Inside Cape Town
Tourists are flocking to the city, but a former resident explains how the legacy of apartheid lingers
- By Joshua Hammer
- Photographs by Per-Anders Pettersson
- Smithsonian magazine, April 2008, Subscribe
(Page 4 of 4)
Zille's own story reflects the city's complex racial dynamics. In the last local election, her Democratic Alliance (DA), a white-dominated opposition party, formed a coalition with half a dozen smaller parties to defeat the incumbent ANC. (Many coloured voters turned against the ANC once again and helped give the DA its victory.) It was one of the first times in South Africa since the end of apartheid that the ANC had been turned out of office; the election results created a backlash that still resonates.
Zille, 57, is one of only a few white politicians in the country who speak Xhosa, the language of South Africa's second-largest tribe, and lives in a racially integrated neighborhood. She has an impressive record as an activist, having been arrested during the apartheid years for her work as a teacher in Crossroads, a black squatter camp. Despite her credentials, the ANC-controlled Western Cape provincial government launched an effort last fall to unseat and replace her with a "mayoral committee" heavily represented by ANC members. Their complaint: the city was not "African" enough and had to be brought in line with the rest of the country. After protests from Zille supporters and criticism from even some ANC allies, the leadership backed down.
The wounds are still raw. Zille bristled when I asked her about being heckled at a rally she attended with South African President Thabo Mbeki. She said the heckling was "orchestrated" by her enemies within the ANC. "This election marked the first time that the party of liberation has lost anywhere in South Africa," she said as we sat in her spacious sixth-floor office in the Civic Center, a high-rise overlooking Cape Town's harbor. "The ANC didn't like that." As for the claim that Cape Town wasn't African enough, she scoffed. "Rubbish! Are they saying that only Xhosa people can be considered African? The tragedy is that the ANC has fostered the misimpression that only black people can take care of blacks."
The Koeberg Nuclear Power Station, Africa's only nuclear power plant, was inaugurated in 1984 by the apartheid regime and is the major source of electricity for the Western Cape's 4.5 million population. I've come to meet Carin De Villiers, a senior manager for Eskom, South Africa's power monopoly. De Villiers was an eyewitness to one of the worst crises in South Africa's recent history, which unfolded at Koeberg for two frantic weeks in early 2006. It may well have contributed to the defeat of the ANC in the last election.
On February 19, 2006, an overload on a high-voltage transmission line automatically tripped the nuclear reactor's single working unit (the other had earlier sustained massive damage after a worker dropped a three-inch bolt into a water pump). With the entire reactor suddenly out of commission, the whole Western Cape became dependent on a coal-fueled plant located more than 1,000 miles away. As engineers tried desperately to get one of the two 900-megawatt units back on line, Eskom ordered rolling blackouts that paralyzed Cape Town and the region, as far as Namibia, for two weeks. "It was a nightmare," De Villiers told me. Businesses shut down, traffic lights stopped working, gas pumps and ATMs went dead. Police stations, medical clinics and government offices had to operate by candlelight. After the city's pumps shut down, raw sewage poured into rivers and wetlands, killing thousands of fish and threatening the Cape Peninsula's rich bird life. Tourists were stranded in cable cars on Table Mountain; burglars took advantage of disabled alarms to wreak havoc in affluent neighborhoods. By the time Eskom restored power on March 3, the blackouts had cost the economy hundreds of millions of dollars.
For De Villiers and the rest of Cape Town's population, the power failures provided an unsettling look at the fragility that lies just beneath the city's prosperous surface. It drew attention to the fact that Eskom has failed to expand power capacity to keep up with the province's 6 percent annual growth and opened the ANC to charges of poor planning and bad management. Now Eskom is scrambling to build new plants, including another nuclear reactor, as the city prepares for the World Cup. The power collapse also laid bare racial grievances: many whites, and some nonwhites as well, saw the breakdown as evidence that the official policy of black economic empowerment had brought unqualified people into key positions of responsibility. "Given the mismanagement of this economy à la Eskom, I am beginning to prefer my oppressors to be white," one reader wrote to Business Day, a South African newspaper.
Paul Maré considers such rough patches a natural, if frustrating, part of the transition to real democracy. Standing on the deck of the Royal Cape Yacht Club at twilight, with a glass of South African chardonnay in one hand and a boerewors (grilled sausage) in the other, Maré takes in the glittering lights of downtown Cape Town and the scene of prosperous white South Africa that surrounds him. Maré's partner, Lindsay Birch, 67, grumbles that in the post-apartheid era, "it's hard for us to get sponsorship for our regattas. Sailing isn't a black sport." Maré, however, is putting his bets on Cape Town's future—and his place in it. "I'm an African," Maré says. "I've got 350 years' worth of history behind me."
