George Koval: Atomic Spy Unmasked
Iowa-born and army-trained, how did George Koval manage to steal a critical U.S. atom bomb secret for the Soviets, that is only now coming to light?
- By Michael Walsh
- Smithsonian magazine, May 2009, Subscribe
(Page 2 of 5)
"They had a different view of patriotism," Ronald Radosh says of the expatriate Russians. "Communism may have been a bad dream, but it was a dream that had merit in their eyes," adds Radosh, co-author (with Joyce Milton) of The Rosenberg File and a leading scholar of Soviet espionage during and after World War II. "It was, in part, a legacy of the czarist past and the pogroms—the czar was the enemy of the Jews."
Traveling on a U.S. family passport, the Kovals had planned to return to Minsk, "but the Soviet authorities did not allow them to do that," says Maya Koval, George's 28-year-old grandniece, who lives in Moscow. "They were forced to stay in the Vladivostok area," in the so-called Jewish Autonomous Region that Stalin had established in the 1920s. They settled in the town of Birobidzhan, near the Soviet border with Manchuria. In 1936, an American named Paul Novick, who edited a Communist Yiddish-language daily in New York City, visited the town and met the Kovals. The family, he would assert to his readers, "had exchanged the uncertainty of life as small storekeepers in Sioux City for a worry-free existence for themselves and their children," according to a book Canadian political scientist Henry Srebrnik is writing on ICOR and Birobidzhan.
Working on a collective farm, Isaya, the eldest Koval son, became a champion tractor driver and married a Jewish girl from Kiev, with whom he had three girls and a boy. (He died in May 1987, in a village near Birobidzhan.) George, after improving his Russian on the collective, was accepted in 1934 to study at the Mendeleev Institute of Chemical Technology in Moscow; there he met and married Lyudmila Ivanova, a fellow student whose father owned a small chocolate factory in Moscow. Five years later he graduated with honors, and he received Soviet citizenship along the way. His brother Gabriel also attended Mendeleev, but was killed in August 1943, fighting with the Red Army.
Exactly how and when the GRU recruited George is unclear, but after he received his degree he left Moscow as part of a subterfuge: "I was drafted into the army in 1939 to cover up my disappearance from Moscow," Koval would later write to Arnold Kramish, an American scientist he would befriend. "I did not accept an offer of military training and service as an army officer at that time, was never sworn in, or wore a uniform here." Kramish is now 86 and living outside Washington, D.C. after a long career at the RAND Corporation and the Atomic Energy Commission. Partly out of a professional interest in Soviet nuclear programs, he re-established contact with Koval in 2000 and kept in touch by letter and e-mail over the last five years of Koval's life.
One thing Koval's correspondence does explain is how he returned to the United States in 1940, even though his parents had relinquished their U.S. passport: "I entered the U.S. in October 1940 at San Francisco," he wrote to Kramish. "Came over on a small tanker and just walked out through the control point together with the captain, his wife and little daughter, who sailed together with him."
Koval made his way to New York City and, Kramish says, assumed deputy command of the GRU station there. The station went under the cover of the Raven Electric Company, a supplier to General Electric and other U.S. firms, with two Manhattan offices. Koval told colleagues he was a native New Yorker, an only child and an unmarried orphan. Standing six feet tall, with a penetrating gaze and a bohemian's distracted air, Koval came across as a baseball fan and an overall boon companion. "I don't know anybody who hated George," Kramish says.
On January 2, 1941—just months after he walked into the United States—Koval registered for the draft, listing a Bronx home address. Raven secured him a job-related deferment for a year beginning in February 1942; according to the Russian historian Lota, Koval's Soviet handlers wanted him to steal information about chemical weapons and believed that his ability to do so would be compromised if he were drafted. But the deferment expired, and on February 4, 1943, George A. Koval was inducted into the United States Army.
