The Triumph of Frank Lloyd Wright
The Guggenheim Museum, turning 50 this year, showcases the trailblazer's mission to elevate American society through architecture
- By Arthur Lubow
- Smithsonian magazine, June 2009, Subscribe
Frank Lloyd Wright's most iconic building was also one of his last. The reinforced-concrete spiral known as the Solomon R. Guggenheim Museum opened in New York City 50 years ago, on October 21, 1959; six months before, Wright died at the age of 92. He had devoted 16 years to the project, facing down opposition from a budget-conscious client, building-code sticklers and, most significantly, artists who doubted that paintings could be displayed properly on a slanting spiral ramp. "No, it is not to subjugate the paintings to the building that I conceived this plan," Wright wrote to Harry Guggenheim, a Thoroughbred horse breeder and founder of Newsday who, as the benefactor's nephew, took over the project after Solomon's death. "On the contrary, it was to make the building and the painting a beautiful symphony such as never existed in the world of Art before."
The grandiloquent tone and unwavering self-assurance are as much Wright trademarks as the building's unbroken and open space. Time has indeed shown the Guggenheim's tilted walls and continuous ramp to be an awkward place to hang paintings, yet the years have also confirmed that in designing a building that bestowed brand-name recognition on a museum, Wright was prophetic. Four decades later, Frank Gehry's Guggenheim Bilbao—the curvaceous, titanium-clad affiliated museum in northern Spain—would launch a wave of cutting-edge architectural schemes for art institutions across the globe. But Wright was there first. A retrospective exhibition at the original Guggenheim (until August 23) reveals how often Wright pioneered trends that other architects would later embrace. Passive solar heating, open-plan offices, multi-storied hotel atriums—all are now common, but at the time Wright designed them they were revolutionary.
When Solomon Guggenheim, the heir to a mining fortune, and his art adviser, Hilla Rebay, decided to construct a museum for abstract painting (which they called "non-objective art"), Wright was a natural choice as architect. In Rebay's words, the two were seeking "a temple of spirit, a monument" and Wright, through his long career, was a builder of temples and monuments. These included actual places of worship, such as Unity Temple (1905-8) for a Unitarian congregation in Oak Park, Illinois, one of the early masterpieces that proclaimed Wright's genius, and Beth Sholom Synagogue (1953-59) in Elkins Park, Pennsylvania, which, like the Guggenheim, he supervised at the end of his life. But in everything he undertook, the goal of enhancing and elevating the human experience was always on Wright's mind. In his religious buildings, he used many of the same devices—bold geometric forms, uninterrupted public spaces and oblique-angled seating—as in his secular ones. The large communal room with overhead lighting that is the centerpiece of Unity Temple was an idea he had introduced in the Larkin Company Administration Building (1902-6), a mail-order house in Buffalo, New York. And before it reappeared in Beth Sholom, what he called "reflex-angle seating"—in which the audience fanned out at 30-degree angles around a projecting stage—was an organizing principle in his theater plans, starting in the early 1930s. To Wright's way of thinking, any building, if properly designed, could be a temple.
In his unshakable optimism, messianic zeal and pragmatic resilience, Wright was quintessentially American. A central theme that pervades his architecture is a recurrent question in American culture: How do you balance the need for individual privacy with the attraction of community activity? Everyone craves periods of solitude, but in Wright's view, a human being develops fully only as a social creature. In that context, angled seating allowed audience members to concentrate on the stage and simultaneously function as part of the larger group. Similarly, a Wright house contained, along with private bedrooms and baths, an emphasis on unbroken communal spaces—a living room that flowed into a kitchen, for example—unknown in domestic residences when he began his practice in the Victorian era. As early as 1903, given the opportunity to lay out a neighborhood (in Oak Park, which was never built), Wright proposed a "quadruple block plan" that placed an identical brick house on each corner of a block; he shielded the inhabitants from the public street with a low wall and oriented them inward toward connected gardens that encouraged exchanges with their neighbors. Good architecture, Wright wrote in a 1908 essay, should promote the democratic ideal of "the highest possible expression of the individual as a unit not inconsistent with a harmonious whole."
That vision animates the Guggenheim Museum. In the course of descending the building's spiral ramp, a visitor can focus on works of art without losing awareness of other museumgoers above and below. To that bifocal consciousness, the Guggenheim adds a novel element: a sense of passing time. "The strange thing about the ramp—I always feel I am in a space-time continuum, because I see where I've been and where I'm going," says Bruce Brooks Pfeiffer, director of the Frank Lloyd Wright Archives in Scottsdale, Arizona. As Wright approached the end of his life, that perception of continuity—recalling where he had been while advancing into the future—must have appealed to him. And, looking back, he would have seen telling examples in his personal history of the tension between the individual and the community, between private desires and social expectations.