Formerly Newsweek's bureau chief in Cape Town, writer Joshua Hammer is a freelancer who is based in Berlin.
Photographer Per-Anders Pettersson resides in Cape Town.
Single Page « Previous 1 2 3 4
Subscribe now for more of Smithsonian's coverage on history, science and nature.









Comments (21)
+ View All Comments
I find it intriguing and yet funny..... that so many people can comment on racism, (people of all colours).... And will write fancy words... Ignorance is a blessing to some.. Self Importance to others...... I for one am glad I do not live nor would ever wish or desire to spend my hard earned cash visiting a land full of hate and divide.
Posted by Irish~ Heart on September 5,2012 | 12:40 AM
Not while we have the right to vote! We are winning and gaining ground all the time. The best thing to happen would be to declare a independent Republic of the Western Cape, which most people want here anyway.You think the grass is greener on the otherside. I have news for you. As a knowledgeable Portugese gentleman once said'' The Rain Does Not Just Fall On My Neighbour's Roof Top''.
Posted by Andre Martinaglia on December 6,2011 | 11:13 AM
I am sorry to inform you that Mare was not a French Hugeneot, but Italian, born in Calabria, in south east Italy, who arrived at the Cape . He was involved with the French Hugeneot's,and had also to flee religious persecution.He settled in the Drakenstein area,in 1707, marrying the daugther of the first Van Vuuren,namely Susanna, who's mother was French. He was a widower on arrival in South Africa. The surname means, someone who lives by the sea.
In early 2010, this was proved correct,when Johan Botha of ''50/50''TV Program was DNA tested by Professor Hilmar Soodyall on his Maternal side, showing the result a week later that his ancestry originated from Italy, because his mother was a Mare. The surname in some cases has through corruption of the family name also spelt Maree.
Posted by Cav. Andre Martinaglia on June 28,2011 | 02:45 AM
To Joe - unfortunately what you say is true but hopefully this will change over time.
Alexis - I am moving there soon too. I think it is a wonderful place.
South Africa is not going to be another Zimbabwe, it will stay stable as with Namibia and Botswana. Botswana is doing well, thank you.
Posted by Joe2 on September 14,2010 | 05:40 AM
I lived in Cape Town for a while and I have to say it was without a doubt the most racist place I've ever been. Not a day went by without several overt racist comments to me, from whites, about blacks. I'm a white American.I never heard any the other way. It's also easily one of the most beautiful places in the world.
Posted by Joe on September 5,2010 | 03:50 PM
hey everything about Cape Town is exciting, most of my family stays there and am in Botswana, i always look for excuses to go to Cape Town. when i think of Water front i go crazy, the only thing that am afraid of is the trip to table mountain.
Posted by should i on April 20,2010 | 06:16 AM
I Love Cape Town! My favorite city on Earth, and the most beautiful city in the world!
I never understand why people say 'All of Africa is doomed' and all that nonsense. The experience I have had of Africa has mainly been Botswana, Namibia and South Africa which are all fantastic and efficient countries! Why do people always bring up Zimbabwe, and forget all the positives from many countries that are increasingly doing well!
To speak frankly I wish more of Europe were as efficient as South Africa is, as I usually want to pull my hair out getting things done in the UK, or Southern Europe generally. Northern Europe tends to be better (with Switzerland amazing) - but frankly I have always found that conducting business and getting things done SA is even more efficient than in Northen Europe.
I find South Africa efficient, clean and productive. And I have now, collectively, spent over 10 years of my life there (yes, including the power problems of 2007, which was a pretty bad time)! My SA friends often out-earn most of my European friends and have an incomparably better quality of life. I am actually emmigrating there permanently in July, and I cannot wait!
Yes there are challenges, but since I started going to SA in the early 1980s I have seen one challenge after another overcome. I know there's much to be done, but I am totally confident that it will be.
Posted by Alexis on May 14,2009 | 09:16 AM
I believe in Philosophy as a mother of all studies & have unpublished theories in Mathematics,History, Politics & Science to back up an explanation of whats happening in present day South Africa. Take History as a sentinel to guide us on what we should do to avoid incidences & regrets in future. Do i sense some insecurity in the analysis of others- i get back to what the Book of God has written in black & white- 'do unto others as you would want them to do to you" It may not happen to you in your lifetime but would you want it to happen to your child or your grandchild. Take the Zimbabwean situation as a lesson to all Africa & even the world then integret the apartheid differential & what do you get- the present entropy of Cape Town of course!