After basic training at Fort Dix, New Jersey, Private Koval was sent to the Citadel in Charleston, South Carolina, to join the 3410th Specialized Training and Reassignment Unit. And on August 11 of that year he was admitted to a new unit, the Army Specialized Training Program (ASTP). One of his colleagues there, Duane Weise, believes Koval scored particularly high on the Army's analog to the IQ test. The move marked Koval's first step toward the nation's nuclear labs.
The Army had established the ASTP in December 1942 to provide academically talented enlisted men with an undergraduate education and specialized technical training at colleges and universities across the country. Koval was sent to study electrical engineering at the City College of New York (CCNY); his surviving former ASTP fellows say he became something of a role model, even a father figure, to them. "At the time his classmates believed there was no better man than George," says Kramish, who was also in the program. "He was superb at every job he had."
Koval was a decade older than the others, Kramish says, and acted more maturely. "That was one of the anomalies about him," Kramish recalls. "In retrospect, there were mysteries that made him stand out." One, he says, was that Koval never seemed to do any homework. ("Of course, that was because he was already a college graduate back in Moscow, although we didn't know that at the time.") Another talent was helping his chums evade bed check by arranging pillows and blankets into "sleeping" bodies. ("He was famous for that," Kramish says.) And he smoked his cigarettes down to where they almost burned his fingers as he pinched the butt. ("That was a very distinctive Eastern European habit," Kramish adds, "which I never knew about until I went to Europe after the war.") Koval's surviving classmates (who at the time knew nothing of a wife in the Soviet Union) also say he was a notable ladies' man.
Single Page « Previous 1 2 3 4 5 Next »
Subscribe now for more of Smithsonian's coverage on history, science and nature.
Related topics: US Army People Cold War USSR
Additional Sources
"A Spy's Path: Iowa to A-Bomb to Kremlin Honor" by William J. Broad, The New York Times, November 12, 2007









Comments (7)
I have not seen any recognition, either from the Smithsonian editorial staff or from readers, regarding the contradiction between the substance of the Koval article in the May 2009 issue and the introductory remarks preceding it. There is not even a hint that this revealing testimony throws a new light on the prosecution and execution of Julius and Ethel Rosenberg, as well as the reputations of others mentioned in the introductory passages such as Harry Dexter White. For documentation I can refer you to the new book "Exoneration" by Emily and David Alman. To clarify the record, I would suggest that the Smithsonian review in detail this very factual book.
Please let me know if you will consider this favorably.
Sincerely Yours,
Lionel Davis
Posted by Lionel Davis on August 12,2010 | 01:46 PM
the question that iam wondering is: how did koval even survive in Russia at the time of Stalin?
Posted by Elias on June 2,2010 | 07:28 PM
Harry Dexter White was identified as a Soviet agent by both Whittaker Chambers and Elizabeth Bentley, acting independently. His hearing before HUAC may have convinced some of his biographers that he was not entirely culpable but the full transcripts reveal a man who was badly tripped up by Karl Mundt and Richard Nixon, unfashionable as that may be to mention. He gave him famous "American creed" speech before Chief Investigator Robert Stripling showed him a photograph of Whittaker Chambers, his courier to the Soviets, whom White had known only as "Carl." At that point White started to fall apart at the hearing. He suffered a "heart attack" on the train back home. White posed as an observant Jew, taught Jewish religious classes and received a Jewish funeral but his body was cremated after his "heart attack" -- and devout Jews don't cremate their dead. Does that strike anybody as odd?
Posted by John Koster on January 30,2010 | 12:50 PM
Sioux City Central High School is not made out of red brick, but, rather is constructed of brownish-pink Lake Superior sandstone (Sioux Falls granite. It really does resemble a castle and it really is on a hill.
Posted by Lucinda Keller Mahmoud on August 7,2009 | 07:41 PM
I feel there is something missing here. Who was instrumental in transferring Mr Koval to these various posts within our atomic program? Seems mighty handy to be placed in one of the few positions which allowed him to do his spying time after time.
