Why the Titanic Still Fascinates Us
One hundred years after the ocean liner struck an iceberg and sank, the tragedy still looms large in the popular psyche
- By Andrew Wilson
- Illustration by Robert G. Lloyd
- Smithsonian magazine, March 2012, Subscribe
(Page 6 of 7)
Survivor Edith Russell still felt possessive of the Titanic story—she believed it was hers alone to tell—and she wanted to exploit it for all it was worth. She and Lord met in March 1957 at a lunch given by MacQuitty at a Hungarian restaurant in London. The gentleman writer and the grand lady of fashion hit it off immediately, drawn together by a shared passion for the Titanic and a sense of nostalgia, a longing for an era that had died somewhere between the sinking of the majestic liner and the beginning of World War I. Driven by an equally obsessive interest in the subject, Lord fueled Edith’s compulsion, and over the course of the next few years he sent her a regular supply of information, articles and gossip regarding the ship and its passengers.
Edith made regular visits to Pinewood, the film studio near London, to check on the production’s progress. Even though Edith was not employed on the project, MacQuitty was wise enough to realize there was little point in making an enemy of her.
As Edith aged, she became even more eccentric. When she died, on April 4, 1975, she was 96 years old. The woman who defined herself by the very fact that she had escaped the Titanic left behind a substantial inheritance and a slew of Titanic stories. To Walter Lord she pledged her famous musical pig. When Lord died in May 2002, he in turn left it to the National Maritime Museum, which also holds Edith’s unpublished manuscript, “A Pig and a Prayer Saved Me from the Titanic.”
In the years after A Night to Remember, the storm that had gathered around the Titanic seemed to abate, despite the best efforts of the Titanic Enthusiasts of America, the organization formed in 1963 with the purpose of “investigating and perpetuating the history and memory of the White Star liners, Olympic, Titanic, and Britannic.” The group, which later renamed itself the Titanic Historical Society, produced a quarterly newsletter, the Titanic Commutator, which over the years was transformed into a glossy journal. Yet, at this time, the membership comprised a relatively small group of specialists, maritime history buffs and a clutch of survivors. By September 1973, when the group held its tenth anniversary meeting, the society had a membership of only 250. The celebration, held in Greenwich, Connecticut, was attended by 88-year-old Edwina Mackenzie, who had sailed on the Titanic as 27-year-old second-class passenger Edwina Troutt. After more than 60 years she still remembered seeing the liner sink, “one row of lighted portholes after another, gently like a lady,” she said.
Many people assumed that, after 50 years, the liner, and the myths surrounding it, would finally be allowed to rest in peace. But in the early hours of September 1, 1985, oceanographer and underwater archaeologist Robert Ballard from the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution—together with French explorer Jean-Louis Michel from the French organization Ifremer—discovered the wreck of the Titanic lying at a depth of roughly two and half miles, and around 370 miles southeast of Mistaken Point, Newfoundland. “The Titanic lies now in 13,000 feet of water on a gently sloping Alpine-looking countryside overlooking a small canyon below,” said Ballard, on returning to America a number of days later. “Its bow faces north. The ship sits upright on its bottom with its mighty stacks pointed upward. There is no light at this great depth and little life can be found. It is a quiet and peaceful place—and a fitting place for the remains of this greatest of sea tragedies to rest. Forever may it remain that way. And may God bless these now-found souls.”
The world went Titanic-crazy once more, a frenzy that was even more intense than the previous bouts of fever. There was something almost supernatural about the resulting pictures and films, as if a photographer had managed to capture images of a ghost for the first time.
Within a couple of years of Ballard’s discovery, wealthy tourists could pay thousands of dollars to descend to the site of the wreck and see the Titanic for themselves, an experience that many likened to stepping into another world. Journalist William F. Buckley Jr. was one of the first observers outside the French and American exploratory teams to witness the ship at close quarters. “We descend slowly to what looks like a yellow-white sandy beach, sprinkled with black rocklike objects,” he wrote in the New York Times. “These, it transpires, are pieces of coal. There must be 100,000 of them in the area we survey, between the bow of the ship and the stern, a half-mile back. On my left is a man’s outdoor shoe. Left shoe. Made, I would say, of suede of some sort. I cannot quite tell whether it is laced up. And then, just off to the right a few feet, a snow-white teacup. Just sitting there...on the sand. I liken the sheer neatness of the tableau to a display that might have been prepared for a painting by Salvador Dali.”
