The Secrets Behind Your Flowers
Chances are the bouquet you're about to buy came from Colombia. What's behind the blooms?
- By John McQuaid
- Photographs by Ivan Kashinsky
- Smithsonian magazine, February 2011, Subscribe
(Page 3 of 5)
Colombia’s flower industry has also been profligate in its use of a vital natural resource: fresh water. Producing a single rose bloom requires as much as three gallons of water, according to a study of the Kenyan flower industry by scientists at the University of Twente in the Netherlands. The Bogotá area receives 33 inches of rainfall annually, but after flower farms and other users drilled more than 5,000 wells on the savanna, groundwater levels plunged. One engineering study reported that springs, streams and wetlands were disappearing. As Bogotá continues to expand, the city and the flower industry will be competing for the same dwindling supply.
In the 1990s, the Colombia flower industry’s success in American and European markets drew attention to its practices; a stream of reports about harsh treatment of workers and depletion of natural resources followed. At the same time, consumers began to care more about how their goods were being produced, so Colombia’s flower farms began to respond. “It’s definitely improved over time, particularly as a result of the different organizations giving everybody adverse publicity,” says Catherine Ziegler, author of the book Favored Flowers, about the global industry.
In 1996, Colombia began a series of initiatives, still underway, to eliminate child labor, and international labor groups report that it has been greatly reduced in the cut-flower business. Farms belonging to the flower exporters association, Asocolflores (about 75 percent of the total), have moved to replace the more hazardous classes of agricultural chemicals, says Marcela Varona, a scientist at the environmental health laboratory at Colombia’s NIH. (But researchers note that flower workers who have used hazardous chemicals in the past may continue to be affected for years.)
In addition, the flower industry created Florverde, a voluntary certification program that requires participating farms to meet targets for sustainable water use and follow internationally recognized safety guidelines for chemical applications. At several farms I visited, the plastic sheeting on greenhouse roofs had been extended and reshaped to collect rainwater. Farms participating in Florverde have reduced their groundwater use by more than half by collecting and using rainwater, says Ximena Franco Villegas, the program’s director.
At the same time, slightly fewer than half of Asocolflores farms participate in Florverde, and government oversight remains weak. “The industry is self-regulated, so it’s up to the owner and up to his ethics what he does,” says Greta Friedemann-Sanchez, a University of Minnesota anthropologist and author of the book Assembling Flowers and Cultivating Homes: Labor and Gender in Colombia. “There are facilities that have enough washrooms, bathrooms, lockers, cafeterias, a subsidized lunch workers can purchase, recycle all organic material, trying to do biological control of pests and fungus, and follow labor laws. And then there are firms that don’t do any of those things.”
Similarly, labor disagreements continue. At the Facatativá headquarters of Untraflores, the flower workers union Aidé Silva helped organize in the early 2000s, she told me that after 19 years in the industry, she lost her job in late 2009 in a corporate reorganization—an action she says her employer, Flores Benilda, took to break the union after workers shut down a farm to protest pay and benefit cuts. Moreover, Silva says Benilda drained an $840,000 employee support fund that workers had been contributing to for 20 years, leaving only about $8,000. Benilda did not respond to requests for comment.
The global economic crisis has had an impact, too. “The dollar has fallen, the peso has been revalued, the competition from other countries has grown, as has the focus on supermarkets,” said Untraflores’ political adviser, Alejandro Torres. “These changes in the global flower markets have generated costs, and those get put on the workers.” Thousands of workers have been laid off, and some flower farms have moved away from hiring employees in favor of contracting labor; Torres and Silva say the arrangement allows the farms to stop paying the employer share of government social security and medical benefits.
By contrast, Catalina Mojica says M.G. Consultores is actually working to retain employees. Mojica’s focus on collecting data about working conditions and her willingness to talk with local officials and reporters, for example, represents a change for the industry; farm owners have tended to be secretive about their business operations and rarely meet with outsiders. “They don’t get together and BS with people,” she says. “Some owners don’t know the local government officials, they don’t know the [labor and environmental groups]. We’re still very awkward. It’s not something people do.”
Single Page « Previous 1 2 3 4 5 Next »
Subscribe now for more of Smithsonian's coverage on history, science and nature.









