Food Like You've Never Seen Before
Molecular gastronomist Nathan Myhrvold creates culinary oddities and explores food science in his groundbreaking new anthology
- By Jerry Adler
- Smithsonian magazine, June 2011, Subscribe
(Page 3 of 3)
And then Myhrvold got interested in gels, foams and spheres, to which modernist chefs have a deep, inexplicable attachment. Among the substances that Myhrvold recommends spherifying are melon juice, capers, mussels, Gruyère cheese and olives. To someone not steeped in the modernist aesthetic, it may not be obvious why you should purée a batch of olives and follow a 20-step recipe calling for xanthan gum and sodium alginate to produce essentially what you started with, a round object that tastes like an olive.
To find out would involve a trip to El Bulli, but the restaurant received around two million requests last year for dinner at one of its 15 tables, and it’s scheduled to close permanently next month anyway, so you might want to try the instructions in Myhrvold’s book. If you own an industrial centrifuge and don’t mind leaving the kitchen for an hour while it runs, in case it flies apart with the force of a small bomb, you can see what comes out when you spin frozen green peas at 40,000 times Earth’s gravitational force. You will find a starchy gray-green sludge at the bottom, clear pea-juice on top, and between them a thin layer of a rich, buttery, brilliantly green pea-flavored substance that can be spread on a cracker to make a fine canapé. And the next thing you know, you’re boiling grated Parmesan cheese and water and pressing it out through a sieve and squirting it into plastic tubing to make Parmesan noodles. If you’re really committed to modernism, you could freeze-dry pasta and grate it on top.
It may have occurred to you that this kind of cooking runs exactly counter to the other dominant trend in dining, the quest for authenticity, traditional preparations and local ingredients that sometimes goes by the name “slow food.” Among its most eloquent advocates is the author Michael Pollan (In Defense of Food), whose motto is “don’t eat anything your great-grandmother wouldn’t recognize as food.” Yet even Pollan was won over by his lunch at the Food Lab, pronouncing the sous-vide short-rib pastrami, a signature dish, “pretty incredible. It’s a realm of experimentation, of avant-garde art. There’s art I find incredibly stimulating, but I wouldn’t necessarily want it on my living-room wall.” For his part, Myhrvold regards Pollan with mild condescension, implying that he has failed to think through his own philosophy. “If everyone had followed his rule about great-grandmothers, recursively back into history, nobody would ever have tried anything new,” Myhrvold says. “Many of the things the slow food people honor were innovations within historical times. Somebody had to be the first European to eat a tomato.”
Yes, and somebody had to be the first person to make a six-foot-long Parmesan noodle, and since I had obtained one of the first copies of Myhrvold’s book, I thought it should be me. I would accompany the noodle dish, I decided, with Myhrvold’s recipe for spherified tomato water with basil oil. In the photographs, these were shimmering, transparent spheres, each trapping within it a bright-green globe of liquid pesto. I could hardly wait to try one.
Right off the bat, though, I faced my limitations as a home cook. Lacking a centrifuge to produce the colorless tomato-flavored liquid the recipe demands, I had to rely on the relatively crude technique of vacuum filtration. Not that I had a machine for that either, but I managed to improvise one with a medical suction device and a coffee filter, which produced, at the rate of about three droplets a minute, a small quantity of slightly cloudy, rose-colored liquid. Also, the brand of agar Myhrvold specifies for the noodles sells for as much as $108 for half a kilogram, which seemed extravagant since the recipe called for only 2.1 grams. Even that amount would make 90 linear feet of noodle. I cut the recipe by three-quarters, and in the process of pouring the mixtures in and out of saucepans and measuring cups, straining and sieving, an awful lot got left behind. In the end I managed to fill just one and a half six-foot lengths of quarter-inch-diameter plastic tubing, which had to be submerged in ice water for two minutes and quickly attached by one end to a soda siphon. Then with one quick burst of carbon dioxide the contents came shooting out in glorious, shimmering heaps that served six people, as long as they were content with three mouthfuls each. I considered this a triumph, especially compared with the tomato spheres, which turned into shapeless, drippy blobs that fell apart as soon as I dunked them in the three bowls of ice water specified by Myhrvold’s recipe.