Over the course of the next few years, around 6,000 artifacts were recovered from the wreck, sent to a specialist laboratory in France and subsequently exhibited. The shows—the first of which was held at the National Maritime Museum in London in 1994— proved to be enormous crowd-pleasers. Touring exhibitions such as “Titanic Honour and Glory” and “Titanic: The Artifact Exhibition” have been seen by millions of people all around the world. Items on display include a silver pocket watch, its hands stopped at 2:28 a.m., the time the Titanic was sinking into the ice-cold waters of the Atlantic; the Steiff teddy bear belonging to senior engineer William Moyes, who went down with the ship; the perfume vials belonging to Adolphe Saalfeld, a Manchester perfumer, who survived the disaster and who would have been astonished to learn that it was still possible to smell the scent of orange blossom and lavender nearly 100 years later. There were cut-crystal decanters etched with the swallowtail flag of the White Star Line; the white jacket of Athol Broome, a 30-year-old steward who did not survive; children’s marbles scooped up from the seafloor; brass buttons bearing the White Star insignia; a selection of silver serving plates and gratin dishes; a pair of spectacles; and a gentleman’s shaving kit. These objects of everyday life brought the great ship—and its passengers—back to life as never before.
Millvina Dean first became a Titanic celebrity at the age of 3 months when she, together with her mother, Georgette Eva, and her brother, Bertram, known as Vere, traveled back after the disaster to England on board the Adriatic. Passengers were so curious to see, hold and have their photographs taken with the baby girl that stewards had to impose a queuing system. “She was the pet of the liner during the voyage,” reported the Daily Mirror at the time, “and so keen was the rivalry between women to nurse this lovable mite of humanity that one of the officers decreed that first- and second-class passengers might hold her in turn for no more than ten minutes.”
After returning to Britain, Millvina grew up to lead what, at first sight, seems to be an uneventful life. Then, Ballard made his discovery. “Nobody knew about me and the Titanic, to be honest, nobody took any interest, so I took no interest either,” she said. “But then they found the wreck, and after they found the wreck, they found me.”
Single Page « Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Next »
Subscribe now for more of Smithsonian's coverage on history, science and nature.










Comments (34)
Great pictures. One problem. In one of the pictures, the author of this article referred to Titanic as a cruise liner. For your information, Titanic was NOT a cruise liner. There is a difference between a cruise ship and an ocean liner.
Posted by Mike on August 29,2012 | 12:36 PM
Super interesting and real the Titanic*s story!!!
Posted by Maria Torres on July 26,2012 | 03:12 AM
Several years ago, a Canadian newspaper columnist noted another strange twist associated with the disaster: the sudden popularity of a Halifax grave bearing the name Jack Dawes, which coincides with that of the Cameron movie's hero. Apparently, he worked in the engine room and had nothing but his name in common with Leonardo di Caprio's rakish swain, but this did not stop processions of teenage girls dropping flowers, emotional notes and yes, lingerie beside the grave. It makes you wonder how much else in what we call history is really just some of us clinging to our myths. Regardless, thank you for a fine article.
Posted by R. Pritchard on April 29,2012 | 10:40 AM
I am a scriber until 2017. The above article I truly enjoyed. Printed this out for my pastor to read. If there is a charge for this you have my address. Thank you so much for your magazine, I learn so much from them. I am 81 years old and don't travel much anymore. The e-mail is my office address - I work at my church part-time. Thank you again. Patricia
Posted by Patricia Niedentohl on April 11,2012 | 08:53 AM
This was a very well written, interesting article, but I'm not sure it was titled appropriately. It never answers the question about WHY the Titanic fascinates us. It should have been titled The Titanic Still Fascinates Us.
