Joyce Carol Oates Goes Home Again
The celebrated writer returns to the town of her birth to revisit the places that haunt her memory and her extraordinary fiction
- By Joyce Carol Oates
- Photographs by Landon Nordeman
- Smithsonian magazine, March 2010, Subscribe
Writers, particularly novelists, are linked to place. It’s impossible to think of Charles Dickens and not to think of Dickens’ London; impossible to think of James Joyce and not to think of Joyce’s Dublin; and so with Thomas Hardy, D. H. Lawrence, Willa Cather, William Faulkner, Eudora Welty, Flannery O’Connor—each is inextricably linked to a region, as to a language-dialect of particular sharpness, vividness, idiosyncrasy. We are all regionalists in our origins, however “universal” our themes and characters, and without our cherished hometowns and childhood landscapes to nourish us, we would be like plants set in shallow soil. Our souls must take root—almost literally.
For this reason, “home” isn’t a street address or a residence, or, in Robert Frost’s cryptic words, the place where, “when you go there, they have to let you in”—but where you find yourself in your most haunting dreams. These may be dreams of numinous beauty, or they may be nightmares—but they are the dreams most embedded in memory, thus encoded deep in the brain: the first memories to be retained and the last memories to be surrendered.
Over the years of what seems to me both a long and a swiftly passing lifetime, “home” has been, for me, several places: Lockport, New York, where I was born and went to school, and nearby Millersport, New York, my home until the age of 18; Detroit, Michigan, where I lived with my young husband Raymond Smith, 1962-68—when he taught English at Wayne State University and I taught English at the University of Detroit; and Princeton, New Jersey, where we lived for 30 years at 9 Honey Brook Drive, while Ray edited the Ontario Review and Ontario Review Press books and I taught at Princeton University, until Ray’s death in February 2008. Now I live a half-mile from that house in a new phase of my life, with my new husband, Charles Gross, a neuroscientist at Princeton University who is also a writer and photographer. The contemporary French provincial house in which we live on three acres fronting a small lake is “home” in the most immediate sense—this is the address to which our mail is delivered, and each of us hopes that this will be the last house of our lives; but if “home” is the repository of our deepest, most abiding and most poignant dreams, the landscape that haunts us recurringly, then “home” for me would be upstate New York—the rural crossroads of Millersport, on the Tonawanda Creek, and the city of Lockport on the Erie Canal.
As in a vivid and hallucinatory dream, I am being taken by my grandmother Blanche Woodside—my hand in hers—to the Lockport Public Library on East Avenue, Lockport. I am an eager child of 7 or 8 and this is in the mid-1940s. The library is a beautiful building like no other I’ve seen close up, an anomaly in this city block beside the dull red brick of the YMCA to one side and a dentist’s office to the other; across the street is Lockport High School, another older, dull-brick building. The library—which, at my young age, I could not have known was a WPA-sponsored project that transformed the city of Lockport—has something of the look of a Greek temple; not only is its architecture distinctive, with elegantly ascending steps, a portico and four columns, a facade with six large, rounded, latticed windows and, on top, a kind of spire, but the building is set back from the street behind a wrought-iron fence with a gate, amid a very green jewel-like lawn.
The library for grown-ups is upstairs, beyond a dauntingly wide and high-ceilinged doorway; the library for children is more accessible, downstairs and to the right. Inside this cheery, brightly lit space there is an inexpressible smell of floor polish, library paste, books—that particular library smell that conflates, in my memory, with the classroom smell of floor polish, chalk dust, books so deeply imprinted in my memory. For even as a young child I was a lover of books and of the spaces in which, as indeed in a sacred temple, books might safely reside.
What is most striking in the children’s library are the shelves and shelves of books—bookcases lining the walls—books with brightly colored spines—astonishing to a little girl whose family lives in a farmhouse in the country where books are almost wholly unknown. That these books are available for children—for a child like me—all these books!—leaves me dazed, dazzled.
The special surprise of this memorable day is that my grandmother has arranged for me to be given a library card, so that I can “withdraw” books from this library—though I’m not a resident of Lockport, nor even of Niagara County. Since my grandmother is a resident, some magical provision has been made to include me.
