The Beer Archaeologist
By analyzing ancient pottery, Patrick McGovern is resurrecting the libations that fueled civilization
- By Abigail Tucker
- Photographs by Landon Nordeman
- Smithsonian magazine, July-August 2011, Subscribe
(Page 3 of 7)
In the lab, a flask of coffee-colored liquid bubbles on a hot plate. It contains tiny fragments from an ancient Etruscan amphora found at the French dig McGovern had just visited. The ceramic powder, which had been painstakingly extracted from the amphora’s base with a diamond drill, is boiling in a chloroform and methanol solvent meant to pull out ancient organic compounds that might have soaked into the pottery. McGovern is hoping to determine whether the amphora once contained wine, which would point to how the beverage arrived in France in the first place—a rather ticklish topic.
“We think of France as sort of synonymous with wine,” McGovern says. “The French spent so much time developing all these different varietals, and those plants were taken all over the world and became the basis of the Australian industry, the Californian industry and so forth. France is a key to the whole worldwide culture of wine, but how did wine get to France? That’s the question.”
Francophiles might not like the answer. Today wine is so integral to French culture that French archaeologists include the cost of cases in their excavation budgets. McGovern, however, suspects that wine was being produced in Etruria—present-day central Italy—well before the first French vineyards were planted on the Mediterranean coast. Until Etruscan merchants began exporting wine to what is now France around 600 B.C., the Gauls were likely guzzling what their epicurean descendants would consider a barbaric blend of honey or wheat, filtered through reeds or mustaches.
McGovern’s Etruscan amphora was excavated from a house in Lattes, France, which was built around 525 B.C. and destroyed in 475 B.C. If the French were still drinking Etruscan vintages at that point, it would suggest they had not established their own wineries yet. The trick is proving that the amphora contained wine.
McGovern can’t simply look for the presence of alcohol, which survives barely a few months, let alone millennia, before evaporating or turning to vinegar. Instead, he pursues what are known as fingerprint compounds. For instance, traces of beeswax hydrocarbons indicate honeyed drinks; calcium oxalate, a bitter, whitish byproduct of brewed barley also known as beer stone, means barley beer.
Tree resin is a strong but not surefire indicator of wine, because vintners of old often added resin as a preservative, lending the beverage a pleasing lemony flavor. (McGovern would like to test the Lattes samples for resin from a cypress-like tree; its presence would suggest the Etruscans were in contact with Phoenician colonies in Northern Africa, where that species grows.) The only foolproof way to identify ancient wine from this region is the presence of tartaric acid, a compound in grapes.
Once the boiling brown pottery mixture cooks down to a powder, says Gretchen Hall, a researcher collaborating with McGovern, they’ll run the sample through an infrared spectrometer. That will produce a distinctive visual pattern based on how its multiple chemical constituents absorb and reflect light. They’ll compare the results against the profile for tartaric acid. If there’s a match or a near-match, they may do other preliminary checks, like the Feigl spot test, in which the sample is mixed with sulfuric acid and a phenol derivative: if the resulting compound glows green under ultraviolet light, it most likely contains tartaric acid. So far, the French samples look promising.
McGovern already sent some material to Armen Mirzoian, a scientist at the federal Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau, whose primary job is verifying the contents of alcoholic beverages—that, say, the gold flakes in the Italian-made Goldschlager schnapps are really gold. (They are.) His Beltsville, Maryland, lab is crowded with oddities such as a confiscated bottle of a distilled South Asian rice drink full of preserved cobras and vodka packaged in a container that looks like a set of Russian nesting dolls. He treats McGovern’s samples with reverence, handling the dusty box like a prized Bordeaux. “It’s almost eerie,” he whispers, fingering the bagged sherds inside. “Some of these are 5,000, 6,000 years old.”
Months later, McGovern e-mails me with good news: Mirzoian has detected tartaric acid in the Lattes samples from France, making it all but certain they contained imported Etruscan wine. Also, the project’s archaeologists have unearthed a limestone treading vat from 400 B.C.—what would seem to be the earliest French wine press, just about 100 years younger than the Etruscan amphora. Between the two sets of artifacts, McGovern hopes to pinpoint the advent of French wine.
“We still need to know more about the other additives,” he says, “but so far we have excellent evidence.”
Single Page « Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Next »
Subscribe now for more of Smithsonian's coverage on history, science and nature.









Comments (26)
technical assistance as in terms of a factory which can turn pineapples into wine and beer .region central region districts masaka,mukono,kayunga.as there are plenty of pinneapples.
Posted by musoke moses on January 19,2013 | 11:23 AM
Interesting. We know more about Sumerian beer than we do about Merovingian (early French) beer, mainly because of the lack of substantial artifacts. Yet beer (which might conceivably have made its way from Babylon to the Germanic groups, if one accepts that Germanic numeric terms reflect knowledge of Babylonian numerals) was the main northern drink for a very long time. I'm bemused that Massilia is not mentioned in regard to French wine; the Greeks are often credited (by anecdote and archaeology) with introducing wine in France. And the fact that Etruscan wine was imported of course does not mean the Gauls were not already making their own wine; they kept importing wines long after their own wine-making is well documented. The Etruscans, on the other hand, may have invented the barrel, which is more often credited to the Gauls.
Posted by Jim Chevallier on October 2,2012 | 10:28 PM
Wow! !! An 18000bp egyptian beer receipe.....talk about medical brilliance!!!!
Posted by medicalarch on November 10,2011 | 10:50 AM
Very interesting article. Never new that hemp was a hallucinogen. Many brewers use hemp as a flavoring much like hops. I think the author may be mistaking hemp for cannabis. But cannabis is still not a hallucinogenic. I could be mistaken but I've never heard of anyone "tripping out on it".
