Discussion- page 1 | Magazine | Smithsonian

Discussion

Discussion

Smithsonian Magazine | Subscribe

From the Editors
“I just got my new 101 objects issue and I am in history heaven!” Judi Schimke of Seattle writes, voicing an opinion that we’re glad to say isn’t unique. Of course, some readers argued with our choices (as we’d hoped they would), insisting we should have included things like the television and the iPod. The object sparking the most commentary is Barbie, probably because of Sloane Crosley’s essay defending the fantastic plastic girl-next-door. “Ridiculous,” PJ Douglas says on Facebook. “Time to dump Barbie for good!” But Heidi Frederick Smith of Murrells Inlet, South Carolina, says concerns about the toy’s unlikely figure are overblown: “I grew up playing with Barbie. That did not mean I wanted to stick a finger down my throat to be what everyone thinks is the norm.” Patti Schanake calls for calm: “It’s just a doll.” On another front, the U.S. military’s use of weaponized drones also sparked disagreement:

Despicable Drones?
It should be pointed out that it [“Predator Drone”] is one of the things that made America despised instead of giving it respect.

Oline Wright
ParramaTta, New South Wales, Australia

Not liking something doesn’t make it unimportant or not historically relevant. I view [drones] like other weapons. They have their uses but can have unfortunate results.

Elias J. Moor
Pasadena, California

The use of drones is an abomination, but denying their status as a game changer would be foolish.

Joe Kloos
Reno, Nevada

Pondering the Pill
Some argue that the real beneficiaries of the Pill were men, who were also the beneficiaries of the sexual revolution, at the expense of women. For better or for worse, the Pill belongs on your list.

Robert A. B. Sawyer
on Facebook

Saluting Science
We build statues to glorify war and libraries to honor political hacks. Perhaps as we honor our troops, we might also wish to honor the scientists and researchers that have made childhood afflictions less deadly [“Polio Vaccine”]. Thanks to Jonas Salk, I was able to take my children to public beaches and pools without fear of polio.

Comment on this Story

comments powered by Disqus