Comments (22)
very nice
Posted by diganto on November 26,2012 | 10:28 AM
Innovation is key to any great achievement in life. Many of know so much about flowers, but never realized the economic value of it. Thanks for this post, cause its really inspiring!
Posted by Princewill Ejikeme on November 14,2012 | 03:41 AM
I thought this was a very informative article. I've participated in online advocacy for organic flower growing because it is better for the environment, but I had no idea how important these changes really are for the workers. Thank you.
Posted by Lynn Fried on September 28,2011 | 08:58 PM
While I feel for the plight of Columbian workers, I would like to point out that many workers in these neighborhood flower shops are single mothers making minumum wage as well. And health insurance benefits? Forget about it!
They work long hours hand arranging each design & trying to please each & every customer. Premade bouquets are fine on occasion but who is going to deliver flowers to your wife at work on your anniversary or your co-worker's mothers funeral out of state on a Sunday when these "increasingly quaint" local florists have all gone out of business?
Posted by Patricia Swick on August 21,2011 | 08:35 AM
Reading the comments on this article makes me proud to be part of the development team bringing an entirely new and disruptive technology to market. Branded as Vivafresh, it has potential to exert a positive influence on the health and well-being of everyone associated with Floriculture, not only in Columbia, but worldwide. Freshening 'agents' are no longer needed. Many of the other chemical agents currently used may also become obsolete. Vivafresh Technology extends the post-harvest fresh handling time for cut flowers by a factor of up to 10 or more. It's based on meticulous environment control, not chemicals. Using nothing but clean air, fresh water, and sealed chambers with automated controls, Vivafresh induces dormancy until it's time for the flowers to wake up and go to work helping people express the feelings in their hearts. The impact on the Floriculture industry's economics is expected to be be huge. However, what excites me more than the financial impact is how Vivafresh is entirely natural and USDA organic-compliant. It can help improve health and safety for everyone who grows, transports, handles, or sells cut flowers. My hope is that Floriculturists will maximize the human benefits as they acquire and deploy this stunning scientific breakthrough that hints at the biological mechanisms plants may have evolved as the planet cooled and life took hold. Learn more at www.vivafresh.net.
Posted by Joseph Riden on June 19,2011 | 04:50 PM
Wow! I just love plants =] This is great!!! Selling and Buying Plants. Plants are so beautiful!!!!! :)
Great Job!!!!!!!!
~Kaleb~
Posted by Kaleb Steele on April 20,2011 | 09:26 AM
I read this article with great interest as I remember when flower production moved out of Southern California for Columbia. I was working in agriculture in Santa Barbara County at the time. I am now an attorney who has been working with the California florists (mentioned above in the comment by Jill Munger). This group of florists here in the States have been severely affected by some form of heavy metal poisioning with the only link between them being they all handled thousands of flowers coming from South American flower producers. Heavy pesticide use there at the time, coupled with heavy chemicals used here to revive the flowers after the long transport. The florists were using solutions heavy with metals, no gloves, numerous cuts on their hands. The Union has been nearly completely AWOL.The old formulations of the "freshing agents" are lost (according to the manufacturer) and the large corporate grocery chains have much larger legal staffs. In the meantime the florists I have met are getting weaker despite all efforts at maintaining their health. I hope the growth in Africa production is not because of cheaper labor and the lack of worker saftey laws...
Posted by Chris Van Hook on March 22,2011 | 08:08 PM
Thanks for posting the response from Jill Munger. She is our daughter and has been fighting the symptoms of flower pesticides for many years.I hope she helped you get the message across! For the person who sAid,"get over it," I WISH SHE COULD! DAVIDA SHIPKOWITZ
Posted by Davida SHIPKOWITZ on March 19,2011 | 01:14 AM
I commend the magazine's editorial decision to assign and print this article on Colombia. It was fair reporting, accurate and unbiased.
Posted by CV Uribe on March 15,2011 | 04:01 PM
Thank you for John McQuaid’s excellent article, “The Secrets Behind Your Flowers,” regarding the South American floral industry and the issues involving daily toxic exposure of the workers handling the floral products. We need to remember that imported flowers treated with toxic chemicals are also handled by florists processing the product at the retail level in this country. Imported floral products are not subject to inspection for unregulated pesticides and fungicides at the border. No regulations exist because flowers are not food.
