Donovan Webster spent 18 months, on and off, investigating the growing problem of dinosaur prospecting—private citizens digging up dinosaur bones and other fossils to sell them—which has paleontologists in an uproar and the legal system in a tizzy ("The Dino Wars,"). It would seem obvious that if a fossil "is significant, it should be in a museum," Webster says, but he discovered that laws about digging vary from jurisdiction to jurisdiction, and "are so carved up depending on where you find the thing"—on public or private land—"even the paleontologists can't agree on what it is we need to protect the significant fossils." The case Webster tracks, which involves a rare juvenile Tyrannosaurus rex skeleton first thought to be on private land but later determined to be on county property, exemplifies the complexities. "At some point we are going to have to have a national dialogue about these questions," says Webster. "These fossils belong to all of us. Somebody's making private money off them. What should we do about it?"
"History isn't always portrayed accurately," says Bruce Henderson, author of True North: Peary, Cook, and the Race to the Pole, from which he adapted "Cook vs. Peary". "History books and encyclopedias have long said that Robert Peary discovered the North Pole, in 1909. Guess what? The claim of Frederick Cook to have gotten there a year before Peary is every bit as strong, and in some ways stronger, because Cook was the first to come out with original descriptions of the pole, before Peary would release his own descriptions. And this was at a time when people didn't know if there was land up there or even a lost civilization. Cook described the pole in a way that was verified by all the people who came after him. That's an amazing thing. So just because it's reported to be history doesn't make it right." For his book on the pair, Henderson spent nearly two years doing research at the National Archives, the Library of Congress and the Byrd Polar Research Center at Ohio State University, reading the explorers' letters and journals as well as a host of related documents. "There's going to be a lot of stories about the centennial of the discovery of the North Pole by Robert Peary. I'd love for readers to know, wait a minute, maybe another guy got there first. Maybe this is actually the 101st anniversary of the discovery. How is it that the forces around Peary completely overwhelmed Dr. Cook? How is it that Cook has basically dropped out of our history books?"
Subscribe now for more of Smithsonian's coverage on history, science and nature.
Comments (1)
It is a shame that pre-history and history gets destroyed because someone makes rules that are hard or too expensive to follow. I have done field work in Kansas and New York and the people are the same. They feel that if they own the land that any artifacts they find belong to them. No one should pilfer public lands. Many Native Americans also make claims on their old tribal lands. It should not matter who owns the artifacts but a mechanism needs to be in place to document the recovery and help get museum grade items where they belong with credit and renumeration made to the true owners. I am sure the lawyers and courts will want their pound of flesh so the problems will continue. I love the magazine, keep raising the issues and maybe some day we will solve the problems.
Posted by Albert Mignone on March 29,2009 | 05:04 PM