Posted by Rhona on April 10,2012 | 05:58 PM
Passenger manifest records for 479 survivors of the Titanic disaster who arrived in the Port of New York via the Carpathia are in the Ellis Island database (e.g., Madeline Astor) – includes passenger names, place of residents, age and images of the original manifests. http://bit.ly/HlYySg
Posted by Suzanne Mannion on April 10,2012 | 01:37 PM
Wikipedia lists twenty-six ships sunk between 1943-45 which each had a death toll exceeding that of the "Titanic." This includes the MV Wilhelm Gustlof and MV Goya, with deaths tolls of 9,000 and 6,000 respectively. Yet I would bet you that not one person in a thousand who can identify the Titanic has ever heard of either the Gustlof or the Goya, or any of the other dozens of ships from this period with such terrible loss of life. So it cannot be the scale of the Titanic disaster alone which keeps it alive in memory. Loss of life in the Lusitania sinking rivals that of the Titanic, but how many books and movies have been made about the Lusitania? I suspect the relative anonymity of these other disastrous sinkings compared to the Titanic is largely due to the fact that the people who died aboard the Titanic died accidentally while those in all the other sinkings were deliberately killed in acts of war. Moreover, most of the dead were citizens of countries waging ruthless war against Britain and the United States. To consider all these other terrible deaths mean thinking about people dying not from a collision with an iceberg but from naval submarines deliberately firing torpedos at them.
Posted by Jack Olson on April 10,2012 | 09:22 AM
My great Aunt Mahala Douglas, my grandfathers brother Walter D. Douglas and maid Berthe were first class passengers on Titanic. Ever since I was a little girl I have been reserching all the info about them, and finally got to the archives of Cedar Rapids, Iowa where they were originally from, to read Aunt Mahalas interviews first hand when she returned from the tradgedy. It is so interesting to read what was really said and how she really dealt with the whole tragedy. I would also like to comment on the fact that it is never brought up that the disaster devastated the towns in England where families husbands were the only ones bringing in the money and all of those men that died in the bowels of the ship put a tremendous amounts of families in poverty.
Posted by Frances Martin on March 21,2012 | 09:44 AM
My great Aunt Mahala Douglas, my grandfathers brother Walter D. Douglas and maid Berthe were first class passengers on Titanic. Ever since I was a little girl I have been reserching all the info about them, and finally got to the archives of Cedar Rapids, Iowa where they were originally from, to read Aunt Mahalas interviews first hand when she returned from the tradgedy. It is so interesting to read what was really said and how she really dealt with the whole tragedy. I would also like to comment on the fact that it is never brought up that the disaster devastated the towns in England where families husbands were the only ones bringing in the money and all of those men that died in the bowels of the ship put a tremendous amount of families in poverty.
Posted by Frances Martin on March 21,2012 | 09:44 AM
A UFA (Nazi) production called "Titanic," directed by Herbert Selpin, predates the melodramas which Andrew Wilson cites. It is available through Kino video. The original was briefly released in April 1943 but then banned by censors because the scenes of panic were too real for a civilian population subjected to Allied "Strategic" bombing. Apparently scenes were lifted by A Night To Remember. While its propaganda nature is blatant, it is the only film which has scenes of the commission's hearings on the disaster.
Posted by Jordan Auslander on March 19,2012 | 06:25 PM
Andrew Wilson's article is a fascinating addition to the lore of the Titanic. But the introductory caption is appalling. What is it about the deaths of 1500 people that you find "glorious"?
Posted by Mary Noll Nagase on March 15,2012 | 12:33 AM
The Titanic tragedy is only one more example of Man vs. Nature with the former often losing out. Hemingway's "Old Man & the Sea" underscored this. And so it was with the Tsunami in December 2004 while hundreds of thousands enjoyed coastal areas, the Fukushima reactors built near an unfortunate unstable vault line with totally inadequate wave breakers. Too many people around the globe are living dangerously too close to their coasts that are often subjected to Nature's wrath.
