The Fatal Consequences of Counterfeit Drugs
In Southeast Asia, forensic investigators using cutting-edge tools are helping stanch the deadly trade in fake anti-malaria drugs
- By Andrew Marshall
- Photographs by Jack Picone
- Smithsonian magazine, October 2009, Subscribe
(Page 3 of 5)
The hologram that Guilin itself puts on its artesunate packages—two mountains above a coastline with rolling waves—was fairly rudimentary to begin with. Some counterfeit copies were "deeply awful," he recalls. "The first two weren't even holographic," including an illustration etched into rainbow-colored foil. Some of the bogus holograms were well crafted but had clear errors: the waves were too flat or the mountains sprouted extra plateaus.
But a couple of the fake holograms exhibited flaws that defied easy detection: the colors were just slightly brighter than the genuine article, or the 3-D image had slightly more depth than Guilin's hologram. One hologram Pizzanelli studied was actually more sophisticated than the real article. Buyers would be "guided towards the fake," he says, "because the fake was better made than the genuine." That troubled Pizzanelli, who says he'd never before done holography detection with a "life-or-death implication."
Green, of the CDC, had previously developed an inexpensive field test for detecting fake artesunate pills. In Atlanta, for the Jupiter Operation, his lab separated, identified and measured the contents of the pills. The fakes contained an astonishing variety of drugs and chemicals, some of them downright toxic. There was metamizole, a drug that can cause bone marrow failure and is banned in the United States; the outmoded drug chloroquine, which might have been added to create the bitter taste that many Asians associate with effective antimalarials; and acetaminophen, a pain reliever that can dull such malaria symptoms as pounding headaches and fool patients into thinking they're getting better. Jupiter Operation analysts also found safrole, a carcinogenic precursor to MDMA—better known as the illicit narcotic Ecstasy. The traces of safrole suggested that the same criminals who produced party drugs were now producing fake antimalarials.
Making matters worse, some of the bogus pills contained small amounts of genuine artesunate—possibly an effort to foil authenticity tests—which could cause the malaria parasite, spread by mosquitoes, to develop resistance to the leading drug treatment for the disease in Southeast Asia. That would be a public health disaster, researchers say. "We were shocked to find out how serious the problem was," says Newton.
The chemists also found that the fake drugs could be identified by their excipient—the inactive substance that carries the active ingredient in a tablet. The main excipient in Guilin artesunate is cornstarch. But geochemists on the team identified the excipient in some counterfeits as a particular type of calcium carbonate mineral, called calcite, which is found in limestone. That discovery would later take on greater significance.
The Jupiter Operation was the first time that palynology—the study of spores and pollen grains—was employed to trace counterfeit drugs. Plant species produce millions of pollen grains or spores, which end up almost everywhere. If a pollen grain's dispersal patterns (what palynologists call "pollen rain") are known, along with the locations and flowering times of the plants, then pollen can indicate where and when an object originated. Trapped in air filters, pollen can even reveal the routes of planes, trucks and cars.
Dallas Mildenhall is an expert (some would say the expert) in forensic palynology. Working from his lab at GNS Science, a government-owned research institute, in Avalon, New Zealand, he is a veteran of more than 250 criminal cases, involving everything from theft to murder. In 2005, Paul Newton asked him if he could extract pollen samples from antimalarials. "I was fairly certain I could," Mildenhall says. He views the trade in fake antimalarials as his biggest case yet. "It is mass murder on a horrendous scale," he says. "And there appears to be very little—if any—government involvement in trying to stamp it out."
In the fake drugs, Mildenhall found pollen or spores from firs, pines, cypresses, sycamores, alders, wormwood, willows, elms, wattles and ferns—all of which grow along China's southern border. (The fakes also contained fragments of charcoal, presumably from vehicle tailpipes and fires, suggesting the phony drugs were manufactured in severely polluted areas.) Then Mildenhall discovered a pollen grain from the Restionaceae family of reeds, which is found from along the Vietnam coast into southernmost China. That location matched the source of the calcite identified by Jupiter Operation's geochemists.
"A mine close to the China-Vietnam border is the only place in the world where this type of calcite is mined," Mildenhall says. The investigators now had two pieces of evidence for the general location of the counterfeit-drug-manufacturing facilities.
Single Page « Previous 1 2 3 4 5 Next »
Subscribe now for more of Smithsonian's coverage on history, science and nature.
Related topics: Monarchy Viruses Poverty Asia Cambodia Towns and Villages
Additional Sources
"A Collaborative Epidemiological Investigation into the Criminal Fake Artesunate Trade in South East Asia," Paul N. Newton et al., PLOS Medicine, February 2008.
"Manslaughter by Fake Artesunate in Asia—Will Africa Be Next?," Paul N. Newton et al., PLOS Medicine, June 2006.









Comments (7)
i need more explanation on the biological and chemical implication/consequences of counterfeit drugs and how they affect the control of parasitic diseases using Malaria as a case study.
Posted by Chukwunonso Gabriel on February 22,2012 | 11:11 AM
i need more published article on the public health significance of fake drugs.
Posted by nwaobia ,darlington onyebuchi on June 7,2010 | 11:34 AM
I have more than a few ideas how to authenticate the real medications from the counterfeits. I do not wish to post them here as I am sure the counterfeiters research these articles. Please contact me through my email address, prove that it is from the WHO, and I will reveal some alternative methodology to weaken the fake ones appeal as well as making the real ones easier to identify. I look forward to your e-mail as I wish to help eradicate this epidemic and protect innocent victims. I pray that you will take such ideas into consideration.
Thank you for your time.
Sincerely,
Rachel Fleury
Posted by Rachel Terry on February 2,2010 | 03:14 PM
Drug counterfeiting is an existing risk to safety in USA.
Food and Drug Administration news release of October 15, 2009 warns of counterfeit H1N1 drug products now offered for sale in the USA.
S-525, now proposed in the US Senate, would weaken current law protecting US citizens by imposing an impossible and costly effort on the Department of Health and Human Services by requiring the Secretary to ascertain the drug safety and effiacacy laws of other countries and monitor their enforcement.
Posted by Martha Mohler on November 1,2009 | 09:16 AM
Many thanks for your informative article entitled, “Fatal Consequences of Counterfeit Drugs”. This problem has been “under the radar” for many years and is just now receiving attention as a public health issue. The practice is particularly devious, since it takes advantage of people already encumbered with disease and poor living conditions. As part of the “team of scientists” involved in Operation Jupiter, I would like to mention another team member, Prof. Facundo Fernandez (Georgia Institute of Technology) whose work using state-of-the-art mass spectrometric techniques was instrumental in identifying the compounds present in the counterfeits as well as providing the chemical fingerprints used to help elucidate the source of the fakes.
Michael Green
Atlanta, GA
Posted by Michael Green on October 19,2009 | 09:03 AM
The answer to eradicating malaria is DDT. Even the UN supports using it, but quietly, to avoid ruffling the feathers of the econuts who still support Rachel Carson's mistaken and erroneous condemnation of this most effective insecticide.
Posted by Wayne Wright on October 13,2009 | 01:01 PM
How terribly tragic, another example of the poorest among us being deceived and hurt. May God help them all.
Posted by Jennie Taylor on October 13,2009 | 08:08 AM