The Great Wall of China Is Under Siege
A journalist's travels along China's 4,000-mile Great Wall reveal widespread deterioration despite the efforts of a few embattled preservationists
- By Brook Larmer
- Photographs by Mark Leong
- Smithsonian magazine, August 2008, Subscribe
(Page 3 of 3)
The Chinese government has vowed to restrict commercialization, banning mercantile activities within a 330-foot radius of the wall and requiring wall-related revenue to be funneled into preservation. But pressure to turn the wall into a cash-generating commodity is powerful. Two years ago, a melee broke out along the wall on the border between Hebei and Beijing, as officials from both sides traded punches over who could charge tourist fees; five people were injured. More damaging than fists, though, have been construction crews that have rebuilt the wall at various points—including a site near the city of Jinan where fieldstone was replaced by bathroom tiles. According to independent scholar David Spindler, an American who has studied the Ming-era wall since 2002, "reckless restoration is the greatest danger."
The Great Wall is rendered even more vulnerable by a paucity of scholarship. Spindler is an exception. There is not a single Chinese academic—indeed, not a scholar at any university in the world—who specializes in the Great Wall; academia has largely avoided a subject that spans so many centuries and disciplines—from history and politics to archaeology and architecture. As a result, some of the monument's most basic facts, from its length to details of its construction, are unknown. "What exactly is the Great Wall?" asks He Shuzhong, founder and chairman of the Beijing Cultural Heritage Protection Center (CHP), a nongovernmental organization. "Nobody knows exactly where it begins or ends. Nobody can say what its real condition is."
That gap in knowledge may soon be closing. Two years ago, the Chinese government launched an ambitious ten-year survey to determine the wall's precise length and assess its condition. Thirty years ago, a preliminary survey team relied on little more than tape measures and string; today, researchers are using GPS and imaging technology. "This measuring is fundamental," says William Lindesay, a British preservationist who heads the Beijing-based International Friends of the Great Wall. "Only when we know exactly what is left of the Great Wall can we begin to understand how it might be saved."
As Sun Zhenyuan and I duck through the arched doorway of his family watchtower, his pride turns to dismay. Fresh graffiti scars the stone walls. Beer bottles and food wrappers cover the floor. This kind of defilement occurs increasingly, as day-trippers drive from Beijing to picnic on the wall. In this case, Sun believes he knows who the culprits are. At the trail head, we had passed two obviously inebriated men, expensively attired, staggering down from the wall with companions who appeared to be wives or girlfriends toward a parked Audi sedan. "Maybe they have a lot of money," Sun says, "but they have no culture."
In many villages along the wall, especially in the hills northeast of Beijing, inhabitants claim descent from soldiers who once served there. Sun believes his ancestral roots in the region originated in an unusual policy shift that occurred nearly 450 years ago, when Ming General Qi Jiguang, trying to stem massive desertions, allowed soldiers to bring wives and children to the frontlines. Local commanders were assigned to different towers, which their families treated with proprietary pride. Today, the six towers along the ridge above Dongjiakou bear surnames shared by nearly all the village's 122 families: Sun, Chen, Geng, Li, Zhao and Zhang.
Sun began his preservationist crusade almost by accident a decade ago. As he trekked along the wall in search of medicinal plants, he often quarreled with scorpion hunters who were ripping stones from the wall to get at their prey (used in the preparation of traditional medicines). He also confronted shepherds who allowed their herds to trample the ramparts. Sun's patrols continued for eight years before the Beijing Cultural Heritage Protection Center began sponsoring his work in 2004. CHP chairman He Shuzhong hopes to turn Sun's lonely quest into a full-fledged movement. "What we need is an army of Mr. Suns," says He. "If there were 5,000 or 10,000 like him, the Great Wall would be very well protected."
Perhaps the greatest challenge lies in the fact that the wall extends for long stretches through sparsely populated regions, such as Ningxia, where few inhabitants feel any connection to it—or have a stake in its survival. Some peasants I met in Ningxia denied that the tamped-earth barrier running past their village was part of the Great Wall, insisting that it looked nothing like the crenelated stone fortifications of Badaling they've seen on television. And a Chinese survey conducted in 2006 found that only 28 percent of respondents thought the Great Wall needed to be protected. "It's still difficult to talk about cultural heritage in China," says He, "to tell people that this is their own responsibility, that this should give them pride."
Dongjiakou is one of the few places where protection efforts are taking hold. When the local Funin County government took over the CHP program two years ago, it recruited 18 local residents to help Sun patrol the wall. Preservation initiatives like his, the government believes, could help boost the sagging fortunes of rural villages by attracting tourists who want to experience the "wild wall." As leader of his local group, Sun is paid about $120 per year; others receive a bit less. Sun is confident that his family legacy will continue into the 22nd generation: his teenage nephew now joins him on his outings.