But everyone was complimentary, and I’m pleased to have played my part in this great culinary revolution. Adrià himself would have understood my impulse to then boil up a large pot of spaghetti and defrost a container of marinara sauce that had been in the freezer since August. As his biographer, Colman Andrews, reports, when Adrià goes out to eat, his favorite meal is fried calamari, sauteed cuttlefish with garlic and parsley, and rice with seafood. In other words, he eats what his great-grandmother would recognize.
Jerry Adler last wrote for Smithsonian about Depression-era art. He says he eats whatever is put in front of him.
Subscribe now for more of Smithsonian's coverage on history, science and nature.









Comments (9)
ssssssssssssssooooooooooooo cool
Posted by on June 25,2012 | 09:33 AM
"The delicious aroma of stock simmering on the stove that is the desideratum of home cooks? A total waste of flavor molecules, dissipating in the air instead of concentrating in the pot; his experimental kitchen is as odorless as a sterile flask"
As I read these words in Jerry Adler's "Extreme Cuisine" I was in fact simmering a pot of stock. My whole house smelled of thyme and onions all afternoon and into the night, giving me, and my neighbors, a sense of comfort and well-being. And the result didn't taste as if too many flavor molecules had dissipated.
I fear that experimenters like Ferran Adria and Nathan Myhrvold may put such emphasis on innovation and surprise that they lose sight of the reasons most people enjoy eating.
Posted by Dale Hill on July 14,2011 | 11:24 AM
Give me authentic French country cooking, please!!!!
Posted by Pete on July 12,2011 | 11:35 PM
"New York City’s Institute of Culinary Education." Yes, indeed, the hamburger nation obviously needs one of those. On the other hand, I thought the article was about food. Then I get: "Nathan Myhrvold, the principal author, “would be a frontrunner for a Nobel Prize in gastronomy, if they had one,” gushed the celebrity food writer Padma Lakshmi, introducing Myhrvold two nights earlier at a symposium at the New York Academy of Sciences. He is “one of the most interesting men I have ever met in my life,” she added...".
So, obviously the woman is smitten about the man, not the food. At least the food he writes about, I guess. The article is absolutely worthless. I have travelled and eaten all over Europe for 50 years. My experience is that food has to be eaten and the final opinion about it is exclusively your very own, no matter who writes about it and certainly not to be discussed, just like politics and religion. I think that "food-writers" or "food stylists" are just people on a magazine's payroll who try to get a free meal at any restaurant they visit by blackmailing. Anyway, what are the academic credentials needed for being hired as one of those? On the other hand, people who need a hand at finding where and what to eat are just to be pitied. They can't find their own mouth without using their 2 hands and a flashlight.
Posted by Pete on July 3,2011 | 05:38 PM
Jerry Adler’s article on modern cuisine brings back many memories of meals eaten at some of the more cutting edge restaurants around the world. A lavender-crusted sous vide salmon at the now defunct Cru in New York City still shines in my mind and my tasting menu meal at Alinea (twenty eight courses stretched over several hours) remains a bucket list type of experience. But a tasting menu meal at a well known restaurant in Barcelona cooked by a disciple of Ferran Adria lingers for the wrong reasons. I just cannot shake the memory of the cod ice cream with caramel sauce.
Posted by Priscilla Kawakami on July 1,2011 | 11:36 AM
Is very impressive this article because , give a lot of information of the differents ingredients to cook well.
Also this article provide knows technique around the world and it comparared the meal that everyone eat like the disavantages of eat fast food and his possible dangerous.
Thanks,
Iam trying to learn and understand the article.My teacher recommend to me to read it and then i wil explain my ideas and opinion about it. such as What do you think?.ect.
Posted by jose argueddas on June 8,2011 | 11:26 AM
Fascinating, like most everything in the Smithsonian magazine. Thanks!
Posted by Mary Lane Leslie on June 4,2011 | 10:31 AM
The BEST possible way to eat a carp. 1 - catch your carp.
2 - dig a hole in your veggy garden deep enough to cover the carp with about 8" of dirt. 3 - place 3 or 4 corn kernels over the carp. 4 - When the corn is ripe, cook it and eat it. Native Americans ate several species trash fish and eels this way.
Posted by david allen on June 3,2011 | 06:27 PM
technically, one DE-bones a duck.
Posted by Leslie Fay Truscott on May 26,2011 | 08:49 PM