The Lockport Public Library has been an illumination in my life. In that dimension of the soul in which time is collapsed and the past is contemporaneous with the present, it still is. Growing up in a not-very-prosperous rural community lacking a common cultural or aesthetic tradition, in the aftermath of the Great Depression in which people like my family and relatives worked, worked and worked—and had little time for reading more than newspapers—I was mesmerized by books and by what might be called “the life of the mind”: the life that was not manual labor, or housework, but seemed in its specialness to transcend these activities.
As a farm girl, even when I was quite young I had my “farm chores”—but I had time also to be alone, to explore the fields, woods and creek side. And to read.
There was no greater happiness for me than to read—children’s books at first, then “young adult”—and beyond. No greater happiness than to make my way along the seemingly infinite shelves of books in the Lockport Public Library, drawing my forefinger across the spines. My grandmother was an avid reader whom all the librarians knew well, and whom they obviously liked very much; two or even three times a week she checked books out of the library—novels, biographies. I remember once asking Grandma about a book she was reading, a biography of Abraham Lincoln, and how she answered me: this was the first conversation of my life that concerned a book, and “the life of the mind”—and now, such subjects have become my life.
Subscribe now for more of Smithsonian's coverage on history, science and nature.









Comments (26)
Just finished reading A WIDOW'S STORY, a memoir by JCO. Am amazed that she is considered a "great" writer and won a Nobel prize! Her writing is loaded with fragments, run-on sentences, repetition, wrong words, way too many exclamations, and far too much narcissism. While she does make some very valid and important points about the trauma of losing her spouse and the horribly lonely aftermath, some of that is lost when you consider that she remarried a year after losing her husband. And her complaining about all the Harry & David gift baskets sent "in sympathy" is downright tacky--rather than throwing them into the garbage, why didn't she give them to a nursing home or homeless shelter? It is hard to accept that she TEACHES WRITING! Too bad her editor-husband could not have "ghost-edited" her overlong tome in which she refers to herself in third person as "The Widow."
Posted by Not So Impressed on April 18,2012 | 07:35 AM
"How innocent and oblivious the 1950s seem to us now, at least so far as parental oversight of children is concerned." Were the parents of the 1950's so cluelessly naive when they would allow their children to walk happily un-chaperoned about town and over country hill and dale? Or was that terrible Ozzie and Harriet era of raging injustice and way too much whiteness simply a much safer place? In any case, how delightfully written was this article by Joyce Carol Oates.
Posted by Thomas Michael Andres on March 16,2012 | 01:27 AM
I too spent my early years in Lockport and lived around the corner from Dorcas Clapsattle. We used to walk to school - Emmett Belknap together from kindergarten until my family moved to the country between 3rd and 4th grade.
Oates stories brought so many memories back.
Posted by kristen york gerling on August 10,2011 | 04:36 PM
There actually is a town (or a Hamlet) called Millersport in the Town of Clarence, NY.
Posted by Darlene Carlo on May 15,2011 | 08:10 AM
It did give me chills, and tears. My favorite summer school class “Greek Art & Literature” was taught by John Koplas and he brought me flowers opening night of the high school musical. He was an amazing teacher. I remember the bus station and it was scary but not as scary as Transit road at night (unless you were going to the Transit Drive-In) it was very desolate out there. We went to the Library often, mostly as a good place to hang out with friends. The Y on the left side and my dentist on the right. Just beyond the dentist was Castle’s Dairy were we got cokes and shakes if we didn’t want to go to Pontillo’s pizza further East.
There was a perceived “difference” from one side of town to another, amazingly so. Lots of us walked, long distances. It seems so long ago. Best about the comments was that they were from many classmates. It seemed good to “hear” from them.