Mankind's messing with Nature often results with allegedly "unintended consequences" - just as New Orleans' defense measures were considered inadequate for decades by those living there and observing near total neglect to anticipate the hurricane that was sure to hit as it did in 1927.
As Prof. Pangloss in Voltaire's "Candide" consoled us with the idea that whatever happens is for the best and we should simply grow our own gardens. "Panglossian philosophy" is immortalized in both Webster and Oxford dictionaries.
Posted by Peter M. Lutterbeck, M.D. on March 12,2012 | 07:01 AM
While this article focused on the survivors of the Titanic sinking, the story of the people who did not survive and of the compassionate people of Halifax, Nova Scotia, captures my attention when I think of the disaster. Halifax had to deal with the aftermath of the disaster, retrieving the bodies, trying to identify them, and shipping the remains home. From the rows of tombstones for the unnamed in Halifax cemeteries, to the Maritime Museum's exhibits, I found this story far more poignant and interesting than that of the survivors.
Posted by Karen Morley on March 9,2012 | 09:31 AM
This was an interesting article, but I'm surprised that when mentioning the movies made about the tragedy there was no mention of the most famous survivor of them all - the Unsinkable Molly Brown! She was not a fictional character. She was very real, and the musical made of her story was very popular, both on Broadway and in movie form. I saw the movie with Debbie Reynolds when I was a young girl and it ignited a life long faccination with the story of the Titanic.
Posted by Joanne Babic on March 9,2012 | 05:35 AM
As a retired meteorologist, the Titanic fascinates me because it illustrates a new theory of climate change. It was going nearly full speed into a dense field of icebergs, near the end of a very cold decade; Niagara Falls froze over in 1911, and there are numerous pictures of people walking across on the ice. 1911 was the coldest year of the 20th Century. Why was the decade so cold? It was a period of minimum solar activity, manifested in a weak magnetic field. This allows high energy cosmic rays to enter our atmosphere, producing more cloud condensation nuclei, more clouds, and less heat from the sun. The connection is illustrated in a weblog by Mr. Nigel Calder at http://calderup.wordpress.com/2012/02/27/cosmic-rays-sank-the-titanic/ Recent experiments, both at CERN and in Denmark, confirm the cloud causation effect of cosmic rays. The current solar cycle is quite weak, and the next is forecast (by NASA) to be even weaker. We may be entering a cool phase of climate.
Posted by Richard C Savage on March 8,2012 | 05:38 PM
I had a friend who was on the Titanic. Her name was Eleanor Johnson-Shuman and she was two 1/2 years-old at the time. She was traveling with with her Mother, nanny (18 year-old Elin Braf) and her brother Fred (who was four year-old). She told me that her brother was dropped into "Collapsible D" by Elin from the deck of the ship just a few minutes before it went under (noting here that page 35 of the magazine shows Collapsible D but the story indicates that it's Lifeboat #7) making Fred the last person to board a lifeboat from the Titanic (see also PBS TV program www.DeathInAmerica.com). Eleanor was a great lady and I have fond memories of her making us chocolate chip cookies during a set up in her home for an interview on a Canadian TV show. Unfortunately her brother Fred didn't fare so well and had difficulties dealing with the trauma of the event for the rest of his life. Just before the premiere of the Titanic movie in Chicago, we introduced Eleanor to James Cameron who told us that although he'd visited the ship several times, she was the first actual survivor he'd ever met! She remembered being held by her mother in the boat (that's allgedly Eleanor's Mom with her back to the camera in Collapsible D) and it being cold but had to go from her mother's description for details of the event. Fred refused to publicly discuss it - ever.
Posted by J.R. Olivero on March 8,2012 | 02:45 PM
Nicely done, Mr. Wilson. Looking forward to your book. I've been fascinated by this tragedy since in grade school (late 1960s) when my brother borrowed Walter Lord's "A Night to Remember" from our library. The book jacket referenced the book, "Futility, or Wreck of the Titan" -- which, to some, accurately predicts the sinking. I've been captivated ever since.