Wright's father, William, was a restless, chronically dissatisfied Protestant minister and organist who moved the family, which included Wright's two younger sisters, from town to town until he obtained a divorce in 1885 and took off for good. Wright, who was 17 at the time, never saw his father again. His mother's family, the combative Lloyd Joneses, were Welsh immigrants who became prominent citizens of an agricultural valley near the village of Hillside, Wisconsin. Wright himself might have written the family motto: "Truth Against the World." Encouraged by his maternal relatives, Wright showed an early aptitude for architecture; he made his initial forays into building design by working on a chapel, a school and two houses in Hillside, before apprenticing in Chicago with the celebrated architect Louis H. Sullivan. Sullivan's specialty was office buildings, including classic skyscrapers, such as the Carson Pirie Scott & Company building, which were transforming the Chicago skyline.
But Wright devoted himself primarily to private residences, developing what he called "Prairie Style" houses, mostly in Oak Park, the Chicago suburb in which he established his own home. Low-slung, earth-hugging buildings with strong horizontal lines and open circulation through the public rooms, they were stripped clean of unnecessary decoration and used machine-made components. The Prairie Style revolutionized home design by responding to the domestic needs and tastes of modern families. Wright had firsthand knowledge of their requirements: in 1889, at 21, he had married Catherine Lee Tobin, 18, the daughter of a Chicago businessman, and, in short order, fathered six children.
Like his own father, however, Wright exhibited a deep ambivalence toward family life. "I hated the sound of the word papa," he wrote in his 1932 autobiography. Dissatisfaction with domesticity predisposed him toward a similarly discontented Oak Park neighbor: Mamah Cheney, a client's wife, whose career as head librarian in Port Huron, Michigan, had been thwarted by marriage and who found the duties of wife and mother a poor substitute. The Wrights and Cheneys socialized as a foursome, until, as Wright later described it, "the thing happened that has happened to men and women since time began—the inevitable." In June 1909, Mamah Cheney told her husband that she was leaving him; she joined Wright in Germany, where he was preparing a book on his work. The scandal titillated newspapers—the Chicago Tribune quoted Catherine as saying she had been the victim of a "vampire" seductress. Wright was painfully conflicted about walking out on his wife and children. He attempted a reconciliation with Catherine in 1910, but then resolved to live with Cheney, whose own work—a translation of the writings of Swedish feminist Ellen Key—provided intellectual support for this convention-defying step. Leaving the Oak Park gossipmongers behind, the couple retreated to the Wisconsin valley of the Lloyd Joneses to start anew.
Subscribe now for more of Smithsonian's coverage on history, science and nature.
Related topics: Frank Lloyd Wright 20th Century Museums
Additional Sources
An Autobiography: Frank Lloyd Wright, Horizon Press, 1932









Comments (10)
Regarding the photograph on page 57 of the June 2009 article about Frank Lloyd Wright; although similar, the two cars are not the Austin Healey 'Bugeye' Sprite. The 'Bugeye' Sprite was produced in England between 1958-1961.
The photo shows Frank sitting in an American made car, produced in Indiana; the Crosley HotShot. Although this model was made from 1949-1952; details suggest that these cars were built in 1949-1950. For additional imformation, please go to the following link: http://crosleyautoclub.com
Posted by Steve Chmelar on January 1,2010 | 09:17 PM
Arthur Lubow, in “The Triumph of Frank Lloyd Wright” (June 2009), mentions, as part of Wright’s ambition to “elevate American society,” his Broadacre City scheme. While Broadacre City remained a dream, Wright was commissioned to design a microcosm of a city, the campus of Florida Southern College in Lakeland, Fla. Thanks to the curators of the Frank Lloyd Wright Archives and the Solomon R. Guggenheim Museum, Wright’s campus is on display in the Guggenheim's 50th anniversary exhibition.
Built on a shoestring with the help of student labor from 1939 until his death in 1959, Wright's campus comprises the largest single-site collection of his work in the world. Of the 18 structures designed, 12 were built, including his only planetarium and theatre-in-the-round; a 1.5-mile network of cantilevered esplanades; and an iconic symbol of the fountain of knowledge, a 60-foot-high water dome, which was only fully realized in 2007 when engineering technology and available funding caught up with Wright's vision. Today, the campus is undergoing an ambitious restoration under the leadership of president Dr. Anne Kerr and funded by the Getty Foundation, the State of Florida, private donors, and the Save America's Treasures program.
If the Guggenheim traces its lineage to the 1924 sketch of an unbuilt parking garage, as Lubow suggests, it also owes much to Wright’s grand design for the Florida Southern College library, a multi-tiered, circular reading room enveloped by clerestory windows and an indoor balcony. Of note, the library was completed in 1945, the same year Wright was working on the Guggenheim drawings. Wright’s campus, rising out of the ground in the midst of an orange grove and constructed of native materials — sand, coquina shell, and Florida tidewater cypress — is a masterpiece of organic architecture. In a 1950 speech, he called it “a little green shoot in the realm of the spirit.”