Posted by Sherrie Smith Norton on October 26,2010 | 04:32 PM
I loved your article on Lockport. I too, was born and raised in that lovely city. However, you mentioned the Irish, Poles and Germans that worked on the canal, but what about the Italians? I had many relatives that came from the old country to work on that canal. Italians were a wonderful addition to the small town. I remember walking everywhere with my Grandmother. We would walk to the little Italian market, whose scent is imprinted on my brain forever. How I loved that market. We would walk to the A & P to get groceries and sometimes we would ride the bus. I have no recollection of the seedy Grey Hound Bus station nor of "strange" men at the Palace. My Grandmother was always there to welcome me home into a warm kitchen of wonderful things to eat when I was released from school at Charlotte Cross. And my Mother would always accompany me to the Palace Theater. I had a wonderful close knit Italian family and felt perfectly safe in that wonderful town. Charlotte Cross elementary school is alive in my memory and I visit it almost everyday. I remember when President Kennedy was shot. I was in Mrs. Kinney's class and it was after lunch. We were on the second floor, a boy came running into the room, out of breath and announced that the President had been shot. Now, in those days you didn't say anything bad about the President of the United States, especially to Mrs. Kinney, because she would slap you before you could blink. We were all taken aback and Mrs. Kinney would not let the boy leave the classroom until the news was verified. Once it was, we all left school. Such a sad, sad day. I wish I could have raised my own children in Lockport, but unfortunately, due to many circumstances, I ended up in California, and I hate it. I am so glad that I have such warm, wonderful memories that was full of a loving Italian family.
Posted by Anna Marie DiGiorgio on April 30,2010 | 11:55 AM
What a treat reading this article! I was born & raised in Lockport & must be about 2 years younger than the author. I lived at William Kenan's Randleigh Farm where my Dad was herdsman & later Manager. I attended St John the Baptist Catholic school & St. Joseph's Academy; gaduated in the Class of 1955. One of my classmates for the 12 years was Jeanne Oates who was, I believe, a cousin of Joyce Carol Oates. For 7 years I lived with my aunt & uncle on Locust St Ext. & many times either took the city bus & walked home past all the mansions there including the Kenan residence, now a center of some kind. Later I would take the school bus on Chestnut Ridge Rd to St John's & then the Greyhound during high school years. I read my way through the Library starting downstairs in the children's area; later upstairs.
My brother Tom married Helena Miller who lived on Transit Rd I think in Millersport. I could go on & on but now Iive in sunny Arizona after 40 years in CA. I attended my 50th High School Reunion in 2005 & enjoyed seeing all the old places.
Posted by Barbara Stedman Gastmeyer on April 5,2010 | 09:16 PM
I loved Joyce's recollections of Lockport! William E. Miller, of whom she made brief mention since he was the only Lockportian to ever run for vice-president, is my father, and though I left Lockport at age 6 to live in Washington when Dad entered Congress, I returned many times over the years during our wonderful,lazy summers in Olcott, to visit dear friends and family. I published a memoir/biography of my father a few years ago, and in it are many of the same recollections and descriptions that imbue Joyce's memory so vividly -- from the early days of the city's founding, my paternal Irish and German ancestors who settled there and helped to build the Erie Canal, my visits to my aunt's apartment overlooking the canal next to the Pine St. bridge from where I watched for hours on end the raising and lowering of the ominous waters, visiting my grandmother's millinery shop on Locust St. and trying on all the fancy hats. I spoke in that library that Joyce so venerates -- albeit to a far smaller crowd than did she! -- upon publishing my book and the hometown folks were so warm and welcoming. Mom and Dad returned there after they left politics in 1965,he until his death in 1983, Lockport being the one place even after all those years in the limelight and excitement of Washington that they felt was truly "home." And they never regretted returning to their roots and to the people who were their truest friends.
Posted by Libby Miller Fitzgerald on March 20,2010 | 04:46 PM
Having been gone from my home town all these years and living some of them half-way around the world (in Bangladesh) I thoroughly enjoyed Joyce Carol Oakes'"Going Home Again". My home was on the corner of Lincoln Drive and South Transit Road. Therefore, I also attended the John E. Pound elementary schol and then, Emmett Belknap junior high school. It was good to see comments by my classmates: Don Wolpert and Richard Gascoyne (class of 1954). [eaton@bbcpa.org]
Posted by Jesse G. Eaton on March 19,2010 | 12:34 PM
The saying goes,'home is where the heart is' and Lockport will always have a part of my heart. It was my families heritage . I loved going downtown every Friday night to meet my dad at his store which bore our family name. And although it would take what to a small child seemed like hours to walk one block because we had to stop every few feet to talk with another passerby it also gave me such a sense of belonging, and security. It was home, it was safe, and it was good. As I think of my grandson's future I sadly know he will not have the luxuary of growing up in the warmth of such an environment. A time past, oh sweet memories.