Posted by Joe Michaels on March 7,2012 | 11:19 PM
I wonder why, after 100 years, Titanic still holds so much interest for us. There have been other shipwrecks that resulted in greater loss of life. The Sultana blew up after the American civil war killing about 1800. Perhaps because the media of the time claimed Titanic was "un-sinkable" (a claim the White Star line, Harland and Wollfe, and Mr. Andrews never made). It could be because of the class distinctions and the disproportionate number of survivors versus victims by class. Dr. Ballard was once quoted that he wished he had never revealed the location of Titanic. He saw it as grave site and didn't want it violated. A cable caught by one of his camera sleds By the way, his discovery of the wreck was an aside to his real mission of mapping the wreck of the submarines Thresher and Scorpion. Plus, it was his chance to test his theories of deep sea research without sending humans to dangerous depths.
Posted by Mark Mueller on March 7,2012 | 07:05 PM
This is a wonderful article. However, there is an error in the illustrations as anyone who is a devoted titanic follower knows the 4th stack was a dummy stack. I saw the Titanic exhibit in Saint Louis, MO when it was here (several times actually), and the exhibit was just fascinating. I really hope it makes it way here again soon.
Posted by Dave W. on March 7,2012 | 03:39 PM
Another thing the writer failed to note is that Ballard became interested in locating the wreck of the Titanic after Clive Cussler wrote the fantastic novel "Raise the Titanic." Cussler's character in the novel (Dirk Pitt) raises the ship using balloon-like ballast and explosives strategically placed around the ship--an idea so plausible that Ballard set out to find her and see if it could be done. Alas, he found the ship in two pieces, confirming what only some of the passengers claimed—that Titanic broke in half before sinking.
I too have been fascinated by the story. My sister and I scoured out anything we could find about the ship in the 1970s, not in either wave of Titanic mania.
Posted by Lulu on March 3,2012 | 09:57 PM
i love the titanic!
Posted by Amaryllis on March 2,2012 | 08:26 PM
For those who are interested, there is a "replica" of the forward half of the ship that you can visit in Pigeon Forge, Tennessee. It contains numerous artifacts from the ship.
Posted by Cleve Gray on March 2,2012 | 07:08 PM
Yes, this is a good article. Just 2 very minor comments:
1. The fresh paint is mentioned by Third Class passenger Elin Hakkarainen in her account (1996): 'Being on the Titanic was a new adventure. Everything was shiny and new and you could still smell the fresh paint'.
2. The foundry where the anchors were cast was not in Belfast, but at Netherton, near Dudley in the West Midlands, England.
Elin's story is one of 12 featured in my Titanic book, due to be published in March:
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Titanic-Last-Night-Small-Town/dp/0199595577
It was historian Walter Lord in A Night to Remember (1955) who described the sinking of the Titanic as 'the last night of a small town'. My book Titanic: The Last Night of a Small Town (Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2012), both builds upon and challenges Lord's famous account. First, it re-balances the narrative, covering First, Second, and Third Class; women as well as men; children as well as adults; crew members as well as passengers; and people from countries other than Britain and America. Second, the book offers not just a minute-by-minute depiction of events, but explores themes - the ship's construction, social class, migration, radio - thereby employing and extending the metaphor of a small town.
The book features the stories of both crew and passengers. The featured crew includes the Second Officer; a Stewardess; the young Assistant Wireless Operator; and the Captain of the Carpathia rescue ship. There are eight featured passengers in all - an amateur military historian and governess in First Class; a teacher in Second; a domestic servant and mother in Third; and three children. On the centenary of the sinking, it is the individual histories of twelve of the inhabitants of the small town that this book reconstructs. The book employs the rigorous, sceptical approach of the social historian, while at the same time retaining the vividness of the eye-witness account.
John Welshman
Posted by John Welshman on March 1,2012 | 05:40 AM
Two illustrations of Titanic are used in the article, and both show smoke coming from the aft (4th) stack. The 4th stack was a dummy, and anyone who has read Walter Lord's A Night to Remember, is well aware of that. The copy was great.
