Saving the Jews of Nazi France
As Jews in France tried to flee the Nazi occupation, Harry Bingham, an American diplomat, sped them to safety
- By Peter Eisner
- Smithsonian magazine, March 2009, Subscribe
(Page 3 of 5)
Bingham's boss in Marseille, Consul General Hugh Fullerton, advised Fry to leave the country. Fry declined. For his part, Bingham surreptitiously broadened his work with Fry—setting him up, for example, with a police captain who was sympathetic to escape operations. The vice consul "had no hesitation to work with Fry," says Pierre Sauvage, a filmmaker who is gathering material for a documentary on Fry's work in Marseille. "If Bingham could find a way of bending the rules, of being accommodating to somebody who wanted to get out, he did that."
Through the summer of 1940, Bingham also gave secret shelter to Heinrich Mann, brother of novelist Thomas Mann; the novelist's son, Golo, also left Europe with Bingham's help. Both "have repeatedly spoken to me about your exceptional kindness and incalculable help to them in their recent need and danger," Thomas Mann wrote Bingham on October 27, 1940. "My feeling of indebtedness and gratitude to you is very great."
Bingham also visited Marc Chagall, a Jew, at Chagall's home in the Provençal village of Gordes and persuaded him to accept a visa and flee to the United States; their friendship continued for the rest of their lives. At the consulate, Bingham continued to issue visas and travel papers, which in many cases replaced confiscated passports. Fred Buch, an engineer from Austria, received an exit visa and temporary travel documents; he left Marseille with his wife and two children and settled in California. "God, it was such a relief," Buch told Sauvage in a 1997 interview. "Such a sweet voice. You felt so safe there in the consulate when he was there. You felt a new life will start." Bingham "looked like an angel, only without wings," Buch added. "The angel of liberation."
State Department files show that Bingham issued dozens of visas daily, and many other elements of his work—sheltering refugees, writing travel papers, meeting with escape groups—were not always recorded. "My father had to keep what he was doing secret, but I think people suspected it," says William Bingham. "From his perspective, what he was doing by defying the direct orders [of his own government] was complying with international law."
Bingham's next act, however, was even more provocative: with winter approaching, he began pressing for U.S. support for relief efforts at the detention camps around Marseille.
In 1940, there were about two dozen such camps in Vichy France, many of them having been originally set up in the 1930s for émigrés from Spain during the Spanish Civil War. Even before the Nazis took Paris that June, French authorities ordered European foreigners to report for internment on the ground that the criminals, spies and anti-government operatives among them had to be weeded out. From November 27 to December 1, Bingham visited camps at Gurs, Le Vernet, Argelès-sur-Mer, Agde and Les Milles, accompanied by an official who was coordinating the work of 20 international relief organizations in Marseille.
French authorities actually welcomed such relief missions, because local officials lacked the infrastructure and supplies to care for the inmates adequately. In a report Bingham wrote of his travels, he cited "immigration problems" as the reason for his trip, but his account portrays a gathering tragedy for the 46,000 camp inmates. Gurs, one of the largest camps, he wrote, held about 14,000 people, including 5,000 women and 1,000 children, and many of the detainees were diseased, malnourished or badly housed. Three hundred inmates had died there in November, 150 in the first ten days of December. "When the shortage of food becomes more acute, the camps may be used as centers of unrest," Bingham wrote. "Resulting riots may be used if desired as an excuse for intervention and military occupation of the whole of France."
When Bingham's report was forwarded to Secretary of State Hull on December 20, 1940, it was preceded by a caveat from Bingham's boss, Consul General Fullerton: "Mr. Bingham's trip to the camps was in nowise official and under instructions from the Department of State," Fullerton had written. "It was, in fact, made at his own expense."
In Washington, immigration policy remained unchanged. Later that month, Eleanor Roosevelt wrote to the State Department to ask what could be done about France's refugee crisis; she may not have seen Bingham's report, but she was still in close communication with the Emergency Rescue Committee. On January 10, Undersecretary of State Sumner Welles blamed the French: "The French government has been unwilling or has failed to grant the required exit permits with the consequence that these persons have not been able to proceed to the United States and remain on French territory where they must be cared for and fed," he wrote, then added pointedly: "I believe, despite some critics who are not aware of the facts, the machinery we have set up to deal with the emergency refugee problem is functioning effectively and well."
But Bingham, despite the State Department's reluctance, continued to work with relief organizations outside the government. With his help, Martha Sharp of the Unitarian Service Committee and others assembled 32 refugees, including 25 children, and got them onto a ship that arrived in New York, on December 23.
Robert C. Dexter, a director of the Boston-based committee, wrote to Hull to commend "the sympathetic and understanding way in which Vice-Consul Hiram Bingham, Jr. carried out his responsibilities at the consulate....Mrs. Sharp reports that his whole conduct made other Americans proud of the way he represents their government to foreigners coming before him for assistance."
Single Page « Previous 1 2 3 4 5 Next »
Subscribe now for more of Smithsonian's coverage on history, science and nature.