Posted by John Voster on May 14,2009 | 05:24 AM
This is an update to the book "We are the Poors". Thanks
Posted by Rodney M. Burton on November 13,2008 | 02:16 PM
Behind those huge curtains of descimination, racism, and deprivation/oppression of one group by the other is the subtle text of class struggle. Yes, diferences exist among the colours and races but they are borne out of a history of contest between the haves and the haves-not, the rich and the poor, the priviledge and the deprived. It is not so much about colour, it is about economics and social stratifications. Of course, politicians (politrickians) will always play up the colour and racial cards. Just as they have always played up the religious card to further their devilish hold on the wellness of the mass of the people. Underneath our so-called differences in colours, races and tongues, is our common humanity, and hat is what we ought to insist on being respected at all times. As in Cape Town so in every other land occupy by modern man.
Posted by Jahman Anikulapo on May 1,2008 | 05:40 AM
Although the basic facts are correct the true fact is that everyone in South Africa faces daily problems. This is true of most countries in the world. I am an American citizen but I have lived in Cape Town since 1972. I've seen the swing from white rule to black rule. The wonderful and most interesting part of the change in the good will that exists between the races. Like any other place, there is conflict when races and cultures collide. Indeed, it is expected. Unfortunately, every group has their own needs, wants and dreams and they these very basic human emotions and desires exclude the consideration of anyone 'outside' of the group. Yes, we have problems but at least this country is trying to resolve the issues. Crime is high, inflation if getting out of hand, much of the education system is in chaos but we still live here. I love living Cape Town. Watchingthe social integration has been something to witness. It has been a rollor coaster ride and will continue to be one for the foreseaable future.
Posted by Bill Holland on April 28,2008 | 09:51 AM
I have just returned from Cape Town after a 2 week holiday. I believe that racism exists everywhere. It is diffuclt to find a Black CEO in the UK where we are still focused on class issues. In India we have the caste system. france, Italy and Spain still have issues on their football grounds. The thing that really shocked me about my visit to Cape Town - the continued use of black, white, coloureds to describe people. If I told you I was brown - what would you think of me? I'm a British born Indian. My grandparents were farmers in India. My father emigrated and worked his way through a system before becomming a leading scientist. My older sister is at Harvard and my younger sister works at a top advertising agency in London. We have friends from all over the world - of ALL races. My "black" friends are as well-educated and also doing very good jobs. The point is we are not from privileged backgrounds but we have achieved. The opportunity was made available to us. South Africa needs to allow this to happen. IT CAN HAPPEN...MAKE IT HAPPEN...Stop telling us its going to become like Zimbabwe. I can't believe it when I hear that Do people really think there are no qualified black people. Both Gandhi and Mandela trained as Lawyers didn't they? And in times of oppression. They aren't one off examples..hundreds of millions of people are like that. I met a young girl in that fashionable part of Cape Town where all the stars hang-out.She massaged me on the beach. We spoke about many things. She told me about this heirarchy - "unlike the blacks, the coloureds will mug you but they won't pull the trigger. The blacks will kill you." Apparently, we Indians/brown people are at the top with the whites. Puh-lease. Is that how it's going to work? You'll change your mind about us when we can afford to pay you for the service/business you offer? Cape Town is beautiful. It really is. And I met some amazing people there (of all colours!!!!)
Posted by Shaleen Meelu on April 18,2008 | 06:45 AM
As I and anyone who looks and reads this article can see that Cape Town is a beautiful place indeed, and this no one cannot deny. As I read, people seemed to speak of apartheid and how it still remained as of this day in the "flats". In so many words, certain individuals seemed to feel that a certain person was not genuine in their remarks, and only making statements to relieve the tention of the people of Cape Town. Some people moved away to different countries, while others stayed in South Africa. I noticed that even through the hardships, the people still remember the good times; instead of "harping on the bad times.
Posted by Tomika C. Walker on April 17,2008 | 01:20 PM
I find Mr. Hammer's comment about the persistence of Apartheid be be rather too nice fingered to convince m,e that his heart was really on the side of black folks in menial employment. He says, on p 60, "Yet there were regular reminders of the legacy of apartheid. When I drove my son down the mountain to the American International School each morning, I passed a parade of black workers from the townships in the Cape Flats trudging uphill to manicure the gardens and clean the houses of my white neighbors." Apparently is was other people, and not Mr. Hammer, that gave these people employment, yet he lived there, he tells us, for nearly 2 years. Which does more for oppressed people? Sympathizing with their plight? Or sympathizing with their plight _and_ giving some of them the honest employment they seek, so they could perhaps raise their families to, perhaps, greater qualifications for economic advancement than they themselves possessed? Personally, I favor the latter, particularly after recoiling from Mr. Hammer's tone of smug satisfaction from _not_ having ground the faces of these poor.
Posted by Don Martin on April 11,2008 | 06:37 PM
+ View All Comments