Posted by s.orvik on May 14,2009 | 10:57 PM
Comments on the Comments:
2. Bill Getz (hi, Bill!) refers to the "much-maligned Senator Joe McCarthy" having reason for his passion against Communists in the government. Passion there was, but enough of his accusations were misdirected that, in response to his bullying tactics, he provided enough ammunition to both the political Left and moderates that their "blow-back" counter-attacks (e.g., by Edward R. Murrow and Army attorney Joseph Welch, inter alia) discredited serious anti-communist efforts for the next several decades.
Two quotes from Romerstein & Breindel’s “The Venona Secrets: Exposing Soviet Espionage and America’s Traitors” (2000; i.e., after access to Soviet-era archives):
P. 451: “One of the most interesting aspects of the new documentary evidence of Soviet intelligence activities in the United States is that it demonstrates to what a very great degree Senator Joseph R. McCarthy was, in fact, irrelevant to the anti-Communist cause.… Ultimately, the attacks on McCarthy did substantial damage to the cause he championed.”
P. 454: “Some of the McCarthy Committee’s probes produced important and damning information,… But the far more knowledgeable and competent House Committee on Un-American Activities … and the Senate Subcommittee on Internal Security … — McCarthy played no role in either — produced an immense body of evidence, collected at hearings and set down in reports. The printed hearings of these two committees remain an invaluable resource, particularly in the continuing efforts to place new revelations in perspective.”*
*In fairness, it should be noted that the Secret reports of McCarthy’s subcommittee were declassified 50 years later, in 2003. It has been my long-term goal to compare the names of those accused by McCarthy’s committee with the documented spies and traitors listed in R&B’s index, but free time has been lacking; xin loi. (JM)
Posted by Jonathan Myer on May 10,2009 | 06:07 AM
Comments on the Comments: 1. Scott Croly reminds us that, whatever may be said about the Soviets, "in the end, they were with us in WWII." Historical facts provide a more nuanced view of who was with whom, and why. First, on August 23, 1939, a bare week before WWII officially began in Europe, Nazi Germany signed a non-aggression pact with the Communist USSR known as the Ribbentrop-Molotov Pact (named for their respective foreign ministers, who signed it in Moscow). This pact assured Hitler of a free hand in Western Europe while reassuring Stalin with both peace and the vision of a Poland divided between them. British cartoonist David Lowe's famous cartoon of the day showed Hitler and Stalin bowing to each other with the greetings: "Bloody assassin of the workers, I presume?" and "Scum of the earth, I believe?" Hitler, as we know, had his own plans, and in December 1940 launched a full-scale attack against an unready Soviet Union (and shocked Stalin) known as Operation Barbarossa. When the U.S. entered the war a year later (after our "Pearl Harbor"), it was in both the U.S.-British and Soviet interests to keep the USSR in the war, despite our antithetical ideologies. Thus, sheer pragmatism, rather than any "hands-across-the-sea" friendship, sustained the Alliance, although to assure popular support at home (especially in light of the sacrifices that resupplying Russia entailed), the USSR was then publicly portrayed as a vital ally in our common struggle against the Axis powers. (The current PBS TV documentary, "World War II: Behind Closed Doors: Stalin, the Nazis and the West" reveals more of Stalin's viewpoint during this time, culled from Soviet archives during the past dozen-odd years.)