Posted by Lisa W on September 23,2011 | 07:59 PM
Living in Portland "Beervana" Oregon, I found Abigail Tucker's "Dig, Drink and Be Merry" article quite interesting from home brewer's point of view. Many of the ingredients that Dr. Pat has analyzed are still used by today's craft brewers, and there's movement underway to rediscover the ancient brews. Intrigued by his association with Dogfish Head brewery, I bought a couple of bottles of Midas Touch for sampling. King Midas and his early counterparts must of had a sweet tooth, for I found it was too sweet for my pallet, but never the less it was exciting to experience a brew from a 700 B.C. recipe. Cheers to civilization!
Posted by Curtis on August 3,2011 | 01:44 PM
Tried Midas Touch last night with a crew of fellow archaeologists from Wayne State University, celebrating the conclusion of a successful field school. Cellar temp (no fridges in Phrygia, mind), served in shallow bowls (per the original vessels). Consensus: excellent brew, very complex--everyone tasted something different. On to Theobroma!
Posted by Dan Harrison on July 24,2011 | 10:47 AM
I found this topic fascinating, and the author obviously did a lot of in-depth research to write the article. However, the conspicuous mention of Dogfish Head Pub over and over bothered me a bit; it made what would otherwise be an informative article seem almost like an infomercial.
Posted by EveT on July 20,2011 | 02:19 PM
As an archaeologist, a student of historical and ancient foodways, and a long-time homebrewer and winemaker, i thoroughly enjoyed this well-constructed story about Professor McGovern's work. I have also enjoyed the fruits of his collaboration with Sam Calagione that have made it to market.
Beside the abiding public interest in things archaeological and things alcoholic, this is important work for increasing understanding of our own humanity. This sort of research and experimentation gives us not only a literal taste of history, but a more perfect understanding of ourselves.
Posted by L. Daniel Mouer, PhD on July 17,2011 | 09:34 AM
One of the most fascinating and entertaining articles I've read in Smithsonian to date. Thanks!
Posted by Stephen on July 16,2011 | 02:09 AM
What a witty, scholarly, intriguing read. Best article I've read on any subject for a long long time! Is professor McGovern related to George who also hailed from Mitchell, South Dakota?
Posted by marlowe anderson on July 16,2011 | 01:55 PM
"...opioids are technically classified as a depressant but can elicit hallucinatory effects."
In my decades of working with abusers: never.
Posted by Diz Pareunia on July 12,2011 | 05:05 PM
Thats a great story. The wines sure is a everybody's choice right from the dogfish time.
Posted by Mathew Leonard on July 11,2011 | 09:05 AM
What if any alcoholic beverages did the American Indians make & drink before European Alcoholic Beverages were introduced to them?
Posted by J. L. G. on July 8,2011 | 06:20 PM
beer, wine, alcohol is of course one of our best foods and far too often villified. I just read of a 700 lb woman working to 'set the record' by attaining 1,000 pounds. She is not alone in abusing food. It is time for the fringe elements (MADD) to stop vilifying the responsible consumption of food/beverage.
Posted by Joepalooka on July 8,2011 | 03:16 PM
I've heard that with old corn seeds from SouthWest Native American Indian pueblos that they were able to spray them with a plant hormone of some sort and get some of them to grow. If it's possible to do that with the old grape seeds, I think they should try that before doing DNA extraction. You could do the extraction from the new plant cells in the plant if it worked...
Posted by Keith Wellman on July 8,2011 | 12:16 PM
I was so happy to read about this article on the Beer Archaeologist in Smithsonian...I am a very avid beer enthusiast and I am looking forward to this new Dogfish Head release of their Ta Henket beer. I always wanted to try a beer based on the type that was brewed in ancient Egypt. The only other company that I know of that released a similar type of brew like this one was Sapporo, but that was a limited release and I don't think that it was available for commercial purchase. I also will have to find Dogfish's Midas Touch...I'd like to try that one!
Posted by George L. on July 3,2011 | 07:23 PM
The author wrote a very interesting article, and all anybody can do with their comments is nit-pick? C'mon. It's really too bad that the place you let the article take you is there. It was wasted on you.
Posted by Pleased and Grateful on July 1,2011 | 02:03 PM
My apologies. Too much beer. Try hieroglyphs instead of hieroglyphics. the ic ending is an adjective. I am a stickler for grammar, but I'm dyslexic and spell phonetically to an extreme fault.
Posted by Randall P. on June 30,2011 | 02:32 PM
Try hyroglyphs instead of hyroglyphics. Serious pet peeve.
Posted by Randall P. on June 30,2011 | 02:26 PM
nit-nit:
Any marijuana plant product that acts on the cannabinoid receptor(s) is technically a hallucinogen, and opioids are technically classified as a depressant but can elicit hallucinatory effects.
-Sean
Posted by Sean Sparks on June 28,2011 | 05:34 PM
I really enjoyed this piece -- I'm a big fan of both Abigail Tucker's graceful writing, and Dogfish Head's delicious beer!
Posted by Amanda on June 28,2011 | 09:59 AM
Is that a mistake in the first sentence? A recipe dating back several hundred centuries?
Posted by jvk222 on June 26,2011 | 08:58 AM
The very first sentence contains a howler, referring to "an Egyptian ale whose recipe dates back several hundred centuries."
Several dozen centuries would be more like it. Even a single hundred centuries would be 10,000 years, about the age of the oldest known alcoholic beverage.
Posted by DWPittelli on June 25,2011 | 09:09 AM
I love the comment "“My wife says I tend to age things too long.” . What better thought could anyone have about a libation. Just wonderful.
Posted by charles s on June 24,2011 | 11:41 PM
a nit:
neither hemp nor opium is properly a hallucinogen
Posted by joel hanes on June 24,2011 | 08:14 PM