Posted by W. Wander on February 29,2012 | 07:54 PM
The Titanic story was something that never held any great interest to me until my son was doing a school project on the subject in 2011, since that time i read any articles i find on the subject,one of the best i have read is a book titled "and the band played on" by Christopher Ward and published by Hodder and Stoughton which covers the disaster and the legacy in relation to the authors family in the years after.
Posted by Gavin Morrison on February 29,2012 | 05:41 PM
@Ben Pittam, I'm not trying to be a jerk, but the writer was intentionally quoting the movie with the fresh paint smell line...the entire paragraph is devoted to it...
Posted by Pamela Webb on February 28,2012 | 11:51 PM
Good grief. 2 people claimed that the article states Millvina Dean said "It’s been 84 years and I can still smell the fresh paint,” she says. “The china had never been used, the sheets had never been slept in. Titanic was called the ship of dreams and it was, it really was.” Read carefully, people. The paragraph clearly indicates the fictional character of Rose from the film "Titanic" said it.
I know, it's stupid and nitpicky to correct people like this, but as someone who writes technical documentation which on occasion some people don't follow properly and then blame me for because they skipped a crucial qualifier, I take offense at poor reading comprehension. ;-)
Posted by Mike Reilly on February 28,2012 | 03:42 PM
I've always been fascinated with the Titanic too, since childhood. About 20 years ago, I discovered the story of Milka Saric (Desic), one of the young ladies traveling in 3rd class and on her way to meet her new husband, in Duluth, MI I think.... Somehow she was never listed among the missing passengers, but her daughters (now gone too) and the entire church community vouched for the authenticity of her claim. She never relished the spotlight, not did her family,but they always valued a little homemade cloth purse Milka had with her that terrible night.
About 15-20 years ago, I tried to tell the authors of some of the books about Milka, but its as if they didn't want to know there were any more survivors. "There are so many false claims," they tried to explain.
Milka's story: "A Walk in Faith: Milka Desich" was written in the March/April 1987 issue of Serb World, USA magazine. It said how she finally made her way to the Iron Range to meet her husband and the town folks waiting her arrival.
Posted by Milana Bizic on February 28,2012 | 03:12 PM
The part of the article that talks about smelling fresh paint was not a memory from the woman who was only 3 months old at the time of the sinking. It is a line that "Rose" from the Titanic movie says as she remembers her voyage on the ship.
This article was great! I am looking forward to the opening of the ehibit at The Henry Ford Museum in March.
Posted by B.G. on February 27,2012 | 09:43 PM
In 1997 there was Titanic exhibit in Memphis, Tennessee, part of WONDERS: The Memphis International Cultural Series. Major sponsors were Coca-Cola, Federal Express Corporation, ICI Acrylics, Inc., International Paper and The Kroger Company. I was awed by this excellent exhibit, as were thousands of other Memphians and visitors.
Posted by Jo Ann Hall on February 27,2012 | 03:50 PM
This was an interesting article with a major omission. Robert Ballard who found the Titanic wreckage began to be fascinated with the idea of doing so after Clive Cussler wrote Raise the Titanic, a fictional account of an attempt to raise the ship from the ocean floor using massive flotation balloons. The book was made into a movie in the mid-70s. It would be difficult then to argue that the discovery of the actual wreckage in 1985 began a second phase of interest in the Titanic as the author purports. Let's give at least a nod to the marine archaeological fascination held by Cussler and whatever influence he may have had over the reading public through his novels.
Posted by Kerry Ketcham on February 26,2012 | 11:14 PM
The 3 month old girl at the end of the article talks about how she remembered the smell of the fresh paint on the Titanic.Come on.Who remembers anything at age 3 months!!!
Posted by ben pittam on February 26,2012 | 02:07 PM
This is a wonderful article. I've been researching Titanic for some time now and I appreciate the broader perspective of this article.
Posted by Paula Moldenhauer on February 24,2012 | 03:47 PM