not going to be another Zimbabwe, it will stay stable as with Namibia and Botswana. Botswana is doing well, thank you.
Posted by Joe2 on September 14,2010 | 05:40 AM
I lived in Cape Town for a while and I have to say it was without a doubt the most racist place I've ever been. Not a day went by without several overt racist comments to me, from whites, about blacks. I'm a white American.I never heard any the other way. It's also easily one of the most beautiful places in the world.
Posted by Joe on September 5,2010 | 03:50 PM
hey everything about Cape Town is exciting, most of my family stays there and am in Botswana, i always look for excuses to go to Cape Town. when i think of Water front i go crazy, the only thing that am afraid of is the trip to table mountain.
Posted by should i on April 20,2010 | 06:16 AM
I Love Cape Town! My favorite city on Earth, and the most beautiful city in the world!
I never understand why people say 'All of Africa is doomed' and all that nonsense. The experience I have had of Africa has mainly been Botswana, Namibia and South Africa which are all fantastic and efficient countries! Why do people always bring up Zimbabwe, and forget all the positives from many countries that are increasingly doing well!
To speak frankly I wish more of Europe were as efficient as South Africa is, as I usually want to pull my hair out getting things done in the UK, or Southern Europe generally. Northern Europe tends to be better (with Switzerland amazing) - but frankly I have always found that conducting business and getting things done SA is even more efficient than in Northen Europe.
I find South Africa efficient, clean and productive. And I have now, collectively, spent over 10 years of my life there (yes, including the power problems of 2007, which was a pretty bad time)! My SA friends often out-earn most of my European friends and have an incomparably better quality of life. I am actually emmigrating there permanently in July, and I cannot wait!
Yes there are challenges, but since I started going to SA in the early 1980s I have seen one challenge after another overcome. I know there's much to be done, but I am totally confident that it will be.
Posted by Alexis on May 14,2009 | 09:16 AM
I believe in Philosophy as a mother of all studies & have unpublished theories in Mathematics,History, Politics & Science to back up an explanation of whats happening in present day South Africa. Take History as a sentinel to guide us on what we should do to avoid incidences & regrets in future. Do i sense some insecurity in the analysis of others- i get back to what the Book of God has written in black & white- 'do unto others as you would want them to do to you" It may not happen to you in your lifetime but would you want it to happen to your child or your grandchild. Take the Zimbabwean situation as a lesson to all Africa & even the world then integret the apartheid differential & what do you get- the present entropy of Cape Town of course!
Posted by John Voster on May 14,2009 | 05:24 AM
This is an update to the book "We are the Poors". Thanks
Posted by Rodney M. Burton on November 13,2008 | 02:16 PM
Behind those huge curtains of descimination, racism, and deprivation/oppression of one group by the other is the subtle text of class struggle. Yes, diferences exist among the colours and races but they are borne out of a history of contest between the haves and the haves-not, the rich and the poor, the priviledge and the deprived. It is not so much about colour, it is about economics and social stratifications. Of course, politicians (politrickians) will always play up the colour and racial cards. Just as they have always played up the religious card to further their devilish hold on the wellness of the mass of the people. Underneath our so-called differences in colours, races and tongues, is our common humanity, and hat is what we ought to insist on being respected at all times. As in Cape Town so in every other land occupy by modern man.
Posted by Jahman Anikulapo on May 1,2008 | 05:40 AM
Although the basic facts are correct the true fact is that everyone in South Africa faces daily problems. This is true of most countries in the world. I am an American citizen but I have lived in Cape Town since 1972. I've seen the swing from white rule to black rule. The wonderful and most interesting part of the change in the good will that exists between the races. Like any other place, there is conflict when races and cultures collide. Indeed, it is expected. Unfortunately, every group has their own needs, wants and dreams and they these very basic human emotions and desires exclude the consideration of anyone 'outside' of the group. Yes, we have problems but at least this country is trying to resolve the issues. Crime is high, inflation if getting out of hand, much of the education system is in chaos but we still live here. I love living Cape Town. Watchingthe social integration has been something to witness. It has been a rollor coaster ride and will continue to be one for the foreseaable future.
