Why is Rem Koolhaas the World's Most Controversial Architect?
Age has not tempered the Dutch architect, who at 67 continues to shake up the cultural landscape with his provocative designs
- By Nicolai Ouroussoff
- Smithsonian magazine, September 2012, Subscribe
(Page 4 of 5)
At the same time, his urban work has begun to seem increasingly quixotic. In a 2001 development plan for Harvard University, which was expanding across the Charles River into nearby Allston, Koolhaas proposed diverting the path of the river several miles to create a more unified campus. The idea seemed preposterous, and Harvard’s board quickly rejected it, but it carried a hidden message: America’s astonishing growth during the first three-quarters of the 20th century was built largely on the hubris of its engineers. (Think of the Los Angeles depicted in Roman Polanski’s Chinatown, a city that diverted water across 250 miles of desert to feed the growth of the San Fernando Valley.) Why, Koolhaas seemed to be asking, aren’t such miracles possible today?
In a 2008 competition for a site off the coast of Dubai, Koolhaas went out on another limb, proposing a development that resembled a fragment of Manhattan that had drifted across the Atlantic and lodged itself in the Persian Gulf—a kind of “authentic” urban zone made up of generic city blocks that would serve as a foil to Dubai’s fake glitz.
His most convincing answer to the vices of global urbanization was a proposal for the West Kowloon Cultural District, a sprawling 99-acre cultural and residential development to be built on landfill on a site overlooking Hong Kong Harbor. Koolhaas traveled to Hong Kong every month for more than a year to work on the project, often wandering up into the surrounding mountains. Inspired by the migrant dwellings and rural marshlands that he found there, he proposed three “urban villages” arranged along a spacious public park. The idea was to create a social mixing bowl for people of different cultural, ethnic and class backgrounds. “In spite of its metropolitan character Hong Kong is surrounded by countryside,” Koolhaas said. “We felt that we’d discovered a really wonderful prototype. The villages were not only a very beautiful urban model, but they would be sustainable.”
The experience ended in disappointment. After more than a year of work on the proposal, Koolhaas lost to Norman Foster, whose projects are known for high-tech luster.
More troubling perhaps to Koolhaas, the architectural climate has become more conservative, and hence more resistant to experimental work. (Witness the recent success of architects like David Chipperfield, whose minimalist aesthetic has been praised for its comforting simplicity.)
As someone who has worked closely with Koolhaas put it to me: “I don’t think Rem always understands how threatening his projects are. The idea of proposing to construct villages in urban Hong Kong is very scary for the Chinese—it is exactly what they are running away from.”
Yet Koolhaas has always sought to locate the beauty in places that others might regard as so much urban debris, and by doing so he seems to be encouraging us to remain more open to the other. His ideal city, to borrow words he once used to describe the West Kowloon project, seems to be a place that is “all things to all people.”
His faith in that vision doesn’t seem to have cooled any. One of his newest projects, a performing arts center under construction in Taipei, fuses the enigmatic qualities of CCTV with the bluntness of the Wyly Theatre. And he continues to pursue urban planning projects: Sources in the architecture community say he recently won a competition to design a sprawling airport development in Doha, Qatar (the results have not been made public). If it is built, it’ll become his first major urban project since Euralille.
Single Page « Previous 1 2 3 4 5 Next »
Subscribe now for more of Smithsonian's coverage on history, science and nature.









Comments (4)
With the Smithsonian's possible kind forbearance, I wanted to make a second comment related to Mr. Koolhaas. It may be somewhat understandable that a person throbbing with artistic sensibility would look at a sprawling third-world mega-city like Lagos, Nigeria and see it not as dysfunctional, but as colorfully thrivingly vibrantly alive, when what they are more likely seeing is a violent corrupt polluted incredibly overpopulated desperately poor human anthill, whose hustle and bustle is probably better explained by everyone understandably scrambling to sell or trade everything not nailed down in order to survive.
Posted by Thomas Michael Andres on October 8,2012 | 11:45 PM
"What was once called the public realm has become a place of frenzied consumerism monitored by the watchful eyes of thousands of surveillance cameras" Sounds like a good description of globalism itself.
Posted by Thomas Michael Andres on October 4,2012 | 11:35 PM
At least his design of the new Rothschild bank in the City of London is totally uninspiring. A pile of dull rectangular shapes. Suites well as an illustration for 'The Wall' by Roger Waters but is incompatible with the City, where you can hardly find a single straight line. This design could have been suitable for Canary Wharf but would have been lost there among much more interesting solutions. A revolution that ends up in boredom...
Posted by Mikhail on September 24,2012 | 11:42 AM
Why is Rem Koolhaas the most controversial architect in the world? Becasue he tries hard to be controversial. It's the old art school ploy to baffle them with b.s. Where as we once admired artists for thier skill and on the side they happened to be "quirky", now we admire artists becasue there work seems quirky, while they themselves are polished snake oil salesmen. Like the author who bends over backwards to praise the plywood and fake leather building in Lille France, while calling the refurbished center of Lille disneyland. Unbelievable that the most sustainable act of preservation of a humanscaled and non toxic environment is derided as disney, especially from an institution as noble as the Smithsonian Institution.
Posted by Daniel Morales on August 28,2012 | 09:02 PM