Posted by Jonathan Myer on May 10,2009 | 05:09 AM
Enjoyed Michael Walsh's interesting article about the spy, George Koval (Iowa-Born, Soviet Trained, 'Smithsonian," May 2009). What wasn't mentioned was a contemporary of Koval's, a brilliant young physicist by the name of Ted Hall, code-name "Mlad." Ted was at Los Alamos concurrently with the time of Koval's misadventures. His name appeared in an earlier Smithsonian article, "Spies Who Spilled Atomic Bomb Secrets." Although he was known to the CIA and FBI, Ted Hall managed to elude incarceration, and eventually "escaped" to Russia (still a mystery). Even more mystifying was the part played by his older brother, Air Force Colonel Ed Hall, also brilliant and one of the leading experts on missile propulsion. I knew Ed Hall in the Air Force's missiles program, and he had a very strange personality and demeanor clearly recognized by his associates and bosses, Colonel (later Lt. General) Charles Terhune, and Brigadier General (later four star general) Bernard A. Schriever, my direct boss. The Hall brothers' parents were Barney and Rose Holtzberg of New York City. Julius Rosenberg was a classmate of Colonel Ed Hall at the City College of New York. The City and College in the mid-1930s "were hotbeds of Depression-spawned Marxist activism." Whether Ed Hall was complicit in or at least knowledgeable of his brother's espionage is still a subject of debate. Their activities came to public light with the publication of the "Venona Transcripts" in 1996. The full story up to 2004 was well-described in an amazing book written by ex-Secretary of the Air Force, Thomas C. Reed, At The Abyss; An Insider's History Of The Cold War, (Random House Publishing Group, New York, 2004) from which the details above derived. The much-maligned Senator Joe McCarthy had reason for his passion against Communists in the government.
Posted by Bill Getz on May 6,2009 | 02:45 PM
John Taber. Thank you for all that detailed and important information and observations. Much appreciated,
Posted by Don Noyes-More on April 24,2009 | 08:47 PM
You can say what you want about Russia, the Soviets, or whoever else, but remember this: in the end, they were with us in WWII. Personally, I am half of them through my mother (my great grandparents came here) and they saved the other half (my father, a veteran) during WWII. They were there for all of us when it counted. I shall never forget. They are an incredible group of people, a macro-communal society (as are we, by the way) encompassing diverse ideas, people and territory with the seminal gifts of music, mathematics, chess, physics, and the dogged determination to maintain forward, principally as expedited through their DOD. Furthermore, they made it from the horse and buggy in 1917 to Sputnik in 1957 in forty years, one and a half generations; the CIA still studies this amazing feat. They are potential and indispensible allies in the current state of world affairs forward.
Posted by Scott Croly on April 24,2009 | 06:27 PM
This will be a movie soon
Posted by Ken Fenslage on April 24,2009 | 05:39 PM
This IS (mmmmmm)very Interesting.
Posted by Tanikki on April 24,2009 | 02:33 PM
Two complaints:
1. Lumping Harry Dexter White with the atomic spies misleads the reader to the false conclusion that White betrayed atomic secrets to the Soviets. There is no evidence of that, not even in Herbert Romerstein's account.
Further, some historians do not accept that White was a Soviet agent. See James Boughton and Roger Sandiland. I too am not convinced. There is one VENONA cable that implies that White, under the covername RICHARD, was a journalist or PR person. This cable has the NSA footnote pointing out this discrepancy. The NSA footnote does not exculpate White because in this instance it is possible that RICHARD was somebody else as yet unidentified. The Soviet agencies changed covernames, and were sometimes inconsistent.
My point is, the VENONA decrypts alone are not sufficient to inculpate White.
My second objection is to your unresearched claim that the decrypted cables had to be kept secret so as not to jeopardize the code breaking.
No.
The Soviets already knew we were reading their cables. They had been informed by Philby, MacLean, and the code breaker Weissband who kept checking on Meredith Gardner's progress (the latter is claimed as the principle code breaker).
Second, the cables were not evidence acceptable to a court. There is a memo from Alan Belmont, third in command at the FBI, that advised not to use the cables in court because they would be hearsay. Belmont explains exceptions to the hearsay rule under which the cables could have been used, but that would open up counter attacks to the defense. There were too many gaps in the decrypts, too many guesses, too many uncertainties as to what the cables really said or meant. I do not mean this as an insult to the NSA - cryptanalysis is a trial and error process, and the decrypts were too early in that process.
In a magazine of your importance, you must do more fact checking and research than I would expect from the National Enquirer.
Posted by John K. Taber on April 22,2009 | 08:47 AM
Wow that is pretty amazing dude!
RT
www.privacy.pro.tc
Posted by Jason Wright on April 21,2009 | 02:24 PM