Lee Mayhall, Vice President, College Relations
Florida Southern College
Posted by Lee Mayhall on June 29,2009 | 03:09 PM
As a graduate of Florida Southern College, Lakeland, Fl. I was somewhat disappointed that you did not show nor mention any of Wrights buildings there, such as the Annie Phieffer Chapel. It too was an important era in his life as was his friendship with Ludd M Spivey, the president at the time of the construction. This was done in the early '40's and is such an integral part of Southern's history.
Posted by betty hancock on June 28,2009 | 04:00 PM
During the time Mr. Wright was working on the Guggenheim he was also working on a very little known project that was to become the "Taliesin Ensemble" or the "Taliesin Line". It was to include fabrics and wallpapers by F. Schumacher and Co.,Rugs by Karastan,furniture by Heritage-Henredon,paints by Martin-Senour Co. and accessories (VASES)by Minic. Between the years of 1953-1955 I was the "runner" between my father, Valentine Minnich,president of Minic,and Mr. Wright. I would bring models and drawings based on ideas that Mr. Wright and my father had and how difficult the pieces would be to bring into production. Mr. Wright liked the idea that my father had faith in a 13 year old to speak on behalf of the Minic firm and for two years I visited the second floor of the Plaza Hotel dropping off the latest sketch or model for Mr. Wright's approval.I still have photos of many of the pieces along with my collection. I would be happy to send by e-mail photos of the vases if anyone is interested in seeing them. Yours, William V. Minnich
Posted by William V. Minnich on June 18,2009 | 10:19 PM
I read with excitement Arthur Lubow’s article celebrating the 50th anniversary of Frank Lloyd Wrights’ Guggenheim Museum in New York City. As an art historian turned woodworker, I was delighted to be involved in the restoration of the famed architects’ last prairie house built in Chicago. This was the Emil Bach House, built in 1917. Bought at auction in 2005 the interior, which had been severely altered over the years, was painstakingly restored with the exception of the heating system. For the rooms unfurnished by Wright, the new owner commissioned original works of art which complimented Wright’s unique details. My effort was a desk made of Illinois black walnut and beech (the primary woods of the house) inspired by the Japanese Tansu style. To ‘marry’ the desk to the house I simply lifted the iconography from the house and applied it to the desk. For example, Wright's use of bands of casement windows 'wrapping around the corners' of the house is reflected by the two checked drawer fronts in that the checks 'wrap around the corner' into the drawer sides. Another example of marrying the desk to the house is the caning on the sliding doors which conceal files. The caning connects the desk to the chair, which is a duplicate of a chair from the original dinette set designed by Wright for the Bach house. (Please See Linked Illustrations Enclosed)
http://marcuswoodworking.com/commissions/feerer_bach_house.html
Marcus Collier, Woodworker
www.marcuswoodworking.com
Posted by Marcus Collier on June 18,2009 | 04:20 PM
As is too often the case with artists & those who talk about their work, the central idea is ignored. Your essay on the Guggenheim Museum is a case in point. Wright figured out the best way to design a museum where you walk around looking at objects on the wall & never being sure which way to turn when you enter another room. Hence, you make it easier to walk by having a slight incline down, & in a spiral so you don't have to decide which way to turn. All that talk about ziggurats & symbols & such by Wright & others, may be true, but obscure the central idea. BTW, I've never started visit to the Guggenheim by walking up, but by taking the elevator & walking down. Then I might walk back up.
Posted by John Mood on June 10,2009 | 07:03 PM
I love the Smithsonian Magazine and truly enjoyed the article about FLWright. Question: In San Luis Obispo, CA, there is a small office building that FLW designed. Do you have any info on that?
The article by Patton's grandson was one of the most touching articles! Thanks for that.
Posted by sonja glassmeyer, ed.d on June 4,2009 | 07:25 PM
Frank Lloyd Wright was the greatest architect of the 20th Century. I believe you can include the 19th, 18th & 17th centuries.
Posted by Theo Dimson on June 4,2009 | 05:55 PM
Jon,
Those are two Austin Healey Sprite autos, nicknamed "bug eyed sprites" for obvious reasons. They were designed that way to comply with federal regulations for headlight height.
The cars were produced in the 1960's and perhaps into the 1970's. For more info, check Wikipedia.
Bob
Posted by Robert Krogh on June 4,2009 | 02:32 PM
I was facinated by the two little cars pictured with Lloyd and his wife. Do you have any information on them?
Posted by Jon Hall on May 26,2009 | 11:58 AM