Posted by Dorcas Clapsattle Kershaw on March 18,2010 | 08:11 PM
Reading this article is like going home. Lockport is my true home event hough I no longer live there. I have so many fond and humorous stories of Lockport. I remember talking my driver's test on a very sunny day in April. I had to parallel park in from of the library and YMCA. Of course many of my 'friends' were sitting on the steps of both establishments cheering me on... I passed but not without much embarrasment. The Willow Park iceskating rink, Emmett Belknap,William's Brothers, The Sample, roller skating down Washburn Street hill...so many memories!
Posted by Marcy (Strouse) Miceli on March 15,2010 | 11:50 AM
I also remember taking the bus from just on the edge of the city limits, into downtown Lockport, a kid no more than 10 years old. Exciting, but safe. Even younger, maybe 4 years old, I remember coming home from the Palace Theater, singing "Thumbulenna" from the movie I had just seen, and I remember the angst and excitement of going there as a teenager, with a girl, or meeting her inside the movie! I remember tickets were 25 cents, 35 cents if you were over 12. (Now I've just become elegible for a senior discount at our movie theater: six dollars instead of eight.) We were told not to ride our bikes near the canal; it was dangerous. Stories of somebody jumping off one of the bridges into the canal, going through the submerged body of a cow floating downstream. I was a stranger to the library, and I found it imposing. I was uncomfortable there as a high school student working on an important paper. But I know Lockport like Ms Oates does. I recently took two friends there, who had heard so much about it, they had to see it themselves. Friends, family (now gone), buildings. Just to look at the words, Lockport, New York, is to feel home.
Posted by Dan Donnelly on March 14,2010 | 05:08 PM
I believe she lived in Middleport, NY and not Millersport, NY when growing up.
Posted by Lindsay on March 14,2010 | 01:32 PM
I really enjoyed reading and reminiscing about my beloved hometown of Lockport, NY. My childhood home was 2 streets north of Lockport Memorial Hospital.I frequented the Palace theatre and Library growing up. My dentist was in that office right next door to the library.
Thanks for the memories.
Posted by Anne Renna Zinna on March 11,2010 | 02:13 PM
I (Coke Dix) was LSHS Class of 58. With older sister Nancy and younger siblings Christoper and Vickie frequented the Library (and the Y next door) hundreds if not thousands of times. I may be mistaken, I don't think so but the motto/slogan over the front door of the Library says it all about Ms Oates and so many others that were blessed to grow up in Lockport:
"Books are like an open door, to set the spirt free"
Posted by E. Scovell Dix on March 8,2010 | 09:56 AM
What a marvelous memory, and so well told, as all of Oates' stories are. I was born, as was Joyce, in Lockport in June 1938. I lived at 12 Pound Street and for that reason our school paths didn't cross (I went to Washington Hunt and Emmet Belknap), the east end of town, not the west end where Joyce went to school. That speaks partly to the question Joyce mentions, “Do you think that you would be the writer you are today if you’d had a middle-class or wealthy background?” Well, Joyce, I had that middle-class background, and my guess is that it wasn't much different from yours. Indeed, we didn't end up in the same place. I've spend my life teaching Latin, most recently at the State University at Albany, NY - not Princeton! And, I wrote a syllabus for teaching Latin - not the Pulitzer Prize, or even the National Book award. But, I bet you remember the ice cream cones from the family dairy whose name I bear: Gascoyne.
Posted by Richard Gascoyne on February 27,2010 | 03:10 PM
This article resonates powerfully with me... growing up in the 1940s out in the country, attending school out of the district in which we lived, taking the bus to town, the magic of the library and the movie theater... all these things parallel my own childhood, but in northern Delaware among farms seven miles from Wilmington. Beyond that, Joyce Carol Oates writes beautifully!
Posted by Richard Ullman on February 27,2010 | 11:25 AM
I am a contemporary of Joyce Carol Oates. Born in 1941, I grew up in that same Lockport. I often walked the streets of the city, catching the Hawley Street bus for home after my jaunts. My school was Charlotte Cross, similar in many ways to John Pound.
My memories are not as dark, not as dreary. Fleeting moments of similarities perhaps but also of a feeling of safety, of belonging, of community. At the art center in Lockport where I now work we have a sign near a display of our home town's memorabilia, "It's a Lockport thing." Many visitors returning here from out of state (or out of country) like to talk about their own lives here. Soon we have made a connection. "Now, what was your mother's maiden name? Did they live on Grant Street?" Time dissolves and we share the bond of hometown again.