From the entrance to the Sun Family Tower, we hear footsteps and wheezing. A couple of tourists—an overweight teenage boy and his underweight girlfriend—climb the last steps onto the ramparts. Sun flashes a government-issued license and informs them that he is, in effect, the constable of the Great Wall. "Don't make any graffiti, don't disturb any stones and don't leave any trash behind," he says. "I have the authority to fine you if you violate any of these rules." The couple nods solemnly. As they walk away, Sun calls after them: "Always remember the words of Chairman Deng Xiaoping: ‘Love China, Restore the Great Wall!'"
As Sun cleans the trash from his family's watchtower, he spies a glint of metal on the ground. It's a set of car keys: the black leather ring is imprinted with the word "Audi." Under normal circumstances, Sun would hurry down the mountain to deliver the keys to their owners. This time, however, he'll wait for the culprits to hike back up, looking for the keys—and then deliver a stern lecture about showing proper respect for China's greatest cultural monument. Flashing a mischievous smile, he slides the keys into the pocket of his Mao jacket. It's one small victory over the barbarians at the gate.
Brook Larmer, formerly the Shanghai bureau chief for Newsweek, is a freelance writer who lives in Bangkok, Thailand. Photographer Mark Leong is based in Beijing.
Subscribe now for more of Smithsonian's coverage on history, science and nature.
Related topics: China Historic and Cultural Monuments
Additional Sources
"Walking the Wall" by Peter Hessler, The New Yorker, May 21, 2007









Comments (10)
What does the great wall help modern China? Westerners think Chinese should preserve all our history, but it doesn't help Chinese people. A small portion should be kept as a Museum, get rid of the rest I think. Don't let the west dictate to China what we do with our own history, Mao was a visionary.
Posted by Fenqing2012 on September 3,2012 | 09:23 PM
GREAT ARTICAL ,I REALLY ENJOYED IT
Posted by FEFE on February 22,2012 | 08:53 PM
Great Wall of China is one of the greatest wonders of the world. It winds its way westward over the vast territory of China from the bank of the Yalu River and ends at the foot of snow-covered Qilianshan and Tianshan mountains. Great wall of China is seldom that we see such a gigantic project in China or elsewhere in the world. The Chinese call it the Wall of 10,000 li. Its size is better seen on a map or from an aerial photograph. According to astronauts who looked back from the moon, of all projects built by man, the Great Wall of China is the most conspicuous seen in space.
Besides culture, policies and economy, another essential part that can't be divided from the Great Wall, which is the history of China. The Great Wall, whose building started more than 2,000 years ago, represents a main part of Chinese history, which has a profound influence on China today. So to speak, in a sense, is history. And you will see that this tendency is reflected in our content. We generally talk about the Great Wall with dynasties who built it, along with events and social aspects of those dynasties, which may branch out as far as to other topics. In this manner of narration, It can be a little loose and sightly off the point, but we think it interesting, and it makes sense to put the Great Wall into the Chinese history.
Posted by Hasheem on March 24,2011 | 01:09 AM
TV Tower is presently the highest building in Shanghai and Asia with its unique design. Don 't fail to visit Tv towers panoramic view of Shanghai, Snake Mount, Chongmin Island and the Yangtze River. http://www.historicaltravelguide.com/great-wall-of-china-facts.html
Posted by Jehnavi on November 17,2010 | 05:22 AM
Very informative post. Huang Pu River was the significantly famed street in Asia with key Far East firms having their head offices in the sea- facing buildings.TV Tower is presently the highest building in Shanghai and Asia with its unique design. Don 't fail to visit Tv towers panoramic view of Shanghai, Snake Mount, Chongmin Island and the Yangtze River. For more details refer http://www.journeyidea.com/splendour-beyond-the-great-wall-of-china-part-iii/
Posted by Great wall of china facts on February 16,2010 | 07:03 AM
ancient chinese characters that say ''the great wall''
Posted by matt on January 27,2010 | 08:11 PM
Good work!
Posted by Aron Cajigas on December 14,2009 | 07:48 PM
The Great Wall of China is an amazing construction and the Chinese are and have done a wonderful job in preserving many parts of it. Especially when you consider there are parts in very remote areas and hardly visited by anyone. In a remote area of Italy there is also another "Great Wall" That of Piemonte at Fenestrelle. You have recently done an article on this fortification which is second largest to the Great wall of China. However a "modern industrialised European" nation such as Italy seems to be unable or unwilling to maintain this important piece of "World changing" history. Maybe we should ask the Chinese to come and help us?
http://www.worldmonumentswatch.org/
Posted by Kent Benson on July 16,2009 | 02:58 AM
nice article especially the wrap up
Posted by paul Nelis on March 15,2009 | 04:24 PM
Now you can spout off facts to your friends while standing at the wall...just like Dad! :) I always love doing that when we travel...:)
Posted by btwalley@gmail.com on February 27,2009 | 10:40 AM
Fantastic article.. very well written.. keep up the great work!
Posted by Rajiv on August 18,2008 | 06:06 AM
Having seen and walked on the Great Wall, I was most interested in this article which I feel is a good potted history of this incredible feat. I only wish more people could have access to this type of article and realise what we are doing to this world. Thank you Smithsonian.
Posted by Barbara Parsons on August 14,2008 | 12:57 AM