Posted by Bill Holland on April 28,2008 | 09:51 AM
I have just returned from Cape Town after a 2 week holiday. I believe that racism exists everywhere. It is diffuclt to find a Black CEO in the UK where we are still focused on class issues. In India we have the caste system. france, Italy and Spain still have issues on their football grounds. The thing that really shocked me about my visit to Cape Town - the continued use of black, white, coloureds to describe people. If I told you I was brown - what would you think of me? I'm a British born Indian. My grandparents were farmers in India. My father emigrated and worked his way through a system before becomming a leading scientist. My older sister is at Harvard and my younger sister works at a top advertising agency in London. We have friends from all over the world - of ALL races. My "black" friends are as well-educated and also doing very good jobs. The point is we are not from privileged backgrounds but we have achieved. The opportunity was made available to us. South Africa needs to allow this to happen. IT CAN HAPPEN...MAKE IT HAPPEN...Stop telling us its going to become like Zimbabwe. I can't believe it when I hear that Do people really think there are no qualified black people. Both Gandhi and Mandela trained as Lawyers didn't they? And in times of oppression. They aren't one off examples..hundreds of millions of people are like that. I met a young girl in that fashionable part of Cape Town where all the stars hang-out.She massaged me on the beach. We spoke about many things. She told me about this heirarchy - "unlike the blacks, the coloureds will mug you but they won't pull the trigger. The blacks will kill you." Apparently, we Indians/brown people are at the top with the whites. Puh-lease. Is that how it's going to work? You'll change your mind about us when we can afford to pay you for the service/business you offer? Cape Town is beautiful. It really is. And I met some amazing people there (of all colours!!!!)
Posted by Shaleen Meelu on April 18,2008 | 06:45 AM
As I and anyone who looks and reads this article can see that Cape Town is a beautiful place indeed, and this no one cannot deny. As I read, people seemed to speak of apartheid and how it still remained as of this day in the "flats". In so many words, certain individuals seemed to feel that a certain person was not genuine in their remarks, and only making statements to relieve the tention of the people of Cape Town. Some people moved away to different countries, while others stayed in South Africa. I noticed that even through the hardships, the people still remember the good times; instead of "harping on the bad times.
Posted by Tomika C. Walker on April 17,2008 | 01:20 PM
I find Mr. Hammer's comment about the persistence of Apartheid be be rather too nice fingered to convince m,e that his heart was really on the side of black folks in menial employment. He says, on p 60, "Yet there were regular reminders of the legacy of apartheid. When I drove my son down the mountain to the American International School each morning, I passed a parade of black workers from the townships in the Cape Flats trudging uphill to manicure the gardens and clean the houses of my white neighbors." Apparently is was other people, and not Mr. Hammer, that gave these people employment, yet he lived there, he tells us, for nearly 2 years. Which does more for oppressed people? Sympathizing with their plight? Or sympathizing with their plight _and_ giving some of them the honest employment they seek, so they could perhaps raise their families to, perhaps, greater qualifications for economic advancement than they themselves possessed? Personally, I favor the latter, particularly after recoiling from Mr. Hammer's tone of smug satisfaction from _not_ having ground the faces of these poor.
Posted by Don Martin on April 11,2008 | 06:37 PM
I am now 80 years old but will never forget a wonderful year in S.A., only the first two weeks in Joburg. We had a SA friend as a guide, he knew and showed us the most interesting places. What an extraordinarily beautiful land. I would give a lot to travel there again. That was in the fifties. If I could afford it I would go back! I was not aware of much racism even then; Not as bad as in our own south. Why all the comments on racism? I am white; is that why I'm less conscious of racism? Our S.A.friend and guide was black.