And yes, I've read all of her books.
Posted by Sally Hilger Bisher on February 24,2010 | 12:01 AM
Yes, the Lockport of today is very different from the 1950's. Is it more of a commuter town for Buffalo, rather than a General Motors factory town of the past? Our family was in rural Niagara County, in what is now the Starpoint School District. We moved to Lockport when I entered first grade and I also made the round of schools from Charlotte Cross to Washington Hunt to Emmett Belknap and the old high school.. We spent most of our free time playing seasonal sports at the Soldiers and Sailors park accross the street from the Hospital on East Avenue. I graduated from HS in 1953, left the Lockport environs in 1968 and am now retired in Minnesota.
Lots of good memories!
Thanks
John Benton
Posted by John Benton on February 24,2010 | 03:32 PM
I enjoyed this article very much, I am 26 an I live in Lockport, NY an was wondering if you ever remembered a building on Main St. called Kelley's Meat Market? My great grandfather owned it. I don't have very much information on it other then that! do you?
Posted by Martin Kelley on February 23,2010 | 12:10 AM
My husband Ron Linderman and I both grew up in Lockport, my brothers and I graduated from Lockport High School as did my husbands family. It was such a joy to see this article about our home town.
Posted by Maja Raysor Linderman on February 23,2010 | 12:07 PM
Thank you for the recollections of Lockport. They brought tears to my eyes. I too have fond recollections of the Lockport Public library, as my mother, Janet was: children's librarian, reference librarian, and ultimately Library Director. She started working at the Library in the 50's so Joyce Carol Oates may have missed her. She did not miss my father Donald, though, as he was her eighth grade english teacher. He told us that even in eighth grade Joyce Carol Oates was writing long opuses that he read and commented on. I have read a lot of Ms. Oates' writing, but not all (its hard to keep up) and really enjoy the writing and the hints of Lockport. Does she know the origin of the quote above the library door "Books are like an open door to set the spirit free"
Posted by Duncan Nixon on February 23,2010 | 10:07 AM
This was a flash back for me also.In 1950 I was 16 years old and was working as a deckhand on a tug boat in the canal. Even at that age I took in the beauty of the entire canal from Tonawanda to Waterford where the canal enterd the Hudson River. I remember the first,trip going by Sing Sing prison at night and fearing for my life that those prisoners were going to get me.
Three years ago I took my wife to Senica Falls and rented a boat similar to the ones used in Europe and took a week to cruse up thru the locks including Lackport,to Tonawanda.
It sure brought back memories.
I should write a book.
Posted by Red Hogan on February 22,2010 | 08:54 PM
This year I added one of Joyce Carol Oates' short stories, "Where are you Going?" to the curriculum and the student response was overwhelming. One of my very quiet students went to the library and took out every book written by her that we had on the shelves at school and read three of them in one weekend; I have never seen her so excited about a writer. When I came home today and opened your magazine, I was thrilled. I can't wait to bring it to school to share with my students. I teach at an public magnet city school in Wilmington, DE, Cab Calloway. Thanks for the article. Thanks to the writer.
Posted by Lisa Coburn on February 22,2010 | 04:58 PM
Thank you for a warm and heart warming flash back to my home town of Lockport NY. Joyce carol Oates is really one of my favorite authors and it's an honor to be from the samr town. 40-45 years ago Lockport was experiencing the blight of its urban renewal. It really did look quite sad at that time. Happily it seems to have risen from those ashes. The palace theater and the Kenan center are now used by the community. I wish though that the veterans memorial obelisk on East Ave. would receive its due recognition.
Posted by Jane Roberts Morante on February 22,2010 | 04:05 PM
I was raised in Lockport NY so the article and pictures brought back fond memories. My father was a dentist and had an office in the Bewley building. We lived on Pine Street and I knew of the narrow bridge as well as the world famous "widest bridge" in the world.
As I was born in 1937 we may have been in the same class ('54) or 1 year apart.
Don Wolpert
H.D. Wolpert
Director of Engineering
Bio-Optics
Posted by Don Wolpert on February 21,2010 | 12:39 PM