Comments (16)
I am a direct decendant of Hiram Bingham. I never met him and neither did my Mother, Grace Marie Bingham, but we are just as proud to be in his family as anyone.
Posted by MItchell C. Hale on November 13,2011 | 08:00 PM
http://hiram7.wordpress.com/2010/03/07/unsung-hero-of-world-war-ii-hiram-bingham-iv/
Posted by David Berger on January 15,2011 | 03:09 PM
I'm a teacher in Kansas and have students who are working on a playlet concerning Hiram Bingham Jr. We all are inspired by his incredibly courageous work in the WWII. My students are trying to contact his children or grandchildren, can anyone help with email addresses.
thanks so much,
Lowell Milken Education Center
Fort Scott, KS.
Norm Conard
Posted by Norm Conard on December 16,2010 | 01:10 PM
The Bingham's are the backbone of this nation. We need the righteous and their deeds for our example. Thank you, sir, for your service and your example. /We honor your righteous memory.
In a time of universal deceit, telling the truth is a revolutionary act. - George Orwell
Posted by MissClarity on June 25,2010 | 01:40 PM
I am just writing to say that I grew up in Salem, CT where the name of the Bingham's was as well known to us as our own. It was not until years later when I was sitting in the very same 18th century farm house mentioned above, that I heard of Hiram Bingham IV's heroic actions. I was so touched to know of the impact he had had on saving so many Jews. These words that I write are to honor his memory, and to say thank you to his family for having shared his story with us on that day. The Bible says that those who bless and honor his people the Jews, shall be themselves blessed and honored.
Posted by Dawn Labbe Jouan on March 30,2010 | 10:10 PM
How beautiful a life that a man though faced with great pressure to conform to the evil attitudes of his time chose instead to do what he knew was right. More than anything, this article presents to me a truth: that although there may be an opinion and a protocol embraced by the majority of society on a particular subject, in the end, it may very well prove to be grossly in error. He was not acknowledged as a hero in his time, but instead proved to be one of those of whom the world is not worthy. I'm very thankful to know the story of Hiram Bingham.
Posted by April Cook on February 2,2010 | 03:51 AM
QUOTE.."A great article. Im writing a report on him and this was verry helpful but im having trouble finding his motivations to do such a task. If anyone knows, could they clear it up with me.Thanks" I am sorry that this writer is having trouble finding Mr. Bingham's movivations to do such a task...?? God bless this wonderful man's memory..to quote our Saviour.." such as you do to the least of these...you do unto me.."
Posted by Ann on February 1,2010 | 02:20 AM
My Grandfather Hiram Bingham's entire life was devoted to doing the right thing at any cost as he even financed much of what he did for others...
Including me...
When I was 14 He and Rose Bingham took me under their wing even though they had little money left to do so...
They taught me so much...
Here's to Hiram and Rose!!!
Posted by Alexander Tucker on November 16,2009 | 01:49 PM
A great article. Im writing a report on him and this was verry helpful but im having trouble finding his motivations to do such a task. If anyone knows, could they clear it up with me.Thanks!
Posted by chris chevalier on May 27,2009 | 08:31 PM
I am a graduate student in history at American University in Washington, and did research and wrote about the subject of American relief organizations in Vichy France. I met Mr. Eisner over the holidays at a party of a mutual friend and we spoke at great length. When I first saw Peter's article in Smithsonian I thought he might have "borrowed" some of my ideas. Not true. Eisner started his research earlier, and followed different lines of inquiry. He even interviewed my former professor (Breitman)during his research. Breitman helped point me in the direction of my research, and knew all along of the overlap in inquiries. Even though both Peter and I met Bingham's daughter (living here in the DC area)during our research - that was the first I herad of Harry Bingham. Breitman never could have predicted that Peter and I would meet at a holiday party. C'est la vie.
Posted by Scott Blair on April 4,2009 | 07:53 PM
Kudos to Peter Eisner for his exceptional article and for getting the story right.
I would like to just note a few things for clarity and since much of this article came from my interviews with Mr. Eisner and my research on my father for a book and film project I want to be sure the record is straight (as things on the internet live on forever).
First, It was Thomas (Golo) Mann Jr. who hid at my father's home (not Heinrich, the brother of Thomas Mann Sr.) while Feuchtwanger was hidden there. Feuchtwanger was disguised as a woman and spirited away from his concentration camp in my father's car with the help of another consul Myles Standish.
Rescuer/journalist Varian Fry was put in contact with my father by a US labor representative (Frank Bohn) who was collaborating with the resistance and my father become a strategic planner in this resistance operation and the underground railroad which rescued perhaps several thousand people (Jews and others, mostly antiNazi intellectuals and activists, but sommon folk who were endangered as well). This network included Andre Breton, the antiStalin Trotskyite Victor Serge, members of the antiNazi and Jewish resistance (including the head of Jewish rescue organization Hicem named Dijours), Social Democrat Fritz Heine, and a French surete official.