Posted by Tilda Redway on April 3,2008 | 12:08 AM
Yes, I agree that Cape Town is the most beautiful city in the world. I have been a Capetonian all my life of 68 years. Unfortunately with blacks now ruling this country of ours, everything will in time collapse like all other services has collapsed since 1994 when the blacks took over. Racism thrives as the present black government's policy is based on race and racial discrimination against whites and coloureds. If you think that the previous regime was racist, you have seen nothing yet. The tragedy is that all qulified people like Doctors, Engineers, Architechts, Lawyers, etc. etc. have left the country or are leaving soon. There is no future in this country for whites and coloureds. And South Africa cannot afford to loose all this expertise. My advice to all non-South Africans out there is to visit Cape Town now while you still can as within the very near future South Africa will be the same as Zimbabwe, a country which our government supports fully. And Cape Town will be no more.
Posted by Ronnie Grace on March 31,2008 | 06:21 AM
I'm an American exchange student living outside of Johannesburg for a year, but have been lucky enough to visit Cape Town...This article perfectly describes the vast gaps between people, neighborhoods, lifestyles, etc that are present not only in Cape Town, but throughout the rest of South Africa. Although I agree that the Cape is one of the most beautiful areas in the world, it's a shame that this one city, the largest tourist attraction in RSA, gets all the attention aimed at it. There are so many other areas of the country where racism doesn't just lie under the surface, it glares you in the face every day.
Posted by Audrey Van Gilder on March 30,2008 | 02:39 PM
As Sen. Obama's recent speech so clearly demonstrated, especially the negative response - America's own unique form of Apartheid is still alive and well here. Some seem to take pleasure out of pointing out that South Africa still has many open vestiges of de-facto segregation a decade since the "end of apartheid." The USA has the same, centuries after the civil war. Only, we hide our prejudice behind our false image of fellowship and cover our guilt with welfare, handouts and "equal opportunity" Who has the most integrity?
Posted by Ian D Goddard on March 28,2008 | 06:33 AM
I am a So. African now living in Tampa, Florida. Your article on Cape Town is a very good reflection of how things really are there now. I was sad on a recent trip to Cape Town, to hear my son and his wife telling us not to open the windows of our car whilst sight seeing because it is unsafe to do so. I could not go for walks on the beach by myself anymore! What an unfamiliar sight to see several street vendors converging on the car at almost every traffic light. Taking in the stunning beauty of Cape Town, one cannot help but feel saddened by the crime situation there. Cape Town is and will stay the most beautiful city in the world to me........
Posted by Bernadine Cornelius on March 27,2008 | 03:59 PM
Yes indeed-Cape Town-a very beautifull area!!! As a 69 yr old Afrikaner(indeed -African if you wish) reading a slanted viewpoint -putting emphasis on all the spots you want to highlite -is oh so easy.The "coloured" folk are being marganalised.White males too...are you surprised that this is happenning? No way. racism & the desperate need for self enrichment is driving the new power brokers.The saying goes that the previous regime skimmed the cream.The present one is skimming the cream,drinking the milk & then slaughtering the cow.There is NO understanding for basic economic/social maintenance at all. Highly skilled scientists are replaced at director levell by people who have not completed their high school education.Consequent decisions effect everybody-white/coloured & black-very adversely.THIS is progress!!
Posted by Jack Beukes on March 27,2008 | 02:51 PM
I recently returned from a visit to South Africa. What a wonderful trip. Cape Town and the Cape Peninsula is beautiful. My grandfather immigrated from there but died while I was too young to have him tell me what it was like growing up there. I would love to go back and explore more.
Posted by Estelle Selzer on March 26,2008 | 04:48 PM
The first thing to rise after the defeat of one form of racism and disenfranchisment is the same thing directed at another group. It never ceases to amaze me.
Posted by Jeff Martin on March 26,2008 | 04:21 PM
I long to return to Cape Town. We lived in Secunda from 1981 to 1985 and my favorite place to holiday was always Cape Town.
Posted by Judy Guffey on March 26,2008 | 03:58 PM