I am one of seven local floral managers of a large grocery chain who struggle daily with neurological symptoms due to exposure to mercury and other heavy metals (lead, cadmium, arsenic, and silver) found in fungicides and pesticides coming from unregulated countries. We are working with a Congressman now to create some legislation regarding this issue. We hope articles such as John McQuaid’s will educate the US consumer on their own secondary exposure, and result in regulations that will protect consumers and floral employees handling flowers in the US as well as other countries.
For those interested in more information on unrealized problems in the US floral industry, check out the following blogs & YouTube video:
http://squishsquash-squash.blogspot.com/2010/02/heavy-metal-florists-mercury-toxicity.html
http://squishsquash-squash.blogspot.com/2010/05/heavy-metal-florists-jills-journey.html
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q5y950Z9Xn8
Posted by Jill Munger on March 14,2011 | 12:36 AM
In regards to the statement by John McQuaid in Flower Power that the practice of getting flowers from neighborhood florists, who bought blooms grown on U.S. farms, as "increasingly quaint" seems to me no more quaint than buying an ink and paper magazine to read an article about flowers. If our intent is to participate in a race to the bottom then I guess we should mindlessly buy the industrially produced grocery store flower arrangements and ignore the "quaint" neighborhood florist that buys flowers as locally as possible and supports their community in doing so. Where's the beauty in that approach? I would suggest that this article certainly could have better explored the responsible and "green" aspects of the floral industry instead of simply repeating the usual stereotypes and quickly glossing over what you did include about these aspects. I know you could do better if you cared to Smithsonian.
Posted by Eric Gustafson on February 10,2011 | 01:14 PM
As David Cheever's brother, I was tremdously pleased to see some recognition of his keen insight into the potential for growing carnations in Colombia and his hard work over the last 50 years. Dave interest in flowers started in grade school when he started growing pansies in our dad's garden and selling them at a small store across the street. Floraculture became his life long passion.
I am so proud of him. Thank you for this wonderful article.
Posted by Bill Cheever on February 5,2011 | 07:42 PM
Very interesting article; we're trying to encourage consumers to change behaviour in New York by demanding fair trade flowers from their local florists - http://www.2tiptoe.com/featured/behind-the-bouquet/. Wholesalers are bringing flowers in but the demand just isn't there from consumers yet - articles like yours will certainly help from an awareness/education perspective.
Posted by Tread Lightly on February 5,2011 | 02:12 PM
I have sympathy with the workers that spend hours a day "bent over working the flowers", however I recall my mother working in a factory lifting, bending, pulling, and tugging the factory products. She did this because she had children to raise. She came home after 8 hours in the factory (before unions)filled with unclean air and chemical products and cleaned our house, sewed clothes for the family, worked in our massive garden in the spring, summer and fall and ultimately canned or froze the produce. In the winter she sewed clothes for all of us and for other family members. Hard and back breaking work is a way of life for many people. This was a choice my mother made and I love her for it! I am 67 and a hard worker, but nothing like my mother... I praise the workers of any country as they do what is necessary for their families.
Posted by Ellamarie Reier on February 4,2011 | 08:05 PM
As a result of reading this article, quite by accident, I will seek out others that you send.
Posted by Eugenia Eden on February 4,2011 | 08:51 AM
I really don't see Mr. McQuaid's issues with the workers. As far as I can tell from the photos, they're all using industry standard protective measures and methods. What's the problem? Pesticides are a necessary evil in this INDUSTRY! It's just a part of the emergence of Columbia from the scourge of the drugeros. Get over it.
Posted by Luc Fletcher on February 3,2011 | 06:56 PM
I was so excited to read this story. When I saw the title, I immediately thought of Colombia. My family and I lived there for only two short years. Due to bad press, Colombia is still thought of as off limits to tourists. I can tell you Colombia is one beautiful country. We lived in Bogota which is very near to where the flowers are grown. The weather is nearly perfect!! I had a chance to meet one of the families who grows flowers there as well. She was an American lady married to a Colombian. Her stories were very interesting and the markets they delivered to were definitely "global". The labor market is extremely cheap there and many people are looking for jobs. These people do not have much, but they are happy because they have their families and such a wonderful country. I miss you Bogota, Colombia!!