It was this network who helped Hannah Arend, Marc Chagall and many others to get out. I know of no evidence that my father helped Arendt directly (he may have).My father was introduced to Jewish resistance leaders by Chagall himself. Dad helped also Jean Moulin (Martel aka "Max"), the French Resistance leader later tortured to death by the Nazi Klaus Barbie, the Butcher of Lyons, and Rabbi Zalman Schachter Shalomi, who became the "Wisdom Chair" at the Naropa Institute and is featured in the film "The Jew in the Lotus" about a spiritual journey to meet the Dalai Lama.
I would welcome inquiries on these subjects at my email address seventhson080754@aol.com
Posted by William Bingham on March 27,2009 | 04:41 PM
It was a most excellent article. I shared it with my study group at church. We were having a lesson on Risk Taking and Hirams actions surely show that. He did what was right in spite of the consequences.
Posted by Carol Wieser on March 14,2009 | 02:53 PM
In reading this story our governments policies make me shudder, that we would turn our backs on the victims of tyrants and then glorifiy these same tyrants later. This makes me feel such shame. These tyrants responsible for horrid and inhuman treatment and extermination of over what 10,000,000 total persons of this earth. There can not be a hell deep enough for those who turned their backs, and no heaven or praise high enough for People of Conscience such as Harry Bingham. Such as He needs to be held high to our children as true heros. But We instead glorify the tyrants of evil. I am reminded of the Ship of Fools incident. All our great patriotic praganda of "Land of the Free and Home of the Brave." taste of ashes after yet another reminder of our government's policy. Rowanda, Darfur, How many more genocides do we sit by watch, with disinterest? There are too few Harry Bingham's in our Capitol Building in Washington DC.
I have lost no one to the Holocaust, nor to any of the genocides since. My family has been here since 1630 in Massachusetts Bay Colony . And the 1600 in the Maryland Colony. But I find my shame for our political stand on Genocide Shameful. Until now, stood proud of my country and our government though I as senior citizen find that our politians give Used Car Salesmen a Bad Name! How do I teach my grandchildren to be proud? Of what a lesser crime than the Tyrant that all claimed they were Never the Tyrant and all were part of the ~~UNDERground~~ FIGHTING THE TYRANTS!! YEAH RIGHT! THEN WHO WERE THE ONES WITH A FINAL SOLUTION?
I was sickened by a recent movie, The Boy in the Stripped Pyjamas.
I felt no compassion for Bruno's family. The screaming mother evoked no sympathy. The sister brought no sense of grief.
Regretfully,
Victoria Hobbs
Posted by Victoria Hobbs on March 13,2009 | 05:25 AM
Hiram Bingham's activities during WWII should serve as a shining example of the value of honoring one's conscience. Not only do the 2,500 human beings he saved owe him a debt of gratitude; his stellar behavior has, and will continue to, save the lives of many, many more in their descendants. The human family at large owes Mr. Bingham a debt of gratitude for modeling for us all this quintessential example of human endeavor: loving our fellow as ourselves.
Posted by Abby on March 12,2009 | 05:42 PM
This would make a great movie. What a generous man. His children have every right to be proud of their father and don't forget his wife. She quietly supported him or he would not have been so successful. This adds to the evidence that FDR and his staff were not supportive of saving the Jews. Read the book "The Ship of Doom".
Posted by Barbara on March 11,2009 | 02:04 PM
As a Connecticut resident it was great to read this piece on Mr. Bingham. While his work as diplomat and the saving of Jews was familiar to me from previous readings it was the mention of him as the designer of the "Sportatron" that brought a smile to my face. As a youngster in East Hartford - where a "Sportatron" still stands under a tarp, I had the chance to play in one for many an hour. My friend's dad, Frank Degregorio, was a teacher in East Hartford and somehow had met up with Mr. Bingham and tried to help him market the product, apparently to no avail. Anyway, Mr. Bingham will be known to history as a brave diplomat who stood up for what he knew was right. While I too will remember him for his great work as a diplomat, I will now also remember him as a man who invented a great big toybox that allowed a little 5'7" white kid to dunk a basketball, something I've not been able to since my last time in the "Sportatron". Here's to those who think outside the box. Peter McCluskey, Glastonbury CT
Posted by Peter McCluskey on March 4,2009 | 01:03 PM
Congratulations on this excellent article of tribute to a very fine son and family of what ethos and culture America has been embodying before the motto "greed is good" came to prevail even as some misguided characters then as Cordell Hull, as in our times, as the Bingham family hymn said, could not "Once to every man and nation, comes the moment to decide.....some great cause, some great decision.....and the choice goes by forever..." How sad that recognition by Yad Vashem preceded by 4 years acknowledement of this great son of America by the Foreign Service Association and the State Department....
Posted by EDWARD LINGURI on March 3,2009 | 02:38 AM
It was a warm-fuzzy pleasure to read the article on "Bingham's List" I first ran across my cousins lives at the memorial chapel dedicated to Hiram Bingham I (Binamu) in Honolulu during the Korean War. Later studies and service led other siblings to Machu Picchu in more recent years. Now to find out about Hiram IV and his courage warms my heart. Hurray for cousin Harry and his family! Frank G Bingham, 6th cousin, three times removed.
Posted by Frank G Bingham on February 26,2009 | 12:09 AM