Letters
Readers Respond to the November Issue
- By Smithsonian magazine
- Smithsonian magazine, January 2008, Subscribe
David Halberstam ("Command Performance") was obviously an admirer of Gen. Matthew B. Ridgway and had little regard for Gen. Douglas MacArthur. Korea was one of our political wars. Generals did not fight it—politicians did. I was there—a 19-year-old airman—and understood how politicians were tying MacArthur's hands behind his back and telling him to fight a war he couldn't win.
Robert Hill,
La Veta, Colorado
Ridgway's Due
Halberstam's article about Ridgway's turnaround of the Korean War was long overdue. For too many years all the credit (and none of the blame) went to Douglas MacArthur, by far the most overrated Army commander since McClellan.
William F. Mahoney
Albany, New York
I was deeply pleased to see the article about General Ridgway. He was indeed a soldier's general. He treated his soldiers with a fatherly affection and respect, but was never patronizing. We knew this was the highest commander we were ever likely to converse with, but we were inspired and encouraged, not intimidated. I met him on a cold winter day in Seoul, when he arrived to replace the late Lt. Gen. Walton H. Walker as commander of the Eighth Army. Ridgway was wearing his trademark grenade and carrying an M-1 rifle. He walked up to me, a private first class, extended a hand and said, "Name's Ridgway. What's yours?" I told him my name, and the next time I saw him he remembered it. I could relate several anecdotes reflecting his fiery dedication to his mission and his unswerving care for the morale and welfare of his troops as individuals.
William J. Opferman
Sacramento, California
Other Gates to Paradise
Arthur Lubow's article on sculptor Lorenzo Ghiberti's gilded doors ("The Gates of Paradise") did not point out that the original doors, which stood at the ancient Baptistery of San Giovanni in Florence, were removed and hidden in a railway tunnel for safekeeping during World War II. After the war, Bruno Bearzi, official caretaker of Florence's artworks, made a mold of the doors. Three replicas have been produced from the mold: one was sold to San Francisco's Grace Cathedral, another went to the Trinity Lutheran Church in Hicksville, New York, and the third replaced the original doors at the Florence Baptistery, which will reside in the nearby Duomo museum (after the doors are reunited with their gilt decorative panels next year).
Jere French
Gulf Breeze, Florida
Save the Corn
Richard Conniff's article about the trade-offs of ethanol and other biofuels ("Who's Fueling Whom?") mentioned the possibility of converting cornstalks into engine fuels. Please keep in mind that this approach, too, has a downside. Cornstalks are needed for long-term soil protection against wind and water erosion and for their organic matter, which maintains soil quality. Uprooting them is unfathomable in this era of knowledgeable agriculture.
John E. Morrison
Unicoi, Tennessee
Against Innovation
I hope my not being enamored of your special issue (37 Under 36: America's Young Innovators) doesn't make me a boorish oaf, but I suggest you mail it instead to the friends and relatives of those who appeared in the issue, not to subscribers who are looking for interesting reading.
John Kerhlikar
Shingle Springs, California
After years of negative news stories about poverty, violence, greed, corrupt politicians and our failed educational system, I had almost begun a free fall into the pits of cynicism. Reading your special issue about young innovators reassured me there is a great future ahead for us.
Benjamin J. Legett
Covington, Louisiana
Subscribe now for more of Smithsonian's coverage on history, science and nature.
Comments (3)
Found you through seeking for travels. Many interesting travels I will come back to that. But I see you work with a lot of things. I should like to know if you know something about the Historical Musee in Bagdad. Is all gone, or? Faithfully Turid (from Norway)
Posted by Turid M. Dankertsen on July 20,2008 | 02:57 PM
Today I received my first issue of my new subscription to Smithsonian, and already I’ve learned things I never new. I learned that scientists have stopped light at near absolute zero (“The Coldest Place in the Universe," Jan 08). Even more surprising, the graphic on page 21 told me that the boiling point of water is not 212 degrees, as I was always taught. Now Smithsonian tells me that the boiling point is 220 degrees! Who knew?
Posted by Mike Mitchell on January 22,2008 | 08:49 PM
Today I received my first issue of my new subscription to Smithsonian, and already I’ve learned things I never new. I learned that scientists have stopped light at near absolute zero (“The Coldest Place in the Universe," Jan 08). Even more surprising, the graphic on page 21 told me that the boiling point of water is not 212 degrees, as I was always taught. Now Smithsonian tells me that the boiling point is 220 degrees! Who knew?
Posted by Mike Mitchell on January 22,2008 | 08:49 PM
RE: January Issue/THE LAST PAGE by Kathleen Flinn Being an avid Julia Child fan since the 50's I never missed opportunity to watch her programs. I found them informative, interesting, and yes, amusing. Ms. Flinn states in her article that the story of the Chicken flying from the roasting pan is not true. I do not know if it is or not. However, I do clearly recall the incident of the couchon de lait (roast suckling pig) she had prepared for roasting flying across the kitchen to smack and slide on the floor as she had abruptly turned after lifting. This was in the late 50's or early 60's. I was just a teenager with an interest in food preparation at the time. Julia, never missing a beat, she stepped to the pig, plucked it from the floor, turned to the camera, and uttered these words, "I am going to do exactly as you would if this occurred in your home." She walked to the sink, rinsed off the piglet and plopped it back on the roasting sheet, lightly and quickly seasoned it then over to the over. After that, she never referred to the incident again. What class under fire. I was rolling on the floor. The above is absolutely true, I viewed it in black and white and Julia was at her best. Bernard McIntyre Hot Springs Village, Arkansas
Posted by Bernard McIntyre on December 25,2007 | 07:21 PM