Posted by Liz Owens on February 3,2011 | 06:17 PM
Regarding the use of water in the Colombian flower industry, the figures are not accurate. This industry use only 6,000 hectares of the 200,000 hectares of the Bogota Sabana. On the other hand, 45% of the Florverde certified farms are using collected rain water. It´s not true to say water is dissapearing because the production of flowers. it's a shame to see some people is taking about studies and surveys from 20 or more years ago. COLOMBIA IS CHANGING...
Posted by Juan Manuel Cadavid on February 3,2011 | 10:04 AM
Did you know Colombian Flower Industry is the first industry in the world that is measuring its sustainability based on the Global Reporting Initiative. Floriculture is an extraordinary oportunity to generate jobs in my country. Of course, there is a lot of things to do, but Colombian growers are doing efforts to be one hundred percent sustainable.
Posted by Juan Manuel Cadavid on February 3,2011 | 09:52 AM
It's great to see how flower growing has helped the people of Columbia and other countries. I only wish it hadn't come at the expense of the greenhouse cut flower industry in the U.S. Moving this production offshore in the 1970's decimated cut flower production in this country and with it jobs and technology.
Rainforest Alliance certification only addresses part of the problem. The fact that these flowers must be shipped thousands of miles by air and truck to reach their destination will never make them 'sustainable'. How can a flower grown in Columbia be cheaper than one grown in a local greenhouse? The true cost of this is not appeciated in terms of the petroleum subsidies required and US. jobs and production lost. I know plenty of people in the U.S. right now who would appreciate decent wages, dignified housing and healthcare for their families! Imported flowers are not a good choice for people looking to support local agriculture, U.S. products and jobs. Just like the slow food and local food movement, cut flowers can be purchased from local growers.
An emerging maket in 'specialty cut flowers' is quickly rising in the U.S. This includes flowers that are not the typical roses, carnations and mums seen at Mothers Day and imported from overseas. Consumers and florists alike need to request local flowers to support U.S.cut flower production and reduce our petroleum dependency.
Posted by Kathleen Field on January 30,2011 | 07:52 AM
As a professional florist, I enjoyed your article on Columbia Flower growers, but I must take exception to Mr. McQuaid's assertion that crafted bouquets and arrangements made to order by your local florist is a "quaint" practice. Most florist are using the world market to purchase fresh flowers of premium quality from across the globe. While big box retailers & grocery stores do provide an inexpensive source, you do get what you pay for..while the article stresses the "cold chain" it does not account for the care given by the retail end reciever. Often the flowers in these centers are of lower quality, are not well processed or attended by often untrained store personnel, thus, wilt faster & under perform, & have to be arranged by amateurs making a frustrating & relatively unattractive display, hence the lower price. Your local professional florist sets themselves apart usually with higher quality, well maintained blooms, that are correctly and artfully arranged for maximum vaselife & enjoyment. We are consistently setting new trends, supporting environmentally & humane conscious growers, and providing our communities with one of the most appealing forms of nature...flowers! We are still thriving for many who truly appreciate the art of giving & receiving flowers for any occasion.
Posted by Bobbi Wixson on January 26,2011 | 12:09 PM
To meet the growing consumer demand for sustainably produced flowers, more and more flower farms are working to become Rainforest Alliance Certified. Rainforest Alliance certification helps to arrest many of the negative social and environmental impacts of flower farming. Certified farms adopt farming methods that protect forests, soils and waterways and minimize the use of agrochemicals, while farm workers enjoy decent wages, dignified housing, occupational health and safety training, and education and healthcare for their families. There are now twenty Rainforest Alliance Certified farms in Colombia, and an additional twenty five across Ecuador, Guatemala, Mexico and Kenya. Shoppers can find Rainforest Alliance Certified blooms at Whole Foods, Costco or FTD.com.
Posted by Anna Clark on January 25,2011 | 10:05 AM